Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Circumcision

606 replies

muma19 · 20/03/2019 15:54

DP wants DS circumcised however I don't. I also have MIL getting involved and pressuring me. What do I do? I want to be fair to my partner but I really don't want him veg for circumcised. HELP!!!!

OP posts:
Smotheroffive · 27/03/2019 12:12

A baby does not have a foreskin in the adult sense of the word. For a baby it is the same as ripping skin off any part of the body because it is not separate from the glans, it is there to protect the glans wholly until around age 5, when is starts to separate naturally. This would be the safer and kinder time to cut it off without tearing it away from the underlying raw tissue.

I can't believe in this day and age we are even having this discussion. It's so abhorrent to those of us who do not have this as a routine practice,just the same as fgm.

Yes, those who do it do try to find support evidence to continue its practice. If you look hard enough there are pro's and con's to most things, even in research its not usually clear cut black and white (seriously no pun intended)

We do not routinely even remove the appendix, which can and does cause serious complications, including death.

We do not inflict unnecessary pain as a matter of course. We do not conduct procedures removing the child's own choice.

We do not own children or their bodies, their bodies belong to them and we are entrusted with their care until they are independent to decide and consent for themselves.

CallipygianFancier · 27/03/2019 10:22

Circumcision is something that should only be done when explicitly medically necessary. Outside of that, it's just mutilation. Utterly monstrous thing to do to your own child.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/03/2019 10:04

but the weight of medical opinion nowadays comes down on it NOT being proven to be beneficial

This is an over simplification. As with any medical intervention there are risks and benefits. It may not be routinely recommended but that's very different from stating that there are no benefits. I note you don't bother to provide any supporting evidence for this assertion. This statement from the Canadian Pediatric Society is pretty typical....

MadMadCow has already said perfectly most of what I would have done in response to this.

I don't deny that cutting off some or all of a body part will reduce or eliminate the risk of illness/infections/cancer in that body part - that's obvious and doesn't require any medical training to know or convince people.

Routinely chopping off a newborn's arms at the shoulders would guarantee that they never suffer from arthritic fingers for the rest of their lives. Removing newborn girls' wombs and ovaries would forever free them of the risk of ever developing cancer in these organs.

Tongue cancer is rare, but devastating when it occurs. Maybe the idea of babies never being able to talk properly would be a small price to pay to know that society would be rid of this condition once and for all.

I find your use of the phrase 'medical intervention' somewhat strange. This phrase is usually used to refer to the treatment of existing illnesses or those for which there is a strong reason to believe that a serious problem is very likely to occur - not something done on the off-chance that one of a few illnesses or conditions could possibly present themselves in later life.

TurquoiseDress · 27/03/2019 09:31

Yikes!

Didn't realise there were 20 page of discussion already!

TurquoiseDress · 27/03/2019 09:30

YANBU

Personally, I think that circumcision is totally unnecessary unless there is a solid medical indication

Your MIL may well have strong opinions on whether your baby gets it done, but at the end of the day she should play NO part in the decision making

It is between you and your partner- it'd be worth getting more information (whether via the internet or from appointment with a medical professional) so you can come to a balanced and reasoned decision i.e. do NOT get it done if you feel it is not right

I do appreciate that when a young baby is involved, all balance and reason goes out the window- you just want to protect your baby at the end of the day

Definitely do not do it to please your partner or MIL!

MadMadCow · 27/03/2019 09:23

Also, even if you agree there is a risk reduction it doesn't justify it. My risk of death in a road accident would be a lot less if I never left the house.

MadMadCow · 27/03/2019 09:18

But someone decides to 'gather data and evaluate it statistically' don't they? It doesn't spontaneously erupt out of nowhere!

Why not remove all breasts at age 18? No doubt if you decided to gather data and evaluate it statistically, the risk of breast cancer would be significantly reduced.

Langrish · 27/03/2019 09:14

You don’t need to be “fair” to your partner, not his penis. You need to be fair to your son, let him make up his own mind when he understands all of the potential pros/cons.
Nothing to do with your MIL.

MissConductUS · 27/03/2019 09:10

but the weight of medical opinion nowadays comes down on it NOT being proven to be beneficial

This is an over simplification. As with any medical intervention there are risks and benefits. It may not be routinely recommended but that's very different from stating that there are no benefits. I note you don't bother to provide any supporting evidence for this assertion. This statement from the Canadian Pediatric Society is pretty typical;

Circumcision of baby boys: Information for parents

It says in part:

Potential benefits of circumcision
A few studies suggest that boys who have been circumcised may be:

Less likely to develop cancer of the penis later in life – although this form of cancer is extremely rare.
Less likely to get HIV and HPV infections.
Less likely to get a urinary tract infection during childhood.
Female partners of men who have been circumcised are less likely to get cervical cancer.

