Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Circumcision

606 replies

muma19 · 20/03/2019 15:54

DP wants DS circumcised however I don't. I also have MIL getting involved and pressuring me. What do I do? I want to be fair to my partner but I really don't want him veg for circumcised. HELP!!!!

OP posts:
MissConductUS · 26/03/2019 18:23

I've not RTFT, so apologies if this has been brought up. I have no skin in this game (ha ha) but the procedure does reduce the incidence of STI's for men and women.

Male Circumcision: A Globally Relevant but Under-Utilized Method for the Prevention of HIV and Other Sexually Transmitted Infections

Association between male circumcision and women's biomedical health outcomes: a systematic review.

I think the practice is more common in the US. I let DH make the call for DS after giving him the medical research.

Lifeover · 26/03/2019 18:08

No chopping body parts off childrenis stupid at best assault at worse. Tell DH your ds will get circumsized the day DH gets abody part of your choosing removed.

samG76 · 26/03/2019 18:01

Smother - my purpose and intent was to say, as I did, that Pattern seems to have a certain lack of diversity among her friends. Suppose I said that none of my friends are gay/transgender/whatever and I didn't realise it was a thing. People wouldn't be impressed. But where someone says they deliberately don't become friends with cultures comprising about 30% of the world population, it is somehow considered worthy and even a matter of pride.

breeze44 · 26/03/2019 17:48

The word barbaric is not in my vocabulary. Do you think using it would persuade anyone to change their view? Obviously not, if anything it would put people off even listening to you.

GladAllOver · 26/03/2019 17:42

It is a genuine problem when people are so unable to see how their own cultural background has informed and influenced their view of a particular practice and then they start using strong language like 'barbaric' and 'sadistic' to talk about something that for other cultures is completely normal and unproblematic.

In some other cultures, FGM is normal and unproblematic. Does that mean we can't call it barbaric?

breeze44 · 26/03/2019 17:41

With regards to what I mentioned about cleaning earlier, I think some people were wilfully misrepresenting what I said. When one poster admitted she didn't know the answer to my question and the two who answered it gave conflicting answers, it's not my naivety that's the problem.
Talking about showering once a day or washing your back is irrelevant to what I was saying because as Muslims we have to pray five times a day at specific times, and if a person has urinated since the last time they had a shower they would have to clean themselves again before praying. If that was in the middle of the day on their break from work they wouldn't have access to a shower.

breeze44 · 26/03/2019 17:34

Smotheroffive, sam's post was nothing of the kind. It was very tame compared to the language used by people on this thread who are against circumcision.

It is a genuine problem when people are so unable to see how their own cultural background has informed and influenced their view of a particular practice and then they start using strong language like 'barbaric' and 'sadistic' to talk about something that for other cultures is completely normal and unproblematic.

Smotheroffive · 26/03/2019 17:15

Whats your purpose and intent here exactly?

Smotheroffive · 26/03/2019 17:14

No pattern - you genuinely didn't realise it happens any more. What a diverse group of friends you must have (though pretty typical for MN)

What a goady, completely unnecessary and sarcastic, nasty post SamG.

samG76 · 26/03/2019 17:05

No pattern - you genuinely didn't realise it happens any more. What a diverse group of friends you must have (though pretty typical for MN).

NoParticularPattern · 26/03/2019 16:38

I didn’t even realise that circumcision was even still a conversation to be had- certainly none of my religious friends (well, not all my religious friends as not all religions “require” it, but you know what I mean) have ever suggested it would be a good idea. There are literally no arguments (save actual diagnosed medical conditions which can only be solved by circumcision) where it is a good idea. Cleanliness is a ridiculous suggestion- no one cuts off their fingers or mutilates their bum crack just because those areas might get dirty. They wash them properly because they were taught how to as children! Same goes for the penis or indeed the vulva. You can’t just cut part of someone else’s anatomy off on the off chance that they might not clean it sufficiently. That’s absurd.

The religious aspect is even more ridiculous. Cut a part of your own child off on the basis that some deity or god who no one in living memory (and arguably any memory at all depending on how religious you are) has actually met?! Fucking hell. I wonder what other stupid shit people could be persuaded into on the sole basis of “because He said so”?! Following a religion doesn't prevent you from using your brain (or at least it shouldn’t!) to realise that mutilating someone else’s body is not ok!

