Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to have realised until now that Joey Maynard’s ‘displaced organ’ was a prolapse?

956 replies

QuaterMiss · 28/06/2019 09:08

I know there is or was an enormous Chalet School thread but I can’t spend six weeks trawling through that.

Fascinated to note (because I’ve been reading the complete synopses how all the CS women taken seriously ill either went straight to the San or journeyed - over days - for a consultation with Sir James Talbot. It was he who diagnosed said ‘displaced organ’. At which point Joey had iirc nine children. May be wrong, lost count.

(I read and reread the entire series over my first three decades.)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Jemima232 · 08/07/2019 19:44

And all the "peasants!"

Peasants always help the gels of the CS out when they get stuck on mountains etc.

In Rivals, seventy girls turn up to a peasant's house. Seventy. They crowd into the peasant's home (which must be the size of a threepenny bit) and are all given warm milk.

Visions of the peasant's DH frantically milking cows/goats to provide for the seventy girls.

Miss Wilson pays for the milk, though, as she knows that the peasants are very poor.

Jemima232 · 08/07/2019 19:36

In Rivals of the CS, Joey and Frieda are given a punishment for putting cornflour on some of the Middles' hair. The punishment is to wash the hair of two of the Middles.

It takes them all afternoon. Unbelievable.

And re - class issues - why did Madge/Mademoiselle even accept pupils from WC backgrounds? The nouveaux riches gels are always depicted as "not quite quite" and the posh girls really look down on them.

DorothyCross · 08/07/2019 18:04

@NewSchoolNewName, I think what I don't like about the way Joan is portrayed is that EBD implies that Joan's unpleasant side stems from her class background.

Ros Lilley has learned ladylike ways because her mother was in service to the upper classes as a lady's maid, and her background is 'respectable' aspirant working class, but Joan is both sexually sophisticated and 'unlady-like' eating chips on the street with 'unsavoury' Vic Coles, swearing, her perm, make-up and grown-up clothes, thinking it's babyish to dance without boys and feckless nouveau-riche, looking down on Ros while her family is squandering the money they won on the pools.

When you think about it, given that we're told that the Lilleys don't have a bathroom and take their weekly bath in the kitchen, it would have been perfectly logical for Ros to have been the one who was slightly taken aback at the daily cold bath requirement at the CS, as it wouldn't have been something she'd done at home. But it's Joan who is depicted as a soap-dodger, and is (I think?) the only CS girl we ever see refusing to bathe, because, while she's concerned with her appearance, it's not in the dainty 'cleanliness is next to Godliness' EBD-approved way. Grin

NewSchoolNewName · 08/07/2019 16:34

Wasn’t Joan Baker planning on bullying Rosamund Lilley because Rosamund’s mum was just a maid while Joan’s mum had worked in a shop, which made Joan’s mum superior? That didn’t show Joan in the most positive way.

Although the scene where Mary-Lou is asking Jack for advice on how to deal with Joan Baker contains some breathtaking snobbery about poor Joan not being the right sort of girl because of her unfortunate lower class background.

Papergirl1968 · 08/07/2019 16:33

Joan Baker was described as cheaply pretty, I think, and had a perm! And her family won the football pools!

Squirrel26 · 08/07/2019 16:14

Isn’t Vera’s problem really that her family are ‘new money’ and worse, got rich during the war? Therefore she’s just not quite the right kind of girl, and obviously is going to be a bad lot, given half a chance.

See also Diana Skelton, who’s father ‘manufactures glue’, and Joan Baker, who never really does anything wrong (other than running away because she just can’t stand being ‘helped’ by Mary-Lou any more. And really, who could blame her?) but is always presented as being Not Quite Nice because her father won the money for her school fees on the football pools.

Jemima232 · 08/07/2019 12:33

Oh and there's a slightly common girl at St. S.
Her name is Doris Potts. Very WC. How on earth did she ever gain admission to a boarding school for English ladies?

The same English ladies who denigrated the CS because it had 'foreigners' among its pupils.

Jemima232 · 08/07/2019 12:30

Am now wondering which books EBD did consider suitable for schoolgirls.

Possibly a different kind of books for middles as opposed to seniors and prefects.

Even sub-prefects. What subject did EBD teach?

Please don't say English Literature.

NewSchoolNewName · 08/07/2019 11:55

I read Forever Amber on the recommendation of it being a book for bad girls

Me too Svalberg Grin

I saw it and thought, oooh, that’s the book that got those girls into trouble, let’s see what the fuss was about. Probably not the effect EBD had in mind Grin

Apileofballyhoo · 08/07/2019 09:53

Pascha and Bumply I wonder could you share? Are they pdf files?

I think all the email providers have got far more security conscious. I've been logging into my DM's email for years for her and the last time she asked, a couple of months ago, I couldn't get in. Not sure it's you etc., even though I know her password, my email is her alternate email, got a code sent to her phone and put it in etc. Still wouldn't let me, I suspect as we were in different locations. It is a Google account rather than Microsoft. But it's very annoying if you want to check something and don't have internet access, you can't get someone to check for you.

