Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dads who are denied access to their children!

43 replies

Shootingstar1115 · 17/06/2019 14:44

Hi all, a bit of a long one. I am very confused right now.

I am 27 and never had a relationship with my father. My mum always told me he didn’t want to see me, never paid for me etc. But never went into great detail. She never really spoke about him. So I always left wondering. I know a bit more about him now though.

I always grew up believing he didn’t want me despite that I now know he’s a fab father to his younger children.

As an over thinking mother of 2 myself I’m starting to have doubts.

Of course, I believe that if a father really wants to see his children he will fight for it but I can imagine my mother made it very difficult for him.

She was young, he cheated, got someone else pregnant, didn’t stay with that woman either (but has a relationship with the child as far as I know). My mum was young and hurt, I totally get that.

A few things my grandmother has said in recent times (she has told me quite a bit about him over the years tbh) has made me think that my mother made it really really difficult for him. Basically used me as a weapon. ‘Get back with me or don’t see your child’ type thing. Apparently he seen me a few times as a tiny baby but when he got a new girlfriend (now wife) this stopped and not seen me since.

Thinking about my mum over the years has made me realise

  1. She stopped my brother seeing his dad
  2. When she falls out with a relative (eg my grandmother) she stopped her seeing us for a while until they made up.
  3. When shes briefly split up with my stepdad she stopped him from seeing his 3 children until they got back together.
  4. When I split with my ex, DS’s dad she told me to stop all contact straight away and not let him into his life. Fortunately I didn’t take her advice and DS sees his dad.
  5. She doesn’t let her mother in law see her grandchildren because they fell out themselves.

It’s like she cannot grow up and get over her own hurt and uses her children as a weapon.

From what I’ve heard she point blank refused to let him see me if he didn’t want to get back with her. When they split she uses her brothers, my uncles to back him away. One of them is a bit of a thug. I would be scared of getting on the wrong side of him.

Apparently his family really wanted to see me but none of them were allowed (grandparents, aunts, uncles etc). Now his parents have probably gone to their graves and never known me and I feel I have this gap in my life. Particularly now I’m not so close to mother (she’s a difficult person in so many ways).

I seen her the other day and she said she often thinks about contacting him herself and asking for 27 years of maintenance payments! I mean really?? Who would do that? Yes he should have paid but a long time has gone by and it’s like she’s still bitter or something. She’s happily married (been married 20 odd years) surely she’s over it by now!

I just feel like she cannot get over herself to see what’s best for both me and her children in general.

Despite this, I didn’t have a terrible up bringing. It’s just cracks have started to show in recent years between me and her. I’ve realised what she’s like and how immature she can be at times!

I just have this thought that maybe they give up because she made it so difficult!

The guy has other children (2 older than me, another my sort of age from when he cheated, and 4 he lives with I think) and he has a relationship with all of them so why not me??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
othersideofthecoin · 30/08/2022 21:43

Go buy some Nutella once husband can hold a job down, might give you the sugar rush to think of something with more intellect behind it.

MsChatterbox · 30/08/2022 18:57

ZOMBIE

othersideofthecoin · 30/08/2022 17:23

I don't blame him, sounds like it come to a point when had to look after number 1.

No doubt if you contact him he would be open to building a relationship.

Mja8317 · 29/11/2021 16:55

He shouldn’t have had to have fought to see his child.....the fact he had or needed to shows the fault lies with the mother. Women don’t have to fight to be mothers the law gives them that straight away it should be exactly the same for fathers, but I guess equality only works when women have some to gain

BigRedLondonBus · 18/06/2019 09:30

I also have the opposite. My ex didn’t see our 4 children for 2 years to “punish me” he has now said he isn’t sure whether he wants to see them again and will have to think about it. I do have sympathy for dads who are stopped but I don’t know any irl. Know plenty who have just walked away through choice though.

SapphireBattersea · 18/06/2019 09:11

@Otterhound I am glad it worked out well for your friend

Why do some parents do this I couldn't alienate any of my dc from their dads it's so cruel 😓

Otterhound · 17/06/2019 20:59

Similar happened with a friend at uni (this was late 80’s) his parents divorced in the 70’s , mum told him and his sister their father didn’t want to know , wasn't paying etc
His father contacted him at uni, and ultimately showed him all the solicitors letters, court orders etc to prove his mother had basically been lying

My friend basically saw his dad and cut off his mum the whole him he was at uni.

