Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Circumcision

606 replies

muma19 · 20/03/2019 15:54

DP wants DS circumcised however I don't. I also have MIL getting involved and pressuring me. What do I do? I want to be fair to my partner but I really don't want him veg for circumcised. HELP!!!!

OP posts:
LeesPostersAreInFrames · 22/03/2019 12:03

My heart bleeds for the man who (hypothetically with no evidence) feels disrespected because strangers agree with his wife who doesn't want her baby's genitals to be chopped up.

.... oh no wait, it doesn't.

WisdomOfCrowds · 22/03/2019 11:52

Yeh, I'm pretty happy to disrespect any individual, culture, or religion that advocates something I find this abhorrent. I do not believe those are opinions that deserve respect. This isn't a "no right answer and everyone's entitled to their beliefs" situation for me. I oppose circumcision in the same way that I would oppose someone who's culture/ religion told them to beat their children. I will openly and vocally "disrespect" all perpetrators of child abuse until it sinks in that it's not OK.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 22/03/2019 11:35

Scientific research shows that those without an appendix are much less likely to get appendicitis. And those without tonsils never get tonsillitis!

A PP mentioned earlier in the thread that those without appendix (sp?) dont get appendicitis, people who have nad their hearts removed dont have heart attacks either and trying to compare that to mutilating your baby's genitals is disingenuous.

Why is the Abrahamic god so interested in male childrens genitals? Absolutely disgusting its a barbaric ritual that needs ending

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 22/03/2019 11:04

I don’t feel he deserved the amount of disrespect that you allowed to happen on this thread

I don't think you understand the strength of feeling that many people (in the UK at least) have at the suggestion of an adult deciding to cut off part of a baby's body for no valid medical reason.

Also, I don't know if you're aware, but this is a public forum and the person who starts a thread has no power or control over what other people subsequently choose to contribute to their thread, so in no way did she 'allow' any perceived disrespect. The only way she could possibly have avoided the potential for this believed 'disrespect' of her husband to be expressed would be if she, and maybe all other women, were never allowed to post anything on the internet. I'm sure you wouldn't want that - that WOULD indeed be disrespectful and outrageous in the extreme.

Moreover, why are you making it about her husband. The primary concern of almost all posters is for a baby boy whose lifelong health and well-being are being potentially put in jeopardy by certain members of his family.

I know you'll consider it a ridiculous question on my part, but what reaction would you have to a man wanting to punch his wife repeatedly on a daily basis because he somehow thought that permanent bruises looked nicer? What if it was your son-in-law wanting to batter your daughter? Even if he claimed it was part of his culture? Would you disrespect him by even daring to raise the subject with others and asking if it was something that you should be allowed to question?

There are many people worldwide who have it in their heads that all Muslims somehow present a clear and direct threat to their own perceived 'culture'. Some of these will want to enter into genuine reasoned debate (in as far as they're capable), which I personally am in favour of for ANY SUBJECT AT ALL as I object on principle to the shutting down of adults who wish to respectfully discuss their beliefs and opinions on controversial matters. In some such cases, this serves to allow these people to expose themselves to the world at large as complete idiots, which is also their right to do.

However, as we are all sadly aware, there are some disgusting creatures who are unwilling or unable to do this and will resort to threatening, aggressive hatred, violence and murder to make their perceived 'point' and, in their own tiny minds, to attempt to 'protect' their white/western supremacist 'culture'

Do you believe that people who speak out against this and the authorities imprisoning such criminals are showing them an unacceptable amount of disrespect?

To reiterate, adults choosing irreversible body modification/mutilation for themselves is absolutely fine and their choice is to be respected. (Having said this, though, I believe a man has just now been charged for assisting consenting adults in modifying/mutilating their own bodies.)

When the same is done to a helpless child, people WILL speak out against it - it's not a case of disrespect, it's speaking up on behalf of a vulnerable person who is unable to do so themselves.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 22/03/2019 10:17

So bare in mind that for the future, you need to find out how to tackle cultural things from a source that you both find respectable and has some awareness of both sides.

