Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Aibu to not want to fill a smarties tube with £1 coins

409 replies

Invisimamma · 02/05/2019 20:26

This will be outing if any parents from my child's school are on here...

Both children came home from school and nursery today with a tube of smarties each as a gift from the PTA with instructions to eat them and fill the tube with £1 coins or 20p, letter specifically states not coppers or 5/10ps. Apparently the tube will hold £12 of 20pences.

There will be a prize for the class who brings back the most money.

Now I have a few issues with this:

  1. my friends child has a diary allergy was really upset he can't eat his treat (she didn't know this was happening so couldn't provide an alternative)
  2. we still have lots of Easter chocolate and don't need more
  3. dp and I both work but childcare and other costs are crippling us at the moment and we're skint, an extra £24 is really beyond us just now
  4. we've just paid £46 snack money to nursery and £12 for a school trip for one and £8 for a trip for another (amongst lots of other recent school costs)
  5. does anyone even has coins lying around the house anymore? I use contactless payment for almost everything and don't draw out cash.

The children have been hyped up about it and both have said they need to raise money for the school. I guess I'm feeling guilty that we're not in a position to participate/it's a pain in the arse idea.

OP posts:
gamerwidow · 03/05/2019 09:12

Ps prizes should be on a class not a individual basis too so as not to penalise children who can’t join in. Prizes are usually very small too like an extra 30mins of playtime so the other kids don’t fill hard done by,

WeepingWillowWeepingWino · 03/05/2019 09:11

I think some people are being very literal about this.

WeepingWillowWeepingWino · 03/05/2019 09:11

aren't they meant to take the tube around friends and neighbours and ask them to donate to the cause? I don't think there's any requirement that you personally have to fill it.

gamerwidow · 03/05/2019 09:09

This idea is always bandied about on the PTA uk website and we’ve never taken it up because it works out very expensive.
Just don’t do it. If no one joins in the PTA will have to think of something else next time.
It’s hard thinking up new fund raising events so I don’t blame the PTA for giving this a try but none of these events are compulsory. Have you approached the PTA and told them £12 per child is too much and you’ll be doing coppers instead? It bet if a few of you did that they’d be forced to be more sensible.

DonkeyHohtay · 03/05/2019 09:08

We did this at school one time (for the PTA) but with a few differences. We didn't specify what types of coins. We didn't specify the tubes had to be filled. We did't keep track of who was handing back which tubes, they just all went into a box in the office and the poor PTA treasurer had to count it all.

Email went out saying something like "Well done, we raised £500" or whatever.

I wasn't personally that comfortable with it as we don't but Nestle either and there's always one parent who objects to free chocolate. But from a PTA point of view it is a very quick and simple way to raise funds. We even got a local cash and carry to give a big discount on the smarties, each tube cost about 10p.

Langrish · 03/05/2019 09:05

Expectation of £12 per child is ridiculous. Why don’t you just put the 20ps in? doubt if they’ll open and check in front of your child if you’re worried about embarrassment (I wouldn’t be embarrassed anyway).

justasking111 · 03/05/2019 09:03

Our summer fair is coming up. They want 50 volunteers some with food hygiene certificates. 200 pupils. Huge crowds in the building it is worrying fire escape wise being in such a crush. How they expect so many parents to get time off work to volunteer for this baffles me

lola006 · 03/05/2019 08:20

I’m in the PTA and I hate this idea (DC have had this challenge via sports clubs). I really think anyone in the position of the OP should write an anonymous letter to the PTA about the financial hardships that are their reality and that the group needs to consider the current economy.

You find with these groups that part of the PTA is affluent and among the ‘I’d pay it!’ because it’s a drop in the hat. The other part offers the reality. And then it seems to come down to which side makes their case the best. They NEED parents to tell them exactly how these things impact household finances.

Waveysnail · 03/05/2019 08:14

Its.something that should have been sent.out in Sept.and give you the year

outvoid · 03/05/2019 08:10

Really strange idea...

I hate the amount of sweets my DC seem to leave school with. They get them for children’s birthdays, fine but they also get them for good behaviour which I find bizarre.

