Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to have realised until now that Joey Maynard’s ‘displaced organ’ was a prolapse?

956 replies

QuaterMiss · 28/06/2019 09:08

I know there is or was an enormous Chalet School thread but I can’t spend six weeks trawling through that.

Fascinated to note (because I’ve been reading the complete synopses how all the CS women taken seriously ill either went straight to the San or journeyed - over days - for a consultation with Sir James Talbot. It was he who diagnosed said ‘displaced organ’. At which point Joey had iirc nine children. May be wrong, lost count.

(I read and reread the entire series over my first three decades.)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Jemima232 · 07/07/2019 17:39

@BertrandRussell

It is always Peter who says things like that.

My least favourite from Harriet is "Can you eat your egg less splashily" to one of the DC she managed to have despite being over forty when she married Wimsey.

Anyway - back to the Chalet School...…………..

I am beginning to wonder why I want to read the books, having just finished one.
But I do. I really, really, do.

Jemima232 · 07/07/2019 17:33

Wow.

I've just finished Rivals of the Chalet School and was horrified by the casual racism within it.

Also the bland mention of the Ku Klux Klan's activities as a method of *paying out" the girls of St. Scholastoka's.

But it was the insistence that starting Guides at St. Scholastika's would sort out their girls' bad behaviour that surprised me the most.

Guides? Really? The antidote to gang warfare?

And YUK to the Robin singing to Joey as she lay apparently dying, and this being the means by which she recovered.

I have more and more sympathy for "the" Robin now.

@RobinHumphries

Come back and I'll stop being horrid and nasty about you.

HoobaHooba · 07/07/2019 17:21

If I confess to naming my youngest child Josephine in honour of Joey, will someone please PM me the one drive details?

I had so many of these (and st Clare’s/Malory towers/Trebizon) etc.

SarahAndQuack · 07/07/2019 17:20

D'you think I should read the whole book as well, or am I ok on the Cliff Notes there? I'd hate to waste time reading.

cutpurse - Grin at 'poncing around in scarlet and blue'. Which is itself a form of snobbery, isn't it?! Not all doctorates being Oxford DPhils. So maybe we can't be too quick to condemn Harriet.

I do see that it is not the same, but I still think there are ways to read the conversation as other than 'OMG the lower orders'.

It is a weird book, though.

Cutpurse · 07/07/2019 17:11

Thanks, @BertrandRussell. I'm relieved, as I have always far preferred Harriet to her parrot-profiled paramour. I can continue to think him insufferable.

I don't think acquiring a doctorate is equivalent -- one would hardly expect a total stranger on whose door you have just knocked late at night to know your academic credentials, especially if you had just picked up your DPhil that afternoon and were not actually poncing around in your scarlet and blue. Grin

And I think the point of Peter's remark is that she got the form of the title right -- she didn't address Harriet as 'Lady Wimsey' for instance.

'Smatch of honour.' Biscuit

BertrandRussell · 07/07/2019 17:10

Fair enough- but if you read the extract it really is pure snobbery!

SarahAndQuack · 07/07/2019 17:02

I know - someone said so upthread - but the point stands. It's not necessarily about snobbery.

I suppose the parallel (and god knows MN thinks it's snobbery) would be if you'd newly got a doctorate, and your husband noticed that someone called you 'Dr Smith'. Even if he's been Professor Jones for two decades, he might still realise you were a bit unbelieving about being Dr Smith.

BertrandRussell · 07/07/2019 16:59

Yeah- but it was Peter said it.

SarahAndQuack · 07/07/2019 16:57

There is a lot of snobbery in DLS, but that doesn't strike me in the same way. I would have thought that if you were Harriet, you would surely be very conscious of your new title, not hardly used to it? Because she's not from that world.

BertrandRussell · 07/07/2019 16:54

“ Our hostess has a certain refinement (I think that's the word) about her which I had not expected. She got your title right first shot, which is unusual. Her life has had some smatch of honour in it. Who was her father?"
"I think he was a cowman."
"Then he married above his station. His wife, presumably, was a Miss Noakes."
"It comes back to me that she was a village schoolmistress over at some place near Broxford."
"That explains it..”

Ah yes. That “smatch of honour”
Unforgivable, really.