I’m struggling to shut my mouth after realising that people do genuinely believe that it is either healthier or holier to have it done. I might remove my kids toes to stop them getting athletes foot. Would save me a fortune on daktarin and years of saying “would you PLEASE dry your feet properly!”

Alsohuman · 26/03/2019 16:12

I like the cut of your jib @SamG76, as a way of avoiding inheritance tax that couldn’t be bettered. You’re definitely on to something here.

Smotheroffive · 26/03/2019 16:05

Sam you have a strange view on things, describing pp as competing ....[levels of] shock

We're genuine RL people who are shocked and distressed and very much against cutting without sound medical reasons

samG76 · 26/03/2019 12:44

Mrs B - the only problem is that the courts have made it clear that it is permitted where both parents agree. But you may have stumbled upon an excellent Inheritance tax dodge. If someone sues their own parents for, say, £1m, it would be received tax-free and reduce the estate accordingly, so saving IHT at 40%, minus legal fees, of course, but these wouldn't be much.

MrsBethel · 26/03/2019 12:32

I think the most likely driver of change is the courts.

A slight change in attitude there, and it could become the norm for circumcised men to sue the medic/cleric who did it to them.

We could easily reach the point where lawyers are advertising on the radio (have you been circumcised against your will?), and where millions/billions in compensation changes hands.

From that point on, no hospital or religion that wanted to avoid bankruptcy would do it. It would be consigned to the past, where it belongs.

samG76 · 26/03/2019 09:17

Turisas - what I'm saying is that this thread is an example of the disconnect between RL and MN. People compete with each other to say how shocked they are, eg "mutilation", "take their kids into care", "I'd never be friends with anyone who did it", "sadistic God", etc etc. But it's just an echo chamber - no-one is actually going to be influenced by it.

In RL, the govt isn't going to do anything. Loads of people, in particular Jews and Muslims, are having their children done, getting on with it, and they seem to be doing quite nicely. so if you want to change things you'll need to engage with them, which is exactly the opposite of what this thread is doing.

GinUnicorn · 26/03/2019 06:48

Not all Jews do this. I am friends with a lovely Jewish couple who completely oppose circumcision saying times have changed.

Turisas · 26/03/2019 04:41

Your saying you live longer because you butcher your children without their consent?

Smotheroffive · 26/03/2019 00:11

You attribute this to loss of foreskin and resultant pain then, or whata your point in saying that here?

It makes no sense considering the threads point. Highly irrelevant.

It's certainly no excuse for enforced unnecessary procedures.

How can you even try to defend it in this way

samG76 · 25/03/2019 23:50

Turisas - you're entitled to your opinion, of course, but Jews seem to have the best life chances of any ethnic group in the U.K, which is remarkable given that we're apparently not fit to be parents.

Turisas · 25/03/2019 22:07

Anyone who makes their child go through a painful, permanent and unnecessary mutilation because they think their sadist of a god demands it is not fit to be a parent imo.

Smotheroffive · 25/03/2019 14:24

I think there is a lot of education needed around this, as clearly religion seems to be 'filling many gaps'.

Somethings very wrong if anyone doesnt know the basics of fe/male bodies in this day.

Religious 'cleanliness' is clearly overriding the facts of reality, and I would suggest that's done through fear of doing the wrong thing. After all, there are still something like 70% of girls cut in Africa.

It's a very vicious circle that needs breaking.

MrsBethel · 25/03/2019 14:23

Well done OP, and well done OP's DH for understanding and not being a dogmatic bell end about it.

There is a non-zero complication rate for these procedures. Infection is not uncommon. It's completely unnecessary, and simply stems from a time when people: a) didn't clean, and b) wanted to stop children masturbating.

Severe complications are thankfully rare, but if you could buy your son a lottery ticket where the prize was lifelong loss of function of the penis (eg accidental amputation of the glans)... even if it was a million to one, you wouldn't do it, would you!

MinnieMountain · 25/03/2019 14:05

Or they are being deliberately obtuse and looking for a reason to justify it JAPAB.

JAPAB · 25/03/2019 09:37

I can only assume that those who think washing it is difficult must be of the female persuasion. Personally I find washing my back more difficult.