Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to have realised until now that Joey Maynard’s ‘displaced organ’ was a prolapse?

956 replies

QuaterMiss · 28/06/2019 09:08

I know there is or was an enormous Chalet School thread but I can’t spend six weeks trawling through that.

Fascinated to note (because I’ve been reading the complete synopses how all the CS women taken seriously ill either went straight to the San or journeyed - over days - for a consultation with Sir James Talbot. It was he who diagnosed said ‘displaced organ’. At which point Joey had iirc nine children. May be wrong, lost count.

(I read and reread the entire series over my first three decades.)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Doubleraspberry · 23/07/2019 07:39

Biddy didn’t even go to St Scholastika’s, did she? She was destined for the ‘local’ school! She did well for herself indeed, begorrah.

Could I possibly have the drop box? I’m moving house next week and am finding many Chalet paperbacks in boxes and also some hardbacks and GGB so once I’ve moved and then gone on my holiday (to the Tiernsee natch) I may be able to offer some paperbacks around.

desperatelyseekingcaffeine · 22/07/2019 22:44

This has brought back some memories! I had the whole set at one point, sold a couple in my late teens to help fund a pre university holiday. Must still have most in my parents loft, have pm'd for the Dropbox as I'd love to reread them without fear of the children destroying them.

Had forgotten how crazy some of them were until this thread - Redheads in particular! I can still remember finding a huge basket of them in a charity shop for 30p each when I was about 8 and buying around 15-20. (If I'd known how much they'd be worth now, I'd have bought them all!)

Pascha · 22/07/2019 22:23

Yes that's the one. Thekla brings raw bacon, someone else pilchards or sardines or something and they eat it all on some cake...

PhilSwagielka · 22/07/2019 22:10

Some of the early stories were batshit insane, but they were well written enough for me (and other readers) to overlook it. It gets ridiculous in the Swiss years though.

I really want to read Lintons. Isn't that the one with the clandestine midnight feast? I read Rebel, which is half of it.

Pascha · 22/07/2019 21:57

Biddy goes from recently orphaned homeless urchin in a foreign land, via being owned by the Guides who pay(!) for her to go to the lesser boarding school, (St. S), via ending up at the CS, teacher training, history teacher at CS and surprise surprise Marrying a Doctor.

Who'd have guessed it would end up that way?

IvysMum12 · 22/07/2019 21:53

I do have the whole series. Loved them as a child, but I now find them rather irritating.
The Senior Consultant (Jack Maynard) rushing to the school to prescribe a "Jorum of hot milk" for everything is unbelievable.
The earphones.
Robin packed off to a convent because Jem Russell (not Talbot) decided she "isn't strong enough for marriage."
Can't decide who is the bigger pain in the neck - Joey or Mary Lou Trelawney.
But the books have something, and as badly written as they are, I still love them.
EBD did start her own school: The Margaret Roper School for Girls. I don't think it lasted long because she was so disorganised.

Pascha · 22/07/2019 21:51

He did! And never came back.

TailsoftheManyPaws · 22/07/2019 21:50

Biddy’s adoption by the Middles reminds me so much of Katy Carr ‘adopting’ a little Irish girl, Mary ORiley? Something like that), randomly renaming her Susquehanna and saving up crusts to feed her.

LaurieMarlow · 22/07/2019 21:46

Well yes Grin but not quite as barking as Princess of imaginary kingdom gets sent to random school then gets kidnapped by mad uncle.

Though the most barking of all is Ruey Richardson. Did her Dad actually hare off to space?!?! Or did I dream that?

Pascha · 22/07/2019 21:38

Biddys story not completely off the wall? Confused

It was barking! Middles find wandering Irish child in Alpine Austria, believe her sob story and decide on a whim to keep her in a shed and feed her scraps?

Pascha · 22/07/2019 21:35

My favourite sale of work:

"The Fifth form of St Scholastica's were to help with the Magic Cave, Miss Elliot and Mademoiselle Berné having reserved to themselves the places of "unseen musicians". They all wore Eastern draperies, with the exception of Ida Reavely and Nancy Wilmot, the two biggest among them, who were got up in full Turkish male costume, and Hilary, who was to be the Peri, and whose floating garments were hung with strings of beads to such an extent that she vowed she felt like a walking jeweler's shop!"

Nancy was made out to be larger than average even as a teenage schoolgirl in Lintons.

LaurieMarlow · 22/07/2019 21:17

i've never heard any people from the Republic of Ireland talk like that either

Well sure, but a Kerry dialect would be closest to the stage Irishman that EBD is clearly influenced by. It’s very far from a Dublin accent too.