Potential risks of circumcision
Circumcision is a painful procedure.

Problems resulting from the surgery are usually minor. Although serious complications are very rare, they do occur. These can include:

Too much bleeding or infection in the area.
Too much skin removed.
Side effects from the method or medicine used for pain relief.
The risk of complications is lower in young babies than in older children. To minimize the risks, the procedure should be done by a trained and experienced practitioner using a sterile technique. Someone should follow up with you in the days after the procedure to make sure that bleeding has not increased.

people with vested interests seek to create evidence.

The medical studies gather data and evaluate it statistically, they do not "create evidence".

The fact that people are determined to ignore the overwhelming evidence that there is risk reduction tells me that this is a "don't confuse me with the facts, I've made up my mind" situation. You can make a perfectly reasonable decision not to circumcise without denying the science.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/03/2019 09:01

If you live in a country where the vast majority of males are circumcised, then the responsible thing to do as a parent is to get it done at a young age when none of these disadvantages would be present.

As a PP has covered, this is 100% the sincere beliefs held by people who practise FGM. However do you arrive at the conclusion that it's responsible parenting to cut off a part of your baby's body for no medical reason whatsoever?

If you grew up in a community where most of the people were deaf, would you feel that it was your responsible duty to cut off your newborn's ears? Do you believe that, because most other people have had something precious irreversibly taken from them without their being able to consent or to prevent it, then nobody else should ever be allowed to have or keep it?

As for the 'disadvantages', I'm shocked by your simple disregarding of the fact that a large part of a person's future sexual pleasure will be taken from him soon after birth and you don't in any way see this as a disadvantage.

Again, the proponents of FGM who cut off a young girl's clitoris and/or labia or sew up her vagina don't see her future inability to enjoy normal sexual relations as any kind of issue to concern themselves about - as long as she 'fits in' and complies with social norms.

MadMadCow · 27/03/2019 08:40

The whole cleaner argument/evidence of lower rates of STIs etc, is so illogical. The practice is fundamentally a religious/cultural one going back millennia. Now we live in a more enlightened age where cultural and religious practices are not unquestioningly carried out when they cause suffering to babies, people with vested interests seek to create evidence.

SugarfreeMe · 27/03/2019 08:38

DS1 had to be circumcised on medical grounds & it was awful!
I really wish that we had, had another option.
Having read up on the negative effects of circumcision I would never have a child circumcised for anything but medical reasons.
Would your husband read information that you gave him?

Acis · 27/03/2019 08:30

Talking about showering once a day or washing your back is irrelevant to what I was saying because as Muslims we have to pray five times a day at specific times, and if a person has urinated since the last time they had a shower they would have to clean themselves again before praying. If that was in the middle of the day on their break from work they wouldn't have access to a shower.

But presumably they need to wash irrespective of whether they have a foreskin or not? So you simply use the same washing method. And yes, of course, you can pull the foreskin back sufficiently to ensure the entire area is clean. It couldn't be easier.

Florescentadolescent · 27/03/2019 08:25

How can cutting the skin prevent herpes and warts?

Herpes and warts are/can be present on the intire penis and are passed through contact.

I'm not going to read those studies because there is nothing they can say that will make me believe them. People create studies to support whatever they want. They just manipulate the data and pay people to support them.

nolongersurprised · 27/03/2019 08:08

That should read that newborns don’t have it done under GA. Which is hideous in itself.

nolongersurprised · 27/03/2019 08:05

Culture is often minimised as a factor of importance but actually the feeling of belonging, of having your place within a wider family, community and culture is very positive for emotional well-being and shared practices can cement that sense of identity and belonging.

But this is one of the arguments used to validate female genital mutilation. It doesn’t make it morally correct.

Where I live (Australia) the paediatric medical and surgical position statement is that any perceived benefit re STIs is offset by the complications of the procedure and there is no medical basis for recommending the procedure.

I have a son. Circumcising was never an option but it’d be a strange thought process if I were to look and him and think, “I know you will grow up and move to sub Saharan Africa where you will have sex with multiple partners and refuse to wear a condom. Therefore I’d better get you circumcised”.

