Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Circumcision

606 replies

muma19 · 20/03/2019 15:54

DP wants DS circumcised however I don't. I also have MIL getting involved and pressuring me. What do I do? I want to be fair to my partner but I really don't want him veg for circumcised. HELP!!!!

OP posts:
LordPickle · 25/03/2019 01:51

Haven't RTFT but I don't agree at all with genital mutilation. Period.

WhatNowDear · 25/03/2019 01:34

I didn't read the entire thread but I honestly believe that in this day and age it is completely disgraceful that practices like this still take place. If it's not for a medical reason it should never be done. We have outlawed many other barbaric and disgusting things. For example I see little difference between the mutilation of dogs (docking, cropping etc) and the apparent need to alter a human being. Imo you should only be able to decide lifelong changes for your own body. If later in life someone wants surgery that's up to them but to have even a small part of your child removed is a grave misuse of power.

Halo84 · 25/03/2019 01:11

Ok their labias.

Smotheroffive · 24/03/2019 23:35

women cleaning their vaginas women don't 'clean' their vaginas, gravity brings everything out and nothing should be put in!!! What do you use soap and vag bristles!?

zeddybrek · 24/03/2019 17:11

Sorry OP I haven't read the thread but just wanted to add we did it and regretted it. If I had my time again I would have never done it. We did it for religious reasons however as it was happening I realised it is so unnecessary. I'm going to be controversial and say times move on and religion needs to and can adapt.

It if helps go and see how they actually keep your baby still. That is enough to change your mind. DH fainted half way through as well.

As I haven't read your thread, sorry I don't know how old your child is but the older the baby then the harder it is. My brother was a newborn and slept through his whereas my son was about 5 months and I'm sorry to say it was horrific. DH and I are still traumatised.

Halo84 · 24/03/2019 16:10

The foreskin just needs to be pulled back to be cleaned. It’s no different from women cleaning their vaginas. To suggest this is something difficult at a time where most people shower daily is ridiculous.

VashtaNerada · 24/03/2019 16:06

If DH suggested circumsising DS (he wouldn’t because he had it done as a toddler and fully remembers the trauma of it) I’d tell him to fuck off. Sometimes children need operations for very good medical reasons but if there is no medical reason there is absolutely no excuse IMO.

NunoGoncalves · 24/03/2019 16:06

OK gamerswidow if you are so well informed about the human body perhaps you can provide a definitive answer to the question I have been asking with regards to whether the foreskin is pulled back or actually folded over on itself when washing. The fact that thus far no one has been able to give an answer speaks volumes

I didn't answer because I couldn't believe anyone would actually ask this in seriousness.

When a foreskin is fully retracted, all of the skin is exposed. There is no hidden part or fold that is not cleanable.

ThatssomebadhatHarry · 24/03/2019 15:59

Male genital mutilation. It should be illegal.

gamerchick · 24/03/2019 15:53

OK gamerswidow if you are so well informed about the human body perhaps you can provide a definitive answer to the question I have been asking with regards to whether the foreskin is pulled back or actually folded over on itself when washing. The fact that thus far no one has been able to give an answer speaks volumes

Nobodies answering because they can't quite believe that someone who has given birth is that uninformed. The foreskin is firmly attached to the head of the penis for a number of years until an age the child can pull it back (not folded over Hmm) to clean underneath.

Now because it is firmly attached and must be for a reason, does it make sense that it's cut and torn off at birth? Just because religion dictates, doesn't make it right.

I'm still of the soap and scourers here for wimmin. Fucked up man.

gamerchick · 24/03/2019 15:45

gamerchick did you mean me with the soap and bristled vag cleaners?

No Grin

dadshere · 24/03/2019 15:35

I can't see why any sane, normal person would want to mutilate a little baby's genitals. Unless it is necessary for medical reasons, it should never be carried out in a civilised society.

sagradafamiliar · 24/03/2019 15:27

Like I said before, breeze's questions about penises/foreskins make her sound very naive. I think she's visualising something like a long wizard's sleeve with a sausage hidden in it somewhere! Given the lack of anatomical knowledge, it's all the more worrying that she and others are consenting to a permanent operation based on it.

Smotheroffive · 24/03/2019 15:22

I would hope NOT to live in such fear

Smotheroffive · 24/03/2019 15:20

You have not removed all bacteria from yourself before devotions, no, its not possible breeze

gamerchick did you mean me with the soap and bristled vag cleaners? Grin

This cleanliness thing is a red herring.