I also love Biddy’s story. It’s very romantic and unlikely, without being totally off the wall like Elisaveta.

PhilSwagielka · 22/07/2019 21:09

i've never heard any people from the Republic of Ireland talk like that either! And yes, she's the Chalet School's big success story. She does learn her nice manners from her mum's mistress, but I like the fact she goes the CS and ends up being a much-loved teacher there.

LaurieMarlow · 22/07/2019 21:05

Well Biddy is from Kerry, isn’t she? That’s very different to Belfast. Not that I’m endorsing EBDs irishisms

The thing about Biddy is that she leaves Ireland aged about six, never steps foot in the place again, yet speaks like that til the end. Weird.

She’s an interesting character because EBD clearly forgives her her ‘common’ origins. She didn’t do that often.

PhilSwagielka · 22/07/2019 20:36

I'm not Irish, but I have a friend from Belfast and she does NOT talk like Biddy O'Ryan. Irish people on the CBB really can't stand the weird way Biddy talks. "Oh wirra wirra," said no Irish person ever. I am half Scottish, though, and as much as I love Highland Twins, I wish EBD hadn't rendered their accents phonetically.

@cerys, I'm surprised they don't call anyone 'boyo'. Grin

@Papergirl1968 Bride is basically the ugly one of the family. There's a mean comment about her in Changes, something about Molly and Dick having three pretty daughters instead of two one day.

cerys · 22/07/2019 20:26

Also, I am Welsh but I have never in my life heard anyone say “look you” or have the speech patterns EBD gives her Welsh characters!

Papergirl1968 · 22/07/2019 20:21

Bride is described as large and rather plain, I think, in Bride Leads. Nancy Wilmot is described as being tall and plump to put it mildly, or words to that effect, in one of the books I’ve just read. It’s the scene where she ends up accidentally riding a pig backwards and the poor thing nearly collapsed, in Jane, I think. And the cook is referred to as Big Karen in Redheads, which I just finished. Shock
If I ever go on Mastermind, my specialist subject would be the Chalet School!

PhilSwagielka · 22/07/2019 19:30

Bride is great though. She's one of my favourite CS characters, along with Daisy and Tom. Bride's friendship group were one of the best as well.

PhilSwagielka · 22/07/2019 19:29

Two Sams is a very weak book, tbh. The Sams themselves are lovely characters, but there's a bullshit twist at the end involving them, and the whole thing is just Chalet School by numbers. Accidents, guided tour of school, nice food, Joey, accidents, annoying Middles, lather, rinse, repeat. The girls are such cows to the Sams as well, Samaris' form because Samaris wants to work hard, and Samantha's form because they're mad about not getting to see Nina Rutherford instead of her, even though the whole thing was Joey's idea. And yes, EBD is obsessed with people's weight. Joey makes a nasty dig about Sophie Hamel and how fat she is (and no, no-one called her 'Fatty' at school, wtf EBD). For someone who thinks vanity is evil, she doesn't half obsess over characters' looks. As if anyone would comment on how hot the teachers are.

QuaterMiss · 22/07/2019 19:27

Parker you’re obviously a born CS girl! Star

Thank you for being so generous with your time. Have a wonderful holiday - and don’t forget to send us endless vast boxes of candies for our staff meetings. Brew Cake

OP posts:
cerys · 22/07/2019 19:16

I am thoroughly enjoying re-reading these stories and filling in the gaps with some of them.
I’m struck by the amount of description of people as plain or pretty, yet poor Sybil has a really hard time of it, as previous posters have said.
Also, so many comments about people’s weight or size Shock

I re- read Carola today and was amused that they decided she could continue with botany but as her Maths was so bad she didn’t need to do that as well! Imagine that these days!

IsFuzzyBeagMise · 22/07/2019 19:10

@Aroundtheworldin80moves 😅

Enjoy your holiday @Parker231 🌞

Parker231 · 22/07/2019 19:07

@Aroundtheworldin80moves - we actually do have twins and DH is a doctor (A GP in central London rather than a Swiss sanatorium!). DT’s are fit and healthy but I’m sure they would like to avoid Uni for an extended stay in Canada.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 22/07/2019 18:55

Parker are you planning on giving birth to twins while there or leaving behind a child so they can become strong in the wonderful climate?

Parker231 · 22/07/2019 18:27

If anyone else wants the Dropbox link can you let me know by Wednesday as DH and I are off on holiday to visit his parents and I won’t be set up for sharing the link.

We’re going to Canada so I think EBD would approve as the Russell’s and Maynards had their visit over there. We’ll be speaking French 100% of the time so the Chalet School teachers should be pleased!