Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Circumcision

606 replies

muma19 · 20/03/2019 15:54

DP wants DS circumcised however I don't. I also have MIL getting involved and pressuring me. What do I do? I want to be fair to my partner but I really don't want him veg for circumcised. HELP!!!!

OP posts:
Magenta82 · 20/03/2019 18:36

@LifeIsToughMate
You had your son ritually mutilated to appease a bloodthirsty deity, but think the ones who oppose such barbarism are fear-mongering?!

Why did you do it? Was it fear of your deity or fear of your community? What would be the consequence of not damaging him?

It seams like the ones who are really acting out of fear are the people who cut bits off their children for religious reasons.

TheCraicDealer · 20/03/2019 18:33

I signed up to the What To Expect When yYoure Expecting app and keep getting emails about active chats on their board which is mostly Is posters- a recent thread on circumcision was enlightening to say the least. To read the posts you'd think an uncircumcised boy was definitely going to have an ugly penis which would cause him pain and result in an agonising circumcision as an older child to remove a tight foreskin. I know no-one who has had to have a circumcision in later life, so it can't be anywhere near as common as they all told themselves. As for it being "cleaner"? Teach your son how to wash his penis. It's basic parenting.

It's completely alien to me to hear these women who fret about accidentally eating a bit of Camembert during pregnancy actively plan to cut a healthy bit of tissue off their newborn child and tell themselves that they feel no pain. Fuck off.

Arnoldthecat · 20/03/2019 18:31

There is no shortage of video material showing male babies responding to being cut and also suffering. I know,lets excise the clitoral hoods of all females once they are old enough. I just checked and my penis is nice and clean despite not being cut. What this is really about is cowardice and the fear of upsetting those who ritually circumcise. We turn a blind eye to brutality and suffering and sanction criminal acts because those who should declare it as such,dare not speak it.

Tomtontom · 20/03/2019 18:31

I can't get my head around what kind of a mother would put their child through a needless medical procedure. It's sick and twisted, however you try and dress it up.

DoneLikeAKipper · 20/03/2019 18:26

I don’t think it’s mutilation

Just because you don’t think it is, doesn’t mean it isn’t. You ripped skin off your baby to please some unproven deity, you scarred his body for life without his permission, whether you don’t see a problem with that is irrelevant - under any other circumstances, doing that to a baby without medical reasons would be considered child abuse.

FizzyGreenWater · 20/03/2019 18:26

I was circumcised at age 7 and it is cleaner, and the girls I've been with said they preferred it (of course, they may have been merely humouring me) - I prefer not having a foreskin and wouldn't reverse it.

They may well have been. It looks horrible, and definitely as if there's something missing.

How would you know what you prefer - it's supposed to lessen sensitivity, so presumably you have no memory and certainly no uncircumcised sex experience to compare this to.

Jimdandy · 20/03/2019 18:24

Circumcision is nasty, cruel barbaric and child abuse.

It does not belong in a modern world at all.

Medical reason excepted.

Disfordarkchocolate · 20/03/2019 18:23

@LifeIsToughMate children taught to wash don't accumulate dirt.

LifeIsToughMate · 20/03/2019 18:20

Op We has it done to my DS. For religious reasons.

It’s definately cleaner as there is no sack or gaps for any dirt to accumulate.

However the procedure is quite hard to watch as a mother even though baby recovered from it quite quickly and he didn’t feel a thing to be honest.

I have no regrets but I do think you need to be gentle on yourself and discuss it together and tell him to wait till you feel ready. Alternatively it can wait for when the child is older (but will be more painful) or when the child is an adult and wants to decide for himself.

I don’t think it’s mutilation and it’s not considered as such so ignore all the fearmongering on here.

gubbsywubbsy · 20/03/2019 18:18

Urgh.. are you American? There was a recent documentary and it's hideous and a lot of men were trying growing ( stretching ) their foreskin again and said sex was so much better with it . It's supposed to be there... please don't mutilate him.

Arnoldthecat · 20/03/2019 18:11

Thanks feelingverylazy for the BMJ link . A very interesting read. Any practitioner who has any sense wouldn't do this with both parental consents in writing. I wonder what happens in the case of estranged or absent parents? I think the judge on whom case law depends may have been biased and/or too cowardly to outlaw ritual circumcision.