Would you be saying the same if they had a daughter and either or both parents were originally from a culture that practised FGM, but were now living in the UK, though? (I don't know if the OP is in the UK, but am assuming it's another 'western' country if not).

Cultural traditions that don't harm other people can and do often travel well, but when they do cause harm to another person, especially a helpless child, the law of the country where they are now living takes precedence - and the moral beliefs of the majority are not to simply be brushed aside as of no relevance at all.

If an adult man decides, without pressure or coercion, that he wants to be circumcised for ANY reason whatsoever, then nobody would have any issues with him having it done.

It's a bit like marriage - an adult is free to choose to marry (almost) any other single adult, however unsavoury that other adult may appear to other people; but children cannot legally marry, even if they themselves genuinely believe that they want to. Similarly, nobody of any age can legally be forced to marry against their will.

I understand that different nationalities and cultures have different moral stances on certain issues. For example, people in the UK are often horrified by people in France eating horse meat and Koreans eating dog meat; and yet countless millions of people in India would be horrified at many of us in the UK happily eating beef.

For the record, I believe that this works both ways and I have no time or tolerance whatsoever for British people who go to live in a different country and then take personal offence at Spaniards being unable or unwilling to speak any language other than Spanish, whilst in Spain.

Bicyclethief · 22/03/2019 08:42

However OP, as a word of advice, I think we all know what posting on Mumsnet for advice on circumcision was going to look like. This won’t be the first time you will have issue with your in laws culture that you need to learn how to handle in a way that doesn’t create tension..*

Patronising

So I don’t feel he deserved the amount of disrespect that you allowed to happen on this thread

How dare you.

Mississippilessly · 21/03/2019 23:36

Yes OP. Next time find a source that is pro-mutiliation.

Hmm
LifeIsToughMate · 21/03/2019 23:24

My DH and I have had the conversation, he had respected my stance on this and agreed with me. This post was never about me questioning whether to do it or not, as for my DS it was never an option but more so about how to tackle MIL and let them know that although I love them very much, I will not be circumcising him.

Well done OP. You sound like you have handled it well. As I said, I circumcise my baby boys, but I completely understand your position on YOUR DS. And more so, I rate you for resolving it directly with your DH and tackling MIL in a more compassionate way.

However OP, as a word of advice, I think we all know what posting on Mumsnet for advice on circumcision was going to look like. This won’t be the first time you will have issue with your in laws culture that you need to learn how to handle in a way that doesn’t create tension..

I’m surprised that you even felt pressured seeing how understanding your DH sounds.. and how you could’ve just discussed with him.

True you might wanted people to equip you with some facts to use... but really I don’t think you needed to come here for ammunition to use against your in laws.. because it’s not your word against theirs, it’s you and your husbands decision and he simply seems on board.

So I don’t feel he deserved the amount of disrespect that you allowed to happen on this thread. Because if he had started a thread on an African forum, discussing all the things in your background that he finds rediculous, you bet he would’ve received advice that won’t make you feel respected.

So bare in mind that for the future, you need to find out how to tackle cultural things from a source that you both find respectable and has some awareness of both sides.

muma19 · 21/03/2019 23:00

@PunkAssMoFo thank you! I'm so glad it's now all over with.

Oh my, how ironic.

OP posts:
PunkAssMoFo · 21/03/2019 22:55

Well done op.

Just as an anecdotal add on- the only person that I know to have had penile cancer was circumcised as a child.

GnomeDePlume · 21/03/2019 22:24

Tell her that this is a private matter between you, your DP and your DS and that no other opinions will be considered.

sagradafamiliar · 21/03/2019 21:54

I'd tell her to stop fixating on my child's penis if it were my MIL. Seriously.

Dutchesss · 21/03/2019 21:44

It's mutilation.
Complications can also occur, in the worst case scenarios complications could be loss of genitals or death.
Don't even consider chopping bits of a baby, I wish they had rights.

Btw, it can get dirty under your fingernails but we don't consider pulling them all off....

muma19 · 21/03/2019 21:42

My DH and I have had the conversation, he had respected my stance on this and agreed with me. This post was never about me questioning whether to do it or not, as for my DS it was never an option but more so about how to tackle MIL and let them know that although I love them very much, I will not be circumcising him.

