Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Circumcision

606 replies

muma19 · 20/03/2019 15:54

DP wants DS circumcised however I don't. I also have MIL getting involved and pressuring me. What do I do? I want to be fair to my partner but I really don't want him veg for circumcised. HELP!!!!

OP posts:
LifeIsToughMate · 20/03/2019 21:47

if my boys weren't 'made Jewish' (mother's phrase not mine) then Hitler would have won. Sometimes things run deeper than we realise.

And there you go why these topics could be deeply sensitive and the approach is all that matters.

A simple: “can we let him be since he is a child now and doesn’t have a responsibility towards faith, and then we can let him choose when he hits puberty what he wanted if he decides to adhere to the teachings?”.

The answer could be no. But you still get to make that last call without looking disrespectful and then starting this whole other debate about whether there is culture clash.

Justheretogiveaviewfrommyworld · 20/03/2019 21:42

Would they be happy with a symbolic blood drop OP? I am technically Jewish, but dad not so we didn't do much cultural stuff, but for some reason my Mum got really exercised that my boys should be done. Was a right faff and I think it's because my grandad escaped from the Nazis and if my boys weren't 'made Jewish' (mother's phrase not mine) then Hitler would have won. Sometimes things run deeper than we realise.

HelloToMyKitty · 20/03/2019 21:41

From 56% in 2006 to 32.5% in 2009 so lower now

That sounded very low to me, so looked it up. Found it varies massively by region, but in 2010 it was 58% of newborn boys were circumcised according to CDC figures.

Across the 32-year period from 1979 through 2010, the national rate of newborn circumcision declined 10% overall, from 64.5% to 58.3%

The drop is mostly due to Hispanic immigration, as this isn’t a thing in their culture. White/Black/Jewish Americans still get it routinely done.

It’s not a massive concern, just something I hope DC doesn’t resent me for later on! Of course, if we stay here it’s obviously not a concern (and my personal preference for a cut penis is not a good enough reason to put him through this)

topcat2014 · 20/03/2019 21:40

Being in possession of a fully functioning penis with no unneeded surgery, I am happy to confirm I have made it to 47 with no hygiene problems.

Can't comment on whether your sex life is worse being circumsized as I have nothing to compare it to - but I had read that sensitivity is reduced.

Too much is done because of 'culture' in my view.

LifeIsToughMate · 20/03/2019 21:38

And from first hand experience,

I’m a mother who corcumsized her child. Come from a religious family.

My brother is married outside our faith to a lovely lady. When she has a son , she will probably be horrified at the concept of circumcision.. which is totally understandable.

I am sure between her and my brother they can work out a compromise. I can imagine one family member being pushy about it (I don’t agree with them usually), but I also can see that even though they might not agree but they can respect the decision if explained to them in a respectful manner. IBut if she comes up with shit arguments that are presented here on this thread, you bet that you would face arguments that don’t respect your point of view... and it would be earnt OP.

He is your DS and your DH son. You knew fully well who he is and how much his heritage means to him before marrying him and part of that means having some respect. You don’t have to agree with it but you need to try find ways to respect it.

You don’t have to adhere to it but you also need to give them the space to not adhere to your thinking.

So when you present your argument, come from a neutral perspective else you are igniting sensitivities for yourself..

My sil has won us all over by her gentle approach, she respects where we are coming from, does some thorough research to see which rules are breakable and lets us know accordingly that she doesn’t feel she would be disrespectful of us if she does it her way.. we don’t always agree but I cannot not respect that...

Just don’t impose your thinknt on others and don’t assume they’re idiots who haven’t done their research or speak to them as such just because you feel passionate about the topic.

It’s ur son, I get it. You can have it your way, just don’t cause drama over it.

The approach matters. And most attitudes on here will land you in a needless argument. So avoid

anniehm · 20/03/2019 21:38

Just say no. It's time it was illegal except for essential medical reasons - cultural or religious reasons should be banned! It's plain wrong.

