Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To believe my 5 year old, not his teacher?

135 replies

Jamhandprints · 11/04/2019 19:31

My 5 year old has ASD with challenging behaviour, usually triggered by routine change.
So today at pick up time the teacher called me over to say he had got his best friend in a head lock for no reason (typical of his behaviour) Then, whilst in time out he has pinned down another child and put a bead up his nose.
I was horrified about this and nearly burst into tears.
I collected my son from the deputy head and asked him, on the way home, to tell me what had happened.
He said he hurt his best friend and put a bead up X's nose.
I asked him to tell me how he had done it and he said:
"I...I don't remember doing it. Miss Y said I did but I just I definitely don't think I did."
I asked a few times in different ways and got the same response, including tears. "You don't have to say tell the truth mummy because I definitely am".
So I phoned the teacher and she said nobody had actually seen it happen but X had said it was my son. She will investigate more tomorrow.
Thinking about it, my son has terrible fine motor skills, so to pin someone down and put a bead up their nose would require a lot of skill.
So i just feel terrible because all the school mums already hate my son (understandably) and I was going to contact the mum and apologise but I think he probably is telling the truth.
He is slow to process speech and respond so probably didn't know what was going on when he was sent to the deputy.
Does it matter?

OP posts:
dragoning · 12/04/2019 09:50

You are not minimising the headlock, you sound like someone who has a good understanding of his behaviour. It sounds unlikely to me that he did the bead, given his fine motor control.

With the parents, we had a difficult situation in my DC's class. One boy whose behaviour was extremely challenging (ripping up other kids' work, hitting, fighting, biting, shouting when overwhelmed, damaging property).

Three years after being too scared to sit next to him, DC and this boy had become good friends and the boy, whilst still struggling in some ways, was far better integrated into the class. His mother had fought tooth and nail to stay in communication with the other parents. She took the impact of his behaviour on the other kids seriously. She got him to apologise where necessary. She organised short playdates outside school, which were a far less challenging environment for her son and which enabled the other kids and parents to see him in a different light. Usually one playdate was enough for DC and parents to depersonalise the school behaviour.

The mum was persistent in getting to know people and it took time. It must have been very difficult for her. This boy is still sometimes scapegoated by teachers. But the kids and parents know him now and he is liked and his behaviour better understood. The scapegoating doesn't come from the kids any more.

In short, please call nosebead mum whether or not your child did it. Express concern, use it as an opportunity to make contact. Say that you take his behaviour seriously and the school is investigating. You can drop in about his motor skills but play the long game. Flowers

aspoonfulofyourownmedicine · 11/04/2019 23:25

I agree with previous posters re using your son as a 'scapegoat'. My 9 year old has ASD traits (awaiting diagnosis) and has been picked up as being the scapegoat within school and gets blamed often.

I'd believe your son, until proven otherwise. If he was in 'time out' what were other children doing near him? I work in a school and our 'time out' is when the child is removed and sat away from anyone else, therefore if it is true what your child has been accused of, why was the other child near enough to antagonise him further?

tinyme77 · 11/04/2019 22:50

Sounds quite possible that the child did it to themselves and blamed him.

theSnuffster · 11/04/2019 22:45

I've been through similar with my 10 year old son. He has ADHD. It is massively frustrating.

He's been with the same class of children throughout school and has often been used as the scapegoat. They know they can blame him and the teachers will believe them. We had one teacher tell us that if a reliable child says our son has done something they have to believe them.... or if several children say he's done something, they believe them as the majority. He's 'owned up' to things in the past that he hasn't done because a teacher has told him he'd get less of a punishment that way... If he doesn't 'own up' he'll also be punished for lying. He's stood in front of the class and apologised for something he knew nothing about simply because the teacher pushed him to say sorry, and because the whole class were being kept in at playtime until he did so.

Recently we were able to prove that he had been punished for something he didn't do- another child made it up, told a few other children, they all reported him to the head saying they'd all witnessed it. When we informed the head that it had all been a lie his reaction was to tell us he was 'shocked'. He refused to speak to any of the children involved as a few weeks had passed and he couldn't remember who had reported it to him anyway. (We named the child that started the rumour, this child often makes things up to get DS in to trouble, calls him names etc but simply gets away with it somehow.)

The whole thing has made me question how many times he has been punished for things he hadn't done! I feel awful because I haven't done enough to stand up for him, I had no idea how bad things were. He's started to self harm through frustration as 'nobody listens to him and nobody believes him.'

