Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Circumcision

606 replies

muma19 · 20/03/2019 15:54

DP wants DS circumcised however I don't. I also have MIL getting involved and pressuring me. What do I do? I want to be fair to my partner but I really don't want him veg for circumcised. HELP!!!!

OP posts:
Smotheroffive · 21/03/2019 00:13

Putting 'DH' on some sort of pedestal you owe it to your DH bollox

It's your baby you owe it to, to protect and keep them save from ridiculous harmful practices for absolutely no good reason

Smotheroffive · 21/03/2019 00:11

Lifeistough god you take yourself overly seriously.

There's no good reason for this no matter how much you talk

FinnegansWhiskers · 21/03/2019 00:09

I've not read the whole thread. I've just come on to say I have 4 boys. None have been circumcised. None have have had any problems. If I thought there was a problem with too tight a foreskin, as a baby, I would have sought medical advice.

OP if you don't think there's a need for circumcision don't do it.

Smotheroffive · 21/03/2019 00:08

Male genital mutilation? Are you fucking joking???

This is a piss take right!? You're not seriously considering mutilating your babys penis for absolutely no good reason?

This should be illegal, wtaf!

LifeIsToughMate · 21/03/2019 00:01

You come across as very militant in your apparent determination for baby boys to be mutilated at will - it seems very strange, and not a little creepy.

Or he comes from a background quite different to yours? Life is a lot simpler when we let it be.

Op. So I’ll give an example from my faith:

Here is how rulings on certain issues are prioritised in terms of hierarchy:

1- orders and mentions in the Quran
2- well referenced interpretations directly from prophetic sayings and narrated actions ( this could be confirmed or unconfirmed)
3- scholarly consensus
4- contemporary scholarly effort to derive rulings on modern issues based on expert advice
5- personal opinion

Not all those practicing the faith have knowledge of anything aside from the basics as they don’t engage in critical thinking much. It is often that fundamentals of the faith are confused with interpretations and replaceable narratives.

Why I mention this is because for example, in the issue of circumcision it is as follows:

1- it is mentioned in the Quran that we shall follow the example of prophets including Moses , Abraham and Mohammed. It doesn’t however mention circumcision as far as I’m concerned. Debating the authenticity of this source is quite disrespectful to a person adhering to that faith, unless it’s an invited debate. But you can debate the interpretations after you go through the filtering of the following hierarchy.
2- the prophet mentions that circumcision is required, in multiple narrations. He mentions that his brethren prophets were circumcised. ( there is no mention as to why or about cleanliness, it’s purely a requirement of god.) at this level there could be critical thinkng employee about whether those narrations are valid, debatable or none debatable based on authenticity. That won’t be disrespectful.
3- scholarly consensus. There is a consensus that circumcision for males is commendable based on interpretations of the above two sources. There is majority scholarly opinion about it being obligatory for males but not a full consensus. Therefore there is some room for debate. Scholarly consensus usually means the stance of prominent scholars which were at the time when this issue arises until valid consensus was reached (circumcision started as a topic since ever). There is majority opinion on this but no consensus. There is still no mention about medical reasoning or so forth. The prophet mentions that where there is no consensus it is usually a way to leave room for differences. There is no consensus that I’m aware of about which age circumsixion is to happen, so that’s totally up for recommendations. It could’ve been recommended by certain scholars but in our faith we don’t regard scholars as “unmistakable” and that so long as the ruling has not been clarified clear as day by the first two scriptures and so long as consensus hasn’t been reached then contemporary scholarly effort is required to tweak the details of the ruling to what fits circumstances.

4- scholarly effort to derive rulings. This is where contemporary efforts come in. So where there is lack of consensus, on a certain issue or on the application of certain issue, then modern scholarly effort is required. There is a huge amount of scholars to choose from and the idea is you can ask as many as you wish to ask and you settle with the one that you feel at ease with. In fact you are obliged to ask as many as you wish and can settle for none of them but what feels ok for u, so long as you haven’t dismissed the first 3 priorities in the hierarchy. The scholar asked should be well versed in the expert advice on the topic as well as on the different religious interpretations of that topic.. so medical advice is important here and any new medical findings. Because not necessarily the understanding of the application of certain things in the past was based on religious context but perhaps was based on a scholars recommendation which is not considered equal to the word of god in any way and must evolve based on new knowledge and circumstances.

Why am I mentioning this? I believe the OP should try her best to put effort to understand the background of her DH and his family, as it comes as a package with marrying into multicultural families... and when she puts effort she might automatically realise that a lot of what she “assumed” might be set in stone religious beliefs or fundamental practice to their family, might actually have a lot of room for respectable debate..

I do not know the background of her DH, but I’m sure many aspects in our lives are based around core principles and some side ones... it is easy to win people over when you remind them that you respect their core principles..

So while we don’t need to compromise what we have strong opinions about, but we do need to compromise on our attitude in how to handle our differences.. we might be able to work out that we aren’t as diffeeenr as we though.

