Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Aibu to not want to fill a smarties tube with £1 coins

409 replies

Invisimamma · 02/05/2019 20:26

This will be outing if any parents from my child's school are on here...

Both children came home from school and nursery today with a tube of smarties each as a gift from the PTA with instructions to eat them and fill the tube with £1 coins or 20p, letter specifically states not coppers or 5/10ps. Apparently the tube will hold £12 of 20pences.

There will be a prize for the class who brings back the most money.

Now I have a few issues with this:

  1. my friends child has a diary allergy was really upset he can't eat his treat (she didn't know this was happening so couldn't provide an alternative)
  2. we still have lots of Easter chocolate and don't need more
  3. dp and I both work but childcare and other costs are crippling us at the moment and we're skint, an extra £24 is really beyond us just now
  4. we've just paid £46 snack money to nursery and £12 for a school trip for one and £8 for a trip for another (amongst lots of other recent school costs)
  5. does anyone even has coins lying around the house anymore? I use contactless payment for almost everything and don't draw out cash.

The children have been hyped up about it and both have said they need to raise money for the school. I guess I'm feeling guilty that we're not in a position to participate/it's a pain in the arse idea.

OP posts:
Dippypippy1980 · 02/05/2019 23:01

We did it with 1ps too. You could bring in a few smartie rolls, but only 1ps inside. It was fun and we had all term to collect them.

5ps might still be pushing up - 20ps are taking the piss!!

IncrediblySadToo · 02/05/2019 23:00

Your DC are only little I know, but you can teach them the value of money. Explain what you could buy with £12 (how many of their favourite treat) then tell them that the prize won’t be as good as that and they might not win anyway.

Then explain that the PTA already has an awful lot of money - enough to buy x number if their favourite treats, so actually your family needs the money much more than the PTA 😊.

The nursery aged child will be happy just eating the chocolate and taking the tube back filled with little stones out of the garden surely?! Sounds just as good! 😊

NHSPension · 02/05/2019 22:57

Haven’t rtft however I would tell them to keep their smarties tubes due to boycotting nestle.

SpaceCadet4000 · 02/05/2019 22:57

If it was just the tube it would be annoying (we never have cash) but I'd be okay with it. The fact there's a prize for the child who raises the most though is just so tone deaf and the request for 20p or £1 is crass.

I'd be sending in a note- it's fine for the PTA to ask for money, but I think school competitions should focus on encouraging skills or kindness instead of rewarding the kid with the richest family.

Davros · 02/05/2019 22:56

I think it stinks that they blackmail you by doing it through the kids. I'd be tempted to complain if I could be arsed otherwise try to ignore

huglessduglas · 02/05/2019 22:55

Graphista
Well said I was about to say the exact same

Sophia as said before I would it tolerate this happening at our school I always look at things from the view point of our families that struggle most

It’s beyond naive to say pta do not know the kids know the kids feel bad when they cannot contribute
At the heart of every school activity should be the feelings and perspective of the children if that’s not positive for every child then just don’t do it

Graphista · 02/05/2019 22:49

Oh come off it Sophia! Cut out the faux naïf nonsense!

You KNOW the kids themselves notice and discuss each other's contributions and the poorer kids will likely get grief over this.

ANY fundraising initiative that makes comparison so obvious/easy is unacceptable and discriminatory.

I'm from an army background so have experience of different schools and methods of fundraising plenty of schools always have managed fundraising without effectively marking the poorer kids with a scarlet letter!

If you genuinely care that poorer kids aren't further discriminated against (they have it hard enough as it is) then you would take the same stance and feed that perspective back to your pta.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/05/2019 22:48

This lacks so much imagination, made me chuckle. ‘Here fill this tub with money.’

Stick a rolled up list of decent fundraising ideas in there Op

Grin Grin Grin

We had a leaflet and a bag with the request to fill it with our 'loose change'. Again, their subtle, imaginative fund raising efforts equated to "Erm, just give us money, will you?!"

The thing is, there's another word to describe loose change: 'money'. Also, magically, when you spend part of a note (money) in a shop and get the difference back in coins, these also count as money and you're actually allowed to spend them as well in your next visit to a shop. I don't accumulate lots of 'loose change' - I spend it. Because it's money and that's what money is for.

Maybe missing the point here (and showing my age), but part of the fun of filling a Smarties tube with coins (hitherto to save up and then eventually spend it yourself) was the fact that it was a rigid, properly cylindrical tube with a removable/replaceable stopper, in which certain coins fit perfectly. How does it even work with the thin, floppy, hexagonal modern ones? You must have to keep them permanently upright (hoping they don't topple over or just collapse) until you fill them and then tape them up to return them, with the coins all loose and rattling around in this flimsy bit of paper which will likely split under the weight and scatter its contents anyway?