SapphireBattersea · 17/06/2019 20:16

@deadbeatdead that's heartbreaking 💔

SapphireBattersea · 17/06/2019 20:09

@HirplesWithHaggis my dh ex did that too

What is wrong with these "mothers" 😞

deadbeatdead · 17/06/2019 18:11

I'm no fan of deadbeat dads, my ex being a prime example who pays nothing and gives no fucks about his child, but it certainly does happen that no matter what is tried a mother can stop a father seeing their children.

A friend of mine had 3 kids and when his wife had an affair she moved away with the kids to a fairly remote Scottish island. Friend went to court, prohibited steps refused as they were 'settled' and her sister lived there.
He had visitation awarded by court, so he'd pay to fly there and she either a) wasn't in, b) said the kids were ill, c) cry and shout that she would miss them and she didn't want them to go, so the children got upset and didn't want to go and then she'd refuse to let them go because they were upset.
Each time it took at least 6 months to go back to court, and all visitation was denied in that time. Each time the judge would order contact and the same would happen. The judge ordered phone contact too - her phone would be dead, or she wouldn't be in, or the kids would be napping, or out at friends. When the judge tried to admonish her she would get hysterical and cry and weep in court and he'd back down.
After more than 5 years of this and many tens of thousands of pounds he had to give up. He'd not seen his children for 4 years by then, he was heavily in debt, he'd lost his job from the time off to travel there for the failed visitations and for the court cases. I really don't know what else he could have done. The judge was not prepared to award him residence as he hadn't seen the children for years... and she couldn't be forced to let him see them. They weren't going to send her to jail when she had young children.
He is just hoping they contact him when they are older and haven't been completely poisoned against him.
She has always been more than willing to accept his maintenance payments though. Which he has always paid.

And this was relatively recently. 30 years ago I doubt a father would have got very far had he gone to court.

Many men are indeed shit fathers but some mothers are just arseholes when it comes to using their children to get back at an ex.

GinoPlaysTheTango · 17/06/2019 17:07

It definitely happens. In my own family there is one person, X, who has denied access to her DD's father for many years, despite him being desperate for contact. X has no conscience about lying to the courts in order to achieve this.

X also has form for doing exactly the same with other family members whenever she falls out with them. (I think it's very telling that you mention your mother doing this, too.) Basically her DD is a pawn and anybody who doesn't do what X wants will not be allowed to see her DD. Family members have an extremely low opinion of X, but continue to put up with her and give her frequent financial handouts, because otherwise her DD will be growing up without any family in her life apart from the psycho X, and that's not a fate you'd wish on any child.

My heart bleeds for her dad, though, who hasn't seen her for 10 years. The DD is 15 now and has had her mind thoroughly poisoned against him by X. The father is still trying but I don't think it will ever happen.

Mummabearto2cubs · 17/06/2019 16:42

I'm going through the opposite at the mo. My DD's dad just isn't interested. He lives 3 hours away from us and only wants to visit 1 day a month because of travel costs etc.. which I agreed to only its not a full day, he only wants them from lunchtime until early evening. We agreed the last weekend of every month- he's managed to see them twice in the last 12months despite me keeping every agreed date free for him.

Pinkmouse6 · 17/06/2019 16:42

I would cut them both some slack in this situation.

Your Dad could have fought in court to see you, he could have turned up at your Mum’s door every week asking to see you and you have been an adult for ten years, why hasn’t he been in touch at all? Assuming you are on social media...

It does sound like she prevented access but he has had options and hasn’t taken them. He also obviously treat your Mum appallingly at the time, it’s no wonder she was hurt.

I would let sleeping dogs lie here. Contact your Dad if you think it’s the right thing to do but I wouldn’t waste time blaming your Mum.

SapphireBattersea · 17/06/2019 16:29

OP my heart goes out to you

This is almost exactly what happened in my family.

Feel free to PM me if you would like to chat more x

AcrossthePond55 · 17/06/2019 16:26

I think counseling is a very good idea.

If you want to meet him, could you look at him more as a 'potential friend' rather than a 'father'? Not try to establish a 'father/daughter' bond, but just as someone you'd like to get to know as a friend.

Frankola · 17/06/2019 16:16

I'm sorry you're in this situation. Unfortunately matters like this are rarely black and white.

Unfortunately it would seem that some women do use their kids as a weapon in a breakup. I currently have a Male friend going through a divorce and so far his stbxw has really gone above and beyond to cause him no end of hurt over their kids.

