Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Aibu to not want to fill a smarties tube with £1 coins

409 replies

Invisimamma · 02/05/2019 20:26

This will be outing if any parents from my child's school are on here...

Both children came home from school and nursery today with a tube of smarties each as a gift from the PTA with instructions to eat them and fill the tube with £1 coins or 20p, letter specifically states not coppers or 5/10ps. Apparently the tube will hold £12 of 20pences.

There will be a prize for the class who brings back the most money.

Now I have a few issues with this:

  1. my friends child has a diary allergy was really upset he can't eat his treat (she didn't know this was happening so couldn't provide an alternative)
  2. we still have lots of Easter chocolate and don't need more
  3. dp and I both work but childcare and other costs are crippling us at the moment and we're skint, an extra £24 is really beyond us just now
  4. we've just paid £46 snack money to nursery and £12 for a school trip for one and £8 for a trip for another (amongst lots of other recent school costs)
  5. does anyone even has coins lying around the house anymore? I use contactless payment for almost everything and don't draw out cash.

The children have been hyped up about it and both have said they need to raise money for the school. I guess I'm feeling guilty that we're not in a position to participate/it's a pain in the arse idea.

OP posts:
ILoveMaxiBondi · 03/05/2019 11:08

Have they got £12 spare and wouldn’t mind changing it into 20p coins and doing it as a bit of fun with the dc?

😂😂😂 what??

Kaddm · 03/05/2019 11:06

Could you ask a grandparent to do it with them? Have they got £12 spare and wouldn’t mind changing it into 20p coins and doing it as a bit of fun with the dc?

ILoveMaxiBondi · 03/05/2019 11:06

I’d support my PTA arranging for the children to take their empty tubes to the offices off all those skiving bastards who are supposed to be at stormont and asking them to fill the tubes with £1 coins. Those fuckers are the reason the schools have no money here.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/05/2019 11:04

Oh my god, moan moan moan. Fine, don't contribute, chuck it in the bin, complain to the school, whatever.

I'd agree with you if this were targeted directly at (presumably non-vulnerable) adults. School staff and representatives are universally considered as wise, trusted adults by the vast majority of children (up to a certain age, at least) and they would never think to question their abilities or motives.

It's the children who are being given the Smarties and told that they must fill up the tubes with quite a sum of money, with it being made into a game and a competition with prizes to win. This is just pure exploitation and emotional blackmail of youngsters.

MrsWillGardner · 03/05/2019 11:02

I’d fill it with 5p’s, regardless of what it said on the letter, and when I sent it in, I’d send it with a note saying to be glad you’re getting anything as this is all I could afford! Bloody cheeky school!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/05/2019 10:56

Look, if it’s a state school you really do have a moral obligation to contribute as much as you can even if that means going withoutholidays, new clothes etc.

Whatever are you talking about?! People (not just parents) pay taxes to fund state schools. Yes, budget cuts have forced many schools to make drastic reductions in often important areas, but I fail to see how successive governments' decisions to divert taxpayers' money elsewhere - frequently to profligate, pointless and/or morally dubious/reprehensible causes - translates into my moral obligation to give more money to running the state school system.

WeepingWillowWeepingWino · 03/05/2019 10:54

Oh my god, moan moan moan. Fine, don't contribute, chuck it in the bin, complain to the school, whatever.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/05/2019 10:50

aren't they meant to take the tube around friends and neighbours and ask them to donate to the cause? I don't think there's any requirement that you personally have to fill it.

That actually makes it worse, though. It's annoying enough when people hassle you to give to THEIR favourite charity, out of the thousands of charities in existence, even if that charity does largely undeniably good work locally/in society/the world (although, even then, people have genuine misgivings - as per the threads about Comic Relief and unscrupulous fund raising methods).

Whoever would assume that people without children at a particular school (or without children at all) would actually care about contributing to a random school? Those without children have already paid a lot in taxes for educating other people's children and those with kids at a different school will surely direct any extra PTA giving to their own kids' school.

Many churches and religious organisations are run as charities, and often rely on giving by their members and visitors - but nobody would ever suggest that outsiders should or would consider giving money to a cause that means nothing whatsoever to them.

Cheekyfeckery · 03/05/2019 10:46

No.

Just no. It’s grabby.

If it were for charity, to help children in poverty or something relevant to children of that age, then yes. But for the PTA? Absolutely not.

PTAs are meant to be about the community of the school. Working together, supporting the school by raising funds and everyone benefitting. It’s give and take, not throwing money into a pit.

I wonder if there is a lack of volunteers or enthusiasm which is why they are looking at a quick fix?

Don’t worry about your children feeling left out - there’s plenty of other ways to contribute. To the PTA or some other charity that’s less grabby.

TheOrigRightsofwomen · 03/05/2019 10:40

Look, if it’s a state school you really do have a moral obligation to contribute as much as you can even if that means going withoutholidays, new clothes etc.

No I don't.

BogglesGoggles · 03/05/2019 10:37

Look, if it’s a state school you really do have a moral obligation to contribute as much as you can even if that means going withoutholidays, new clothes etc. If you can contribute nothing then you don’t. Just explain to your children that you can afford it. It will be a good lesson for them.

