Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you let your 15 year old go on a day trip to London alone?

222 replies

Comefromaway · 24/02/2019 20:31

Just before he broke up for half term I had a phone call from ds’s school. His head of year was very concerned because he’d told a member of staff that he was planning to spend his birthday money going to London on a train to watch a West End show!

I of course made all the right noises, promised to speak to him. Explained that we were actually planning a family West End trip and we go approx once or twice a year. The head of year said he’d told her he’d been in London alone before and they were concerned. I assured her that had never been the case. (Turned our he meant last year when dd and dh went to get sushi, I went to a jacket potato place and he went to Burger King in Leicester Square and we met up 15 mins later outside the Lego shop.

So I spoke to ds and it turns out he was serious. He said yes I was going to tell you. I’ve done the maths worked out how much the train and tube will cost I looked up the price of tickets for the Saturday matinee and I have enough left over for lunch at Bella in Leicester Square at 12.30 before the show starts at 2.30. I was quite impressed to be honest. However I pointed out that pretty much all West End theatres have a no unaccompanied children under 16 policy (and he looks young for his age)

But AIBU to think there are worse things a 15 year old could plan? The school was treating going to London like it was Syria or somewhere!

The upshot is that he is going to post phone his trip until after his 16th birthday next year!

OP posts:
domton · 25/02/2019 11:39

Doesn't it depend? Where I live, young people hardly ever use public transport because it's apalling. Most will have been to smallish towns, possibly a few cities for day trips with friends and family etc. Hardly any of the 15 year old I know would be able too navigate the tube etc., simply because it's not in their experience. The amount of people alone would be a shock! My nephew is 12, 13 this year and like most of his mates had only been on a train a few times, and it would take a bus and a train to get to the nearest city. Kids in London may use the tube at this age, but there's no way at all him or his mates would manage to get to the city. No way at all.

If however your 15 year old has been off and on buses etc for years, is used to large crowded cities then why not?

Clavinova · 25/02/2019 11:33

I realise I have given my own anecdote before someone mentions it. Smile

Clavinova · 25/02/2019 11:32

My ds1 has been travelling into London during the day since the age of 14 - with friends.
And he still involves me with the arrangements aged 16 now.

Clavinova · 25/02/2019 11:30

Depends where you live, but I used to occasionally go to london by train from bath with a friend from age 15.

Why do posters keep giving anecdotes about travelling with friends?

This boy planed to go on his own - 170 miles away - with a somewhat unusual itinerary - and his parents knew nothing about it when the school phoned.

My ds1 has been travelling into London during the day since the age of 14 - with friends.

SleepingStandingUp · 25/02/2019 11:28

London is full of 15 year olds who live there your point being what? It isn't that LONDON is inappropriate, it's that it's 170 miles away.

I'd let DS go to Birmingham at thst age but I wouldn't let him go to Glasgow or London.

Given that OP didn't say he had a gf, there's a chance he had arranged to meet someone off the Internet who MIGHT be a 15 Yr old girl or boy or who might have been 30 and looking for a kid to abuse. It isn't unreasonable to consider thst or to acknowledge tbat I'd have found it much harder to be groomed by a stranger back in 1996 than you would today

outpinked · 25/02/2019 11:25

My Dad moved to london when I was 8 so I split my time between Yorkshire and London growing up. I spent a fair few days out alone from about 14. It’s not a scary place really, if he’s comfortable navigating his way around then I can’t see an issue and can’t see why this would be a concern to the school either.

SleepingStandingUp · 25/02/2019 11:24

You obviously don't know much about the Book of Mormon actually very true. I only meant that the Lego Shop is hardly for kids only, lots of adults adore Lego

dairymilkmonster · 25/02/2019 11:18

Depends where you live, but I used to occasionally go to london by train from bath with a friend from age 15. To museums, theatre. Late 1990s. I was sensible and boringly responsible.
Think probably an over reaction by school.

Clavinova · 25/02/2019 11:17

there were no mobile phones either!

Indeed - you couldn't arrange to meet up with strangers online.

Clavinova · 25/02/2019 11:15

SleepingStandingUp
You obviously don't know much about the Book of Mormon - the op was too embarrassed to tell us what show he was going to see at first.

waterrat · 25/02/2019 11:14

honestly I am truly worried for the state of this world if adults think a 15 year old can't do a day trip on their own. sweet jesus - as everyone here says - London is full of 15 year olds who live there ! I went to secondary school in central London and managed to travel unaided around London from age 11! I think at the age of about 12 I was going into town - central London - to go shopping at weekends with friends.

