Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Advice on financial situation...

155 replies

Midnightspecial · 13/01/2019 13:28

A & B are a couple, together 7 years and living together.

Person A earns £25k a year and has approximately £10k in savings.

Person B earns £76k a year and has £94k in savings, plus a further £18k inheritance just recieved.

Couple need to put money towards something this will cost roughly £18-20k and is to be split 50/50 so each person pays £9-10k each towards it.

Person A has piped up now the inheritance has come through and said that they feel it isn’t ‘fair’ that they have to wipe out their life savings completely and that they want to pay less than half. When asked why, they have just said it doesn’t feel right that one person is left with nothing and the other left with a lot.

Person B thinks that it isn’t fair that they pay more. That it was agreed half and, really, that’s that.

Thoughts?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Meraas · 02/09/2021 05:43

This marriage is doomed. Does B realise A could potentially get half of their savings in the event of a divorce?

abstractprojection · 02/09/2021 05:36

I love you so much, will you marry me

Yes

Ok hand over your entire savings to pay for your half while I keep my 100k to myself

MurielSpriggs · 02/09/2021 00:55

I'm with person B here. 50/50 always the fairest solution.

timeisnotaline · 02/09/2021 00:07

@TemptedToSleepInTheShed

Person B is right. If it is a shared expense, share it equally. Person A should be grateful to B because A would not be able to do it at all alone….
Well no, you can’t have a wedding with just one person. Kind of obvious no?

I do know it’s a zombie!

DifficultBloodyWoman · 01/09/2021 23:38

The fact that it is a wedding makes it different to me than if it were a car/boat/investment of some kind.

For an investment, I’d say 50/50 because A and B aren’t married.

For a wedding, I would say it depends on how you intend to treat money after the wedding and whether or not you have a pre nap. I think this is a good opportunity to talk about all of that before marriage.

If you decide that, after marriage, you will be a 50/50 joint venture or partnership, then it is a moot point and A and B can both pay 50/50 for the wedding and have access to joint savings and inheritance afterwards. Or B can pay for it all and share A’s savings after the fact.

If A and B intend to get married but not co-mingle money, then it should be split 50/50. A and B should also take seriously about long term plans for the future, specifically what standard of living they will have in retirement when one has very little money and the other can afford round the world cruises etc. Would B be willing to treat A then? Would B travel and leave A alone at home? Would B expect A to cough up and come along and make savings elsewhere?

TemptedToSleepInTheShed · 01/09/2021 23:28

Person B is right. If it is a shared expense, share it equally. Person A should be grateful to B because A would not be able to do it at all alone….

FlumpsAreShit · 01/09/2021 23:02

If they're getting married won't it become their money?

Does B really want to join their lives with someone then let them have a lower quality of life/less control over money (unless they split in a decade or two which leaves A much better off!)

I think if they're adamant about keeping finances separate and both A and B desperately want the fancy wedding too they should split it £5k-£15k. If B isn't fussed about fancy wedding stuff half and half sounds ok but if B driving fancy wedding then B should pay.

bridgetreilly · 01/09/2021 23:00

Now I want to know what happened! @Midnightspecial, care to update us?

bridgetreilly · 01/09/2021 22:57

Person B is a total nob and person A should not marry them until and unless they can come to a much better agreement re. shared and equitable finances.

timeisnotaline · 01/09/2021 22:56

A should consider carefully before marrying tightwad B. I paid most of our wedding as we were young and I started working earlier. In b’s situation I’d have paid it all without a thought. In A’s situation there is nothign not lifesaving that I’d wipe my savings out on, so the wedding would have to cost about 8k total (no idea how to do that personally, I’d probably tell the tightwad fiancé we had to skip everything he wanted in the wedding to tailor it to my budget.). Strong feelings about tightwad B insisting their partner wipe out their life savings just for the highly dubious pleasure of marrying them!!
Someone should word A up that they need to talk about if A contributes less to the house deposit will they be allowed to think of it as their house or will b be resentful? If a is female and they have children will b expect to pay most expenses while a is off on mat leave? Sounds like the type that would expect A to have saved up and once again wipe out their life savings to pay their mat leave. Seriously, if you’re close to A flag these things. It’s so important to talk about them before a marriage.

timeisnotaline · 01/09/2021 22:51

@KintsugiCat

When I got married I had less money that STBXH.

