Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Aibu to not want to fill a smarties tube with £1 coins

409 replies

Invisimamma · 02/05/2019 20:26

This will be outing if any parents from my child's school are on here...

Both children came home from school and nursery today with a tube of smarties each as a gift from the PTA with instructions to eat them and fill the tube with £1 coins or 20p, letter specifically states not coppers or 5/10ps. Apparently the tube will hold £12 of 20pences.

There will be a prize for the class who brings back the most money.

Now I have a few issues with this:

  1. my friends child has a diary allergy was really upset he can't eat his treat (she didn't know this was happening so couldn't provide an alternative)
  2. we still have lots of Easter chocolate and don't need more
  3. dp and I both work but childcare and other costs are crippling us at the moment and we're skint, an extra £24 is really beyond us just now
  4. we've just paid £46 snack money to nursery and £12 for a school trip for one and £8 for a trip for another (amongst lots of other recent school costs)
  5. does anyone even has coins lying around the house anymore? I use contactless payment for almost everything and don't draw out cash.

The children have been hyped up about it and both have said they need to raise money for the school. I guess I'm feeling guilty that we're not in a position to participate/it's a pain in the arse idea.

OP posts:
tor8181 · 02/05/2019 22:07

mine dont do school as we home ed but a family in the street had 8 kids(few sets of twins)in the one primary

if this happened to her i would feel so sorry for her

RomanyQueen1 · 02/05/2019 22:03

This is terrible, yes fundraising is important but schools are part of the wider community that can help raise money.
Does the school have a PTA?

I wouldn't be doing it and nor did I do any of the charity things.
I can't afford much and have a particular charity I give to, when I can.
Parents shouldn't feel as though they have to do this so their dc won't be left out, that's awful.

JemSynergy · 02/05/2019 22:02

Our school does this and I don't participate. In fact I now ignore all fundraising that involves food wanted as donations or sold deemed unhealthy according to their over the top pack lunch policy.

birdinatree · 02/05/2019 22:00

YES the bloody cake sales which don't even make financial sense as they're sold at a loss.
Just let the kids stand at the gate with a contactless card reader and get a quid or two off everyone that way - no faff, more cash!

Teenagemaw · 02/05/2019 21:58

Fill with 1p's then put 2 20p's on top

bibbitybobbityyhat · 02/05/2019 21:58

Genuinely, this is one of the most shocking things I have ever read on Mumsnet and I've been here for 12+ years!

Is this even true?

I haven't read the whole thread as I'm so gobsmacked by your OP but has anyone in the previous 103 messages actually defended this unbelievable idea?

This is one I'd like to see in the Daily Mail and I never thought I'd say that.

Butterfly84 · 02/05/2019 21:57

Wtf? Let them eat the smarties and don't return the tubes. So cheeky to ask/request donations like that through children who will see it as fun...and the parents take the financial hit.

cdtaylornats · 02/05/2019 21:52

Presumably the school would have a fit if you put the Smarties in their lunch.

FancyAPint · 02/05/2019 21:52

I'd let them eat them then fill it with coppers and tell the DC's you had special permission if they say anything or if you have to fill it up then say at the end you had to give it to the teacher early but keep it, better still let them eat them and ignore it all!

bettycat81 · 02/05/2019 21:50

The way our PTA run it is any coins that fit (but 20p's are the best fit due to shape) no pressure to fill to the top. All returned tubes are named, emptied and put into a tombola. A few are pulled out and win a prize. (So no pressure to collect the most).

We are just happy if we make a profit over the cost of the tubes (usually 25p each).

For a PTA (or any other organisation) that relies on only a few volunteers this is an easy fundraiser to run.

Oblahdeeoblahdoe · 02/05/2019 21:49

Send the Smarties back and say you are boycotting Nestle as a family I'd also ask what the money being raised is for and why are they sitting on £7k.

RhiWrites · 02/05/2019 21:47

I don’t buy Nestlé products either.

And this challenge sounds really cruel to lower income families. OP?”, if you do want to do it I suggest looking for money in the gutters. Any 20p the kids find they put in the tube, any other coin they keep. They’ll end up with a couple of 20ps and a £1 of copper I think. I used to pick up money as a kid and I found 20p just last week.

