Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Homophobia within the Muslim community

430 replies

thankssomuchforthat · 27/03/2019 09:07

Please can we keep this thread calm and good natured as this is a genuine question.
I was genuinely shocked at a spokesperson for the Muslim community on GMB condemning gay people as sinful. Saying being gay is fundamentally wrong. Saying most Muslim people vehemently believe this. Is this true? Or are gay Muslims tolerated within the community? What would happen if a Muslim teenager was gay. Would the family disown them?
Genuine question. I suppose I mix in circles that are tolerant of homosexuality.
Please keep comments nice and friendly.

OP posts:
Lweji · 28/03/2019 10:42

He has been sitting a bit on the fence, although lately he's been more forceful and I do feel he has been forced to finally face the issue.
I wouldn't call him an apologist, though.

Having said that, he is facing an Everest of issues within the Catholic Church itself, from corruption to treatment of gay, divorced, etc members, women, to abuse victims in many contexts.
It's not done in a day.
Coming from a Catholic community, I know the internal struggle by some members to catch up with the times, for more inclusion and openness. I'm very aware of the undercurrents of more religious fundamentalists, or traditionalists, but essentially misogynists and racists and science deniers.

I imagine that Islam as a whole deals with similar issues, with traditional and entrenched values and practices still very strong among some groups, due to cultural or religious factors. It will be mostly an internal process, encouraged by external pressures.
But, we should be careful not to make it "us" vs "them". We should direct criticism to the specific homophobic (whateverphobic) groups.

It's important that more moderate muslim groups are vocal in their more inclusive opinions. The problem is, how many newspapers are willing to give them a voice? It sells more to show the homophobic protesters.

Everanewbie · 28/03/2019 10:35

The way I look at it, schools have a duty to teach facts as facts, and opinions and opinions to be critiqued.

Fundamentalist Christians demand that evolution not be taught in schools. Shockingly, in the USA this is actually listened to in some place, thankfully not here. So evolution is taught as fact given that all credible scientists are certain that all the evidence backs it up. Creationist theories are taught as just that, a theory. This religion believes in Adam and Eve etc. This is not backed up by any evidence, so science ignores it.

RE children should learn about all the major religions, what they believe and why they believe it. It helps understanding and tolerance.

Similarly, social issues should be taught as, well: certain people are attracted to people of the same sex. They can live together and be married. In the UK we now believe that this is valid and ok. They are born with this preference and they deserve our respect. Some religions teach that it is not ok. Gay people have been treated badly because of these teachings. In a civilised country like the UK, you can disagree with their choices, but you should respect them and treat them equally. This is actually the law.

If you are muslim, for example. I don't think you can possibly ask that children learn about your religion so that they develop a knowledge and erespect of your religion, then in the same breath exclude their own children from learning the same tolerance for other peoples life choices.

Just to add my opinion in here some more. Homosexuality is something you are born with. Its not really a choice. Religion is a belief system. Like following a football team that that is just a bit more historical. As a society i don't know why we give so much credence to ancient texts and the beliefs of their followers, but i suppose we have to for the sake of peace.

LeesPostersAreInFrames · 28/03/2019 10:06

even the frickin pope is an apologist

I'd really appreciate a potted explanation of what he's said or done, if possible please.

I've somehow managed to have lived under a rock regarding this pope and his stance or action/inaction on paedophilia in the church.

Lweji · 28/03/2019 09:06

So, to say that Catholicism doesn’t protect paedophilia when the Church so clearly does, even the frickin pope is an apologist.
The clergy, yes. Catholicism in general, no.

I meant the heads of Christian schools are more likely to pay attention to any protesting parents, assuming Christian or Catholic schools invite outside groups.

I actually find it interesting that while the New Testament is about tolerance, but some Christian groups are very intolerant anyway, which suggests that at the core it's not the religion but the people or the culture.

N0rdicStar · 28/03/2019 08:20

Being / doing how dare you tell my son he is wrong for either. Do you know how damaging it is for gay children to hear these views.

Dress it up all you like, it’s homophobic. There is nothing wrong with my son being gay and there is nothing wrong with him having same sex partners in the future.Angry

thankssomuchforthat · 28/03/2019 08:19

Some interesting points on both sides. Its really important to discuss these issues.

