Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Circumcision

606 replies

muma19 · 20/03/2019 15:54

DP wants DS circumcised however I don't. I also have MIL getting involved and pressuring me. What do I do? I want to be fair to my partner but I really don't want him veg for circumcised. HELP!!!!

OP posts:
Smotheroffive · 24/03/2019 13:30

Why is urine dirty?
Actually it's sterile.
Behind the ears gathers a lot more dirt from sweating and dust particles gathering.

Vaginas are not dirty, vulvas get sweaty and smell of sex, but there is a reason for the penis evolving the way it did, and that's to protect a highly sensitive sex organ, designed to be super sensitive.

How does it matter the means of retraction?

It has also been said that pre-5 ish the glans and foreskin are one. They are not separate. The skin is attached over the glans to protect it.

Erection/penetration pulls the foreskin back naturally which can be done manually.

Why is cleanliness the issue? Some people are hygenic some notsomuch, does mean we should start routinely hacking off body parts, that's not an argument.

Ears are very waxy and necessarily so, some think that vaginal discharge is dirty and over wash so much that the body produces masses of water to flush away all the soaps; there might be in some quarters lack of bodily education, but that's all.

By the cleanliness reasoning all manner of bodybparts should be hacked off,but that still doesn't give anyone else the right to do the hacking off!

sagradafamiliar · 24/03/2019 09:16

Breeze my point was that to clean behind your ears, you'd probably hold your lobe back but it's such a small deal, you wouldn't consider whether you were holding it back/lifting it/folding it...you'd just clean the area and think nothing of it.

Mississippilessly · 24/03/2019 08:30

I have never examined how the underside of a foreskin goes back. I have never needed to - it doesn't matter. It has been explained to you several times that washing it takes moments and is not a hassle in any way. All the bits that need to be clean are.

You are being deliberately obtuse to continue an argument that to any rational mind is ludicrous. Bodies do not need bits of them to be permanently removed by surgery unless there is a problem with them. That's all there is to it. And if for some reason - be it cultural or religious - that you feel there is a need then YOU should be allowed to decide what happens to your body. Not somebody else.

dementedpixie · 24/03/2019 08:24

But fingernails grow back, foreskins don't, so it's not equating like with like. It's easy to clean an intact penis - pull foreskin back, quick swoosh under water, done. It hardly takes hours and no nail brushes needed

breeze44 · 24/03/2019 08:24

Urine and pre-seminal fluid do not come out from behind the ear, and cleaning behind the ear does not involve pulling or folding anything back. Still no-one has explained whether the foreskin glides back or is folded back. If it glides back, then the underside of the foreskin will never be cleaned. If it is folded back, then that’s hassle every time you want to wash.

Mississippilessly · 24/03/2019 08:04

I don't really known what to say. We arent going to agree.

sagradafamiliar · 24/03/2019 08:03

You sound really naive breeze but then again you've been taught to believe that that small bit of skin is alien and dirty and more of a bigger deal to clean than say, cleaning behind one's ear, which isn't your fault.
I agree with PPs who say it should be illegal.

GinUnicorn · 24/03/2019 07:59

I find it bizarre that anyone would want to remove a healthy body part.

As far as I am concerned circumcision should be illegal without consent of the owner of the penis - not before they are 18.

If needed medically of course it should happen though.

It’s worrying that we are giving a message that boys aren’t perfect as they are. No one needs a healthy piece of skin removed and foreskin helps protect the penis and give sensitivity during doc. It’s also easy to clean!

breeze44 · 24/03/2019 07:57

If you read my post, you will see that was not the argument I was making, I only mentioned it to explain why the other poster was wrong to equate circumcision to removing entire fingernails.

Mississippilessly · 24/03/2019 07:52

I think any religion that would suggest the entire removal of a penis would, by definition, die out pretty quick though wouldn't it?

Im not sure saying 'it's better than removing the entire organ'is any kind of argument.

Anyway. Your practise your religion, I'll practise mine. I wouldn't follow anything that told me doing that to my child was a good thing and now that my God was being merciful by not asking me to cut more off him.

breeze44 · 24/03/2019 07:48

You say ‘washing like normal’ but what’s normal for you is cultural. If you lived in a culture where circumcision was the norm you would see pulling back the foreskin to wash as strange.

breeze44 · 24/03/2019 07:45

No, the equivalent of permanently removing the fingernails would be removing the whole penis. The pink parts of the nails don’t get dirt underneath only the white parts do and there is no way of permanently removing the white parts. See how merciful Allah is to His creation. Cutting the nails, which is easy, has to be done repeatedly, but circumcision, which is more difficult, only has to be done once and then the benefits last a lifetime.

sagradafamiliar · 24/03/2019 07:44

Breeze your posts are bizarre. We'd have have no body parts left if we just went around snipping them off instead of just washing like normal.
I've never given my sons instructions specific foreskin cleaning instructions, by the time it glides back they're of an age to figure out to clean it as with everything else under there. I think some people are sadly dogmatised to believe it really is filthy compared to everything else but it isn't. Most people don't give it a second thought.