I wouldn’t partake tbh, you already give the school more than enough. You’re right about coins as well, we also use contactless for everything.

ferrier · 03/05/2019 07:26

Terrible idea for the PTA to fork out money for the smarties on the assumption that people will want their kids to have yet more chocolate.
Plus I wouldn't be happy about anything Nestle coming into my house. Maybe educate them about the Nestle boycott.

Teacakeandalatte · 03/05/2019 07:20

I may be missing the point here (and showing my age), but surely the whole joy of collecting coins in a used Smarties tube was always the fact that it was a rigid, perfectly round cylinder which was a perfect fit for certain denominations of coin and had a removable/replaceable seal. The thin, floppy, hexagonal ones that they have now are not an ideal shape for coins, are flimsy and tear easily. They are not sturdy, would have to be left as upright as possible in one place until they are full and then need to be taped shut, during which time they are liable to overbalance and topple over and vomit their contents all over the floor at any time.

Well I haven't had Smarties for a long time and I am very sad to hear they have changed the tube, sacrilege! Almost as bad as taking the walnut off the walnut whipAngry.

Seniorschoolmum · 03/05/2019 04:25

I’d make a formal complaint to the head teacher & to the LA immediately and get it stopped.

That’s appalling, asking children to compete about how much money they can bring !

SleepingSloth · 03/05/2019 03:55

We had school photos done recently and they are shit and cost a fortune.

They are shit but to be fair you don't have to buy them. I rarely bother now, I can take better photos myself.

SleepingSloth · 03/05/2019 03:54

If you can't afford to do it then that's the end of it. I'm sure most people will just put a few pounds in or whatever they can afford, not the full £12.

Personally I would be more in favour if it was for a charity.

OkPedro · 03/05/2019 03:10

Yep hollyhobbi was coming on to say the same. I’m sick to death of my dcs school asking for money. Every week it’s €2 for this €5 for something else. No one is asked if they’d like their child to take part in the activity, so you can’t exclude your child. We had school photos done recently and they are shit and cost a fortune. The school clearly make money from using the same photographer year after year

floribunda18 · 03/05/2019 03:05

Gah, what a pain! The money will be a stretch for many, plus as you say, who even has a load of coins hanging around these days? It sounds like an idea from the 1980s, though at least then it would have been pennies.

The good news though is, as it's PTA, it's not obligatory to join in.

MonsterKidz · 03/05/2019 02:41

Don’t do it OP of it will put a strain on your family. I am sure no one on the PTA would want that.

It might be an idea to raise this as a concern to the school. At the very least, I think prior advertisement about things like this is good practice. That way as parents we can manage our kids expectations of participation.

Although I completely understand if you’d rather not flag it.

malificent7 · 03/05/2019 02:40

We didnt bother when our smartie tube came. No harm done.

Topseyt · 03/05/2019 02:38

This is absolute cheeky fuckery. I would not be participating.

At best I might put a few 1p coppers in the tube, along with an angry note explaining why I thought it such a shit idea.

Alicewond · 03/05/2019 02:37

This is emotional blackmail OP, you should be able to choose how much you donate, even if it’s zero. It should be anonymous not making it a competition for children

Hollyhobbi · 03/05/2019 02:27

Jeepers ye should be glad ye're not in Ireland! Primary school was forever having cake sales, quiz nights etc. Secondary school worse again! €300 voluntary contibution or €500 if you have two daughters in the school! Then sponsored walks, cakes sales, Christmas fair. Never ends! Then books and uniform in first year nearly €1,000. And no these are not private schools! Oh and then essential costs like locker rental, photocopying etc. €130 per year.

Stovetop · 03/05/2019 02:05

Just don't do it. I ignore all requests for fundraising. Its not compulsory. If anyone queries it just say 'sorry im not doing it'

1forAll74 · 03/05/2019 01:59

i would ignore this kind of thing. who think's these things up in schools nowadays,?

BadLad · 03/05/2019 01:43

If every child just brought 5p each that would be a hell of a lot of money for not much effort.

A 500-child school would raise £25. I wouldn't say "a hell of a lot of money".

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread