Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Aibu to not want to fill a smarties tube with £1 coins

409 replies

Invisimamma · 02/05/2019 20:26

This will be outing if any parents from my child's school are on here...

Both children came home from school and nursery today with a tube of smarties each as a gift from the PTA with instructions to eat them and fill the tube with £1 coins or 20p, letter specifically states not coppers or 5/10ps. Apparently the tube will hold £12 of 20pences.

There will be a prize for the class who brings back the most money.

Now I have a few issues with this:

  1. my friends child has a diary allergy was really upset he can't eat his treat (she didn't know this was happening so couldn't provide an alternative)
  2. we still have lots of Easter chocolate and don't need more
  3. dp and I both work but childcare and other costs are crippling us at the moment and we're skint, an extra £24 is really beyond us just now
  4. we've just paid £46 snack money to nursery and £12 for a school trip for one and £8 for a trip for another (amongst lots of other recent school costs)
  5. does anyone even has coins lying around the house anymore? I use contactless payment for almost everything and don't draw out cash.

The children have been hyped up about it and both have said they need to raise money for the school. I guess I'm feeling guilty that we're not in a position to participate/it's a pain in the arse idea.

OP posts:
HexagonalBattenburg · 03/05/2019 19:20

I'm a governor and I'm on the PTA. This idea comes up occasionally in meetings and always gets blocked - more than anything else, with the way some of our more affluent parents kick off and refuse to pay for school trip contributions etc - we reckon we'd come out at a massive loss for buying the Smarties and not getting any money back! (Yes we have an issue with affluent parents refusing to pay for anything school related - guess it's obvious how they're affording the three Mercs and swimming pool in the garden really!

Our PTA has a given amount they tend to keep in reserve at this point in the year - but they do so because they KNOW that to put on the summer fair will cost a certain amount of money initially in stock and they make sure that's in reserve to do so. They also hold a very strong line on not funding things that should be covered by the school's finances... although school funding in general is a fucking terrible situation that can't be understated how bad it's got incidentally. We simply would not do this and would definitely NOT do anything in a competitive, parental pressure manner as a matter of course... actually it's some of the skintest parents in the school who hold up the PTA in ours - and yes I include my own family in that!

Our PTA funds requests from the school - things like a dedicated baking area, new library building, forest school equipment - the stuff that enhances provision and really makes a difference to the kids' time there. It's stuff the school staff specifically have asked for to enhance the curriculum - not the stereotypical MN view of a bunch of busybodies sitting there deciding what to do with the school - the staff make requests, and the PTA vote to approve or deny (and that has happened) them accordingly.

Hanspannerly · 03/05/2019 19:18

I agree that the school has made a mistake turning this into a competition and specifying the type of coins to be used.

However, donating when possible to the PTA (if you can afford it) is so important. Our PTA and school is implementing poverty proofing but still need to raise funds. Our funds mostly go towards reducing the cost of school trips by £6 per child per trip (which is x3 a year) so parents see a good return for their donations. The situation in some schools is so desperate that PTA funds are needed for vital services and supplies. It’s terrible.

Laura221 · 03/05/2019 19:14

Wtf. No way would I be doing that. I have 3 kids. Not a chance in hell.

Anytime · 03/05/2019 19:11

When our PTA does did it we also had the threat of the class who returned the most getting a prize. They even sent a note encouraging kids to ask friends and family for the 20ps. It is totally crazy.

But then our PTA also send an empty paper plate home with the kids twice a year (at least) giving them a day to return them full of cakes to be sold! This is usually in the same week we are asked for contributions to the teachers presents (which I have no problem at all with) and the class raffle box!

Streamside · 03/05/2019 19:02

What about making it clear to the school that you're not happy with it.People are under so much pressure and it's very unfair.My 80 year old mother sits with her friends and knits woollen caps for the local maternity unit They're never really thanked and the caps are given away for free.When the hospital runs low in caps they contact them.These little ladies sit at a £2.00 luncheon club and buy their own wool to provide this service.

Insanelysilver · 03/05/2019 18:50

It’s quite a lot of money to expect parents to find and telling the kiddos there’s a competition for the class getting the most money, really adds to that pressure..
Makes you feel like filling the tube with toy money lol

YouBumder · 03/05/2019 18:36

Oh and when we did it the tubes didn’t have names on them (although they were collected by class) so no one knows who returned them and who didn’t. All the PTA are trying to do is raise money to improve everyone’s children’s school experience. Bashing and criticism from people who never get off their arse to help while happily letting their children reap the benefits of the funds raised get on my wick.

Citygirl2019 · 03/05/2019 18:35

My DC school did this. I never filed them fully. Just put a few in each to take back.

YouBumder · 03/05/2019 18:33

Is it the school or the PTA? Our PTA do this as well.