Mississippilessly · 24/03/2019 07:43

I think I might be missing something. All this tallk of washing makes it sound like an uncircumcised penis is the dirtiest, hardest thing to clean in the world. It really isnt - it takes a matter of moments. If cleanliness is the excuse to subject your children to an necessary medical procedure then I'm sorry but it just doesn't stand up.

And as for it being the equivalent of trimming nails, the mind boggles. That suggests an astounding level of ignorance.

breeze44 · 24/03/2019 07:23

@NunoGoncalves
Well, I really don’t know which is why I’m asking. I was taking the word ‘pull’ literally and thinking that the underside would still be underneath but just scrunched for want of a better word. But now it seems like you’re saying that the foreskin would be folded back on itself so the underside would now be facing up? Is that right? I’m just curious as those of us whose sons are circumcised have no experience of teaching how to wash an uncircumcised penis.

dementedpixie · 24/03/2019 07:21

Surely the equivalent would be permanently removing the finger nails rather than cutting them periodically? Do we do that? Of course we don't!

breeze44 · 24/03/2019 07:15

@Bookworm01
Of course Allah did not make a mistake. Allah created males with a foreskin and also decreed that they should remove it. Just like we are all created with fingernails that grow. The vast majority of people cut their fingernails. When you see people who don’t cut their nails regularly enough, they either go around with a constant grey line of dirt under their nails or they have to work really hard to keep them clean by using a nail brush and so on. It’s better to just cut your nails short from the beginning and it’s better to get circumcised as well.

Bookworm01 · 23/03/2019 22:53

@user1480880826 I absolutely agree.

Bookworm01 · 23/03/2019 22:49

It never would have crossed my mind, as a British person, to circumcise my son, no less than performing FGM on my daughter.

On the religious point: God/Allah sent our children to us as a gift, and they came to us as God/Allah wanted them to be. Therefore, if God/Allah advocates circumcision, He's made a mistake? Confused (Disclaimer: not religious myself)

On the cleanliness point: My husband knows well enough how to clean his willy properly, as do millions of males around the world. Parents need to teach males how to do it.

On medical reasons point: Of course, if the foreskin is too tight, or if there is any other medical reason for cutting the foreskin, that should be permitted, as long as it is backed up by evidence-based practice.

nolongersurprised · 23/03/2019 22:27

Narrowing of the end of the urethra is also a fairly common complication of circumcision (5-10%) but can be under recognised because some boys may not recognise that their urinary stream isn’t normal.it happens because one of the jobs of the foreskin is to protect the end of the urethra, and with the foreskin gone it becomes abraded and scarred. It is managed with another operation and if not managed, after years of urinary difficulties, there can be back pressure on the kidneys and kidney damage.

www.monashchildrenshospital.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/meatal-stenosis.pdf

PinkPupZ · 23/03/2019 22:17

My son had it done at primary age for severe medical issues. I used to be strongly against it. But it was very straightforward and he had very little pain. So I am less judgemental now it's a difficult one. I would not have had it done it it weren't the last resort.

financialjobs · 23/03/2019 21:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MrsAmaretto · 23/03/2019 21:14

I personally wouldn’t recommend that you get it done for cultural reasons. My son has had it done for medical reasons and it was not pleasant watching him recover. It is not natural to want your child to suffer an operation for no reason. And despite the pain meds it was a week until he stopped feeling pain.

I do sometimes wonder if I made the right decision, but he was in so much pain and swelling from infections that the GPs and surgeon advised it was necessary. His uncle had to have one in his 40s and THAT was truly horrific as he got an infection.

Smotheroffive · 23/03/2019 21:05

Fgm and mgm are not equivalents in any way, they both involve cutting and mutilating in terms of changing the look and sensations in the penis.

MeAgainAgain · 23/03/2019 12:43

I can't see circumcision being outlawed in the UK any time soon, many of the religious communities who practice it are long established and integrated in society and it would be seen as an attack, I can't see it flying.

I also believe it is wrong to circumcise unless there is medical reason.

So on the basis that FGM and "MGM" which are completely 100% equivalent and should be treated the same, I suppose that means we need to legalise FGM.

AFAIK there have only been 2 prosecutions with 1 conviction in the 10+ years the law has been in place, so it might as well be legal anyway.

Then the playing field will be fair again, and there can be fresh efforts to get them both made illegal. As in the UK "MGM" is the harder sell, best start with that.

Sounds like a plan.