Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to have realised until now that Joey Maynard’s ‘displaced organ’ was a prolapse?

956 replies

QuaterMiss · 28/06/2019 09:08

I know there is or was an enormous Chalet School thread but I can’t spend six weeks trawling through that.

Fascinated to note (because I’ve been reading the complete synopses how all the CS women taken seriously ill either went straight to the San or journeyed - over days - for a consultation with Sir James Talbot. It was he who diagnosed said ‘displaced organ’. At which point Joey had iirc nine children. May be wrong, lost count.

(I read and reread the entire series over my first three decades.)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
LaurieMarlow · 07/07/2019 21:25

Also the presentation of the ‘beastly’ Mau Mau in CG from Kenya. Though I guess if you were Jo Scott you could be forgiven gut thinking that.

ddl1 · 07/07/2019 21:16

'You're right, the KKK stuff in Rivals is mid-blowing, especially the way in which it's viewed as sort of colourful American 'fighting for your rights' stuff.'

Ugh, yes. This very clearly is the consequence of Joey (and her creator presumably) reading too many of the ghastly Elsie Dinsmore books. I like and collect 19th century children's books, but those are insane! Very reactionary in political tone, even by the standards of the time; and also just - eurgh! Elsie is a pious little girl, whose mother is dead, and whose father is a nasty bully, who tries to force her to play the piano on the Sabbath Day. She refuses; he insists that she stay there till she does as he's told; she eventually faints and he is remorseful and become pious and devoted to her, but still a bully. He keeps her totally dependent on him, withdraws affection to punish her on the rare occasion that she disobeys, e.g. when she tries to prevent him from repeatedly whipping her toddler half-brother. Eventually she grows up to be a saintly young woman who marries her dear papa's close friend and contemporary (it was obviously illegal to marry daddy himself!) I don't generally go in for Freudian interpretations of literature, but Freud really would had a field-day with that series!

carsleyladiessociety · 07/07/2019 21:01

I'm another person who can't seem to log into the OneDrive

Is there a secret way of doing it or am I lost forever?

cwg1 · 07/07/2019 20:44

Shirley Nielsen, proprietor of the Old Children's Bookshop has very recently opened a new shop - Priorsford Books in Peebles. I can't easily make links, but if you look for Greyladies Books, there are contact details there.

Encore Books and Topsy Turvy books are online and owned by keen fans of the Chalet School and other old children's books and sometimes have hardbacks available. My dealings with them have always been very good.

As mentioned, GGB are an excellent source - all their books have full original text and are well-produced on good-quality paper.

Disclaimer - no personal connections, just a grateful customer Smile

Emilyclimbs · 07/07/2019 20:35

Cutpurse - Jarvis did have distressing tendencies didn’t he? But I couldn’t abide Teddy’s milkiness - Perry was infinitely more liveable. Veering slightly sideways Peter Wimsey was my ideal for many a year and responsible for first college boyfriend - whose straw colored hair, prominent nose and highly strung disposition segued into narcisissism (put me off the books for years but you’ll be glad to know that is now resolved). Adored Joey as a child (and still adore child Joey if that makes sense) but adult Joey is nearly as annoying as Dear Mary-Lou. My small ones are miaowing ao updates will be intermittent

SarahAndQuack · 07/07/2019 20:03

YY, cutpurse, I do know what you mean - I just wonder if it wasn't so much assessing her social savvy, as indicating what was uppermost in their minds? Eg., Peter feeling conscious she's newly 'Lady Peter' and she's being faced with all of these conventions; Harriet giving off vibes of nervousness about it?

I dunno.

It does seem clear that one of the things between Peter and Harriet (in addition to her ethical debt over the legal case) is the fact that if she marries him she will be subsumed into a world of extreme privilege.

burnoutbabe · 07/07/2019 19:56

Sorry for the confusion people, when I said I'd read the 10 kingsctotes I really meant the ones about the family. And not the one's that was not about them (Thursday kidnapping?)
I also enjoy re reading the Trebizon books, they were fairly lightweight but I liked the mystery each books and they were far more present day. Wish they had shown the sixth form.
Though nowadays it only takes my 45 minutes to read one!

Squirrel26 · 07/07/2019 19:37

I imagine the 'misplaced organ' to be similar to Susan's 'wandering spleen' in Desperate Housewives.

'Has anyone seen my uterus? It's escaped again.'

Cutpurse · 07/07/2019 19:28

@Emilyclimbs, we could add in a discussion of purple-eyed, slow-smiling young Canadian aspirant writers who get the flash, clash with their aunts, and are fought over by men, including a decades-older creepy cousin who remarks on her white neck and kissable lips when she's about 13 and says he'll wait for her to grow up, the perve.

Emilyclimbs · 07/07/2019 19:19

I fear it would be pointless. Last week I attempted to instigate reward charts and was stymied by the small ones (6 and 3) assigning them to the aged parents instead. Intensive brainwashing is required - I’m envisaging headphones at bedtime to deliver the Chalet School Way of Life to the subconscious. And yes I mistyped obeisances - blasted iPhone keyboard.

XXcstatic · 07/07/2019 19:08

I have an embryonic Jack Lambert here who needs to be educated in the benefits of Home Economics Classes and the art of fainting gracefully at the feet of a suitably capable doctor (said child is 6, hates pink and wants to be a naval captain slash superhero slash archeologist but brainwashing can never start too early!!)