LonelyDadNeedsHelp · 20/03/2019 21:31

@THEsonofaBITCH

Every reputable medical professional will tell you that any operation has risk. Boys literally die for nothing. I understand the risk if done in a first world hospital by a trained professional is pretty small but there is still a risk.

I feel desperately sorry for parents who feel so pressured or conditioned by their culture that they will put their baby's life at risk.

Even if you could remove all risk (which you can't), there's still the question of consent. You are removing part of someone's body when they are unable to consent. To me, that is utterly abhorrent.

To those who say it's part of their religion or culture, what if your child chooses a different path in later life? What if they choose not to follow that religion, as is their basic human right? They've already had part of their body removed, on the name of a religion they may not believe in.

If they believe so strongly in it when they are able to consent, then get it done as an adult if you must. I don't see what's so wrong with that.

Ginnymweasley · 20/03/2019 21:30

I don't understand the its cleaner argument. Surely if you teach a child how to wash then both would be equally as clean?? My dh isn't circumcised and is perfectly clean etc. His brother had to be circumcised for medical reasons. I just asked dh if his brother had ever felt alienated cause he was different to his father and sibling, his reply "we don't sit around and discuss our dicks, I haven't seen his since he was a small child" so I really doubt it would make much difference to a childs seld esteem if he is different to family.

Shortandsweet96 · 20/03/2019 21:29

I dont understand how, if no medical reason, this is still a thing?!

There is a law against FGM. So why isn't there a law against Male Genital Mutilation?

Stompythedinosaur · 20/03/2019 21:28

Stand up for your child and don't allow this to happen to them.

They can opt to have it done as adults if they like.

HotpotLawyer · 20/03/2019 21:25

HelloYoMyKitty you may DH d that is a generational thing. Circumcision rates are falling fast in the U.S. From 56% in 2006 to 32.5% in 2009 so lower now.

So your Ds will definitely not be in the minority.

Bananasarenottheonlyfruit · 20/03/2019 21:24

My brothers are both cut. Neither has ever forgiven our parents for having it done. My younger brother particularly feels he was mutilated. He is also sure that he has reduced sensitivity compared to being left intact.

There were no spurious religious excuses or valid medical reasons, just my father wanting it done and my mother not standing up to him.

LifeIsToughMate · 20/03/2019 21:21

Secondly, it is part of a Muslim faith to circumsize but not necessarily at birth. The at birth thing is just to limit pain/ which is an arguable point.

Many people in previous generations waited until boys were older , 10 or so. My father remembers queuing up for it and it was when he felt ready to “become a man” (prepared for backlash). Some wait for them to become men and do it themselves.

This is because the child is not considered responsible for any faith obligations until puberty.

So If your DH or his family subscribe to Islam or Judaism, try look into that. The “when” part is a matter of culture and no harm in debating.

But if you approach this from a narrow minded perspective, you are likely to get ur DH be on the defensive.

Yes many Muslims mix culture with faith and assume there is a deadline on things. There is a difference of opinion on the matters of when, and so on.

From a non faith point of view, I honestly feel yiu should do your research from
Credible sources as many arguments on here are emotional and unscientific. Total bullshit that a circumsized man doesn’t enjoy intimacy. Plz guys stop farting from your mouth

Florescentadolescent · 20/03/2019 21:16

There's a doc on Netflix about circumsistion, get him to watch that. It's barbaric and there are risks.

LifeIsToughMate · 20/03/2019 21:10

My family is Muslim. It is both a religious and cultural practice for Muslims

Please don’t speak in my name. You haven’t stated whether you are a Muslim yourself.

I know plenty of Muslim families who have never opened the Quran and have only inherited the religion, yet don’t practice it or have any knowledge of it.

Doesn’t suddenly qualify your critisism, still just a random opinion from someone who doesn’t practice the faith and using their background to bully people or faith. As good as any other pp on here who might know nothing and have zero background.

HelloToMyKitty · 20/03/2019 21:05

you'd think an uncircumcised boy was definitely going to have an ugly penis

In the States, and an uncircumcised penis is definitely considered ugly and unclean. I actually do dislike of uncut penises due to my upbringing.