When I was 15 I went to Glastonbury on my own ! as did many of my friends - there were no mobile phones either!

This is why people have mental breakdowns when they go to university.

Clavinova · 25/02/2019 11:12

He's certainly matured in the last year - from the Lego Shop to The Book of Mormon

It was a joke!

Clavinova · 25/02/2019 11:10

My dc still like Lego (although ds1 is probably just amusing ds2) - and they play musical instruments (hence the user name) - but they wouldn't be going to see The Book of Mormon 170 miles away on their own at just 15.

And you've still no idea why the school contacted you??

At least he wasn't planning to see The Full Monty.

DolorestheNewt · 25/02/2019 11:05

Well done, OP, you raised a sensible one. My DS, same age as yours, would never think through the pricing and timetable in the same way as yours.

Comefromaway · 25/02/2019 11:02

Most the people in there are adults/tourists taking pictures of themselves sitting on the lego tube train or by that fantastic light up plan of London on the stair wall.

OP posts:
millythepink · 25/02/2019 11:00

Don't have a problem with 15 yr old DD catching train to London but it's something she does with friends. Recently she was planning a trip to Paris, had researched the trains, found a decent AirBnB, figured out the Metro. But in the end I had to say no, but have agreed she can go when she is 16. I'm so pleased she is so intrepid and resourceful because I so wasn't at her age.

SleepingStandingUp · 25/02/2019 11:00

He's certainly matured in the last year - from the Lego Shop to The Book of Mormon because no adults like lego?? Who do yo u think is doing those massive 4 billion piece ones that cost hundreds??

Comefromaway · 25/02/2019 10:55

We still always visit the Lego shop. He has quite a Star Wars Lego collection including a highly coveted Death Star. I don't think you ever really grow out of Lego.

Then a trip to Foyles, Musicroom.com and the Yamaha instrument shops are a must.

OP posts:
theemmadilemma · 25/02/2019 10:53

I regularly traveled into London alone from SE (around an 1 hour or so) from 14 onwards.

He sounds smart and sensible.

Clavinova · 25/02/2019 10:52

He's certainly matured in the last year - from the Lego Shop to The Book of Mormon. Grin

Comefromaway · 25/02/2019 10:41

Why don't you offer to pay for your ds to take a friend with him as a birthday treat?

At almost £90 per ticket that ain’t happening I’m afraid.

OP posts:
Comefromaway · 25/02/2019 10:28

I think he had only come up with the plan that day.

He had birthday & Christmas money which he was going to spend on a musical instrument. A couple of days before the MD of his theatre group offered to give him an instrument they had spare to start him off.

He’s wanted to see BoM for years. First I said he was too young. Then he went and bought the playscript from Foyles and last summer an ex cast member did a dance workshop. He’s since taught himself the tap routine from the show from YouTube.

He knows we won’t take him to seeit in London because Dh and I already saw it and we have the tour booked.

OP posts:
Clavinova · 25/02/2019 10:23

As family this is a history of our London visits

But the school don't know any of this - and they care about your son's welfare - so they phoned you.

Why don't you offer to pay for your ds to take a friend with him as a birthday treat? The girlfriend would be a problem if her parents don't know she has a boyfriend.

NoCauseRebel · 25/02/2019 10:22

There are IMO two issues here.

I live just outside London and my sixteen year old regularly travels into the city and often alone. I don’t have an issue with this, but you do have to be streetwise. He was very recently almost mugged by two men claiming to be homeless who tried to grab him and make him go with them. Fortunately the owner of a nearby shop intervened and I reported the incident to the police but a child not used to travelling around the city alone could easily have been unsettled by that.

My other concern however would be that the school felt the need to call you as they clearly have concerns. And IMO the concern isn’t so much that he was planning to London but the fact that you were unaware of this plan. Why is that? Why has your DS not communicated to you what he was planning to do and when until he was confronted with the fact through a phone call from the school. That would concern me more than the fact he wanted to go tbh. And pricing up the tickets is fine but again he hasn’t taken account of the fact that he won’t be allowed into the theatre under the age of sixteen.

I wonder whether he has actually been embellishing what he’s doing at school in order to make him look different to how he is perceived, and I would be wondering about that. ESP given he’s given up the idea so readily iyswim.

Re access to social media, there is obviously a vast difference to being able to access a child’s social media and accessing it. I have access to my sixteen year old’s social media should I ever want it. Don’t though, so it’s not an issue.....

Swipe left for the next trending thread