Tsk, you need to nip that sort of thing in the bud right now. Make her write out, 'Her voice was ever soft, Gentle and low, an excellent thing in woman' 100 times, then darn some socks.

QuaterMiss · 07/07/2019 19:01

It is rather a pity Emilyclimbs that the two series don’t run in tandem. We run out of Peter and Harriet just as the CS gets really good - with Exile at the start of WWII.

OP posts:
NewSchoolNewName · 07/07/2019 18:52

And I agree that the casual racism in some of the books can be horrific.

Emilyclimbs · 07/07/2019 18:49

I have found my spiritual home. Chalet School and discussions I’d class in DLS. That exchange re poor Miss Twitterton always grated with me - however I rest secure in the smug knowledge that I have the ability th address the wife of a Duke’s second son appropriately! Can’t say it comes in useful in rural Ireland. Given the dearth or second hand Chalet School books here and the fact that I am languishing with abridged Armadas - is there any way I too could have access to the
One drive? I have an embryonic Jack Lambert here who needs to be educated in the benefits of Home Economics Classes and the art of fainting gracefully at the feet of a suitably capable doctor (said child is 6, hates pink and wants to be a naval captain slash superhero slash archeologist but brainwashing can never start too early!!) graceful obesisances in advance

NewSchoolNewName · 07/07/2019 18:47

@Jemima232

I don’t know about acquiring old hardback CS books, but I filled in a lot of my CS collection via Girls Gone By Publishers.

They’ve reprinted a lot of the Chalet School books using the original unabridged text. Plus they’ve published a lot of fill-in books by different authors.
They don’t have all the CS books in print at once though, I had to keep an eye on what they were publishing until I’d completed my collection.
Hopefully a clicky link to Girls Gone By Publishers below:

www.ggbp.co.uk/

ddl1 · 07/07/2019 18:31

'Mary Lou runs off with Reg, doing Len an enormous favour in the process.'

I agree as Reg is a total drain on Len, and what my father once described in a different context as 'a male chauvinist pig of the most oink-oink variety'. I don't think Mary Lou and he would really have tolerated each other, however. I'm ambivalent about Mary Lou; she could be very self-centred and bossy, but intelligent teenagers often are, and ambitious females possibly had to be a bit pushy in those days if they didn't want to get totally trodden on. Reg should have run off with almost any school Matron in almost any school story: they would have deserved each other!

RobinHumphries · 07/07/2019 18:08

I’m still here.
I think of all the characters it’s Sybil I feel the most sorry for. I mean she was pretty, but supposedly not clever, but was working really hard in order to do well in her exams and then she doesn’t even go to needlework school. Gets dragged to Australia instead as her mum wants the company (although that must be some consolation as Australia is my favourite place on earth).

Pollaidh · 07/07/2019 17:56

@Alicecooperslovechild Thank you for the 'problem' book ref. A day searching the web, and I should just have gone on Mumsnet.

Cutpurse · 07/07/2019 17:56

I do see that it is not the same, but I still think there are ways to read the conversation as other than 'OMG the lower orders'.

@SarahAndQuack, that's not really how I mean it, more that it sits oddly with me that a title newly borne by Harriet is used (about which you would expect both P and H to feel slightly self-conscious as they've very newly married and trying to get into Tallboys to consummate their marriage!) as a way of reading the social savvy of a stranger. (And I said scarlet and blue doctoral robes because that's what mine were, back in the mists of time, and I have no idea what any other doctoral colours are. I do realise other doctorates are available.Grin)

Guides? Really? The antidote to gang warfare?

Phone Sadiq Khan immediately.

You're right, the KKK stuff in Rivals is mid-blowing, especially the way in which it's viewed as sort of colourful American 'fighting for your rights' stuff. Shock

Gooddie · 07/07/2019 17:52

I always felt that "the misplaced" organ was suspended half way down her body. I don't think I had studied any science/biology at that point!!

Love the CS, although agree with many PP about Joey being a complete pain in the last few books. Absolutely hated Len and Reg's romance - why were all the proposals so mundane?

Anyway @BertrandRussell I'd love that link too please. Thank you so much.

XXcstatic · 07/07/2019 17:52

one of the DC she managed to have despite being over forty when she married Wimsey.

No, she is 35/36 - someone has helpfully done a timeline. She is 10 years younger than LP.

Ancient for a first-time mother in them days, of course, but still plausible to have had 3+ DC, as long as she got cracking.

Allington · 07/07/2019 17:49

I never was a Chalet Girl sob however Lord Peter is only just edged out of first place of Man I Was Meant To Have Married by Francis Crawford of Lymond. And possibly his brother Richard as well, there are times it is a close call...

Edged out by Richard as well as Lymond, I mean, not that I want both brothers at the same time. That would be altogether Too Much. They would probably start fighting.

And you have all inspired me to look on archive.org and find they have The Marlows and The Traitor, which is one I have never read. An act of true sisterhood to one who has been in the San all day. Without wandering organs, though, something rather more mundane.

Jemima232 · 07/07/2019 17:45

@FrancisCrawford

Are there any bookstores online which sell the old hardback CS books?

Does anyone know - apart from Amazon?

FrancisCrawford · 07/07/2019 17:41

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.