Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Circumcision

606 replies

muma19 · 20/03/2019 15:54

DP wants DS circumcised however I don't. I also have MIL getting involved and pressuring me. What do I do? I want to be fair to my partner but I really don't want him veg for circumcised. HELP!!!!

OP posts:
Mississippilessly · 28/03/2019 09:19

Cutting off a perfectly healthy body part isnt in their best interests.

It just isnt. You can pretend to justify it all you like.

breeze44 · 28/03/2019 09:16

Mississippilessly you said:

I'll keep saying it til I'm blue in the face because you arent responding to me: IT IS NOT YOUR PENIS. Therefore it should not be your call to make.

I'm fully aware that it is not my penis. Please re-read my response above to JAPAB and to Smother where I have covered this.

To recap, as parents we take all kinds of decisions on behalf of our children when they are too young to consent, based on what we believe to be in their best interests. The difference here is that you don't see the benefits of circumcision and so don't class it as being in their best interests. We do.

Leaving it up until the child is old enough to express a preference means a higher risk and a more difficult recovery. I told you about the NHS doctor who told me about horrendous difficulties during recovery including the penis swelling to twice its size. Any parent would want to avoid that for their children, in the knowledge that if they grow up uncircumcised in a community which routinely circumcises, they will be the odd ones out and wish they had been circumcised. We have to take that high likelihood into account.

Again, if you try to understand this issue from within the perspectives and priorities of a community with a focus on individual choice, and in which circumcision is not routinely done, you are not going to be able to understand this.

We have to take decisions on behalf of children who are going to grow up in a community with a different mindset, and make assessments of what is in their best interests within that context.

sagradafamiliar · 28/03/2019 09:03

breeze this paragraph you wrote, The community as a whole does not see it as a big deal. Your attitude reflects a Western individualistic perspective whereby the freedom, choices and personal decisions of the individual are seen as paramount, even when they significantly differ from each other within the same society.

Is quite sinister. You make it sound like the 'western perspective' of freedom, choices and personal decisions of the individual, bodily autonomy being paramount, is a negative.

Mississippilessly · 28/03/2019 08:50

I'll keep saying it til I'm blue in the face because you arent responding to me: IT IS NOT YOUR PENIS. Therefore it should not be your call to make.

And again when asked about mutilation our culture doesn't define it thus that is irrelevant. It IS mutilation. You are permanently mutilating a body. What you mean is 'but we think its ok'. Your arguments could be used to condone all sorts of practises- FGM, foot binding, breast binding etc etc. Just because you think it's ok it doesn't mean it is. If it is such a clearly sensible thing to do then you would let adult males decide for themselves.

I'm currently rocking my 6mnth old DS as he has a tummy bug and is sad. I'm trying to imagine how I could condone chopping bits off him.

breeze44 · 28/03/2019 08:45

Bibijayne you said
In the UK, unless you have medical grounds for it, circumsicion can only be carried out by a registered rabbi or Iman.

My BIL and his wife (currently TTC) were having the same debate. She's anti, he's pro because it's easier to keep clean. When he realised it cannot be done by a doctor in the UK unless there's medical need, he changed his mind and they now won't circumcise.

May I ask who told you this? This is untrue. In some areas of the UK you can get a referral from your GP for boys to be circumcised in an NHS hospital under GA at around 1 year old, even without medical need.

There are also private clinics where the practitioners are trained doctors/surgeons and the procedure is done under LA. In the one we used a letter was sent to our GP from the clinic so medical records could be updated. Some clinics specify only infants under 3-4 months old, others will do it for toddlers. It depends on the surgical technique used.

Both NHS hospitals and private clinics will carry out assessment to ensure the child is fit to undergo the procedure and that it is in their best interests.

I think you should check this online and let your BIL and his wife know so that they make a fully informed decision. However, if she is firmly against it, then neither the NHS nor most clinics(if any) will perform the procedure without both parents present to sign a consent form.

I'm not sure about the exact situation in the Jewish community but I have not heard anything about Muslim imams getting trained to do circumcision. An imam is someone who leads prayers, some of them might be trained but from my experience in the Muslim community it is usually done by doctors/surgeons who are not imams.

breeze44 · 28/03/2019 08:20

JAPAB said:

If it's all the same to you I'd rather have the full whack of everything I am naturally capable of.

Again I am not trying to convince you personally to get this procedure.

Rather than having a reduction to it made on my behalf because someone else does not see this as a big deal.

The community as a whole does not see it as a big deal. Your attitude reflects a Western individualistic perspective whereby the freedom, choices and personal decisions of the individual are seen as paramount, even when they significantly differ from each other within the same society.

In my community, such ideas are less influential. There is a stronger sense of community and of having a shared religion which is also a complete way of life. Look at the stats on circumcision in Muslim countries, most are more than 90% with many countries being more than 99%.