OP posts:
N0rdicStar · 28/03/2019 08:17

All state schools are supposed to deal with homophobic language and bullying which will occur everywhere. There will need to be provision for struggling LGBT pupils. 6% of the population are gay so gay pupils will be in every school.And no Christian kids don’t just go to Christian schools in the same way Muslim pupils go to a variety of schools. My dc go to school with Muslim pupils. Not heard of any parent trying to shut down the huge amount of work done to eradicate homophobic language and bullying or to halt support given to LGBT pupils.HmmSuggesting heads would give in to Christian homophobia but not Muslim ihomophobia is one of the most ridiculous things I’ve heard on these threads.

JAPAB · 28/03/2019 08:11

"Same with this proclamation that the Quran/ bible/ insert religious text here says that homosexuality (as this is what homosexual sex is) is wrong but apparently followers of the book don’t care if someone else is gay. This is demonstrably false when looking a any country who’s laws are based in religion, I include the UK in this as legalisation of gay marriage is so so recent."

Forming same-sex relationships is part of the doing that they object to. Not sure why a disaproval of same-sex marriage demonstrates the falsity of the notion that it is not the being that is wrong, but the doing.

IStillMissBlockbuster · 28/03/2019 08:01

It seems disingenuous to me to try so very hard to separate the religion from the practice. So, to say that Catholicism doesn’t protect paedophilia when the Church so clearly does, even the frickin pope is an apologist.

Same with this proclamation that the Quran/ bible/ insert religious text here says that homosexuality (as this is what homosexual sex is) is wrong but apparently followers of the book don’t care if someone else is gay. This is demonstrably false when looking a any country who’s laws are based in religion, I include the UK in this as legalisation of gay marriage is so so recent. Just as being atheist is so controversial n these religions because it is going against the book. It’s bullshit to try to claim otherwise imo.

You might say that it is the influence of humans (men) who pollute the message and practice, but these religions are man made so there is no pure religion away from the meddling of man.

N0rdicStar · 28/03/2019 07:57

Islam regards homosexuality as a sin so one would deduce that yes they are saying it’s wrong.Hmm

I think some using Christchurch to make a point is pretty repugnant.

There were threads re the Christian cake abd guest house protests, I posted on those too. Have also posted against Christian extremism in some schools. I am an atheist. When therre are threads re Christian or Jewish followers trying to push their homophobic views in schools rest assured I’ll post on those too.

I think this is a valid discussion for the op to start given current events. Seeeping homophobia under the carpet is damaging and does society only harm.

Lweji · 28/03/2019 07:49

I think the issue with Muslims and school protests has at least two confounders.
One is that, still, many Muslims are immigrants or recent immigrants and from more traditional cultures, which makes culture and tradition other factors besides religion itself.
The other is that fundamentalist Catholic and Christian parents are already sending their children to faith schools where it's less likely they'll invite LGBT groups to speak. Or protests go straight to the Head and are probably accepted very quickly.

Lweji · 28/03/2019 07:42

dottierichardson genuine question. Are you on threads about paedophila in the catholic church pointing out that peadophilia also exists within muslim communities? Did you also comment on the thread about the Chriatain couple refusing to bake a cake for a gay couole and feel the need to point out that muslims have a homophobia problem too?

I wasn't the target, but as a cultural Catholic, I would disagree if anyone said that the Catholic faith at heart encourages or protects paedophilia or that Christians are homophobic based on those cases. And I'm pretty sure I've pointed out in other threads that other religious systems are up for abuse of power too.
Yes, the Catholic Church's hierarchy has a problem with the cover ups that needs urgent and vigorous address.
Yes, many fundamentalist Christian faiths have homophobic (as well as several other less Christian phobic and isms behaviour).

I'm the first to be concerned with fundamentalist Muslims and with the treatment of women, gays, etc in some Muslim countries, as in some Catholic traditional countries. But I wouldn't want to consider the entire communities as the problem.

There will always be a conflict between dogmatism and intolerance and with tolerance and mutual respect. But that's where the conflict should lie. Not between religions or between atheists and religious people. It's the dogmatic and intolerant people that should be fought, with the danger of losing the sight of where the real fight is.
And with the danger of playing into the hands of certain types of intolerant and dogmatic people who simply don't like people from other religions or skin colour.

Ihatesw · 28/03/2019 06:34

Great thread op. I’m also Muslim. I don’t agree with people eating pork and drinking alcohol, sex outside marriage or homosexuality. Yet I have friends who do these things and I still love them.

I have friends who don’t agree with hijab, halal meat, sex until marriage and they still accept me.

I also teach in a non faith school where Muslim children have openly professed they are gay and no one including myself could care less.

