Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Circumcision

606 replies

muma19 · 20/03/2019 15:54

DP wants DS circumcised however I don't. I also have MIL getting involved and pressuring me. What do I do? I want to be fair to my partner but I really don't want him veg for circumcised. HELP!!!!

OP posts:
ScreamingValenta · 27/03/2019 07:06

I'd like my foreskin cut off please, said no man ever!

My husband was glad to have it done for medical reasons when he was about 8 or 9 - he was in a lot of pain beforehand. It's never bothered him in later life.

breeze44 · 27/03/2019 06:56

Posted too soon - note they also say the procedure is safe

breeze44 · 27/03/2019 06:53

Florescent that's not the only reason circumcised men have lower rates of STDs. The World Health Organisation recommends male circumcision as a preventative measure against the spread of HIV in countries with high rates. They say:

'There is compelling evidence that male circumcision reduces the risk of heterosexually acquired HIV infection in men by approximately 60%. Three randomized controlled trials have shown that male circumcision provided by well trained health professionals in properly equipped settings is safe. WHO/UNAIDS recommendations emphasize that male circumcision should be considered an efficacious intervention for HIV prevention in countries and regions with heterosexual epidemics, high HIV and low male circumcision prevalence.'
www.who.int/hiv/topics/malecircumcision/en/

Smotheroffive · 27/03/2019 03:14

Not a flawed analogy at all...you just missed the point Grin

Those with foreskins survived, for some.reason, no matter whether they made it past 30, whereas infection killed.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/03/2019 00:28

X-posted with nolongersurprised, who said pretty much the same as I did but much more succinctly!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/03/2019 00:27

Data from earlier studies indicate that monogamous women with circumcised sex partners are only half as likely to get cervical cancer as are women with uncircumcised sex partners. And the Tobian study shows that circumcision cuts the risk of HPV, the virus that can cause cervical cancer

So what parts of a baby girl's body do you propose should be routinely removed chiefly in order to lesson the risk to the the health of any men with whom she may or may not be sexually active when she's grown up? Or might it be slightly more reasonable and morally acceptable to leave it to adults - men AND women - to decide which of the various available methods they wish to use to protect themselves, should they choose to be sexually active with people who may have transmittable STIs?

You can certainly make a moral case that it's wrong to perform elective surgery on an infant, but the medical benefits are irrefutable.

Nonsense. There's historically been a great deal of controversy about the supposed health benefits, but the weight of medical opinion nowadays comes down on it NOT being proven to be beneficial.

Even if this were the case, what IS irrefutable is that circumcising a male will remove many thousands of sensitive nerve endings which would otherwise have provided him with full natural sexual enjoyment for many years - and this is completely irreversible.

There are countless documented cases of men who were circumcised as babies who have lifelong emotional and psychological issues as a direct result of it.

Apart from spurious claims from people who apparently believe themselves lacking in basic hygiene skills and thus considering themselves unable to teach their sons this rudimentary lesson, all of the purported medical benefits of circumcision relate to sexual activity. Therefore, why not give males the choice as to whether or not they wish to consider a circumcision shortly before they become sexually active?

This would enable them to weigh up the reported pros and cons for their own health and also take into account whether they are willing to have their bodies irreversibly mutilated at the request of a female partner who believes it to be beneficial to her health or, otherwise, if they believe such a request to be abusive and/or controlling and to move on to another potential partner instead.

As adults, they may well choose to strike a bargain between themselves that he have a circumcision at her request and she have, say, a breast reduction/enlargement or face-lift etc at his request, if that's what they both prefer sexually, for as long as their relationship lasts. In fact, he could go the whole hog and ask her to have a hysterectomy, which would guarantee that they wouldn't go on to have children together who may suffer from any illness or condition whatsoever.

Common sense would otherwise suggest spending a few quid on condoms, but if we're going to completely disregard a cheap, temporary method that's proven to be very reliable and instead look for extreme solutions....