I wanted a wedding that coat about £4K and to split it down the middle, as that’s what I could afford.

He wanted a wedding about £25k as that’s what he could afford and he has a larger family than me etc.

He said he’d pay. I fought that for a while saying I wanted for us to be equals but he was insistent.

I ended up feeling so guilty and beholden. I did all the organising, but corners on things that would have been meaningful to me (dress, flowers etc) in order that I didn’t feel “greedy” spending someone else’s”/ money on myself.

It caused a lot of resentment.

If your plan was 4K and the budget was 25k no idea why you were cutting costs on everything that you wanted, some of this seems in your head ‘oh I can’t… oh I have to prioritise him…’
emilylily · 01/09/2021 22:39

Clearly person A is right. If person B loves person A they shouldn't want to see person A use up all of their savings.

DoubleTweenQueen · 01/09/2021 22:38

If one person is reneging on an agreement to pay half towards their OWN WEDDING to the other person, then it is doomed.

a) reduce budget to a more comfortable sum. Did A or B come up with the budget? If A came up with the budget and is now squealing then they need to re-assess priorities

b) realise that marriage brings a level of combining of worldly goods

anxiouscrazymum · 01/09/2021 22:29

Person a and person b should not have his and hers savings. They should have combined savings and take the money from their combined pot.
If either person thinks this is wrong they should not be getting married as it's a equal partnership.

TatianaBis · 01/09/2021 22:25

Who won I wonder, and are they still together?

Cornishclio · 01/09/2021 22:23

Given there is a large disparity in earnings and savings I would think that person B should pay more especially if it is for a wedding. I would be seriously concerned that they do not see them as a couple even though they are getting married. What happens in the future if they have children and person A takes maternity/paternity leave. Will Person B step up and cover outgoings?

Wiredforsound · 01/09/2021 22:16

It would depend on if B was happy with a £20k wedding in the first place, especially if they were being expected to stump up most of the cost. If A had decided on a £20k wedding but expected B to pay for the bulk of it then I can see B getting quite shirty. On the other hand, if they both want everything in that wedding then there should be a difference in contribution.

Viviennemary · 01/09/2021 22:10

I think they need to split up. Its not going to work. Their attitudes to money and sharing are too different.

PlanDeRaccordement · 01/09/2021 22:09

The wedding is unaffordable for A.

A&B should pay for the wedding as they mean to handle finances while married, so proportionally. This means that A should pay at most 25% and B should pay at least 75%.

I don’t think the inheritance should be counted at all.

Immaculatemisconception · 01/09/2021 22:09

ZOMBIE THREAD

Monestera · 01/09/2021 22:05

I wonder what happened. Guess with COVID, likely not a lot.

LakieLady · 01/09/2021 22:01

B is a tightfisted git and I wouldn't marry them if I was A.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 01/09/2021 21:59

Normal purchase in a dating couple, 50/50 regardless of savings or salary, the lower earner can always move jobs, take a second one etc if they want more money left over.
I’d never spend £20k on a wedding and wouldn’t empty my savings pot for a party. If that was what the other person wanted re spending so much, I’d be looking at my relationship. Marriage is about the vows and commitment not the money or the whole big day.

beigebrownblue · 01/09/2021 21:57

Not sure what the couple's status is.

Common law relationship? Scotland? England?
Married?

You have not said.

It makes a difference.

Calmdown14 · 01/09/2021 21:51

Who wants a wedding costing that amount? If it's all joint decisions, B should probably pay more.
If A has developed more extravagant taste than originally agreed, can see B's perspective more.
But really it all seems academic once married and if it isn't seen as a full union don't bother

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.