Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Leaving midwifery, what’s next?

92 replies

TastingTheRainbow · 26/05/2019 01:10

I have made the decision to leave my job as an NHS midwife. It breaks my heart but sadly I can no longer cope with the short staffing, increasingly busy days and my mental health is suffering. I am crying in bed most nights knowing that I gave terrible care to women as I just couldn’t split myself between the needs of 20 women and their babies when on my own on the ward. The anxiety that one day I’m going to make a mistake or miss something and cost someone their life as a result is crippling.

The question is what next? I have no qualifications or experience in anything other than midwifery as it’s what I’ve always done and always wanted to do. I’m also a direct entry midwife so didn’t qualify as a nurse first.

I can afford to take a pay cut for better work / life balance and I would save on childcare costs anyway so it would balance out.

Can anyone give me any suggestions of what (non NHS jobs) would be open to someone with a degree in midwifery?

OP posts:
SinkGirl · 26/05/2019 19:56

I had a 36 hour prem labour and three different MW - the last one out of kindness did stay past her shift - but as long I was being looked after and my baby was safe I would not have cared whether I had one or three. It sounds ridiculous

You wouldn’t have one midwife for your whole 36 hour labour. The idea is that you would have some contact during labour from a midwife that you know and have seen during your pregnancy, and that you’ll see again during your postnatal period.

That’s the aim anyway. Most places seem to be going with the team model, so you’ll have a named midwife but could see anyone from their small team (4-6) if they are not available.

SinkGirl · 26/05/2019 19:53

so why are your management not screaming out that this system will not work ? On any level ? I would imagine that any MW who has a family will not be able to work in that way?

It’s a national change. Every maternity service will have to meet targets for the number of women who receive continuity of care. At the moment each service is defining it differently, mostly using teams of midwives to try and deliver it. Studies show that it leads to much better outcomes, which is great, but we don’t have the staff or the funding to pull it off.

SusieOwl4 · 26/05/2019 19:50

so why are your management not screaming out that this system will not work ? On any level ? I would imagine that any MW who has a family will not be able to work in that way ?

I had a 36 hour prem labour and three different MW - the last one out of kindness did stay past her shift - but as long I was being looked after and my baby was safe I would not have cared whether I had one or three. It sounds ridiculous .

VanillaCoconutDove · 26/05/2019 19:47

I wouldn’t suggest doing a nursing degree at this stage. Seems a bit of a jumping from the fire to the frying pan scenario really if the nhs budget/staffing situation is the crux of the issue.

Calltheguards · 26/05/2019 19:44

Could you try starting a doula business? I was looking for a doula, just so if needed I would have an additional birthing partner in hospital and my husband could do childcare if we needed. I was quoted around £650 for a birthing package by a student doula and £1000 for an experienced doula in the north west. You could choose how much work you take on.

Mummyme87 · 26/05/2019 19:43

Do private antenatal classes, postnatal care, lactation consultant. I have a friend who went to be a HV, she hated it and is about to start a job as an immunisation nurse (she’s direct entry).
You could do sexual health and top up with some bank shifts in midwifery

Kizziebel · 26/05/2019 19:38

I got back home at 7.30am and after my 25 hours of no sleep could only have 5 hours sleep before going back to work my late shift.

You are entitled to 11 hours rest between shifts, this includes on call work, you shouldn't have been back at work before 6pm. I'm lucky in that my trust are very good with the rest time (not a midwife but do 1 or 2 on calls shifts/week

EarlGrayT · 26/05/2019 19:35

How sad for you that this is the situation. Very few people could cope with that amount of hours without sleep. It would be so difficult to combine with family life.

I work in health research. Some of my colleagues are from a midwifery background. It retains your registration and you do not have had to have been a midwife for a set number of years to go into research. I realise this is not for everyone.

Could you also do breastfeeding support. I know a midwife who is a lactation consultant and she retains her registration and works regular hours.

I do think that many trust will change the way they have interpreted the new frame when they start losing experienced staff.

Waveysnail · 26/05/2019 19:33

2 year graduate accelerated nursing degree?

Blondiecub0109 · 26/05/2019 19:32

You may have answered this already about the direct midwifery/nurse distinction, but many of the nurses at the fertility clinic I had ivf at were previously midwives. 8-4 Monday - Friday, Saturday mornings on a rota

HappyDappy3 · 26/05/2019 19:27

Could you become a midwife at a private wing/hospital? I recently had a baby in a private wing of a London hospital and had my own midwife 1:1 for first 24 hours and then 1:2 for the rest of my stay. It sounds a lot less stressful than your current workload.

Alternatively, look at private maternity nurse work through an agency. Or one of my friends hired a private midwife for her antenatal check ups at home and then took her to the hospital (as a companion) for her NHS birth.

Hope you find a less stressful alternative path 💐

TastingTheRainbow · 26/05/2019 19:27

@thatsnotmyotter For now! Currently 20% of women are case-loaded, that’s soon to change to 40%. Your 1-2 days will then at least double. They are also tightening up on continuity in a team where the woman has only met the midwife who delivers once in pregnancy and moving to a named midwife system. It’s going to get a LOT worse yet.

OP posts:
TastingTheRainbow · 26/05/2019 19:24

@buddytheelf85 Exactly! It’s so dangerous and they don’t seem to recognise this.