Justanothervoiceintheworld · 20/03/2019 18:08

It is mutilation!!!!! Would you cut off your daughter's clitorial hood just because someone told you too? This is a religious belief pushed on every other religion and nonreligious person. This is not about health!!!!!! Go ahead and cut off a part of your vagina first. Then ask if it seems right to you.

LonelyDadNeedsHelp · 20/03/2019 18:06

@room32 "it's clearly not that harmful"

Male circumcision literally kills more than 100 boys in the US alone each year.

HotpotLawyer · 20/03/2019 18:03

Missed FeelongVeryLazy's post about consent.

I would let it be known to your DP that it is not legal for one parent alone to consent, tell him it is not happening and that is that.

Then tell MIL the same and say the discussion has ended. And ignore any ensuing histrionics.

HotpotLawyer · 20/03/2019 17:58

OK, I have just checked a London clinic offering circumcision - CircumcisionPRO . Interestingly, under their heading 'Health Benefits' they use weasel words ("supporters of circumcision have cited benefits") but say they do not advocate circumcision on general health grounds.

Under the Age Groups they have a section on consent which says both parents must be present and consent, or if a parent is unable to be present they must have a signed letter, with proof of signature.

I guess not all clinics would be so particular.

Happydove · 20/03/2019 17:56

We had arguments aout this before DS was born. ( proper big arguments with research papers being thrown across the room at each other).
Well DS was born DH is a typical man so of course it was never done. I stayed quite and got my way. But no way in hell was I ever going to concent to that one. I also didn’t have MIL on my case as to be honest she had probably forgotten about having her own son done and certainly wouldn’t have thought of it.
You have my sympathy but you don’t agree to it you never give concent and it will not be on NHS so would actually take effort to organize. Loose the MIL as that’s probably your biggest risk here.
Don’t do it though!

feelingverylazytoday · 20/03/2019 17:54

Arnold both parents must give consent to elective circumcision, though not other procedures.
jme.bmj.com/content/30/3/259

Arnoldthecat · 20/03/2019 17:45

Why wouldnt they arrest anyone? Who is the decider with regard to medical procedures? Can either parent make an autonomous decision or must both agree? I think this would be an interesting test of the law. The procedure was non essential . Has an assault taken place? The child is unable to consent. One parent consents, the other doesnt.

Weathermonger · 20/03/2019 17:44

@greenpop21 I agree, and that's why when our son was born we decided against it. However when our first child was due (25 years ago) we didn't have access to the information that is available now, and were regaled with what you could say were old wives tales, of what could go wrong if we didn't do it. Different generation.

HotpotLawyer · 20/03/2019 17:43

How old is your baby / child?

I established before pregnancy that no child I gave birth to would be circumcised unless there was a medical need. e.g tight foreskin beyond puberty, constant balinitis etc.

In your shoes OP I would seek advice on whether you can legally stop your DP doing this. Is he in the birth certificate? I would get it put on the child's medical notes that you withhold consent for circumcision.

I understood that it is hard to get an elective circumcision on the national health these days as it is not approved as necessary, but I suppose that communities which favour it know of private doctors that would do it?

Do you have any concern that MIL would persuade DP to go secretly to a private clinic?

celtiethree · 20/03/2019 17:39

CDC findings are not in line with health guidelines from other countries and reflect the strong bias in the US towards circumcision: www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/17441692.2016.1184292?scroll=top&needAccess=true

Itwouldtakemuchmorethanthis · 20/03/2019 17:39

They wouldn’t arrest anyone but I doubt you’d live in harmony afterwards.

Hazlenutpie · 20/03/2019 17:39

It's genital mutilation. Don't do it.

THEsonofaBITCH · 20/03/2019 17:39

How common is penile cancer? Not very.
STDs? Being circumcised is the not the most effective way to prevent them

Nonsense, my DC are fully vaccinated and I think circumcision is barbaric
You did read the link that eth CDC says circumcision is healthier than not? That the CDC says vaccinating is healthier than not? That the risks of the most severe STDs is death? From your posts I guess you didn't.

Arnoldthecat · 20/03/2019 17:38

This is just hypothetical but if your DH had a day off whilst you were at work and took DS to a practitioner and had him cut, when you returned from work, could you go to the police station, report an assault and have him arrested and charged or would they not take it seriously? Who would they arrest? Your DH , the practitioner or both and what might the charges be?