And from first hand experience,
I’m a mother who corcumsized her child. Come from a religious family.
My brother is married outside our faith to a lovely lady. When she has a son , she will probably be horrified at the concept of circumcision.. which is totally understandable.
I am sure between her and my brother they can work out a compromise. I can imagine one family member being pushy about it (I don’t agree with them usually), but I also can see that even though they might not agree but they can respect the decision if explained to them in a respectful manner. IBut if she comes up with shit arguments that are presented here on this thread, you bet that you would face arguments that don’t respect your point of view... and it would be earnt OP.
He is your DS and your DH son. You knew fully well who he is and how much his heritage means to him before marrying him and part of that means having some respect. You don’t have to agree with it but you need to try find ways to respect it.
You don’t have to adhere to it but you also need to give them the space to not adhere to your thinking.
So when you present your argument, come from a neutral perspective else you are igniting sensitivities for yourself..
My sil has won us all over by her gentle approach, she respects where we are coming from, does some thorough research to see which rules are breakable and lets us know accordingly that she doesn’t feel she would be disrespectful of us if she does it her way.. we don’t always agree but I cannot not respect that...
Just don’t impose your thinknt on others and don’t assume they’re idiots who haven’t done their research or speak to them as such just because you feel passionate about the topic.
It’s ur son, I get it. You can have it your way, just don’t cause drama over it.
The approach matters. And most attitudes on here will land you in a needless argument. So avoid