My advice is to believe your son. Get this sorted now before it gets worse and don't stand for any more of this sort of crap.

corythatwas · 11/04/2019 22:26

OrchidInTheSun Thu 11-Apr-19 19:51:14
Bead up a nose sounds a very unlikely thing for another child to do. Seems lmost likely that the child put a bead up their own nose

THIS. I have come across many children who have done this to themselves, never one who's done it to somebody else.

And if a 5yo can lie, then that doesn't just go for the OPs 5yo; it goes equally for the other child.

Justajot · 11/04/2019 22:03

Both of my DDs, at age 4, have blamed the 'go to' child for something at nursery for doing something on a day when he wasn't at nursery. Different 'go to' child each time as my DDs are now 4 and 8.

My 8 year old has always been impeccably behaved at school and nursery and mature for her age, so would be likely to be believed. I'm actually glad to have has the experience of them being mistaken/lying at nursery as it has prevented me from believing that my children are infallible.

I agree that there's every chance your DD didn't do it. I think moving school (as suggested by a previous poster) might be an over reaction and not in his best interest.

Quietlife333 · 11/04/2019 21:57

I think I would believe my son. It sounds like you’ve got a gut feeling that this isn’t right. Also no teacher should be saying that he must have done it because x child accused him of it. Also you don’t know what the child who makes this accusation is like. They could well be making it up. Why should this child be believed over your child? I’d be asking his teacher to act more responsibly in relation to how this kind of thing is handled in future. Flowers

ShawshanksRedemption · 11/04/2019 21:45

Further investigation is needed. Your DS in time out (sitting on a chair away from others?) just happened to have a bead on him to stick in another child's nose, whilst holding them down with no-one seeing? Is that likely?

However I would like to add that I work with kids with SEN incl ASD and some do lie. Indeed my own DC with ASD has occasionally lied!

Morticiaismymumgoal · 11/04/2019 21:43

They DO NOT (DO NOT!!) hate your son understandably. If they don't invite him to parties etc whilst inviting all the others they're nasty. Obviously it's unlikely they know about your son's ASD as school can't tell them and if he's not being invited you can't tell them but he is doing what he can in a mainstream setting (presumably). Please never think they understandably hate him, they may not realise his behaviour stems from his disorder but if they hate him, dislike him or exclude him having never taken the opportunity to find out from you his issues they're not very nice people.

Serin · 11/04/2019 21:42

I remember being caned as a 7 year oldAngry for biting another child. It was a horrific bite with blood pouring down her arm.
No one believed that I hadn't done it even though I was the most placid of children and I got hit at home for it as well (1970's).
About a week later she admitted that she had done it herself.
No one apologised.

I would be inclined yo believe your boy OP.
Whatever happened to innocent until proven guilty? AngryAngryAngry

TixieLix · 11/04/2019 21:41

Do you have any beads at home OP? Or some small buttons? Maybe you could "play a game" with your DS and get him to help you sort them in to colours or count them into piles of 5, to see how he copes. That will give you an idea if he could even manage it.

sonypony · 11/04/2019 21:29

YANBU. unfortunately IME a teacher who just believes the child who can communicate more easily because it's the easy option and doesn't believe that communication can be poor whilst being able to speak is not going to improve and it causes significant emotional damage. My poor son (5yrs asd) has had this or similar a lot. It's so so hard.

Jamhandprints · 11/04/2019 21:25

@Langrish, I know but ASD isn't something you can see so they're not necessarily aware of it. To them he s just the naughty boy that hurt their child for no reason. I don't see them socially as we don't get invited to parties or play dates, so I've never been able to explain.

OP posts:
Takethebuscuitandthesink · 11/04/2019 21:25

*were

Takethebuscuitandthesink · 11/04/2019 21:25

It seems very unprofessional a teacher would send a child to the deputy heads office and tell the parent as if we’re definite fact before completing the investigation especially as no one actually saw this “incident”. Regardless of anything else I would be annoyed about that. I definitely think this needs looking into further.

freddiethegreat · 11/04/2019 21:12

Even with a teenager, I have fought this battle twice recently. Once DS (whose EHCP states that he dissociates and has complex PTSD) didn’t remember what he had done. I didn’t (necessarily) dispute that he had done it, but I did argue strongly (& successfully) for there being a real need for them to be very careful when sanctioning him that he understood why, because it could very easily feel like further proof that the world is against him if they sanction him just as normal for something he doesn’t remember doing. And - given the contents of the EHCP - I absolutely refused to let them impose a further sanction for lying. DS wasn’t even saying he hadn’t done it, just that he didn’t remember the ten minutes around the incident. But I was much more vocal when AN Other student said he had done something & my son said definitely not & it was acknowledged that they had no other proof but AN Other student is ‘very reliable Ms Freddie’. No. I mean maybe he had done it, though on that particular occasion I don’t believe it myself, but one student’s word against another (it wasn’t even something directed at the other student or anyone particularly) needs more investigation.