Bibijayne · 28/03/2019 08:11

We had this debate recently (our DS was born last summer). My DH and I are not religious. DH was circumcised as a baby (he was born in London, but grew up in the middle east). His mum was keen on circumcision (she's British, but from an expat community. She's also nominally CofE). And espoused 'health benefits'. We said no. She said it's more painful if it is done when older (true) but DH and I pointed out we live in the UK where most boys are not circumcised. Not in the middle east where 99% of boys are circumsised regardless of religious background.

In the UK, unless you have medical grounds for it, circumsicion can only be carried out by a registered rabbi or Iman.

My BIL and his wife (currently TTC) were having the same debate. She's anti, he's pro because it's easier to keep clean. When he realised it cannot be done by a doctor in the UK unless there's medical need, he changed his mind and they now won't circumcise.

I think sometimes family go for what is familiar. Or worry that there choices are negatively benign judged if you do something different. It's not the case. Things change and circumstances change.

sagradafamiliar · 28/03/2019 08:08

The men I've been with who were circumcised as minors enjoyed sex but they obviously don't know any different. My ex who had to have it done for medical reasons as an adult, was gutted because of the decrease in pleasure as like enter said, the glans is incredibly sensitive and as it has to harden/adapt/become much less sensitive, that clearly goes for sexual enjoyment as well.

breeze44 · 28/03/2019 08:06

Continuing to quote:

The adult human male has told us all very clearly. You simply ignore it.

If you are talking about the poster who talked about sensitivity, I didn't ignore it. His post describes his experience and his reasons for not wishing to be circumcised. I'm not trying to convince him personally to go ahead with the procedure. But I don't see how this one individual experience outweighs the experience of those men who have been circumcised as infants and now have a positive view of it, in terms of being a compelling argument within communities who do routinely circumcise.

Are we ignoring the male who tells us he couldn't tolerate even the feel of sift cotton underwear against his penis if it were to be circumcised?

Is that not a widespread fact?

This made me laugh! I'm not sure what is meant by a widespread fact, I guess you mean a fact which applies on an extensive scale? In any case, I'm not sure how one individual's description of his experience can constitute a fact. I don't see how it impacts anything other than his personal decision not to get circumcised.

JAPAB · 28/03/2019 07:57

"With regards to loss of sensitivity, this would not be severe, and is only an issue if you see the maximisation of sexual pleasure as a goal to be aimed for in and of itself."

Blimey. If it's all the same to you I'd rather have the full whack of everything I am naturally capable of. Rather than having a reduction to it made on my behalf because someone else does not see this as a big deal.

breeze44 · 28/03/2019 07:50

Smother, I will quote some of your points and answer them:

Can you actually hear yourself!!!? Well, I didn't say it out loud, so no, but I am fully aware of what I am writing here, if that's what you mean. Your outraged and incredulous reaction suggests to me that you are so used to being surrounded by like-minded people from a similar cultural background, that you have come to see your perspective as a kind of universal norm from which everyone must see themselves as deviating if they practice circumcision. That's not the case, other people have different perspectives from within which they engage in a practice established for millennia.

It's quite clear; you would presumably see any slight pain and redness caused to your child by vaccinations as being outweighed by the benefits of the vaccine.

Similarly for us, slight pain and redness which heals quickly and completely is outweighed by the benefits. You don't accept the benefits of circumcision as being more significant than the pain and initial redness; that's your perspective. We see them as being more significant; that's our perspective.

I think you must have come here for....well what purpose exactly.

I'm not sure if this is a question or a statement but my purpose in posting on this thread is to try and show how some of the arguments routinely used by those who are anti-circumcision are not necessarily relevant to all those who practice it. I have seen threads on this subject in the past before I started actively posting on here and a pp was correct in saying that they are often just an echo chamber.
I'm also trying to give people an insight into the perspective of someone from a community which routinely practises circumcision as such perspectives are often absent from discussions on this forum. And finally, I'm just engaging in general discussion with other posters on the topic and responding to their views.

I might ask you the same thing. The OP's issue has been dealt with and the proposed circumcision is not going ahead but you are still very active on the thread, so how do you see your purpose here?

breeze44 · 28/03/2019 07:15

WeBuilt, in answer to your question: At what point do you judge that an act of non-consensual mutilation which brings with it undeniable negative consequences is a step too far?

'Non-consensual': In general our experience leads us to believe that the vast majority of our sons when grown up will be happy that we consented to circumcision on their behalf.

'Mutilation': People in our community don't define it thus.

'undeniable negative consequences': I don't believe that there are. The only potential consequences which have been mentioned are pain and possible loss of sensitivity.
Pain, especially nowadays in an era of easily available anaesthetics, is usually minimal. Any slight amount of pain will be quickly forgotten and is outweighed by the lifelong benefits.
With regards to loss of sensitivity, this would not be severe, and is only an issue if you see the maximisation of sexual pleasure as a goal to be aimed for in and of itself. I repeat that circumcised men have normal sex lives and the same fertility rates as non-circumcised.

