Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Homophobia within the Muslim community

430 replies

thankssomuchforthat · 27/03/2019 09:07

Please can we keep this thread calm and good natured as this is a genuine question.
I was genuinely shocked at a spokesperson for the Muslim community on GMB condemning gay people as sinful. Saying being gay is fundamentally wrong. Saying most Muslim people vehemently believe this. Is this true? Or are gay Muslims tolerated within the community? What would happen if a Muslim teenager was gay. Would the family disown them?
Genuine question. I suppose I mix in circles that are tolerant of homosexuality.
Please keep comments nice and friendly.

OP posts:
turquapple · 31/12/2021 17:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

crestedrobin · 22/01/2020 12:20

Our family all Christian, with a gay family member. It isn't a big deal to us. Yes most religions are against homosexuality but don't make a huge issue out of it in the same way Muslims do. Why down play it by saying "all religions are the same" type of thing. They aren't.

Gliese163 · 22/01/2020 12:01

I've heard Indian people say proudly "There are no gay Indians". What does that tell you?

Ramzan Kadyrov said the same thing about Chechnya.

zsazsajuju · 21/01/2020 20:30

I have a close gay Muslim friend. He is openly gay but also a religious Muslim. I’m sure everyone doesn’t accept him but he doesn’t seem to generally have an issue on a day to day level. He lives at home with his family and is actively involved in his community, well I suppose both his communities.

I’m a religious Jew and we also have openly gay people in our community who are an integral part of it. Our community is progressive and so we welcome gay people same as anyone else. Many (maybe even most) religious people are not hateful or intolerant.

PhilSwagielka · 21/01/2020 20:16

@SmellyBeard you can't reason with people like that, sadly.

Also, is a collapse of ethnic solidarity among native Brits code for 'white people shagging/marrying outside their race'? Hmm

WeeSleekitTimerousMoosey · 21/01/2020 19:18

Some Anglican Churches in the western world may turn a blind eye to those teachings but worldwide there is no question that mainstream churches consider homosexual acts to be sinful.

Not just Anglican ones, some Calvinist churches do as well. The Church of Scotland does, but it was a divisive move and a number of congregations left and joined the Free Church as a result. Last I heard the Free Church was the fastest growing denomination in the land, though I may well be out of date here as I'm no expert.

Can't speak for other strands of Protestantism, but I'm pretty sure both Pentacostalists (the largest group) and Anabapists are anti. Not so sure about Baptists or Lutherans.

SmellyBeard · 21/01/2020 18:58

My Palestinian colleague (in his 20s) believes 100% that homosexuality is caused by something happening in early childhood and that you can be counselled out of it. He also believes that there are hardly any gay men in Muslim communities as he has never heard of any. He would not be able to be friends with a gay man.

Trying to reason or offer other evidence doesn't work. I've tried.

mbosnz · 21/01/2020 18:35

I wouldn't call 50 years pretty recently.

Interesting article.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/may/23/fifty-years-gay-liberation-uk-barely-four-1967-act

PhilSwagielka · 21/01/2020 18:28

@Bezalelle me too! One reason why I converted was because Reform Judaism would accept me as a bi woman. I couldn't be Orthodox because I'd be forced into heterosexuality.

PhilSwagielka · 21/01/2020 18:27

@FrankSlater you forgot 7. Misogyny.

PhilSwagielka · 21/01/2020 18:26

The Muslim community have a long way to go. I do know gay/lesbian Muslims, and Imaan do some good work, but I remember at uni, I was in the LGBT Society and we had Muslim members who were cagey about being seen with us. UJS had BAGELS for LGBT members, which I can't imagine the frummers being too happy about - I went to a BAGELS gathering with some gay lads - but FOSIS had no equivalent. Also, homosexuality is punishable by death in a lot of Islamic countries.

As for my own religion, there's an organisation called Keshet for LGBT Jews. I have friends who were members - there were Orthodox Jews whose families had sat shiva for them after they came out. To bring home how horrible that is, sitting shiva is what you do when someone dies.

Gliese163 · 21/01/2020 18:13

It's worth noting that marriage equality was only legalised in part of the UK this month, and the DUPs religious fundamentalism is part of why it took so long.