No decent human, let alone God, would have you chop about your 'god-made perfect' body to make it clean. It's an unhealthy obsession.

Im not getting the obsession with the method of retracting? (Rolling or folding)

Did you read that the foreskin and glans are one? It is literally not loose skin, but skin, attached to the membranes beneath, just as any other part of the body.

I'd like to see people get their arseholes spotlessly clean!

What does 'clean' even mean?

If it's not defined specifically then it can't be done and its a misnoma.

I can't believe all this is about its dirty chop it off! There's a lot of arse removals needed. You can't tell me these men don't get skiddies in their pants!!

Ripping off human flesh is abhorrent.
And yes, extremely painful. 'Just cos we think it's not clean' is no reason to mutilate a beautiful baby boy, born as nature needed him to be born.

I would be erring on the side of caution frankly, seeing as god s word is widely open to interpretation! He/she is not here to speak specific dictats and even if he/she were, I would hope to live in such fear of said entity as to deliberately inflict harm and pain to an iñfact by ripping skin off it.

Segmentationfault · 24/03/2019 14:39

Almost no pain? That's sick.

breeze44 · 24/03/2019 14:35

Sorry should have said gamer chick. Got mixed up with a poster from another thread.

breeze44 · 24/03/2019 14:34

I know people object to the idea of circumcision when a child is too young to consent. But if you wait until they are old enough to consent the risk of complications increases, the recovery is more difficult and of course the boy will remember the whole experience. The responsible thing is to take the decision on their behalf as it’s in their best interest to avoid all that. An NHS doctor I met said that some of the complications he saw in cases of adult circumcision were horrendous with the penis swelling to twice it’s normal size.
When my boys had theirs done they had almost no pain, recovered quickly and now I’m sure don’t remember a thing. Vastly preferable.

breeze44 · 24/03/2019 14:27

Smother I think all of what you mentioned is different from the foreskin. And I don’t generally keep my nails long enough to need a nail brush

breeze44 · 24/03/2019 14:23

OK gamerswidow if you are so well informed about the human body perhaps you can provide a definitive answer to the question I have been asking with regards to whether the foreskin is pulled back or actually folded over on itself when washing. The fact that thus far no one has been able to give an answer speaks volumes.
I’m not being obtuse. I’m well aware that non-Muslim uncircumcised men who care about hygiene feel that retracting the foreskin and washing is sufficient for them to feel fully clean. I get it.
BUT I don’t understand why people keep saying to those that circumcise “all you need to do is teach him to wash properly” without realising that we have different expectations about hygiene.
Muslims have to remove all impurities from the private parts as much as they can before praying. If I was a man, and I wasn’t sure if even after washing whether the underside of the foreskin was fully clean or not, I wouldn’t feel fully comfortable praying. Just like I, as a woman, feel uncomfortable when my nails are too long until I cut them.
I’m not saying or asking any of this to try and persuade you, I know you’re satisfied with the level of cleanliness. But why say “just wash” without being clear on the standards we require.

gamerchick · 24/03/2019 14:02

I have to ask,do you have particular difficulty in washing/cleaning yourself that you can't comprehend of a man keeping himself clean?

I must admit I have pictures of bars of soap on sticks and scrubby brushes to clean a vagina properly going on this posters words. Scary when people can't be bothered to find out how the human body works.

Segmentationfault · 24/03/2019 13:56

Cleaning my feet means I have to bend over. Would have been much easier of my parents had them copied of when I was a baby.

Smotheroffive · 24/03/2019 13:53

Florescentadolescent Grin
...but then..you know..colostomy bag/poo?

Florescentadolescent · 24/03/2019 13:50

I'm gonna get my sons arse hole sewn up and a colostomy bag put on. Because you know arse holes are dirty.

Smotheroffive · 24/03/2019 13:43

Breeze
I have to ask,do you have particular difficulty in washing/cleaning yourself that you can't comprehend of a man keeping himself clean?
Do you not separate toes to get in between to clean and dry? Do you not clean your vulva and have to separate your legs to get in there with a towel to dry yourself properly? Lift your arms to soap and rinse your pits? Use a nail brush to scrub under your nails with soap.

All our bodily cracks and crevices need getting into and cleaning and crying, so what's the hang up with this one bit of skin?

I can't believe you really feel this is reason to cut it off do you?

I get that (having seen some of the states that young males go about in intimately) there definitely is a need for upping the ante around cleaning regimes, but that goes for feet, as well as pits and penises, and arses. Is that what this is really about?