Obviously, if she had any concerns about getting an STI from him for any reason, she could simply insist on a condom or decline intercourse, so it's not like there's any medical or health issue. Unless extremely paranoid about circumcision-related mythology, she would know that the risks of getting an STI from a faithful and/or condom-wearing intact man are far lower than those of it from sleeping with a promiscuous and/or unfaithful circumcised man - with or without a condom.

Your sincerely-held beliefs that baby boys should be circumcised because of supposed health benefits for themselves and any potential partners in later life are exactly the same sincere beliefs held by many people for their daughters and their possible future partners in many countries. Yes, there are plenty who do it purely to subjugate women, but probably the majority of FGM is actually performed at the insistence of older female family members. Regardless of their genuine beliefs of supposed benefits, if they do it to baby girls in the UK, they will be sent to prison.

As I said before, this is one of the very few cases where females' basic rights are considered of value and protected in law but those of males are not.

nolongersurprised · 27/03/2019 00:25

That's a flawed analogy. Circumcision isn't asserted to prevent cancer of the foreskin but it is shown to reduce the risk of systemic STI's.

So let the sexually active boy/man make his own risk assessment. What gives you the right to make decisions/inferences about his sexual practices when he is a baby?

Maybe he’ll choose abstinence, maybe he’ll be asexual. Terrible excuse given to circumcise a newborn.

Alternatively, he may be angry about those tiny nerve endings that have been popped off without his consent, again, he can be given the choice.

MissConductUS · 27/03/2019 00:02

If foreskins were useless and harboured infection, it's very strange that they have not disappeared entirely after thouamds of years of evolution.

By the way, this comment reflects a common misunderstanding about evolution. If something doesn't kill us before we pass the earliest possible child rearing age it's irrelevant from an evolutionary standpoint. You're basically out of warranty by age 30 or so because by then you've either passed on your genes or you haven't. This is also why we have no effective defense against diseases like cancer or heart disease that are quite rare in people under the age of 30.

MissConductUS · 26/03/2019 22:54

If you cut the bollox off there wouldn't be any testicular cancer

That's a flawed analogy. Circumcision isn't asserted to prevent cancer of the foreskin but it is shown to reduce the risk of systemic STI's.

If foreskins were useless and harboured infection, it's very strange that they have not disappeared entirely after thouamds of years of evolution.

Not at all strange. There are other lots of useless or maladaptive things in human anatomy that evolution hasn't eliminated.

The Most Unfortunate Design Flaws in the Human Body

You can certainly make a moral case that it's wrong to perform elective surgery on an infant, but the medical benefits are irrefutable.

Smotheroffive · 26/03/2019 22:49

I'd like my foreskin cut off please, said no man ever!

nolongersurprised · 26/03/2019 22:47

Surely decisions about sexual health should be made by the teenager or young adult themselves? Present them with the up to date sexual health information, discuss condom use and then they can decide whether or not to opt for circumcision as an adult. And then at least it’ll be done under GA which is more humane.

Every single organ in the body can potentially become diseased or infected. They don’t all need to be removed as a baby “just in case”.

Smotheroffive · 26/03/2019 22:36

Yes glad they evolved for a purpose.

GladAllOver · 26/03/2019 22:35

If foreskins were useless and harboured infection, it's very strange that they have not disappeared entirely after thouamds of years of evolution.

Smotheroffive · 26/03/2019 22:35

If you cut the bollox off there wouldn't be any testicular cancer, oh and slicing of women's breasts will remove breast cancers
Not forgetting hysterectomy to remove cervical and ovarian cancer

We could be opting for heart removals too that way there'd be no heart attacks

Same.flawed logic Confused

MissConductUS · 26/03/2019 22:26

I may be wrong but, I think the reason circumsised men have lower rates of std's is because the groups that have it done - relegious or higher social / economic class, tend to have less sexual partners and/or practice safe sex more.

If you look at the links I posted you'll see that most of the studies were conducted is sub Saharan Africa. There no inference from any other cohorts.