SallyWD · 21/01/2020 07:18

It's a common view in many religions. There are plenty of homophobic Christians. However looking at people on an individual basis I've known Muslims who don't have this view and have got on well/been friends with gay people. To be honest I'm surprised you're so shocked by this discovery. Pleas not let's single Muslims out. My DH is Hindu abd being gay is not acceptable to many Hindus either. I've heard Indian people say proudly "There are no gay Indians". What does that tell you?

SecretGuiltyPleasureLoveIsland · 21/01/2020 07:13

Being gay was actually illegal in the UK until pretty recently

I wouldn't call 50 years pretty recently.

Gliese163 · 20/01/2020 18:24

Your citing Andy Ngo on this? The man who starts fights and then claims he was attacked?

Bezalelle · 20/01/2020 07:34

This is one of the many times I'm bloody proud to be a Reform Jew. Unlike the other end of the spectrum of Judaism, we welcome gay people, trans people, women. More than that - we make them Rabbis and cantors and teachers. In this day and age there's no reason religions should not move and change with the times.

FrankSlater · 20/01/2020 07:08

@charlestonchaplin I agree the majority of Christians worldwide disagree with homosexuality. Nonetheless there is still a distinction to be made between the traditional Christian and Muslim understandings of terrestrial law.

charlestonchaplin · 20/01/2020 06:57

I don’t know what this ‘fundamentalist Christianity’ people speak of is. Homosexuality is quite clearly proscribed in the Bible, both in the Old Testament (so Jewish law that shouldn’t necessarily be followed) and New Testament Christian teachings. Some Anglican Churches in the western world may turn a blind eye to those teachings but worldwide there is no question that mainstream churches consider homosexual acts to be sinful.

Christians, especially British Christians, may not air their beliefs on the subject much for various reasons (including recognising their own sinful behaviour and not wanting to be hypocritical, not wanting to make people uncomfortable and not wanting to be branded with various names like extremist and bigot), but that doesn’t mean that Christianity, even in the west, has widely rejected Biblical teaching on homosexuality.

FrankSlater · 20/01/2020 06:47

@recrudescence I think the phrase "ethnic solidarity" is a perfectly straightforward term to be honest. I assume he thinks I should have written "racist" or something similar. Clearly the grooming wasn't "mismanaged" it was "managed away". I can't speak for anywhere else but in Peterborough it still is.

recrudescence · 20/01/2020 06:43

Yes the issue of grooming was mismanaged

Unbelievably, in the same breath, you accuse another poster of “some scary dressing up of language”!

echt · 20/01/2020 06:40

To repeat:

ZOMBIE THREAD

GCAcademic · 20/01/2020 06:37

India a Hindu majority country currently ruled by a Far Right Hindu despotic government with a thumping majority trying to create a National Register of Citizens religions Germany style - has had homosexuality as a criminal offence till a few years ago.

That was a colonial law. It was the British Raj which criminalised homosexuality in India in the nineteenth century.

Thoughtlessinengland · 20/01/2020 06:33

an Indian friend who happens to be Hindu who said it is very unacceptable to 'come out' within their community.

India a Hindu majority country currently ruled by a Far Right Hindu despotic government with a thumping majority trying to create a National Register of Citizens religions Germany style - has had homosexuality as a criminal offence till a few years ago. The current legal status changes nothing on the ground. It’s just not accepted by Hindu families or Muslim families with exceptions.

DisinterestedParty · 20/01/2020 06:29

Zombie thread

FrankSlater · 20/01/2020 06:25

@Warsawa31 Also remember what most people forget (or don't realise) about Islam. Unlike Christianity, Islam never developed a secular law which is territorially rather than theocratically based. In the western tradition there is "church/ecclesiastical law" and the "secular law" of the nation/people. In Islam there is only the Sharia.

We are talking about 2 legal traditions. The west derives its law from the people - which is expressed in a territorially limited way through the state.

Strictly speaking under Islam the law is derived from god, expressed through the Sharia and is for all mankind to follow

Swipe left for the next trending thread