The latest is that she sent him a text telling him his children hate him and no longer want contact. He called his 14 year old to arrange contact and they seemed to have no idea about it.

Yesterday she also sent him a photo of a Father's Day card her kids apparently got her. For being their father figure. He got nothing from his kids. I cant help feeling this was facilitated by her.

Justbreathing · 17/06/2019 16:08

It sounds like both your parents have let you down and behaved selfishly for different reasons. I’m very sorry about that. It was the shit cards you were dealt.
Now you have a dh and kids. A hopefully happy family.
I would 100% go and get some therapy. I think it will really help you.

Pleasebequietnow · 17/06/2019 16:04

asking for 27 years of maintenance payments!

I think you’re minimising this. If he had wanted to see you enough, he would have done. If he had cared, he would have paid. Don’t dismiss years of supporting a DC without help; especially if you were the beneficiary.

Shootingstar1115 · 17/06/2019 15:59

Thank you all. It is has something that has confused me for a long time. I do want to meet him but cannot see myself being close to someone who has missed so much!

I just feel like she felt about their relationship rather than me actually having a dad but I do understand she was hurt and he clearly has issues.

Sounds bad but I feel envious of other people and their relationships with their fathers, how close they are etc. I have my grandad who I always close to but I just feel like I’m lacking something.

My OH has an amazing bond with DD (and DS his stepson). It makes me so emotional that I’ve never had that. Of course I was lucky to have my mum but we haven’t been so close in recent years! She likes things her way or no way and is very controlling and I moved out at a young age!

I think I do need some form of professional help. Not just about my bio father but about other things from my childhood which I won’t go into detail here!

OP posts:
DisgraceToTheYChromosome · 17/06/2019 15:42

DSIL's mother used access as a weapon, until she remarried and HE told HER she'd better grow up and do the right thing. So now we can all sit round a dinner table and not be stabbing each other. Makes DGS's babysitting pool that much larger too.

ArnoldBee · 17/06/2019 15:35

From 1993 if you claimed income support they automatically took a claim for chikd maintenance unless you denied you knew who the father was or you would be in danger if the claim went ahead ie. Domestic violence. The government also took the amount of maintenance you received off you income support payment so you often ended up in a worse position not knowing how much money you were going to have to put food on the table. So people often lied and said they didn't know who the parent was etc as it put them in a better financial position of stability and if the other parent bunged them a fiver for the kid every so often they felt it was a win win. Another poster is right in that now we have Google in our pockets we are able to find out how to do things the proper way. Back then it's unlikely your dad would have gone to court as he wouldn't know what to do. Your mum was hurt at the time and you are judging her by 2019 standards so maybe cut her a little slack. 27 years is actually quite a long time in social history. I still remember a time when you didn't have bins at train ststions...

Bluebell878275 · 17/06/2019 15:33

My DH's ex made contact very difficult. It was extremely controlled. Contact between my DH and his daughter was 'pointless' according to her. There were times when my DH was ready to give up and rely on his daughter making contact one day. I'm not sure how serious he was at the time, I just know he was so worn down - I guess it seemed like the best option all round. Fortunately we pushed, and pushed, and pushed. Got a solicitor involved and eventually things started to settle.

I think a lot of men struggle now with the battle; support for Fathers is only now becoming evident. It must have seemed the best option for many men back in the day.

cranstonmanor · 17/06/2019 15:33

Well, they're human and they made mistakes. The question is now what you need. Do you need information? Counselling for your feelings? Do you want answers? From who? Do you want to contact your dad?

Happyspud · 17/06/2019 15:30

What kind of a shit man has 8 children with 4 women, definitely cheating on at least one of the mums and not attempting to contact one child at least for their whole lifetime.

Your mum may well be a piece of work but your dad doesn’t sound like someone who should be given a break either.

HirplesWithHaggis · 17/06/2019 15:27

Today 15:02 Shootingstar1115

She says that he never paid maintenance, he didn’t but I’m not sure she even tried for it. Back then things were different I believe. To claim income support as a single parent she had to convince them she didn’t know who the dad and I was conceived through a one night stand, to claim income support so they don’t chase the father up? That’s what she told me once but Does that sound correct??

Sort of. Back in the day, it was assumed that absent parents would pay whatever had been decided, and that sum was deducted penny for penny from your Income Support... whether you got it or not. So, no daddy, no deductions. Sound financial reasoning.