I don't fully understand your points about murdering and punching people in the street; it reads as if you think I am trying to persuade you that circumcision should be done within your own ideological framework/worldview and according to your decision-making criteria. I'm not; I'm trying to give some insight into the perspective of some of those who do routinely circumcise, but that takes place in the context of a different worldview and a different set of decision-making criteria.

Finally, you said: I just can't understand the desperation to mutilate babies for no actual reason and try to justify it by saying "oh, they'll probably be fine - even though they've had thousands of sensitive nerve endings taken from them without their consent, it probably won't make any difference - it's not like I've chopped their arm off."

That's blatantly not what I am saying and you know it. I don't have to justify it; male circumcision is currently not illegal in any country.
I do have actual reasons: circumcision is mandated in my religion and is also a cultural norm which people are happy to adhere to.

breeze44 · 28/03/2019 06:51

CallipygianFancier, I don't think it is ok, because it is harmful. Circumcision is not harmful. But if you wanted to try and persuade people to give up the practice of breast ironing, you would have to put together a coherent and logical argument and engage in discussion with people.
Just going in shouting 'barbaric!' is not going to make any difference, and I often wonder when people come on to threads like this just to say how appalling they find a certain practice: who are the comments aimed at and what are they hoping to achieve?

Smotheroffive · 27/03/2019 17:55

Are we ignoring the male who tells us he couldn't tolerate even the feel of sift cotton underwear against his penis if it were to be circumcised?

Is that not a widespread fact?

You can't surely ignore what he's written,truthfully, this is what it is actually like, so as you cannot put sufficient controls into an experiment where a man can flip between being circumcised and not, all you have is the guy who isn't knowing how sensitive it is to any exposure!

Smotheroffive · 27/03/2019 17:51

That newly exposed skin might be red for a day or two but it is perfectly healthy

Can you actually hear yourself!!!?

I think you must have come here for....well what purpose exactly.

The adult human male has told us all very clearly. You simply ignore it. You ignore everything in favour of slicing off foreskins, which actually are fully attached as babies to 5ish. Saying its done by a qualified surgeon, doesn't make it acceptable to do to a infant to mutilate their perfect little bodies. A woman who never wants to bear dc and certainly wouldn't ever BF has no need of her female parts which can increase chances of illness, but you don't presume to take that decision for them.

You presume to have the right, but its wrong. You have no right to cut your children, its gross.

They're clearly not perfect for you, and that makes me feel a bit sick really.

JAPAB · 27/03/2019 16:07

"There are studies showing sensitivity and pleasure is the same after circumcision of adult males and others that say it decreases, but for me, I would never choose to be circumsized, regardless of any slight health benefit!! No way."

The studies that show it doesn't must assume that the actual males who have reported that it has had this effect, must be lying.

I think it is fair to say that in some males it definately does. And that means you don't risk that lightly on behalf of another, as you cannot know ahead of time that it won't have this effect on this male.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/03/2019 15:38

WeBuilt, the analogy doesn't work because if you cut off a person's arms or their tongue or removed their ovaries their life after that would be severely restricted.
Circumcised men generally lead normal lives and have normal sex lives.

It wasn't really meant to be an analogy - just a logical extension of where you could end up using 'medical' justifications. How about a couple of fingers or toes, then, or maybe earlobes that could harbour dirt? At what point do you judge that an act of non-consensual mutilation which brings with it undeniable negative consequences is a step too far?

Would you say that, because murdering a random stranger in the street would clearly be abhorrent, it would therefore not be bad (or maybe even an act of kindness?!) to just knock them out with a mighty punch from which they would recover after just a couple of days in hospital? After all, you never know what other previously-unknown health conditions might be discovered and subsequently cured whilst they're in hospital?

Even if you are/were a man who had been circumcised as an adult and were therefore in a position to say that YOU noticed no difference in your pre- and post-circumcised sexual enjoyment, you still wouldn't be able to speak for all men in general.

I just can't understand the desperation to mutilate babies for no actual reason and try to justify it by saying "oh, they'll probably be fine - even though they've had thousands of sensitive nerve endings taken from them without their consent, it probably won't make any difference - it's not like I've chopped their arm off."

CallipygianFancier · 27/03/2019 15:14

"If men weren't happy about it they wouldn't do it to their own sons" isn't a great argument. Look at the beast ironing thing that was in the news this week (which I'd never even heard of before), it's women doing it to their daughters. So is that OK?

A barbaric practice that's normalised in a given culture is still a barbaric practice.

breeze44 · 27/03/2019 15:06

MrsBethel, I think if the 100 boys were proportionate percentage wise to the current religious and ethnic demographics of the world as a whole, you are right that most would be 1 or 4.
However, if the 100 boys were Muslims or from another community which routinely practises circumcision then I think that most would be 2 or 3.