Svalberg · 08/07/2019 09:20

I read Forever Amber on the recommendation of it being a book for bad girls Blush

Cutpurse · 08/07/2019 08:48

(Elaine, the mean, mean nasty girl, pushed the Robin slightly and outraged the entire CS as a result.)

Mind you, Joey had a screw loose about anyone who didn't immediately worship the Robin. Joyce Linton doesn't take any particular notice of her on her first evening at the Sonnalpe is she the one who says 'Oh, night night, kid', or is that someone else? and Joey puts it down as a Black Mark against her character.

In fairness, Joyce is annoying, but she has recently discovered her mother is seriously ill, had to leave her old school and home and trek halfway across Europe with her mother in an ambulance, and has just been thrust among a bunch of complete strangers after a long journey up a mountain -- it's hardly surprising she has more on her mind than a little girl she's never met before saying good night.

Pascha · 08/07/2019 08:22

I haven't received a pm yet but don't sweat it because I remembered I downloaded lots onto an old tablet so I'm charging that one up (for the first time in months) to see what I do and don't have.

ReanimatedSGB · 08/07/2019 08:11

I always wondered what Vera might have been reading, as well. Rivals was written in about 1932 so it was too early for DH Lawrence...

Jemima232 · 08/07/2019 00:54

Bloody hell. Gone With The Wind?

And EBD was obsessed with Guiding.

Elaine was just the type of girl to need all that the Guides could have given her

(Elaine, the mean, mean nasty girl, pushed the Robin slightly and outraged the entire CS as a result.)

NewSchoolNewName · 08/07/2019 00:31

Poor Vera. What was she reading?

Later on - post WW2 - some Chalet School girls got into trouble for reading the scandalously unsuitable book Gone With The Wind / Forever Amber (IIRC the exact title varies depending on which edition you’ve got).

Just to give you an idea of what type of book EBD considered unsuitable for schoolgirls!

Jemima232 · 08/07/2019 00:06

@Squirrel26

In Rivals of the Chalet School, a girl is expelled from St. Scholastika's for

a) writing an anonymous letter to the King of Belsornia

and

b) having a book which isn't on the school's reading list in her desk

It doesn't say which book it is, but Miss Browne, the luckless head of St. S. says to the luckless expellee:

We want you girls to retain your purity of mind as long as possible. Do you think that you can soil your minds with the thoughts and deeds recorded in such a story and retain that purity?

Poor Vera. What was she reading? The Forsyte Saga? She was the only pupil Miss Browne had ever expelled.

ReanimatedSGB · 07/07/2019 22:50

I was also appalled at the presentation of the KKK as 'fighting for your rights', given that EBD was at least slightly progressive for her time. I wonder if she just didn't know.
Oh and I went to Interlaken on holiday a couple of years ago and got all wildly excited on the train - 'Lake Thun! The Jungfrau ! to the general bemusement of all the other people in the tour party.

Squirrel26 · 07/07/2019 22:33

Redheads is one of the more bonkers ones, IMO. Isn’t there a throw away line about how the people who kidnapped Val planned to ‘turn her into a drug addict’? It feels like EBD had been reading the kind of books the Chalet School would have strongly disapproved of.

TailsoftheManyPaws · 07/07/2019 22:31

Never mind the question of why Miss Twiiterton knew how to address wives of the
minor nobility. How did Harriet, aged 31/32, remember the maiden name and occupation of Miss Noakes the village schoolmistress from some time more than 40 years previously?

Doubleraspberry · 07/07/2019 22:26

I think someone’s already mentioned it upthread but the ‘Chalet Schools Sales and Wants’ group on FB is very good and includes some of the bigger dealers in school stories like Gill Bilski. The Armadas usually go for not much and hardbacks minus a dust jacket have fallen in price since GGBP began reprinting.

Bumply · 07/07/2019 22:07

I have a bunch of books from previous sharing of one drive copies.
Just read Red heads at the Chalet school for the first time.
We've changed her surname so no one could possibly recognise our Flavia as the red head Flavia they want to kidnap.
When they kidnap Val by mistake, keep her drugged for several days before dumping her on a random stranger (who happened to be an old acquaintance of Jack's) the victim blaming of poor Val was appalling. (You were truanting so it's ALL YOUR FAULT that you got kidnapped)
It got worse after that, but I'll stop with the spoilers.

carsleyladiessociety · 07/07/2019 22:03

Isn't there a passage in one of the early books about having to 'work like n***s to get all the work finished'. Its something to do with one of the fairs

DD has started reading my CS books (I have the full Armada set) however that's one particular book I have left off her reading list.

Papergirl1968 · 07/07/2019 21:38

Hold fire, those who still want the log in details because the blasted thing appears to have locked us all out.
@nellwilsonswhitehair if you’re reading this, I’ve sent you a PM begging for help.

LaurieMarlow · 07/07/2019 21:26

For thinking that

Swipe left for the next trending thread