It saddens me that homosexuality is shunned and people are still vilified. For me it’s entirely about being able to have your own value system but also being able to respect someone else’s.

Nursejackie1 · 28/03/2019 04:32

@wafflyversatile. So in this exact scenario it is at least 90% muslims proteating if not more. Please answer....are you one of the what about the men posters when the issue is domestic violence because you seem unable to accept we are allowed to talk about the main group of people who are the main perpetrators and blatantly showing their homophobic views in this instance.

Nursejackie1 · 28/03/2019 04:29

@dottierichardson genuine question. Are you on threads about paedophila in the catholic church pointing out that peadophilia also exists within muslim communities? Did you also comment on the thread about the Chriatain couple refusing to bake a cake for a gay couole and feel the need to point out that muslims have a homophobia problem too? Or is it just Islam that we are not allowed to talk about in your opinion without being accused of "singling" them out.

Also I live not far from where the proteats are taking place. I can promise you that the parents protesting and taking theor kids out of school are Muslim. I have no reason to lie about that. A friend of mine is one of the people who started the community meetings to arrange the protest and it is predominantly Muslims not just a bit of a majority but almost all. Its ok to talk about that. Ffs.

JAPAB · 28/03/2019 00:06

My understanding is that none of the religions say thatbeing gay is wrong.

So theoretically at least, whetherr gay muslims are tolerated or not will depend on whether they abstain.

Unless if they become trans, because then I believe some Muslim authorities will see that as acceptable.

wafflyversatile · 27/03/2019 23:57

And according to the media other religious groups supported them.

wafflyversatile · 27/03/2019 23:55

It's ridiculous to suggest, as some have, that we shouldn't bring up homophobia in other religions because the op only mentions Islam.

Dottierichardson · 27/03/2019 23:54

You undermined your own position, you claimed that it was homophobia that bothered you and that came up because of an interview that you saw with a Muslim representative who was anti-gay. But when people made it clear that this is not an Islamic thing but cuts across several religions, you kept bringing it back to Islam. You ended your opening post with a comment that you were used to liberal circles tolerant of gay beliefs, but rather than wanting to talk about homophobia and religion again you kept bringing the discussion back to Islam. So that suggests it's Islamic beliefs that bother you more than homophobia.

thankssomuchforthat · 27/03/2019 23:49

Anyway, thanks for the contributions on this thread... it has been genuinely interesting to see all the different viewpoints. Its been a strange experience being called incendiary, islamaphobic and a covert racist, of which I am none. Just genuinely interested in getting a few different view points.

OP posts:
Eliza9917 · 27/03/2019 23:45

I want to know why it's accepted that muslims are against homosexuality but it's not ok for Christians to say they don't want them in their hotel/B&B or to bake cakes for them. It's double standards imo.

thankssomuchforthat · 27/03/2019 23:41

I think its a red herring to say its islamaphobic to discuss specifically UK Muslims views on gay people. According to the media ALL 600 primary pupils who were withdrawn from the school were Muslim children. They make up 80 per cent of the children in the school where protests are: Parkfield Community School. So its a specific issue concerning Muslim parents objecting to their children being taught that gay relationships are to be accepted. So I cant see why people are saying we need to talk about other religions in this instance?

OP posts:
IAmNotAWitch · 27/03/2019 23:41

Religions (pretty much all of them) are about control and setting people up with an 'us and them' train of thought.

This is just a manifestation of that.

SnowdropsiUnderTrees · 27/03/2019 23:38

Just like to point out that there are people from all religions and also atheists protesting about this programme. Don't tar all Muslims with the same brush. Some are against it some aren't. You wouldn't like me accusing all white people of being white suprematists.

The actual people protesting are the ones who disagree with the program, not the whole Muslim/Christian/Jewish/Buddhist/atheist/Jedi etc population. Just those few. Don't generalise.

Dottierichardson · 27/03/2019 23:37

You can discuss whatever you like, doesn't meant that some of us can't question your motives, particularly as you've fixated on the Muslim GMB guest, when there was a Christian representative arguing against LGBT classes on GMB a few days ago, and there have been Christian protests in South London against LGBT classes, Pride at Schools, in Manchester, and elsewhere in the UK over the last year. Rows about gay ministers in the Church of England, over celebrating gay marriage in various Christian denominations. Funny how you've only just noticed homophobia in religion when it also linked to Islam.

Swipe left for the next trending thread