Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Circumcision

606 replies

muma19 · 20/03/2019 15:54

DP wants DS circumcised however I don't. I also have MIL getting involved and pressuring me. What do I do? I want to be fair to my partner but I really don't want him veg for circumcised. HELP!!!!

OP posts:
PleaseJustSayNo · 21/03/2019 08:45

See my username

BabyDarlingDollfaceHoney · 21/03/2019 08:42

@Stompythedinosaur www.nhs.uk/news/lifestyle-and-exercise/male-circumcision-doesnt-affect-sexual-satisfaction/

BabyDarlingDollfaceHoney · 21/03/2019 08:40

@Hazelnutpie care to elaborate at all? Omits own your statement is pretty pointless.

Ear piercing leaves you with mutilated but functioning ears. Circumcision leaves you with a mutilated but functioning penis. FGM leaves you with mutilated genitalia and a lifelong inability to enjoy any form of normal sex life and therefore normal sexual relationship.

I'm not saying circumcision is the same as ear piercing, but there are more similarities between the two than there are between circumcision and FGM.

Stompythedinosaur · 21/03/2019 08:37

Yes, it's done without consent. That's basically where the similarities lie. It's closer in nature to getting a baby's ears pierced than it is to FGM.

Except that getting a baby's ears pierced isn't so painful, likely to lead to complications, or going to impact their sex life as an adult.

KidLorneRoll · 21/03/2019 08:36

"Here is how rulings on certain issues are prioritised in terms of hierarchy: "

Well, that's just fucking stupid isn't it. To be blunt, if the rules in a fictional book supersede, oh, I dunno, the rights of a parent to make an intelligent choice for their child then clearly something is wrong.

Hazlenutpie · 21/03/2019 08:33

It's closer in nature to getting a baby's ears pierced than it is to FGM

That’s utter bollocks.

BabyDarlingDollfaceHoney · 21/03/2019 08:30

Yes, it's done without consent. That's basically where the similarities lie. It's closer in nature to getting a baby's ears pierced than it is to FGM.

Hazlenutpie · 21/03/2019 08:29

Both are mutilation, let’s not forget that. Just because male circumcision removes less than FGM, it doesn’t make it right. Comparing the two isn’t helpful.

JacquesHammer · 21/03/2019 08:26

CIRCUMCISION IS IN NO WAY COMPARABLE TO FEMALE GENITAL MUTILATION

For me the comparison isn’t the nature of the procedures which I agree are vastly different. But in that they both are procedures done to young people without their consent.

BabyDarlingDollfaceHoney · 21/03/2019 08:26

I'm against circumcision too by the way but let's not be utterly utterly ridiculous here and compare it to FGM.

BabyDarlingDollfaceHoney · 21/03/2019 08:25

I've only read up to page three but couldn't actually contain myself any longer before posting.

CIRCUMCISION IS IN NO WAY COMPARABLE TO FEMALE GENITAL MUTILATION.

In FGM the clitoris is removed, to keep girls "clean" by preventing them from experiencing sexual pleasure. This is removing a basic human right. Circumcised men retain the use of a fully functional penis and enjoy normal sexual sensation and pleasure.

I'm actually incandescent at men claiming the two are the same. It's another example of the bloody men men men men men obsessed culture we live in that the two issues are even being discussed on the same thread. And there's a load of women making the comments too?! What is wrong with people?! 🤯

Hazlenutpie · 21/03/2019 08:12

I’ve seen first hand baby boys who have been circumcised. It’s genital mutilation and is barbaric. I have a boy child and the very thought of having a part of his body removed fills me with revulsion.

Mother87 · 21/03/2019 08:04

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

cochineal7 · 21/03/2019 08:00

My DH had it done as an adult (different country different culture) so unlike most is in a position to compare. His vote is a resounding no don’t do it. And he convinced his (religious reasons) friends to not do it to their son.

HotpotLawyer · 21/03/2019 07:50

Whatever anyone else’s ideological position the OP does not want her baby circumcised and needs to find a way to remain resolute about this whilst still, presumably, keeping her family relationships.