OP posts:
FullOfJellyBeans · 21/03/2019 21:37

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

Brilliant comment.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 21/03/2019 21:06

CIRCUMCISION IS IN NO WAY COMPARABLE TO FEMALE GENITAL MUTILATION.

In FGM the clitoris is removed, to keep girls "clean" by preventing them from experiencing sexual pleasure. This is removing a basic human right. Circumcised men retain the use of a fully functional penis and enjoy normal sexual sensation and pleasure.

I'm actually incandescent at men claiming the two are the same. It's another example of the bloody men men men men men obsessed culture we live in that the two issues are even being discussed on the same thread. And there's a load of women making the comments too?! What is wrong with people?! 🤯

There are 4 identified levels of FMG, all rightly illegal, and male circumcision has been assessed as being approximately equivalent to level 2 of FGM.

You are absolutely correct that women are massively disadvantaged and discriminated against in a huge number of factors throughout their whole lives, and this is, of course, appalling. However, this is one of those rare cases where the reverse is true: female babies cannot legally have their genitals cut, altered or mutilated in any way; however, male babies are not considered deserving of the same legal protection.

The PRINCIPLE is exactly the same, even if the level of harm caused frequently is not.

I assume from your confident assertion that you must be a man who opted for circumcision after becoming an adult. Even though YOU may not personally have observed any difference in your sensation and pleasure in sex before and after you were circumcised, this is not the experience reported by the vast majority of other men, whose experiences DO follow as one would logically expect as a consequence of having tens of thousands of sensitive nerve endings removed. It's just basic common sense.

Mississippilessly · 21/03/2019 20:48

I'm watching American Circumcision now.
The picture of the baby being circumcised has really upset me. I have no idea what would bring someone to do this to their baby.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 21/03/2019 20:42

If I thought there was a problem with too tight a foreskin, as a baby, I would have sought medical advice.

Not getting at you at all, as even a lot of medical professionals alarmingly appear not to know, but baby boys are always born with tight foreskins. As long as he can wee properly, it is no more a cause for concern than the fact that he can't talk yet, can't yet control his bowels or (probably) doesn't have any teeth. A baby obviously has no need for his penis to function sexually, however he IS going to be sitting in pooey nappies, from which substance the sensitive head of his penis benefits significantly from protection.

For all the people claiming that circumcision prevents sexually-transmitted infections, the foreskin does actually help to prevent faecal-based infections in somebody far too young for sex to be of any relevance.

sagradafamiliar · 21/03/2019 20:26

LTB

Toodleoopuddle · 21/03/2019 20:14

Right now on Netflix is 'American circumcision' very interesting and might challenge his thinking.

JAPAB · 21/03/2019 20:11

Vaccines usually just constitute an imjection and there isn't as effective an alternative way to achieve the same benefits.

Circumcision risks a loss of sensitivity, permanently alters the appearance , and there are other ways to achieve the same benefits (amd surpass them).

Stick to your guns, OP. Some things should be Up to the individual when it is them that will have the changes and risked changes.

HermioneWeasley · 21/03/2019 20:10

Another voice saying please don’t do it. Living in a hot, dusty country with no running water I can see the advantages and why it became traditional, but there’s absolutely no need living in the U.K. now.

Bicyclethief · 21/03/2019 20:06

Please don't allow this for your son. He's meant to have this skin there. Millions of years of evolution, it's there for a reason. Most of all, let him decide when he's older and save him the pain.

FullOfJellyBeans · 21/03/2019 19:21

@THEsonofaBITCH

You are coming across as irrational and hysterical. You've posted links which had NO peer reviewed medical advantages to routine circumcision. Literally none. The very minor reduction in STD transmission wouldn't be nearly enough for most men to consider the procedure when contraceptives would be necessary anyway and in any case by the time a man is sexually active he can choose for himself.

Smotheroffive · 21/03/2019 18:53

...and what have vaccines got to do with this Confused rhetorical, as obvs nothing

Swipe left for the next trending thread