Playmytune · 03/05/2019 10:32

I was always taught that you gave a “gift” because you wanted too, not to get something back!
So kind of the pta to spend a few pence on their gift to the pupils, but want back many times the value of that gift!
We had this at my children’s school, and it was specified as £1 coins. Due to my husband being very ill and unable to work (off for 9 months, so on half what was already a poor wage, plus the extra cost of travelling for treatment) I could barely afford the extra cost of a multipack of smarties never mind fill the tubes up with £1 coins (3 children so 3 tubes). I spoke to the head teacher who responded to just fill 1 tube, and he would explain to the pta! I don’t think he believed how hard up we were and even 1 tube filled would make the difference between my kids being fed and not being fed!
In the end, to prevent my children being picked on, I sent in the 3 tubes, filled with 1p coins, which was more than I could actually afford! That’s the problem with pta’s which are run by the well off parents, who think that just because they can afford it so can everyone else.

Strongecoffeeismydrug · 03/05/2019 10:14

My daughters school do this every year!
I put 5 twenty pences in and that's it .
She enjoyed joining in and I saved myself a few quid for the next fundraiser that will be thrust upon us .

ctrlalt · 03/05/2019 10:13

Chuck some Monopoly money in.

The cheek. I bet the prize is a tube of smarties.

ILoveMaxiBondi · 03/05/2019 10:04

Oh FGS!

Ours only got their smartie tubes on Wednesday and this morning a mum has already uploaded a photo of her child holding up Their filled smartie tube to the PTA fb page. Hmm this is really a competition for the mums.

hibbledibble · 03/05/2019 09:51

I agree with you op. Saying no small change is unfair on low income families, who may only be able to give coppers.

When I was at school we were given film canisters to fill with coppers. This seems more acceptable, apart from the plastic issue, which people weren't so aware of then.

Personally I would rather give by bank transfer or direct debit. I don't have time to faff about with change or participate in cake sales.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 03/05/2019 09:39

I' send it back, with the sweets still in it. I'd add a link to Milkwatch and Mark Thomas nd ask why n Earth they are supporting Nestle?

www.theguardian.com/business/2018/feb/01/nestle-under-fire-for-marketing-claims-on-baby-milk-formulas

www.babymilkaction.org/nestlefree

And then I would ask them to send the tube back to you full of pound coins or 20ps as you are fund raising to keep your family in good health!

Sadly PTAs are full of well meaning people who are well off enought o be able to spare the time and effort to be active on the committee. Few of them have the experience of wacthing the coppers and living a truly hand to mouth experince! £20 is wouldn't be much of an issue to moist of them and the would be very surprised at the pressures such a fund rainsing action can put on parents with little or no disposable income!

It really should be banned, along with all other advertising / fundraising that uses 'Pester Power'

mrsglowglow · 03/05/2019 09:24

If they had just said fill with any change and bring in whatever the amount that would have been fun and PTA would still have a nice sum. The competition aspect is awful and puts the children from wealthier families at an advantage. Activities like this can chip away at children's confidence from such an early age and I do think primary schools could do a lot better at ensuring children are treated equally. Our primary school did similar and went as far as photographing and naming the top 5 biggest fund raisers on their news letter. They also held an annual tennis tournament that the whole school had to watch and it was the same winning children year after year who were raved about in the news letter. They failed to mention that these children were the ones who received weekly tennis coaching after school at a hefty cost while the other children may have had a handful of PE sessions where they could have a go a tennis.

Langrish · 03/05/2019 09:19

Sagradafamiliar

I'd be tempted to write 'fuck off' on a rolled up piece of paper and slip it into the tube”

Grin
Sagradafamiliar · 03/05/2019 09:17

The prize would probably be another tube of smarties anyway.

DonkeyHohtay · 03/05/2019 09:16

I'd also ask what the money being raised is for and why are they sitting on £7k.

Fine to ask what the money is being raised for.

As for the healthy bank balance - not unusual in May/April in my experience. School budgets are generally set from 1st April to 31st March (or at least they are in Scotland). At the beginning of April the Head crunches the numbers to see what they can afford to do and works out what extras they'd like the PTA to help fund. Our Treasurer often dished out loads of cash through May and June, booking things for the following academic year or committing to the purchase of ipads or sound systems. Then by August we'd be back down to very little and the cycle would all start all over again.

GrassIsntGreener · 03/05/2019 09:16

Giving children a prize for bringing the most money is disgusting imo.

woollyheart · 03/05/2019 09:16

It's a very manipulative way to go about raising money. We've given you Smarties so now you are obliged to give us money!

I find this approach very distasteful and would be teaching my children that donating to good causes is a great thing, but NOT when someone tries to manipulate you like this. So I would ignore it and we would think of something worthwhile we could do instead.

Sagradafamiliar · 03/05/2019 09:16

I'd be tempted to write 'fuck off' on a rolled up piece of paper and slip it into the tube, but in reality would just put it in the recycling.
It's the 'no coppers or 5s' that angers me. Any money should be gratefully accepted but instead they are pressuring and alienating people by demanding more. Wrong.

azulmariposa · 03/05/2019 09:14

The competition aspect of it is crap. Puts so much pressure on kids, that don't understand the value of money just yet. My school said no pennies- guess what I did! Wink

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread