Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Circumcision

606 replies

muma19 · 20/03/2019 15:54

DP wants DS circumcised however I don't. I also have MIL getting involved and pressuring me. What do I do? I want to be fair to my partner but I really don't want him veg for circumcised. HELP!!!!

OP posts:
MrsBethel · 28/03/2019 13:27

The men who were circumcised as a child have two choices:
a) make an issue of it, upset their parents, admit to themselves that they are probably having less fulfilling sex than they otherwise would, and challenge their own cultural upbringing.
b) convince themselves it's fine and just 'go along' with the culture.

What's done is done, it can't be changed. Most men will rationalise (b).

I like to think if I were a father contemplating this for my own son I would have the integrity and intellectual fortitude to be honest about what is best for my child, rather than going with whatever rationalisation makes me feel better about myself. But who knows?

CallipygianFancier · 28/03/2019 11:32

Their mindset is theirs. They can be happy with their own circumcision and that's fine. That is the limit on who they are morally right to circumcise: themselves.

breeze44 · 28/03/2019 11:29

CallipygianFancier you said that I should reject the community's mindset, but it's my mindset as well, and the mindset of those who were circumcised as children.

breeze44 · 28/03/2019 11:27

JAPAB you said
No-one wants to stop people having a shared community or religion in common. They just want adults to be able to choose to not be a part of it, and for permanent physical alterings to be delayed until the person being altered is in a position to accept or reject it.

I realise that, but are you hoping that parents will change their minds about infant circumcision and voluntarily give it up, or are you hoping that governments would ban it altogether?

CallipygianFancier · 28/03/2019 11:24

The reasons why you are not right to compel a coworker to go and pray on her lunchbreak are the same as why you are wrong to circumcise your child.

You think it is not harmful, or "worth" doing. It is not your decision. Your right as a parent to make decisions for you child does not extend to unnecessary surgery because you want it done. Why you want it done is irrelevant.

How long it's been done for, how many people have done it or continue to do it, all irrelevant.

breeze44 · 28/03/2019 11:24

One of the effects I should say

breeze44 · 28/03/2019 11:22

Nuno I think some of my posts about health benefits and cleanliness may have been taken as my main reasons for circumcision when actually I was just mentioning them as advantages and trying to explain why the arguments of 'just teach them to wash' etc. are not really convincing for me.

I'm not saying we do it just because everyone else does in the community, it's primarily for religious reasons. But the effect of everyone in a religious community doing something is that it becomes the norm.

ConcreteUnderpants · 28/03/2019 11:12

Now you and Sam are saying you do it just because everyone else in your community does it. Fine. That probably won't go down well with a lot of people either but at least you admit that's the primary reason.

I think the primary reason is that God said it should be done, part of the covenant.
Being part of a community, the same as everybody else is secondary.

(Cue 10 pages of God/sky fairy is evil, mutilating babies etc......)

breeze44 · 28/03/2019 11:10

I also don't think anyone can argue that circumcision for infants is contrary to British culture because it is not just relatively recently established communities like Muslims who do it. As well as the long established Jewish community the British aristocracy used to practice it as standard.

NunoGoncalves · 28/03/2019 10:58

I don't think anyone is really trying to "persuade" anyone else or change anyone's mind (apart from the OP's originally, and she's long gone now). It's just a discussion. It's perfectly ok to talk about something without necessarily trying or expecting to change the other person's opinion. Especially when it's a hot topic like this where people are very set in their own beliefs.

The conversation has become a bit circular though. I think a lot of people initially took issue because some people tried to claim they did it because of the tiny, debatable, minor health benefits. Now you and Sam are saying you do it just because everyone else in your community does it. Fine. That probably won't go down well with a lot of people either but at least you admit that's the primary reason.

breeze44 · 28/03/2019 10:53

I don't see how what I said is sinister. Maybe I have not worded it clearly?

Perhaps you think I was espousing a principle whereby parents have the absolute right to control over their child's body and can get any procedure done that they wish? No, that's not the case at all. The only procedures we can consent to on behalf of our child are circumcision or non-harmful and permissible procedures which is agreed by trustworthy doctors to be medically beneficial e.g. vaccination.

Maybe you mean that not adhering to a belief in full individual freedom and choice is sinister? Ok, let me give you an example to try and show it's not sinister. Let's say I'm at work, and I have an hour for my lunch break. My colleague, who is not religious, feels that they have complete freedom to do what they want with that free hour; they can go to a restaurant, they can go for a walk, they can go and do some shopping. Nothing influences their decision other than their own preference and choice. As for me, I don't feel that I have complete freedom and choice to do what I want because I know it is the time of the mid-day prayer, and so I have to spend at least 15 minutes or so of my lunch break to do wudoo' and pray. For me this is obligatory. I can't just decide that today I will go and sit in the park for a full hour instead.
As long as I am not compelling my colleague to pray alongside me (and why would I or how could I?) I don't understand why that would be seen as problematic for anyone. In fact, non-Muslim people in the UK are usually quite supportive of using break times to pray.

Or maybe the problem here is the mere existence in Western society of people with different beliefs and attitudes. You put 'western perspective' in quotation marks as if to suggest that the values you mentioned are actually universal when this is not the case. It amazes me that so many people are shocked to learn that not everyone thinks as they do.
I live in the West. I'm not here to attack anyone's freedoms, or to try and force my beliefs on them. I live here in peace, don't break the law, and interact with people from outside of my community. But it would be naïve for anyone to think that everyone who comes here automatically adopts mainstream secular values. The reality of multiculturalism is that people have different beliefs from the mainstream society. As long as they are not forcing it on others or breaking the law, why is that sinister?

samG76 · 28/03/2019 10:30

No, Miss - they weren't there in official capacity - just friends and family.

Acis · 28/03/2019 10:28

In some areas of the UK you can get a referral from your GP for boys to be circumcised in an NHS hospital under GA at around 1 year old, even without medical need.

Only on a private basis. The NHS won't fund for surgery on children where there is no medical need.

Mississippilessly · 28/03/2019 10:24

Thankyou SamG76.
Does that amount of people not ring alarm bells about the risks though?

samG76 · 28/03/2019 10:21

Mississipi - I hope your DS feels better.

I should add it was done by a dentist in the presence of about 8 GPs and 10 hospital doctors, including the heads of paediatrics and the ICU at the local hospital. So I think we had the bases covered!

Disfordarkchocolate · 28/03/2019 10:10

You can Mississippilessly and I have heard some horror stories about it too.

Mississippilessly · 28/03/2019 10:08

You allowed a dentist to cut off your sons foreskin?

Right. So fucking glad I'm not expected to do any of this shit.

samG76 · 28/03/2019 10:05

Bibijayne- there is no such thing as a registered rabbi, as it not a state organised thing. There are a group of people who do circs for the Jewish community in the UK, most of whom are doctors. We used a doctor for one DS, and a dentist for another.

Outpinked - the way you have worded it, it seems your DGM and DGD didn't bring up their kids as Jewish. So your anecdote supports Breeze's and my argument that it is an integral part of being in a community.

CallipygianFancier · 28/03/2019 10:04

We have to take decisions on behalf of children who are going to grow up in a community with a different mindset, and make assessments of what is in their best interests within that context.

Saying "fuck the community's mindset" and not mutilating your child is probaby a good place to start.

Hell, docking dogs tails has been banned (with a "necessity" exemption for working dogs) for more than a decade.

Acis · 28/03/2019 10:02

I don't see how this one individual experience outweighs the experience of those men who have been circumcised as infants and now have a positive view of it, in terms of being a compelling argument within communities who do routinely circumcise.

I don't see how the experience of men who have been circumcised as infants comes into it at all, given that they have no memory of the event and have never known anything different.

Any parent would want to avoid that for their children, in the knowledge that if they grow up uncircumcised in a community which routinely circumcises, they will be the odd ones out and wish they had been circumcised.

That's a very stifling point of view. No parent has to bring their child up within such a limited community, and refusing to let your child mix with and grow up with children outside the community is in itself contentious. Fitting in with a community you have chosen to restrict yourself to, when your child may well make different life choices, is simply not an excuse for mutilating your child.

Mississippilessly · 28/03/2019 09:34

Breeze I'm not trying to persuade you. You've made the decision. And the fact you keep banging on about fingernails shows that all the reasoning in the world wont do anything.

Its really sad. I hope this loke so many other practises does out.

JAPAB · 28/03/2019 09:30

"Your attitude reflects a Western individualistic perspective whereby the freedom, choices and personal decisions of the individual are seen as paramount, even when they significantly differ from each other within the same society."

So if I said I wouldn't want to needlessly lose some of my sense of taste or sight or anything else that represents an individualistic Western attitude.

I think it just represents not wanting to needlessly miss out.

No-one wants to stop people having a shared community or religion in common. They just want adults to be able to choose to not be a part of it, and for permanent physical alterings to be delayed until the person being altered is in a position to accept or reject it.

outpinked · 28/03/2019 09:29

My DGM and DGD are/were Jewish and neither of them would circumcise my Uncle or Dad. Kind of liberal for the 1960s really but they just wouldn’t have it. It’s completely unnecessary and causes more harm than good.

breeze44 · 28/03/2019 09:26

Mississippilessly 'it just isn't' is not a persuasive argument and I'm not pretending anything. This is the reality of how people who are different from you live their lives and grow up to want the same for their own children.

breeze44 · 28/03/2019 09:24

'Mutilation' is a value judgement. Some people see organ donation as mutilation. Others don't.

Presumably you cut your child's fingernails? You will say it's not permanent. But as soon as they grow back, you cut them again. In Western society, would anyone who had, say, five inch long fingernails be able to live a normal life? Then in societal terms, it has the same effect as cutting them off permanently.