Last week I worked an early shift, 7am - 2.30pm I was then on call from 5pm. At 5.40pm I was called out as labour was very busy and needed help. I worked on labour ward from 6pm when I arrived until 7am when I handed over to the day staff. I had been awake for 25 hours at that point and was in no way safe to be delivering babies.

Luckily the lady I cared for had a normal uncomplicated delivery, if there was an emergency I can guarantee I wouldn’t have handled it as well as I normally would.

I got back home at 7.30am and after my 25 hours of no sleep could only have 5 hours sleep before going back to work my late shift.

It’s unrealistic and midwives are leaving in huge numbers due to this. Midwifery is now a profession only those who are young, newly qualified and without children can reasonably do. All the experience of the elder midwives will be lost and care will become more and more unsafe. It’s heartbreaking to watch this happen.

OP posts:
Thatsnotmyotter · 26/05/2019 19:20

The way they are implementing continuity of carer depends on where you work. For me it will just mean working 1-2 shifts per month in the unit in line with my normal community days as we’ll be partnering up with delivery suite midwives.

Buddytheelf85 · 26/05/2019 19:17

The COC thing is such dangerous rubbish. Apart from placing midwives under pressure, I don’t want to be cared for by a midwife who hasn’t slept for 36 hours because she’s been caring for another one of her caseloaded patients. Madness.

ClaraTA · 26/05/2019 19:15

I left my qualified job in social care for very similar reasons, I really feel for you! I now work in the voluntary sector, the pay is less but I am much happier! You obviously have tremendous values and skills that would easily be transferable to a supportive role. It might be worth checking charityjob etc for vacancies local to you. Good luck ☺️

TastingTheRainbow · 26/05/2019 19:13

@munchymunkin I would love to but I’m a direct entry midwife and not a nurse first so in order to maintain my registration (which I would need to in order to keep my job in sexual health) I have to prove that I have been doing midwifery work. Sexual health is considered nursing and proving nursing skills won’t maintain a midwifery registration so I’ll lose my registration and therefore my job.

It’s sadly well researched now that direct entry midwifery simply traps midwives, at the time I thought it was great. In hindsight it’s the worst thing I ever did. If I was a nurse / midwife I would have so many options now!

www.nursingtimes.net/direct-entry-now-means-no-exit-from-the-midwifery-profession/5015601.article

OP posts:
Mummyme87 · 26/05/2019 19:10

tastingtherainbow you don’t need to be sponsored by your hospital to do health visiting. Just apply for it externally. Nothing to do with where you work now.

The COC thing is bollocks. It will not work. There are not enough midwives that can or want to work like this. Myself included

breakfastpizza · 26/05/2019 19:00

I have a friend who left MWery and went into forensic pathology as a sexual offences examiner, taking samples and examining women who have been raped. Awful and difficult job emotionally, but also rewarding knowing that her work has helped to secure convictions in some cases.

I hope I never need this service, but grateful to hear there are highly trained people like your friend caring for victims.

MunchyMunchkin · 26/05/2019 18:59

Come to sexual health! No night shifts, practical work like coils and a fairly easy going client group. Lots of our nurses are Ex midwives.
Or work for bpas or Marie stopes providing abortion care.

SinkGirl · 26/05/2019 18:53

I work for the maternity service in a very part time patient representative role - I think the continuity they’re trying to implement is an absolute disaster waiting to happen in terms of staff retention.

There may be strategic roles available at the CCG if you want to stay involved in maternity.

TastingTheRainbow · 26/05/2019 18:46

Another hospital won’t solve the issue as it’s the same everywhere now and there is also no longer the option to just go into community midwifery.

The continuity of carer that’s being implemented nationally means that women need to have the same midwife all the way through pregnancy, through labour and after the baby has arrived so we are all being forced into covering all areas now with rotating shifts and many on call shifts also. The profession is changing into something that simply isn’t possible when you have children and commitments to juggle also.

My hospital is trialing the system we are expected to soon switch to and it is resulting in being on call 5 nights a week on top of working your full time hours. One of my children is disabled and childcare is already a struggle. Every hospital does it differently right now but once it becomes compulsory they will all end up the same with unrealistic expectations so a change of hospital would be a short term solution only.

Specialising in one area isn’t an option as I have not been qualified long enough and would need several more years experience first.

Private also isn’t an option as no private hospitals in my area have a maternity department, it loses more money than it makes so not many private providers happy to provide midwifery services. The only option for being private is being an independent midwife and again you need a lot of experience to be confident and safe being completely independent.

I have considered health visiting but from what I understand the hospital you work for has to sponsor you through your training and provide work placements. That’s not going to happen, we can’t even afford staff never mind to train staff to leave! If any health visitors know if there is another route to train I would be very interested to know!

Some other options here I’m going to look into also. Thank you for the suggestions.

OP posts:
Livedandlearned · 26/05/2019 10:30

My sister also left midwifery to be a hv and she loves it. No weekends or nights and 9-5

Diemme · 26/05/2019 10:27

I went from midwifery to health visiting 5 years ago. Best decision I've ever made.

MoonstoneMagic · 26/05/2019 10:22

My mother was a midwife and went into Heath Visiting.