HariboLecter · 02/05/2019 21:46

If every child just brought 5p each that would be a hell of a lot of money for not much effort.

If we'd done that at my primary they'd have raised the grand sum of about £7 Grin

OhDearGodLookAtThisMess · 02/05/2019 21:44

Our school does this. But I would say that under half of each class actually returns the tubes filled with coins.

Doesn't stop them eating the Smarties though!

JaneEyre07 · 02/05/2019 21:42

My DD and her DH are on a low income, and she's really struggling with the demands from the PTA and the playgroup committee within the same school. I often end up helping her out by donating items for raffles/making cakes etc and I've told her she needs to attend a meeting and express how crap some of it makes her feel.

bellaellie · 02/05/2019 21:40

Isn't the government funding the school? Hmm

Graphista · 02/05/2019 21:40

Sophia I hope you take back to your pta that any fundraising activity that marks out poorer family's and their children is an unacceptable way to fundraise.

Goldmandra · 02/05/2019 21:38

I'd fill it with pennies and send it back with a note daring them to mention the 'not pennies' rule to my child and asking them to make sure that future fund raising projects do not put pressure on anyone who might struggle to give more than 10p.

This is PTA CFery at it's best and needs challenging.

slappinthebass · 02/05/2019 21:38

Then complained because I sent a 6 pack bought in ASDA for £3 (honestly... the kids loved them, still made £1.20 out of them and no FT working single mother and allergic child were harmed in their production)

My dd's old school rejected cakes I slaved over once because apparently they didn't accept home made. Zero mention of this in the letter. They looked at me like I was mad. Child 2 is in a much more middle class area school now and it's out of my league gold standard home made cakes at the school fairs.

formerbabe · 02/05/2019 21:36

I'd fill it with a few twenty pence pieces...no more than £2 worth. I wouldn't be filling it up all the way.

Graphista · 02/05/2019 21:36

I'm so glad dd is done with school!

I could not have afforded to do this and I suspect there will be families within the same school in the same position - is it possible to check stats on free school meals recipients in a school?

I'd be speaking to the head of the pta and the head teacher on how ill thought out and prejudicial this is to poorer family's and particularly the children of those poorer family's who could well end up very embarrassed or even bullied as a result of this stunt!

There's also the food allergy/intolerance issue which they clearly didn't check or even think about!

Appallingly badly planned all round.

Especially when as you say the pta funds are pretty healthy at the moment - why ARE they so good? Are they not spending the money they're getting and if not why not?

It's all sounding deeply dodgy!

Cattenberg · 02/05/2019 21:36

I know this isn’t the point of the thread, but I’m glad I’m not the only person who’s still boycotting Nestle.

Sophiafaith63 · 02/05/2019 21:35

As a member of a PTA who has done something similar, I'm really sorry to learn so many people are unhappy with this . It was not our intention to make anyone feel under any pressure to contribute. We are very much aware of how difficult it can be, especially for parents with multiple children. Its purely voluntary and we try hard to make parents aware of that.

We did this just before Easter (although we did have diary free alternatives) and suggested kids do chores to get coins for the tube. We are also offering a prize but it will for the class who bring back the most tubes regardless of how much they contain.

Our PTA does have a substantial sum in the bank, but only because we are raising funds towards a new playground, its not because we are just sitting on it!

howabout · 02/05/2019 21:35

Ignore it. The fewer people join in the sooner PTAs get the message that they are out of order.

Also the sooner you teach your DC the value of standing up to peer pressure the better and the easier it becomes to do later.
(Mum chooses to ignore the PTA pressuring her when DC are 5, makes it much easier for a 13 year old to follow the example with their peer group)

AmethystRaven · 02/05/2019 21:34

I would tell the PTA how you feel. I'm on ours and it can be tricky finding different ideas to raise money for the things parents want us to buy, but never ever would we want any parent to feel they have to give money they can't spare.

If they're normal reasonable people they will take your comments on board and be glad you said something, and if not then just ignore all PTA stuff from now on! We are a tiny PTA and sometimes things don't get fully thought out because there just aren't many of us, but we would want to know if we'd cocked up with something like this. If they're having a summer fayre soon too, asking for a random £12 now isnt really on.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.