The argument re “not remembering” is backwards. Older boys and men will have it done under GA and won’t remember. Newborns don’t - just because they don’t have sophisticated memories of the event doesn’t mean they haven’t internalised the trauma.

Mississippilessly · 27/03/2019 08:03

Again - it ISNT 'you personally'. It's not your penis. As has been explained the underside can be very thoroughly cleaned. But that isnt the point. It's not your cleanliness to worry about. It isnt your body.

breeze44 · 27/03/2019 08:01

Ok dementedpixie fair enough. It's just a different perspective really. I guess if you do something often enough it doesn't seem like a difficulty and just becomes normal for you, although I still think it would be difficult when not in the shower. And obviously some people have different definitions of 'clean' and 'dirty' if they see urine as clean.

breeze44 · 27/03/2019 07:53

And by the way, I'm not declaring that any uncircumcised man is definitively dirty. The Islamic scholars disagreed and debated about whether it was essential for adult converts to get circumcised, and some of them mentioned that people became Muslim without getting circumcised and went ahead practising their religion and living their life.

I'm just saying that for me personally it would be a concern if I was male, and it's something that occurs to me every time I see people saying 'just learn how to wash' etc.

dementedpixie · 27/03/2019 07:53

Look on wikipedia, it shows your there! And yes, when retracted the inside skin of the foreskin is exposed. When erect there is no fold of skin at all

breeze44 · 27/03/2019 07:48

Smother, the argument about cleanliness is just going around in circles. You are the one talking about bacteria and sterility, I have not mentioned anything of the kind. I am talking about removing physical traces of impurities such as urine, pre-seminal fluid, faeces, menstrual blood etc. i.e. things that people either wipe off with tissues and/or wash off using a bidet or similar.

The kind of dirt present on the rest of the body other than the private parts of both males and females is not impurity, it is just sweat, dead skin cells etc. and doesn't need to be washed off before prayer.

What I am querying is whether it will be possible/difficult to clean urine or pre-seminal fluid from the underside of the foreskin. Again I never mentioned the word 'rolling'. Some posters referred to pulling back the foreskin and I queried whether that was meant literally or not.

You say you don't understand what I mean. Let's take an analogy. Try slightly pulling up the sleeve of your jacket while you're wearing it, toward your elbow, with one hand, without exposing the inside of your sleeve. This is what I understand by pulling.

Now try folding the sleeve back on itself slightly so that the inside of the sleeve is now on the outside. This is what I understand by folding.

Now try to think about whether retracting the foreskin is more akin to pulling, or folding.

If it is more akin to pulling (which I strongly suspect), then the underside of the foreskin is never exposed and thus can't be washed.

If it more akin to folding(which I strongly doubt), then it will just be difficult to do this every time you want to clean. Not difficult in the sense of deciphering the Rosetta Stone, just an everyday difficulty that it would be easier not to have to do.

ConcreteUnderpants · 27/03/2019 07:41

Oh and we don't get me wrong, I am no supporter of circumcision at all.
I'm just grown up and intelligent enough to believe there is a better way to debate this rather than insulting and berating other cultures and ridiculing people's 'stupid sky-alien' beliefs.

ConcreteUnderpants · 27/03/2019 07:36

It makes me wonder whether you have seen a foreskin retract on an erect penis, I guess not considering your culture has them all butchered.

I admire the passion your numerous posts on this show, smotheroffive.

Can you share what you actions you take against these butchering cultures? Writing to your MP? Demonstrating outside mosques, synagogues, African churches?

And presumably you also hold approach baby ear piercers in the street and give them a piece of your mind, too.

Surely you don't just froth and attack certain cultures on anonymous forums?

breeze44 · 27/03/2019 07:26

why not give males the choice as to whether or not they wish to consider a circumcision shortly before they become sexually active?

Because by that age the risk of complications is higher, the recovery process is slower and more difficult, and the person will be fully aware of the process and usually never forget it.

If you live in a country where the vast majority of males are circumcised, then the responsible thing to do as a parent is to get it done at a young age when none of these disadvantages would be present.

Culture is often minimised as a factor of importance but actually the feeling of belonging, of having your place within a wider family, community and culture is very positive for emotional well-being and shared practices can cement that sense of identity and belonging.

cranstonmanor · 27/03/2019 07:19

Just tell him that you will pay for it once your DS turns 18 and asks for it himself. It's ds's body, so he should decide.