Purplecatshopaholic · 02/05/2019 22:43

I am going to sound like that Victor Meldrew bloke, but seriously?? No, no, and no again.

kateandme · 02/05/2019 22:35

this is really tough op.you cant stretch yourself and worrying about it wont be helping your situation.im trying to think of how you coud avoid it but so far....
could you talk to the school?would that be something you would feel comfortable doing.

kittens876 · 02/05/2019 22:34

Ergh! I disagree with this on so many levels! My sons old primary school constantly asked for money and if I couldn’t afford it they would send the TA out to find me with her hand out. Literally. I ended up moaning to some other parents and quite a few found it hard to raise cash for extras. I stopped contributing. And ignored the hand held out. Schools should Not be doing this! And £12! Blimey that’s loads to find if you’re short. Don’t even get me Started on ‘bring a bottle of booze to school day’ for the school Christmas fair. There goes little Timmy with 2 litres of whiskey and a fuck off great red Bow... ‘he just insisted on that one....’ erm. I digress. It Really bugs me! X

whyamievenamazeddotcom · 02/05/2019 22:32

Used to do this when my DC was at junior school and again quite a well to do area but we didn’t have that much disposable income we filled with coppers and on some occasions just returned the full unopened smartie tube as a) we don’t eat smarties and b) couldn’t afford that much cash.... the school needs to be made aware that not everyone is level financially ...I hated this aspect of school life made me feel very inadequate at times ... just return the tube or fill with Coppers and top and tail with a 20p each end ...

bringincrazyback · 02/05/2019 22:31

The grabby approach alone would be enough to make me refuse.

Dhalandchips · 02/05/2019 22:27

My kids wouldn't accept the smarties because they're Nestlé! And, yes, it's crazy to expect every family to do this! We're skint!

Sophiafaith63 · 02/05/2019 22:26

Graphista, we dont mark out any child or family. We have no idea who sends anything back and who doesnt

TidaQuel · 02/05/2019 22:23

Cakes sold at a loss? 20p per cake? Our school charge £1 per cake. Even the dozen for £1 fairy cakes go for 50p each along with each Maryland (supermarket own brand) cookie.

Our pta run events used to be ok. They are embarrassing now. I get that they want to make money but the £1 a go chance to win a prize which turns out to be a mini haribo bag is just too much. Another stall prizes contained a sweet, a balloon and a cheap plastic Christmas cracker gift - but I mean the mini tree cracker plastic shape. With a bit of forward planning and clever shopping, they could source decent prizes for very little.

willstarttomorrow · 02/05/2019 22:19

I totally understand OP. When DD was at primary school there was some NSPCC fund raising and the amount raised meant they got a certain level of badges. It was sponsorship and for a start we have no family nearby to ask and I was not going to pester friends and workmates. But is was so important to DD to not be the one without badges. I am a single parent and donate happily to charities I believe in but will not be blackmailed into sending money to one I do not choose support. It is is not okay. DD is older now and will happily tell teachers that the NSPCC do nothing except spend money on adverts (disclaimer I am a CP professional) and are not actually rushing out to act on referrals to their help line and rather just passing on to the local social work team. Families I work with literally do not have a pound to spare these days and the kids I work with just feel even more singled out by Christmas jumper days, world book days etc.

Walkaround · 02/05/2019 22:18

Seems weird just to ask parents to fill the tubes with money. They did similar at my dss' school once, but you were supposed to put 20p in the Smarties tube each time your child did something helpful round the house. Funnily enough, very few tubes came back even a third full! The exercise was not repeated, but given it required the kids to make a bit of an effort for their Smarties and there was no expectation to fill the tubes, I didn't mind - it made my kids less whingey for a couple of weeks when I asked them to help do stuff!

Sewrainbow · 02/05/2019 22:17

I usually support pta wholeheartedly but I think this is dreadful, for all the reasons pp have said (although I haven't read all posts) I feel so strongly I'd write a complaint letter I wouldn't just ignore it as I think the head teacher should be aware of the position they may be putting some families in. It's naive at best or humiliating cruel to those that struggle and their children are feeling bad when listening to the propaganda speech. Angry

Teacakeandalatte · 02/05/2019 22:11

Put the 20ps in lengthways rather than standing up.

Ihatemyseleffordoingthis · 02/05/2019 22:10

Our PTA has done this a couple of years, though they stopped short of asking for pound coins.

We did mixed coins from change jar the the first couple of times, this year we just ate the smarties.

I'm afraid my willingness to contribute to the PTA has diminished over the years as I've seen money spent, frankly, on total vanity projects whilst I know there are schools down the road where kids are arriving to school hungry each morning. And when 2 summers ago some of the kids asked if some of the money that had been raised could go towards Grenfell survivors, they were told no because the PTA wanted to raise the most ever in a year for the school...

£12? Are they having a laugh?

ethelredonagoodday · 02/05/2019 22:09

Our school does this every year. But suggest 20ps for chores done over the Easter hols. Every year I sack it off and send them back with a fiver each.

Popcorntwice · 02/05/2019 22:09

Just ignore it and don't sent the tubes back. I never bother doing that kind of thing, and tbh I think the school have got a cheek to ask!

bibbitybobbityyhat · 02/05/2019 22:08

RomanyQueen1 - the op says "both children came home from school and nursery today with a tube of smarties each as a gift from the PTA"

AriadnePersephoneCloud · 02/05/2019 22:08

We've had this before. I filled it with coppers anyway. Some money is better than none right and that's what they'd have got otherwise! CFs

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.