Good luck, OP.

JacquettaW · 11/04/2019 20:54

Another one here with a child with ASD. My DS doesn't lie and often other kids will say things that he has done when he hasn't.

I've had years of this (he's 11) and it really winds me up. It's all to easy to pin the blame on someone who has difficulties.

Flowers for you OP. You mentioned other parents not liking him. One of the Mums at my DS's school told her child he wasn't allowed to play with mine and now wonders why I unfriended her on Facebook and have blanked her in the playground ever since!

thesnapandfartisinfallible · 11/04/2019 20:44

I'm inclined to believe him. More likely that the other child stuck it up his own nose and was lying to get out of trouble. They dont think it through at that age.

How would he have done it? As you say, his fine motor skills are shit so how on earth would he manage to pick up a bead and put it up the nostril of another child, who was, presumably, a moving target, all while holding this child down, in a classroom and no one saw or heard a damn thing.

It's not realistic. Where was the teacher? I'd wager: not far and certainly within earshot. I doubt the other child just laid there and let him do it with nary a protest. If he was held down (could your son even have overpowered him?) then there must have been a struggle. Why did no one hear it, even if they didn't see it?

Langrish · 11/04/2019 20:43

Who knows? But it made me sad to read you saying it was “understandable” that all the other mum’s hate your son. If they’re aware of his difficulties, surely they’d be a bit more understanding. Ok, it’s real life, they may well be wary because his behaviour is challenging, and maybe rightly so, but surely a reasonably sensible parent wouldn’t hate a 5 year old?

whatwouldkatyactuallydonext · 11/04/2019 20:40

I'm another with a ds with asd who, at that age, found it impossible to lie. Kids that age are always shoving things up their own noses/in their ears and immediately know that they shouldn't have - much easier to blame someone else for it than own up to being so silly.
Thanks hope you can get to the bottom of things.

Worsethingshappen · 11/04/2019 20:38

I feel sorry for you OP and your precious boy.
Given everything you said it sounds v unlikely your son did this. But even an “investigation” might not get to the full story.
You sound sensible - I would stick by your boy on this and trust your judgement and instinct.

Hadenoughofitall441 · 11/04/2019 20:30

Something similar happened with my DS 11 who has asd. On the las day of term 20 minutes before home time his teacher called to tell me that whilst he was playing with some friends another child came and disrupted him and tried to take over in which he got angry and pushed said child to the floor. The teacher made a point to say that he was provoked and that she wS worried about him walking the half way down the road by himself so would I come to the school. Well in that time the events had escalated and according to another teacher who called DP he escaped isolation and stormed onto the playground and pushed a child from another year group. Now either they are making him sound like a lunatic for what ever reason or he was so mad he zoned out and doesn’t remember, he’s still adamant he didn’t push anyone else other than the child who interrupted him. He’s n3ver one to induce violence unless someone has irritated him or provoked him, most of the time he minds his own business. I’m not really sure what happened as all 3 different stories I’ve heard have inconsistencies. He did tell me another boy hit him and he hit him back but didn’t tell the teacher as the boy that hit him often acts like he never does anything so the teacher dismisses any wrongdoing. There’s several kids like this in his class and h3s getting annoyed that everyone always believes everything those kids say or do.
You need to find out if anyone else was a witness. It sounds like a case of he said she said but they could be trying to make your boy look like a nutcase. It happens.

BottleOfJameson · 11/04/2019 20:30

I do think it's possible that your DS is the go to person to blame now. It seems unlikely he could have done it without anyone noticing. S

lottiegarbanzo · 11/04/2019 20:29

So I think you should talk to the teacher and stick to the facts, like a detective. 'We know that this occurred, between this and that time. X and Y were together at this time, they were supposed to be doing Z, no-one was watching them closely, no-one saw what happened.'

Don't let her describe it to anyone else as something your DS did. That is not known.

SkintAsASkintThing · 11/04/2019 20:28

I have an ASD pair too.

My youngest is almost 18, and no way on earth could he do that. He wouldn't have the fine motor skills, not to mention his brain firing off in different directions processing the different tasks.

It's obvious your son is the class ,and school scapegoat. Amongst the kids and even worse the staff. Because the accusation itself is so ridiculous the teachers response should have been ' did that really happen '?? Along with a firmly, raised eyebrow.

I think it's time for a new school and a.fresh start. It may even be time to homeschool him for a while so he can build up his skills, no way would I be sending him back into that hell pit with those Hellions.