How can she best do this?

Itwouldtakemuchmorethanthis · 21/03/2019 07:28

Why and how many boys/men need to be circumcised for medical reasons?

StoppinBy · 21/03/2019 03:27

First off.... tell your MIL to butt out, it is none of her business.

When I was pregnant the issue came up, my husband is circumcised and wanted our children if they were boys to be done too. I asked him whether he would be happy if we had a daughter to have her circumcised and I also showed him a video of a circumcision and asked him if he would hold our baby while they were circumcised, both times he answered, no that he wouldn't. I told him straight out that if he was truly ok with it then he would be ok with holding our children while it was done and he agreed.

Luckily that was the end of the story for us. To be honest whether he had said yes or no it would have been over my dead body that someone would be cutting off parts of my child unnecessarily but it definitely made it a lot easier having him on board.

We now have a DD and a DS, he is not circumcised.

Bicyclethief · 21/03/2019 03:19

lifeistough Bore off with your close minded nonsense.

Wow, this would be funny if it wasn't so serious.

Butterflycookie · 21/03/2019 02:04

LifeIsToughMate

Just because you don’t think it’s barbaric doesn’t mean it isn’t.
Just because your religion tells you to do or behave in a certain way doesn’t mean other people should agree.

For example, if my religion said that babies must have their little finger cut off for whatever reason, surely you’d think that was barbaric. Or that children must be locked in the dark without food or water because it’s written in the holy book, does that mean you’d agree. These are ridiculous examples, but just trying to explain that just because your religion tells you to do something doesn’t mean other people have to accept it and doesn’t make it right. We can have our opinions....and if people think it’s barbaric and you don’t then that’s your opinion.

LeesPostersAreInFrames · 21/03/2019 01:55

you are asking the wrong crowd about a topic they know nothing about but what they hear on media

They are asking a bunch of mums and their peers. It seems like only people outside of the communities who do this see it for what it factually is; unnecessarily significantly and permanently damaging a baby's genitals, causing severe pain and distress.

But to just disrespect circumcision as a whole and call it barbaric mutilation and bloody bla as a result of specific interpretation by a specific group, is ignorance

Go on then. Convince us that it's not unnecessarily mutilating a baby's genitals, causing great pain, suffering and trauma.

Rottencooking · 21/03/2019 01:04

But to just disrespect circumcision as a whole and call it barbaric mutilation and bloody bla as a result of specific interpretation by a specific group, is ignorance

No it's not and your entire post is a load of waffling bollocks as well. Spin it any way you want, you are causing unnecessary harm and removing an important feature of your child's body without him even being able to consent. Do you even know how many adults grow up wishing they were kept intact and go on to attempt foreskin restoration? A lot. Even though it's all they've known, funny that.

Smotheroffive · 21/03/2019 01:03

Doctors on NHS will refuse even a man asking for this, unless there is sound medical issues necessitating

Rottencooking · 21/03/2019 01:00

Circumcision should only ever be decided by the man when they reach an age to be able to do so. Don't mutilate your child for bollocks religious or hygiene reasons. It's not unhygienic or dangerous to have a foreskin and even medical conditions can almost always be cured too.

I greatly judge anyone who does that to their child.

Bambooshoot · 21/03/2019 00:52

A question for for anyone who comes from a culture where this is routinely practised - (LifeIsToughMate - I think you have done a good job in presenting the background and I hope this does not come across as confrontational, it is more of a theological query) - if you believe that God or the higher power created mankind, how does your religion explain that God somehow created children with extra parts that it was mankind's duty to get rid of - does this mean God is not perfect, since He/She made a mistake man has to correct?

The alternative seems to be that He/She asking that you make small children suffer, which I cannot get my head around, for a being who supposedly deserves to be worshipped. How is this justified in the religious sense?

Smotheroffive · 21/03/2019 00:17

No one needs to understand anything other than its wrong to mutilate a beautiful baby by doing unnecessary and very painful procedures. Screw that shit, and shit it is

Swipe left for the next trending thread