To the pp mentioning about “sucking” the blood out of a circumsized genital, I’m sure this is not fundamental to the Jewish practice and I’m sure discussing how this practice is grim and leads to medical issues should be ok....

I can understand the debate about the age of conscent and body autonomy. This all still falls within the reason of what’s not just acceptable, but “welcomed” debate based on how my religious understanding is derived and many educated Muslims. However in the presence of medical evidence that can support each side of the debate, I can still refuse this interpretation being imposed on me.. but that’s personal belief. And I can be humble enough to accept i might be wrong- medically speaking. It’s not offensive to be told I’m medically wrong it’s simply a debate.

But to just disrespect circumcision as a whole and call it barbaric mutilation and bloody bla as a result of specific interpretation by a specific group, is ignorance. It’s disrespectful as you are fundemrnally disrespecting the second source of my faith for example.. which is quite an end to any fruitful debate because no one who adheres to this thinking will want to respect you more than their prophet.

I don’t know what set of beliefs derived your in laws understanding of circumcision but it really is worth your efforts to try listen.try look further into things.. ask opinions of those who are intellectuals but within that same culture as your DH not those who will just want to reassure you that you are “right”... not to entertain the possibility of circumcising your child but because this topic might open your eyes about them as people.. which will help you understand how to deal with many issues in the future where you might feel differently- understandably.

No one will force you. You are the mother... you get to make the final call with your DH. And your DH sounds mature enough to think outside the box since he married outside the box!!!

But don’t shut doors or building understanding and tolerance because you are asking the wrong crowd about a topic they know nothing about but what they hear on media.

Part of marrying your DH was to know that you had to at least respect his core values and beliefs... circumcising at birth might not be one of them.. but it sure is part of his core values that he looks up to certain things in his heritage and won’t appreciate you calling it barbaric. So won’t be able to tolerate any debate on side values .So won’t be solving anything.

I’m not saying you will be disrespectful. But this is an emotional topic for you and you are being egged on in this thread, I’m probably gonna have this debate with sil as she is very open with us so will save this on my notes .

You do owe it to your DH that if you want to make some “reform” to his cultural understanding - which isn’t a bad thing - that you at least first make an effort to understand it and find out the core principles that you must not disrespect.

And just because you have a strong opinion about something, doesn’t make it the right answer for someone else. You still need to debate respectfully.

user1496701154 · 20/03/2019 23:33

It's both parents descions unless for medical reasons. My OH is not done but my son has had to be due to medical reasons. I think if he hadn't he won't be. As long as husband teaches babe how to clean down below properly when he's older there's no problem with it not been done

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 20/03/2019 22:51

THEsonofaBITCH

You come across as very militant in your apparent determination for baby boys to be mutilated at will - it seems very strange, and not a little creepy.

Whether it is comparable with FGM or not (and I don't see how the principle, when not done out of genuine medical necessity, could possibly be seen as different, regardless of the level and severity of mutilation), why is one of them so very wrong and the other such a great idea to be actively encouraged?

I'm not saying you personally (I have no way of knowing your own views), but it's the equivalent of saying that, because the majority of DV victims are female, and the consequences for them almost always more severe, that must logically mean that, whenever any man gets beaten up for a partner (male or female), it is of absolutely no concern and nothing to care about. In fact, going on your apparent pro-circ enthusiasm, a more realistic equivalent (which I'm not suggesting for a minute that you would agree with) would be that it's actually a GOOD thing for men to get beaten up and it should happen much more routinely in relationships.

Sex is irrelevant here - it comes down to whether you believe in bodily autonomy or you believe it acceptable that a stronger person can always dictate what they do to a weaker person's body for no reason other than that they wanted to.

squeekums · 20/03/2019 22:51

Which culture is that?! Certainly never happened when my boys were done

While I didn't make the comment that led to this, that poster isn't lying.
There an episode of Andrew zimmern, bizzare foods where he goes to a circumcision ritual where the blood is sucked and the grandfather eats the foreskin
Absolutely vile, it's the one episode I turned away from. I can't remember if it was Jewish or African though

Circumcision is abuse in my eyes and should never be done unless a Dr says it's needed for health reasons, under anesthetic.
Vanity or religion is not a valid reason

DomTheDonkey · 20/03/2019 22:48

@Justheretogiveaviewfrommyworld It definitely happens in New York with awful consequences. NY mayor Bill Di Blasio released a statement concerning the practice. Utterly horrifying reading www.dnainfo.com/new-york/20170309/borough-park/neonatal-herpes-infection-ritual-jewish-circumcision-orthodox-mohel/

LeesPostersAreInFrames · 20/03/2019 22:42

Things I believe from when I researched this a while ago that you might want to check out to see how your feel about them;

The body keeps the score, and forced trauma to the penis at such a very young age is never forgotten in the body.

It adversely affects sexual pleasure. All those nerve endings densely packed in a small area removed. The desensitisation of the head of the penis knocking around on the underwear.