It's nothing to do with cutting a bit of skin off, but the myth is kept going in America. I mean think about it, hiv is in the fluid how would cutting the skin stop the spread.

The studies I cited did't test for a mechanism of action. The effect is quite robust and not in anyway a "myth". Here's what researchers think the MOA's are:

Study Shows Circumcised Men Have Less Risk of Herpes, Genital Wart/Cancer Virus

How can circumcision prevent STDs? In at least three ways:

When the foreskin is removed, the skin covering the head of the penis becomes tougher. That may protect against "microtears" during sex that can provide a point of entry for germs.

The mucosal lining of the foreskin may allow germs to penetrate to underlying skin cells.

After sex, the foreskin may prolong the time that tender skin is exposed to germs.

Circumcised men may be protecting their sex partners as well as themselves, suggest University of Washington researchers Matthew R. Golden, MD, MPH, and Judith N. Wasserheit, MD, MPH, in an editorial accompanying the Tobian study.

Data from earlier studies indicate that monogamous women with circumcised sex partners are only half as likely to get cervical cancer as are women with uncircumcised sex partners. And the Tobian study shows that circumcision cuts the risk of HPV, the virus that can cause cervical cancer

Hadjab · 26/03/2019 22:17

I didn’t have my son circumcised. He ended up having it done at the age of 16 as his foreskin was too tight.

Smotheroffive · 26/03/2019 22:15

It makes me wonder whether you have seen a foreskin retract on an erect penis, I guess not considering your culture has them all butchered.

Smotheroffive · 26/03/2019 22:14

Can you explain your issues with 'folding' or 'rolling' as it is beyond me to understand what you mean by 'folding' back?

And why this matters so much to you?

Smotheroffive · 26/03/2019 22:12

...and in some.cultures beating the shit out of your wife is normal so is raping her, that's upsettingly 'normal' in the UK!!

Normalised, minimised, whatever you want to call it its not ok.

It's certainly not ok to permanently maim a child just because you can't get to a shower in the middle of the day, surely the rest of your body is filthy too, by that reckoning.

And no, its not about having to accept something that I do see as harmful, painful, lifelong infliction, without a baby's consent

I can get pissed about it, and I don't agree there's a reason to justify this.

What 'rule' is this that says you are unclean because you took a piss?

You do you urine is sterile?
So please define 'dirty'

Even if we wash, we are still dirty, this is just crazy talk.

ConcreteUnderpants · 26/03/2019 21:52

Dismissing other people's religious faith as an excuse is utterly insulting. The contempt for deeply and sincerely held beliefs here is truly shocking.

Well said, Alsohuman
Really shocked at some of the insults and disgraceful comments on here.

It appears some people are unable to put their point of view across without being downright offensive and showing an iota of respect.

Florescentadolescent · 26/03/2019 21:28

I may be wrong but, I think the reason circumsised men have lower rates of std's is because the groups that have it done - relegious or higher social / economic class, tend to have less sexual partners and/or practice safe sex more.

It's nothing to do with cutting a bit of skin off, but the myth is kept going in America. I mean think about it, hiv is in the fluid how would cutting the skin stop the spread.

Connieston · 26/03/2019 18:34

Leave him as he is.dont inflict surgery on a newborn.

sagradafamiliar · 26/03/2019 18:31

Breeze, what were the two conflicting answers to your question?

Mississippilessly · 26/03/2019 18:29

You know what really reduces STIs? Condoms.

Mississippilessly · 26/03/2019 18:28

But pain is pain it's irrelevant whether its culturally acceptable.
The Incas thought that child sacrifice was ok. Obviously I'm not equating the two but where is the line? As has been explained circumcision is more drastic than the 2 lowest levels of FGM and yet most would consider FGM unacceptable.

For me the biggest argument is that regardless of the levels of pain or the risk of your injury it shouldn't be a decision made by anyone except the individual.