All that said, I just couldn’t bear to do it to my child. But I do get worried if I ever go back to America that he will feel ashamed for not having it done.

animalprintfree · 20/03/2019 20:59

OP I was once in a similar position. My DS is not circumcised, but this issue was literally the straw that broke the camel's back in my marriage. My son's father comes from an African country where practically all boys are circumcised regardless of religion. I worry about my son resenting my decision when he realises he is different from his peers, but I simply couldn't do it to him. If you value your marriage and your relationship with your MIL, try to put your point across respectfully. I'd avoid reference to 'mutiliation' and 'abuse'.

A previous poster thought it was a ridiculous assertion that a family member would get this done without one parent's consent, but I've certainly known it to happen. Good luck.

BigFatGiant · 20/03/2019 20:54

@Alsohuman bullshit. If people believe something stupid there is no reason to respect that. If anything there is a moral to imperative to criticise and argue.

THEsonofaBITCH · 20/03/2019 20:54

Nope. Try again. Complications in all cases were minor, treated and fully resolved.

BigFatGiant · 20/03/2019 20:47

@SONofaBITCH perhaps that’s just because circumcision isn’t a cause of death? The cause of death reported would be something like blood loss or sepsis. Sometimes doctors even put down ‘cardiac arrest and respiratory failure’ as a cause of death. I would hope that deaths, even in the US, are very rare. I can think of a few deaths reported in papers/that I have heard about second hand. These were all attributed to people who weren’t trained adequately. I can also recall a few people who had children that suffered infections afterwards but thankfully they all survived. It’s not as straight forward as you think. A lot of circumcisions aren’t done in hospitals or even reported to authorities and medical professions wouldn’t list it as a cause of death typically. In the UK the rules are also quite relaxed. I know of one (really dodgy guy who isn’t even a doctor) who runs (ran?) an outpatient clinic offering circumcisions for example. If one of his procedures went wrong the child would wind up in hospital, he probably wouldn’t even know about it. If the child died circumcision wouldn’t be put down as cause of death. The only way the information would end up in the public domain is if there was an inquest or the parents sued.

BigFatGiant · 20/03/2019 20:36

My family is Muslim. It is both a religious and cultural practice for Muslims. We haven’t circumcised for generations because it barbaric and dangerous. It is barbaric because parent have no right to mutilate their children especially when it involves removing an errogenous zone which is tantamount to sexual control. It’s dangerous because the procedure itself, especially if poorly performed or the aftercare is poor, can result if severe blood loss or infection. Just like child marriage, blasphemy laws, persecution of homosexuals and polygamy it should be left firmly in the past.

THEsonofaBITCH · 20/03/2019 20:30

LonelyDadNeedsHelp

@room32 "it's clearly not that harmful"

Male circumcision literally kills more than 100 boys in the US alone each year.
Typical anti-vaccination technique. Cite a study that was an extrapolation of a guess from an assumption that has been discredited by all scientific journals to back up your argument. The CDC did a multi-year study and found the rate of death was ZERO in hospitals and clinics. If you don’t find the CDC credible as one poster said then fine if you read the study and disagree with it/it’s results. I’ve read studies on the issue and find them credible and compelling. Screaming it’s mutilation our child abuse or comparing it to FGM which has no medical basis just shows one to be an ignorant jackass.

HotpotLawyer · 20/03/2019 19:50

I think it is important not to stigmatise or make negative comments about circumcised men: lots of have to have it done for credible medical reasons.

It would be a shame if they felt self concious as a result.

I have had partners circumcised and not and it would never be even the most minor factor in how enjoyable the sex was, either way. I can’t even remember whether a few long term partners were circumcised or not.

My own boys are not circumcised, but if it had to be done I would hate for them to feel like freaks as a result.

newcamper · 20/03/2019 19:42

I've pm'd you

Alsohuman · 20/03/2019 19:39

Completely disagree. Circumcision is a basic tenet of two of the world's oldest religions. The motivation of people carrying out the acts you describe isn't laid down in religious law, it's their interpretation of it. Anyway we're not going to agree so this is pointless.