Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Aibu to not want to fill a smarties tube with £1 coins

409 replies

Invisimamma · 02/05/2019 20:26

This will be outing if any parents from my child's school are on here...

Both children came home from school and nursery today with a tube of smarties each as a gift from the PTA with instructions to eat them and fill the tube with £1 coins or 20p, letter specifically states not coppers or 5/10ps. Apparently the tube will hold £12 of 20pences.

There will be a prize for the class who brings back the most money.

Now I have a few issues with this:

  1. my friends child has a diary allergy was really upset he can't eat his treat (she didn't know this was happening so couldn't provide an alternative)
  2. we still have lots of Easter chocolate and don't need more
  3. dp and I both work but childcare and other costs are crippling us at the moment and we're skint, an extra £24 is really beyond us just now
  4. we've just paid £46 snack money to nursery and £12 for a school trip for one and £8 for a trip for another (amongst lots of other recent school costs)
  5. does anyone even has coins lying around the house anymore? I use contactless payment for almost everything and don't draw out cash.

The children have been hyped up about it and both have said they need to raise money for the school. I guess I'm feeling guilty that we're not in a position to participate/it's a pain in the arse idea.

OP posts:
gamerwidow · 03/05/2019 15:08

This particular idea is poorly thought out and I would do it at our school. However state schools are desperate for money. They can barely afford staff let alone all the other necessities a school needs. £7k in the bank at this point in the year is normal for a PTA. ours is currently saving for a new set of laptops we need £10k to get enough for a whole class to use. Currently the IT the school have is so unreliable that they often have to abandon IT lessons altogether. There’s a whole section of the syllabus our kids are missing because the school equipment isn’t fit for purpose.
I understand it’s annoying and if you can’t afford to contribute that’s fair enough but if parents don’t pay then no one else will buy the stuff the school needs. It’s shit but that’s where we are with education in this country at the moment.

pelirocco123 · 03/05/2019 14:52

One set ofgrandchildren sed to go to a school that was always raising money for PTA funds and in the early days ( new school) they would raise thousands , and then just spend it for the sake of spending it . I always felt they should have at least donated some of the money raised at the summer / christmas fetes to charity . At least spending money at fetes is something you can choose not to do and escape the guilt .
One of my other grandsons came home with a request for money and he insisted his teacher said they had bring it in .

They often get requests for school trips and holidays and the requests for payment are just before Christmas

ILoveMaxiBondi · 03/05/2019 14:31

go out to the bank? Come on, you're being ridiculous.

Gran, I'm raising money for school, I want to try to fill my Smarties tube!

OK, let me see what I've got in my purse - here's 50p.

No. The poster said “Have they got £12 spare and wouldn’t mind changing it into 20p coins and doing it as a bit of fun with the dc?"

I don’t know about you but my parents don’t tend to hold a reserve of 20ps. It would be a trip to the bank For sure to fulfil that request.

Topseyt · 03/05/2019 14:31

Look, if it’s a state school you really do have a moral obligation to contribute as much as you can even if that means going withoutholidays, new clothes etc

Bollocks! No, we don't. We have a moral obligation to feed and clothe our families, and this sort of twattery from schools is thoughtless because it badly impacts families who can already be struggling.

DD1 went to a state grammar school. I remember one year they decided that in order to raise money for a variety of things they would send home standing order forms and a suggestion that parents should pay a monthly £40 - £50 on a pretty much open ended basis. We couldn't afford it so I filed the form carefully in our recycling bin. A few weeks later they threatened my DD with a detention because she hadn't brought the completed form back!!

They sent another form. This time I completed it, by just writing on it that we couldn't afford this, wouldn't be contributing in that manner and I expected that to be the end of the matter. I signed and dated it too. Strangely enough, we heard nothing more about it.

Some schools just don't get the impact that some of these ideas can have on families.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 03/05/2019 14:16

Go to the bank... change some money Well, as our nearest bank is more than 10 miles away I doubt m/any people will be volunteering for that little road trip - adding pollution, petrol, mileage, wear and tear on the car etc etc etc.

Daft idea that shows, again, that some poeple can't always see beyond their own circumstances!

Anytime · 03/05/2019 13:58

My children's school did this last year. I think it's disgraceful. Our PTA organised it. It's encouraging unhealthy eating AND putting pressure on family finances. Awful all round.

Tobebythesea · 03/05/2019 13:55

I personally don’t see it as cheeky. Schools are seriously underfunded.

You have the option to ignore it or return the smarties!

I’d put in £1/£2 worth of 20ps in so it raises something and covers the cost of the smarties.

babysharkah · 03/05/2019 13:36

I quite like the idea as a saving money scheme for myself. Absolutely not for a school competition, ridiculous.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/05/2019 13:31

go out to the bank? Come on, you're being ridiculous.

Gran, I'm raising money for school, I want to try to fill my Smarties tube!

OK, let me see what I've got in my purse - here's 50p.

Job done. No pressure. Back to whatever they were doing.

To quote the PP:

"Could you ask a grandparent to do it with them? Have they got £12 spare and wouldn’t mind changing it into 20p coins and doing it as a bit of fun with the dc?"

Do you tend to have 60 20p pieces to hand as a matter of routine? I certainly don't.

Pigsinduvets · 03/05/2019 13:26

I’d get the DCs to write a note inside saying “We don’t have enough money for this “ because it’s the truth.

formerbabe · 03/05/2019 13:03

@formerbabe that's the opposite of charity though isn't it - wanting your money to benefit you

I never said I was a fan of charity or wanted to give to charity. I don't. I'm skint. If I must donate to something via my dcs school, my preference is that the money benefits the school directly and subsequently my DC.