The idea of being upset that your parents got you circumcised is generally quite alien to people from my background. If men weren't happy about it, they wouldn't go on to circumcise their own sons.

breeze44 · 27/03/2019 15:00

WeBuilt, the analogy doesn't work because if you cut off a person's arms or their tongue or removed their ovaries their life after that would be severely restricted.
Circumcised men generally lead normal lives and have normal sex lives.

Smother, first of all, the foreskin is not ripped off it is generally surgically removed by a trained surgeon or other person with the relevant training. Secondly, it is not the same as removing skin from anywhere on the body, if you removed skin elsewhere you would be left with a wound, with circumcision it heals perfectly because there is another skin underneath. That newly exposed skin might be red for a day or two but it is perfectly healthy.

Thirdly, I disagree that it would be better to do it at five years old because a child that age will understand some of what is happening but is not old enough to fully understand why it is happening.
It is not a painful procedure for babies/toddlers at all. Nowadays the procedure is usually done under anaesthetic and young children recover so quickly. One of my sons got it done as a toddler and as soon as we got home he went comfortably down for a nap and when he woke up he was laughing and bouncing around on his bed. Another son who had it done as a baby had a feed immediately afterwards and from then on he was fine.

When I said that adults or older boys would remember it, I meant they would remember the healing process which will be more difficult and painful in their case. I don't agree that GA is preferable to LA as you have to fast for a few hours before that so if that was done with children they would be distressed from being hungry and thirsty by the time they woke up afterwards. With LA they use a numbing cream first before the injection.

breeze44 · 27/03/2019 14:35

What vested interest does the World Health Organisation have in promoting circumcision or manipulating data?

enterthewaterman · 27/03/2019 14:20

There are studies showing sensitivity and pleasure is the same after circumcision of adult males and others that say it decreases, but for me, I would never choose to be circumsized, regardless of any slight health benefit!! No way.

I know this: when my foreskin is retracted, the head of the penis is very sensitive! If it was rubbing on the inside of my underwear all day, it would feel VERY uncomfortable. As in, I wouldn't be able to cope with it. So the fact that a circumsized man can walk around like that all day every day, to me, implies he has less feeling (basically no feeling?) in the head of his penis.

No thanks!

MrsBethel · 27/03/2019 14:14

A thought experiment.

Suppose we could study the choices of 100 baby boys.
Suppose they are not circumcised as infants.
How many of those children, when they are older, will fall into these categories:

  1. Has considered the pros and cons of circumcision. Is glad they weren't circumcised an as an infant.
  2. Has considered the pros and cons of circumcision. Regrets the fact they weren't circumcised an as an infant. Does not wish to be circumcised as an adult, as the complication rate is higher. Wishes their parents had done it to them as a kid.
  3. Has considered the pros and cons of circumcision. Regrets the fact they weren't circumcised an as an infant. Elects to thave the procedure as an adult.
  4. Has not considered the pros and cons of circumcision.

If the vast majority of that 100 were in groups (2) or (3), you could make a case for performing circumcision on infants, arguing the removal of choise is an acceptable opportunity cost.

I would suspect you'd end up with the vast majortiy of those 100 in either (1) or (4).

NunoGoncalves · 27/03/2019 14:09

I think there is clearly evidence of some small benefits with regard to STDs, herpes and HIV. It's a very small advantage though, and those health problems are already so easily mitigable through other means, that the cost of chopping off part of your body is probably not worth it.

I'm sure if you went and asked a bunch of 18-25 year old men if they thought it was a good trade-off, they'd decline, even when armed with the latest scientific evidence. So I don't think any adult should really be making that decision for their baby, if most adult males would say no. Why not let him choose when he himself is an adult?

MrsBethel · 27/03/2019 14:04

It's funny how the 'medical benefits' are so often espoused by people who want to practise circumcision for cultural reasons!

There are studies that demonstrate there is no benefit to circumcision. There are others that demonstrate the opposite. Sadly, most on either side are compiled by people with a cultural agenda.

IMO the most likely explanantion is almost certainly as Florescentadolescent stated: circumcision is correlated with religious practise, which is in turn correlated with groups who have less sex anyway. Control for that and there will be no benefit. Don't control for that and you will see correlation and not causation.
And there's no reason to believe that will not equally well apply in sub-Saharan African where most of these studies take place.

Either way, that is not an argument to practise circumcision on infants, as infants won't be having sex. The complication rate is higher, but anyone of majority age can themselves elect to be circumcised, if they themselves are convinced by those uncontrolled studies and wish themselves to run the risk of having unprotected sex with a circumcised penis.

Men don't often elect to be circumcised for non-medical reasons. That tells us something.