It is usual for the scab to be pulled away, repeatedly, when changing baby's nappy. Imagine the repeated agony.

It's common for the procedure to be done without sufficient anaesthetic.

I consider it barbaric and would be a hard no.

muma19 · 20/03/2019 22:41

@LifeIsToughMate I will not be approaching it in anyway which will cause offence or disrespect their culture in anyway. This is my husband and his family who is also my family and I love them dearly. I simply do not feel comfortable. And have said that when DS is old enough I would like to leave the decision for him to make. I am trying to make a stand without causing an argument or upsetting home life. But the final answer is no DS will not be circumcised, and that will be respectfully explained to my DH's family.

OP posts:
Ivegotthree · 20/03/2019 22:36

There's no way I would allow my son to be mutilated in this way. No way.

LonelyDadNeedsHelp · 20/03/2019 22:32

@LifeIsToughMate

I apologise, I can see that I probably come across as bullish, insensitive and without direct experience of the situation. I can also see that you are giving respectful and sensitive advice to the OP.

I continue to stand by the things I have said, but I concede this may not be the best forum for such a discussion.

However, there is no real compromise in this situation. It's a binary choice and therefore one party will need to concede.

I'm stepping away from the keyboard now.

LifeIsToughMate · 20/03/2019 22:18

Bold fail

LifeIsToughMate · 20/03/2019 22:18

*I read your earlier post. You're approaching it from the perspective of mother and father being from different cultures, but you completely ignore the child, who is the most important person in the discussion and also the most vulnerable.

You said "don’t impose your thinking on others" but choosing to remove a part of your child's body is imposing your thinking on the child. And it's irreversible!

So again, what's so wrong with letting them choose when they are able to give informed consent?*

So you are recruiting this lady to use her marriage and child as a tool for activism to change an entire cultural understanding about a topic that’s been debated to death?

Who are you helping this way other than yourself? Certainly not her child who now considers this multicultural family his home.

I gave her a reasonable “respectful” argument which gets the child out of the “imposed” corcumcision until they make that choice themselves. And in fact an approach that will work for many of her cultural differences with DH and his family without being so dramatic and inviting tension. So again, read my post.

OP wasn’t asking anyone here about how to start a campaign to change her DH and his family’s perspective before her son is born. That’s crossing many boundaries which clearly were not in her views and screams superiority complex.her limits is what applies to her child and her home and herself... a multicultural home of her choice. Which I hope she will learn to see the beauty of and celebrate differences, while maintaining her position on what she believes works for her.

I get it you want to start a debate about whether those circumcising are barbaric or illogical or stupid. But I’m sorry I didn’t post on here to join that debate, I came here to tell a lady who knew the culture she married into and happily had a child, about My perspective on how to approach it successfully without compromising her own beliefs.

I am also sure that her DH probably has a lot of things to say about her heritage. The approach won’t be to go heads on make her sound barbaric and stupid... because to many people outside that culture I’m sure there is that perspective too on many
Aspects.

This is not a battle ground, this is someone’s peaceful home, and a child’s nest.

Jsmith99 · 20/03/2019 22:02

Male genital mutilation = Female genital mutilation.

Both are child abuse. Both are equally indefensible.

One is, rightly, a criminal offence. The other is not due to pandering to backward, barbaric religious and cultural practices.

LonelyDadNeedsHelp · 20/03/2019 22:01

@LifeIsToughMate

I read your earlier post. You're approaching it from the perspective of mother and father being from different cultures, but you completely ignore the child, who is the most important person in the discussion and also the most vulnerable.

You said "don’t impose your thinking on others" but choosing to remove a part of your child's body is imposing your thinking on the child. And it's irreversible!

So again, what's so wrong with letting them choose when they are able to give informed consent?

LifeIsToughMate · 20/03/2019 21:58

Which culture is that?! Certainly never happened when my boys were done.

Ignore her she is just desperate for scoring points yet has no real logic to share.

I reported.

makingmammaries · 20/03/2019 21:56

How is this still allowed? Even tail docking of dogs is banned.

tinyme77 · 20/03/2019 21:55

Wait until he is 18 and then he can decide.

LifeIsToughMate · 20/03/2019 21:55

What's so wrong with letting them choose when they are able to give informed consent?

If you read my previous explanation you would find that I had answered your question.

LifeIsToughMate · 20/03/2019 21:53

OP, I’m sorry a lot of pp here are disrespecting your DH’s heritage.

I expect you would be making a small stand? Or do you expect him to be standing up for you to make sure everyone respects your conclusions while you are exempt ?

Justheretogiveaviewfrommyworld · 20/03/2019 21:53

Which culture is that?! Certainly never happened when my boys were done.

LonelyDadNeedsHelp · 20/03/2019 21:52

@LifeIsToughMate

It's nothing to do with culture clash. It's about the lack of consent from the person having a piece of their body removed. It's being done in the name of a religion they may not choose to follow. What's so wrong with letting them choose when they are able to give informed consent?

BartholinsSister · 20/03/2019 21:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.