Not everyone participates so don’t feel bad if you don’t. And there’s certainly no pressure to send the tubes back full. But maybe if you could think of some other ways the PTA could raise funds that you do approve of you could maybe let them know or even better join the PTA and help out yourself.

peachdribble · 03/05/2019 18:30

If you can’t afford it then ignore it or fill it with whatever you can. It’s very exclusive of the school to allow this to go ahead, as well as dangerous when considering food allergies - I would definitely complain

Fallingrain · 03/05/2019 18:30

I would treat this in the category that I treat all such requests - as entirely optional. I do about a third of what is asked for our school Xmas fair. I often volunteer for stalls etc and that’s just as valuable, if not more, than handing over cash. I understand it’s difficult for DC but in the medium/long term, it’s no bad thing for them to learn that not everything is affordable all the time. I suspect they are not going to open them at school so if it really bothers you, fill with coppers and put a quid on top. I think that makes the point that it’s too much of an ask.

I live in a wealthy area and our PTA never asks for anything like that much. £12 per child is crazy. Are you 100% sure you are supposed to fill it up?

TheGrey1houndSpeaks · 03/05/2019 18:29

It’s once a year, all you dental nuts, not once a week. Calm down Hmm

sawsan · 03/05/2019 18:24

This is shocking! Not just the expectation of money but the encouragement to eat sweets. Surely that is at odds with the curriculum and healthy eating? I wonder what the local dentists would think?

sawsan · 03/05/2019 18:21

This is shocking- for the expectation of monies plus the encouragement to eat sugar-the 'hidden curticulum' is important. I wonder what the reaction of the children's dentists would be 🙀

Ifyoudontlaughyouwillcry · 03/05/2019 18:12

I’m on a PTA and am a governor. Neither the head teacher, the governing body or the PTA of our school would accept this CFery. We are a mix of fairly comfortable families and families who struggle. If we ask for contributions for tombolas we say one per family. I’m astonished by the number of posters saying their school does this. Please DO NOT engage with this. If a PTA has 7K in the bank then that is disgraceful- they are merely the custodians for monies donate to the school to spend on the school not to boast a healthy balance. No PTA in my opinion should have more than 2 or 3K in the bank!

LipstickHandbagCoffee · 03/05/2019 18:10

I’ve read some right ole chuff on mn.but this tops everything.utter fuckery
Look, if it’s a state school you really do have a moral obligation to contribute as much as you can even if that means going withoutholidays, new clothes etc. If you can contribute nothing then you don’t.Just explain to your children that you can afford it. It will be a good lesson for them

Let’s address those points
even if that means going withoutholidays,new clothes
There is no amount of money I’d give the pta that equals cost of our family holiday

Just explain to the kids that I can afford it. My kids know I generally give the PTA nada,nothing,nowt. I don’t give money. No money.ever. Occasionally I’ll rummage for some tinned food, a shop bought cake that’s it.only if I can be bothered

justasking111 · 03/05/2019 18:09

In Wales they have cut education to increase NHS funds to health boards they say. Their opinion being we cannot have it all ways there is only so much money in the coffers. So schools are having to scrounge even more now. I look forward to an improvement in our health service (cough)

Ihatemyseleffordoingthis · 03/05/2019 18:05

If parents keep on plugging the gap left by inadequate funding nothing will ever change.

Fifflefaffle · 03/05/2019 18:01

I wouldn't fill it.
But I also see how desperate schools are for money (not enough pens and pencils etc)
It is not our responsibility to fund schools.

WindsweptEgret · 03/05/2019 18:00

One way to make money for the PTA is to set up easyfunding. Then when people shop online, the retailers make a small donation to the cause. I think that provided the PTA is a registered charity, it should qualify. Our school does this, but so does our Scout group. I choose to donate to our Scout group, I haven't raised much though, as I don't buy much. I think the issue is that no parent can donate to everything, even when it's free.

contentedsoul · 03/05/2019 17:59

They did this when our son was at primary school
I thought it was bloody cheeky, especially as they would constantly cancel events "due to staffing issues" but then expect parents to pour cash into the school coffers.
Needless to say, my son politely turned down the tube of smarties as we had promised to buy him 2 from the newsagents after falling to this scam the previous year. A few other parents did the same - lol

I'm all for donations - but it's on my terms, sorry

Saltylandcat · 03/05/2019 17:57

As a member of a PTA who has done a smartie challenge this Easter I am a bit in shock at the high handedness of this. We are grateful for whatever contributions made whether they are pennies or pounds.
Also we gave them out at the end of last term so before the chocolate glut. We suggested that the kids earn't the money by doing little jobs over the holidays for either their family or friends/neighbours so at least the patents got something of it rather than just being fleeced!
We try to be really careful about how we word things so that people don't feel too much pressure.

LipstickHandbagCoffee · 03/05/2019 17:53

PTA are really out of order. Any contribution must be voluntary and not imposed
I’d email HT explain your misgivings I wouldn’t get into a debacle with the pta cows
It’s a horrific thing to model to kids,that money will make you popular et a prize

artyone · 03/05/2019 17:52

m3lon you almost had me there Confused

gamerwidow · 03/05/2019 17:52

One way to make money for the PTA is to set up easyfunding. Then when people shop online, the retailers make a small donation to the cause. I think that provided the PTA is a registered charity, it should qualify.
We’ve had this for 6 years and made a grand total of about £60. It should be an easy win but parents either want to use their own cash back site like top or just don’t want the hassle of downloading an app or tool bar to track cash back from purchases.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.