KittyVonCatsington · 03/05/2019 12:48

that's the opposite of charity though isn't it - wanting your money to benefit you.

Schools are not-for-profit organisations. Perfectly acceptable to raise money for a school as 'charity'. It is not only benefitting you.

justasking111 · 03/05/2019 12:41

On top of all this... we have fancy dress day, Jeans for genes, red nose, etc. etc. That mounts up.

To be fair the PTA have paid for all outdoor improvements, all the computers, the books, colouring in stuff. Every penny is spent, decided by the Head teacher. The list of the schools needs are endless. I sometimes wonder if the allocation for each child is swallowed up by salaries, etc. with too little left over. Now in Wales it has been cut again, the teaching assistants are for the chop.

ArgyMargy · 03/05/2019 12:40

@formerbabe that's the opposite of charity though isn't it - wanting your money to benefit you.

formerbabe · 03/05/2019 12:35

If it were for charity, to help children in poverty or something relevant to children of that age, then yes. But for the PTA?

I disagree with this. If I have to donate money, I'd rather it went to help the school and therefore my own children.

PotterHead1985 · 03/05/2019 12:26

Jeepers ye should be glad ye're not in Ireland! Primary school was forever having cake sales, quiz nights etc. Secondary school worse again! €300 voluntary contibution or €500 if you have two daughters in the school! Then sponsored walks, cakes sales, Christmas fair. Never ends! Then books and uniform in first year nearly €1,000. And no these are not private schools! Oh and then essential costs like locker rental, photocopying etc. €130 per year.

My secondary schools 'voluntary' contribution in Ireland was 500 pound per child in 1997. I was from a poor single parent no job household. They HOUNDED my mother near weekly for the 'voluntary' contribution. And that was only the start of it.

Hollyhobbi · 03/05/2019 12:21

Forgot about the school photos. And it is the same photographer every year! One year they were so slow getting them back to us we had to collect them in the school holidays! And they had been paid for months before! At least they don't have this in secondary schools.

WeepingWillowWeepingWino · 03/05/2019 12:10

go out to the bank? Come on, you're being ridiculous.

Gran, I'm raising money for school, I want to try to fill my Smarties tube!

OK, let me see what I've got in my purse - here's 50p.

Job done. No pressure. Back to whatever they were doing.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/05/2019 11:58

I just tried to make a suggestion to help the OP. She can disregard it if it isn’t helpful.
There’s no need to ridicule it. We are supposed to be helping each other on this site.

Not meaning to be unkind, but it just seems very grabby and unkind to transfer the pressure to give straight on to grandparents and consider it all sorted. It doesn't sound like the most fun or quality time that a GP and GC can share - GP has to go out to the bank and then sit and watch as GC takes 2 minutes to drop coins into a sweet tube.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/05/2019 11:54

Could you ask a grandparent to do it with them? Have they got £12 spare and wouldn’t mind changing it into 20p coins and doing it as a bit of fun with the dc?

For some reason, that instantly brought to mind the old Catherine Tate character who was involved in a foreign romance scam and blissfully unaware that she was being completely taken for a ride.

"We have a relationship based on love. I send him money whenever he asks for it.... and he loves that!"

TheABC · 03/05/2019 11:31

Complain. This is badly thought out and unnecessary.

I am on the PTA of my local school and every action we take is measured against the hypothetical family of three on a low income. Time and cash are always in short supply and we know that most parents only remember on the morning of the event and may grab something on the way out of the door. For the bottle tombola at the Christmas Fair (for example), we get anything from whiskey to washing up liquid! We don't place any restrictions on the bottle types for that reason.

You never expect a 100% attendance or contribution and we do not shame the kids or prevent them from taking part (e.g. a dress-down day).

If you want to add some humour, buy chocolate coins to take in.

AGirlHasNoCake · 03/05/2019 11:28

This drives me crazy. Our kids school once did something similar - I had 3 at school, and one of the teachers told DD she was selfish for not taking part.

Another year we were instructed to bring in items for a hamper that would be raffled at the Summer Ball. (tickets: £160 a couple). So poor families to contribute to raffle prizes only available to those who can afford £160 tickets.

Another ripping wheeze was for "homework" - to make a cracker filled with toys and sweets for the school christmas fair. Homework. Hmm so not voluntary at all. And they did this every year.

The PTA mummies have no frikking idea how some struggle.

Now kids are in senior school, there is a voluntary donation scheme in £5 increments that no-one pushes, its just "available to buy" on the school payment system. So if I'm feeling flush, I put a £5 or £10 in. If not, there's no pressure.

Oh and I grew up in country where we paid school fees. I wouldn't mind this. But I hate the emotional blackmail of children, making them feel bad for the financial situation of their parents.

MachineBee · 03/05/2019 11:17

Sorry I haven’t RTFT but wanted to comment as this sort of thing really gets me cross.

I used to chair a PTA and cannot tell you how many requests we had from the school to run competitive fund raising events between classes for the teachers. One new head wanted to do this EVERY TERM!!!! ‘to teach the children about charity for those less fortunate’ Hmm

My DCs school was in an ok area but it certainly wasn’t that well heeled.

I would write to the Chair of Governors copying in the headteacher and PTA chair setting out how this adds unnecessary pressure on families and sends out the message that it’s only money that counts to be kind, caring or successful.

There are lots of imaginative ways children can learn about being charitable without it coming down to cash all the time.

Kaddm · 03/05/2019 11:14

I just tried to make a suggestion to help the OP. She can disregard it if it isn’t helpful.
There’s no need to ridicule it. We are supposed to be helping each other on this site.

notatwork · 03/05/2019 11:11

YY to PP polished pennies!
Not as important how many as how shiny!

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.