Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to have realised until now that Joey Maynard’s ‘displaced organ’ was a prolapse?

956 replies

QuaterMiss · 28/06/2019 09:08

I know there is or was an enormous Chalet School thread but I can’t spend six weeks trawling through that.

Fascinated to note (because I’ve been reading the complete synopses how all the CS women taken seriously ill either went straight to the San or journeyed - over days - for a consultation with Sir James Talbot. It was he who diagnosed said ‘displaced organ’. At which point Joey had iirc nine children. May be wrong, lost count.

(I read and reread the entire series over my first three decades.)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
emerencealwayshopeful · 07/07/2019 15:32

I love that this thread is so full of people all needing access to the books again. I hope onedrive works for people - I know it's been temperamental in the past.

Someone asked unthread about the chalet girls grow up - I once spect a lovely afternoon reading the amazon reviews of that. I've never come across any other book that raised blood pressure (and ire) in the same way. It's not the best book I've ever read from a literary standpoint but I absolutely recommend it if you don't mind that it is absolutely not a continuation of the series. It's not even a little in the spirit of the books. (Girls Gone By has printed many fill ins and also a continuation that the purists much prefer)

Cutpurse · 07/07/2019 15:07

Mary Lou runs off with Reg, doing Len an enormous favour in the process.

I will refrain from making bad-taste jokes about Mary Lou being a 'champion butter-in'. Grin

Cutpurse · 07/07/2019 15:01

I adore Gaudy Night and Have His Carcase -- basically, the more Harriet the better, which is my only quibble with The Nine Tailors.

I think the tone wavers all over the place in Busman's Honeymoon, which I do like, genuinely I think it's the combination of frantic below stairs/village jolliness and the Wedding Night as Sacrificial Rite that jars a bit, but interestingly. And I think it jars because DLS is working out stuff she found a genuine intellectual problem how do two complicated, intelligent people with notorious and involved amatory and professional pasts and an obsession with their work, from different social classes, one of them with an extremely involved, if discreet, butler, manage once married and having sex?

BertrandRussell · 07/07/2019 14:40

Just checking that all the Forest fans know about Hilary Mackay and her Casson books. Very different, but the same sort of “proper books for children” vibe.

Doubleraspberry · 07/07/2019 14:35

Mary Lou runs off with Reg, doing Len an enormous favour in the process.

missclimpson · 07/07/2019 14:32

Ha ha. I maintain my activities as an assistant investigator whilst living in a château in Normandy, humping the kapok and looking after dear Joey in her dotage. (Now that is outing).

Jemima232 · 07/07/2019 14:27

@missclimpson

No. There is little scope for your activities in The Nine Tailors, but you were very perspicacious when deciphering Vera Findlater's confession shorthand in Unnatural Death. And you were nearly murdered by the murderer.

XXcstatic · 07/07/2019 14:25

My absolute favourite is The Nine Tailors, even though I am not in it.

It lacks only you, Miss C.

I think Strong Poison is my favourite, largely thanks to you

However Nine Tailors has my favourite exchange in all the LPW books, along the lines of:

Hilary: most people are awful idiots, aren't they?

LP: yes, but it ain't kind to tell them so.

I have to remind myself of the LP response on a daily basis at work Grin

Jemima232 · 07/07/2019 14:14

@QuaterMiss

I love Busman's Honeymoon, too.

However I must take issue with you on one point.

DH and I could not have coped on our honeymoon without our butler. He was an essential adjunct to our perfect communion.

Having said that, we didn't have to cope with a common charwoman upsetting our case of port and rendering it undrinkable.

Mrs. Ruddle was well out of order for not realising that the dusty bottles cost 17/6d a pop.

Or was it 35s? Aaaaargh……...now I'll have to hunt for Busman's Honeymoon...…...be back soon.

Jemima232 · 07/07/2019 14:14

@QuaterMiss

I love Busman's Honeymoon, too.

However I must take issue with you on one point.

DH and I could not have coped on our honeymoon without our butler. He was an essential adjunct to our perfect communion.

Having said that, we didn't have to cope with a common charwoman upsetting our case of port and rendering it undrinkable.

Mrs. Ruddle was well out of order for not realising that the dusty bottles cost 17/6d a pop.

Or was it 35s? Aaaaargh……...now I'll have to hunt for Busman's Honeymoon...…...be back soon.

missclimpson · 07/07/2019 14:13

My absolute favourite is The Nine Tailors, even though I am not in it.

XXcstatic · 07/07/2019 14:10

Ah, I so much prefer Have His Carcass & Gaudy Night, with Harriet out of prison (hurrah!), wealthy thanks to all the prurient interest in her court case (hurrah!) and independent (hurrah!) - with LP desperate to please (double hurrah!).