BertrandRussell · 07/07/2019 16:51

I’m just hunting for the reference- I seem to remember that there is N additional piece of worse obnoxiousery in the scene ....

Cutpurse · 07/07/2019 16:37

I don't think it's intended to mean that Miss Twitterton 'should' address Harriet as Lady Peter - they are just surprised that a small-scale chicken farmer knows the intricacies of aristocratic titles

Yes, that's what I meant. I find it deeply annoying that two newly-married people are using a title one of them one of them has borne for only a few hours as a way of judging the level of education/sophistication/social savvy of a woman they've just dug out in the middle of the night for a house key! (I did think it was Harriet who said it, but can't put my hand on my copy of BH...)

I think you just have to put your fingers in your ears and hum through all the snobbery or you’ll spoil the stories for yourself.

You are right. I am better at it some times than at other, and alas, my seven year old is insisting on reading me the Five Find Outers at bedtime at the moment, which means I keep doing Marxist analyses of the treatment of poor working-class Ern by the insufferable Fatty.

Alicecooperslovechild · 07/07/2019 16:37

For whoever warned the travel book reference in Problem - Tauchnitz editions designed for travellers.

floraloctopus · 07/07/2019 16:33

Mary Ann was horrible and I can imagine Joey being really, really annoying.

QueQueQue · 07/07/2019 16:30

Please please could I have the link

floraloctopus · 07/07/2019 16:25

BTW returning to the Chalet School - is Joey 100 this year?

If she is then she's the same age as Jon Pertwee.

XXcstatic · 07/07/2019 16:21

Harriet says that Miss Twitterton, unlike the Ruddles, gets her title right first time (addressing her as 'Lady Peter').

Whichever of them says it, I don't think it's intended to mean that Miss Twitterton 'should' address Harriet as Lady Peter - they are just surprised that a small-scale chicken farmer knows the intricacies of aristocratic titles.

There are whopping amounts of snobbery in DLS, with lots of rude mechanicals like the Ruddles, but Miss Twitterton is sympathetically written, and DLS is generally good on the many petty humiliations of being short of cash.

missclimpson · 07/07/2019 15:56

BTW returning to the Chalet School - is Joey 100 this year?

missclimpson · 07/07/2019 15:54

I get annoyed with the JPW ones because she gets basic facts wrong and muddles up the ages of Peter and Harriet's boys. Some of the writing is very clunky.

BertrandRussell · 07/07/2019 15:53

DLS used the stories as an escapism for herself- apparently she once had to walk home because she couldn’t afford the bus fare, so bought Peter a Daimler!

BertrandRussell · 07/07/2019 15:52

“n Harriet says that Miss Twitterton, unlike the Ruddles, gets her title right first time (addressing her as 'Lady Peter').“

Pretty sure Peter said that, not Harriet!

I think you just have to put your fingers in your ears and hum through all the snobbery or you’ll spoil the stories for yourself. It helps me to know that DLS was as alien to that world as most of us are. Apparently she made a lot of mistakes- and people who have used her as a guide to the upper classes have come croppers on occasion!

Cutpurse · 07/07/2019 15:48

The line I must admit really annoys me in Busman's Honeymoon is when Harriet says that Miss Twitterton, unlike the Ruddles, gets her title right first time (addressing her as 'Lady Peter').

This strikes me as a bit insufferable, as well as a bit out of character. I mean, it's Harriet's wedding day, so she's hardly used to being married to the man she's loved for years, let alone her brand new title -- she's only been Lady Peter for a few hours, most of which she's spent in a a car alone with her husband and Bunter.

QuaterMiss · 07/07/2019 15:43

Thrones, Dominations? Is that right? Long time since I read it. IIRC the relationship stuff was rather cool; the crime aspect was a bit heavy handed.

OP posts:
BertrandRussell · 07/07/2019 15:40

The Jill Peyton Walsh follow ons do address the dealing with “staff” issue rather well.

BertrandRussell · 07/07/2019 15:38

DLS didn’t want to write Busman’s Honeymoon- she’d written it as a play, but was persuaded to turn it into a novel. I think she’d got over Peter by then, and just wanted to devote herself to Dante.

Swipe left for the next trending thread