QuaterMiss · 07/07/2019 14:05

I don’t remember that episode being ‘jolly’ Cutpurse. To my mind it was all rather weightily solemn - some sort of (pseudo) sacred rite.

But then, I don’t agree with Ruth Rendell at all. While I would not, personally, choose to take a butler on honeymoon, and would feel murderous towards anyone who touched my luggage (and I’ve had it happen occasionally) I actually find it a completely perfect novel.

Maybe it’s the shift in power once they’re married. Maybe it’s the fact that my idea of romance probably does involve both a gold wedding gown and a Donne manuscript. Maybe it’s Harriet’s palpable relief and relaxation that resonates with me. Dunno. All I know is that it makes me happy!

OP posts:
XXcstatic · 07/07/2019 14:01

Poor Theodora - being non-consensually defrizzed like Mr Messy Sad

IsFuzzyBeagMise · 07/07/2019 13:56

Poor Theodora. I identified with her from a hair point of view. She was thoroughly 'taken in hand'. There was a ruthlessness about Joey Maynard. I would have been petrified of her as a child.

Cutpurse · 07/07/2019 13:49

I am not sure it’s appropriate that I’m now simultaneously eating lunch and recalling Bunter giving Peter a thorough scrub down before he is delivered to his conjugal fate ...

Yes, and that's exactly the weirdly jolly terms it's conveyed in, isn't it?

I assume the internet is positively crawling with Bunter/Peter slash...

Cutpurse · 07/07/2019 13:47

I suppose Frizz Ease wasn't an option.. Grin

Or Matey suggesting she got a keratin blowdry?

Cutpurse · 07/07/2019 13:46

I did read it, @Doubleraspberry, though years and years ago. Whose husband does she run off with again, remind me?

IsFuzzyBeagMise · 07/07/2019 13:46

@Cutpurse 😅 I had forgotten that phrase...I used to love Mary Lou. I had that book about Theodora. I suppose Frizz Ease wasn't an option...

Cutpurse · 07/07/2019 13:41

@XXcstatic, does Ruth Rendell say that about Busman's Honeymoon? She's quite right! It's the oddest novel, the way it seems to bob about between Harriet and Peter investigating the murder, with Bunter bustling about lighting fires, and them driving about cheerfully finding the sold-off Tallboys chimneypots etc and then the weirdly emotionally overwrought bedroom scenes with all that coded writing about Harriet's sexual responsiveness, and then Peter breaking down at the end.

Doubleraspberry · 07/07/2019 13:33

I would have liked Mary Lou to be given a small electric shock every time she said 'I will lift mine eyes up to the hills'. I always imagine her saying it in a slightly sickly Special Voice.

Please do read Chalet Girls Grow Up. It will heal you.

QuaterMiss · 07/07/2019 13:32

I am not sure it’s appropriate that I’m now simultaneously eating lunch and recalling Bunter giving Peter a thorough scrub down before he is delivered to his conjugal fate ...

OP posts:
Cutpurse · 07/07/2019 13:32

I would have liked Mary Lou to be given a small electric shock every time she said 'I will lift mine eyes up to the hills'. I always imagine her saying it in a slightly sickly Special Voice.

Another madly EBD scene that's just come back to me since reading this thread was when Theodora shows up at the CS with an attitude problem, a record of expulsions and Thick, Untidy Hair, and within about an hour Joey has renamed her Ted without so much as a by your leave and Hilda Annersley has reinvented her hairstyle with a red ribbon and a thorough brushing (though I never quite see why this is the miracle is it presented as, as surely brushing shoulder-length hair off your face and keeping it there with some kind of hairband is the one of the most obvious things to do if it's not plaited etc?)

That's also the one where Margot throws a tantrum about something, goes into the Freudesheim garden and lies under a bush to wrestle with her Devil, overhears Joey blithely gossiping about Theodora's dysfunctional background to the school secretary, and then uses it as blackmail, isn't it?

XXcstatic · 07/07/2019 13:21

Mr. Mervyn Bunter gave us valuable information on how to pack ladies underwear in suitcases.

Argh- how could you remind me? Pass the literary mind bleach.

So much wrong with that book - I agree with Ruth Rendell, who said that the bedroom scenes were the most embarrassing in the whole of English literature Grin. OTOH DS is perceptive about the misogyny & ageism of male characters towards Miss Twitterton.

Doubleraspberry · 07/07/2019 13:06

Mary Lou’s story is my favourite. I like her so much more.