Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are there any cons to applying for an Irish passport?

157 replies

battenburg100 · 05/01/2019 10:54

Hi
With Brexit so close now, I'm in a dilemma whether or not to apply for an Irish passport. I'm hesitant as although I can see the benefits of having one, alongside my British passport, there are bound to be negatives too - but I'm not sure what they may be, so I would be grateful for any mumsnetters feedback....

Background info - I was born in the UK and have a British passport - my mum was born in Northern Ireland. My sister who lives in France was worried about her employment status there, so applied for and received her Irish passport. She now has dual nationality which has pleased her French employers, but what could be the consequences, particularly negative ones, of me having both types of passport living here in the UK?

OP posts:
BikeRunSki · 05/01/2019 14:23

To work for the MOD, or on MOD contracts, you do indeed need a British passport.

Somerville · 05/01/2019 14:19

It's not us being used for Irish citizens who didn't have the good fortune to be born in Ireland to gain a passport, youwould think Hmm They have just as much right to them as you and I, under Irish law. And how has it put people under duress?? Waiting longer for a passport renewal is a pain, sure, but the waits for straightforward applications and renewals are not nearly as long as people are saying. I got my babies PP through in only two weeks longer than my older kids took, some years ago.

youwouldthink · 05/01/2019 14:11

You know we've had over 100,000 'Brexit' applications for passports here this year. People who would never have applied for Irish passports suddenly deciding that this would be a good idea with no real clue how Brexit will affect their future travel to Europe. People with absolutely no interest in Ireland except getting a passport out of it. Thereby putting our people under duress in carrying about our normal business and passport renewals etc have become a nightmare for thos of us who are living and working here. I hope they clamp down big time and people stop 'using' us!

Yesitwasmethistime · 05/01/2019 14:04

Took me so long to write that that several people answered before me!!

loveautum · 05/01/2019 14:04

@madmum5811 yes her grandchildren can apply for a passport. My grandfather was born in Ireland and my brother who lives in the US recently got his Irish passport as was worried about the whole brexit situation and traveling in Europe. I live in the UK and have yet to sort mine out, but probably will at some point. My brother had a lot of paperwork to complete than just applying for a passport as he had to prove our grandfather was from Ireland and provide birth certificates ect. He applied via the Irish embassy in the US and got his passport pretty quickly.

Yesitwasmethistime · 05/01/2019 14:04

@FlyingElbows - Was GrandpaElbows born on the island of Ireland? In which case Mr Elbows would automatically already be an Irish citizen in Ireland’s eyes.

You can apply for MiniElbows to go on the foreign births register without doing anything for MrElbows himself.

My grandfather was born in Ireland, my mum was not but was brought up in Ireland until 21. She never had an Irish passport or did anything to formalise her citizenship and still has not. She lives in the UK with a British passport.

I have just applied to go on the foreign births register and hence get citizenship. I will then apply for the passport.

So, move that all a generation down and your kids may be able to do it without MrElbows doing anything?

Cyberworrier · 05/01/2019 14:02

You will need your mother’s birth certificate- I imagine you can apply for a certified copy from the national birth and deaths office/registry in Ireland. Her grandchildren can get passports after you and they register on foreign birth register and become Irish citizens.

williteverend99 · 05/01/2019 13:58

@flying

I would challenge that for a medium security job as it is nonsense.

If you look on eg GCHQs web site they make it clear that dual citizenship is NOT a barrier to employment provided one of the citizenships is British. And all their jobs are high security. Same applies for the Foreign Office etc.

It might be a problem if the dual citizenship was Russian or Chinese but Irish would not be a factor.

Ici

madmum5811 · 05/01/2019 13:57

So my mother is Irish, I think she lied about her DOB only know she grew up in Kilkenny. How do I prove she is Irish.

Also can her grand children apply for Irish passports?

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 05/01/2019 13:56

You certainly can hold passports for Ireland and Australia at the same time! My son is entitled to both, and a U.K. one too, as will I be when my aussie citizenship is sorted. There are no disadvantages, everyone born in NI can hold both U.K. and Irish passports.

golondrina · 05/01/2019 13:54

Mini elbows are eligible if they have an Irish grandparent. They have to register as foreign births first, but they can get an Irish passport whether their father does or not.

JennyHolzersGhost · 05/01/2019 13:54

Elbows - if the grandpa in question was born on the island of Ireland then your DH is already Irish, passport or no. The mini elbows can become Irish by applying to join the foreign births register, without their father having an Irish passport. You’ll just need all the relevant birth and marriage certificates etc. It’s very easy to do.

If the mini elbows were to have children they would not be able to pass on the citizenship unless they had already joined the foreign births register before the kids were born. If that makes sense. So in theory it is possible to continue to pass it down the generations but in practice it means making sure each generation (after the first, ie your DH) is registered before they beget the next generation. If you see what I mean.

Somerville · 05/01/2019 13:52

There is is some fearmongering around about having a second passport, but in the case of Ireland there is nothing to be fearful of. If you cna afford it then go for it If you can't then do it when you can - Brexit won't affect your status or application.

The most amusing one was a poster on here who was warning others that they could be called for national service and have to fight againt Britain at the Irish border in the Irish army in a no-deal scenario. Grin
(Never going to happen - putting aside that Ireland is a neutral country so would never be going to war, the 'Troubles' were always an internal UK civil war.)

FlyingElbows · 05/01/2019 13:50

Yep. Grandpa Elbows is Irish. Mr Elbows and three others were told if they applied for dual Irish/British nationality they would lose their jobs. Annoying because its something which may benefit the Mini Elbows but I'm not sure if we can apply for them without Mr Elbows doing it first.

Satsumaeater · 05/01/2019 13:45

Mr Elbows needs mod security clearance for his job and has been told that if he applies for dual nationality he will lose his job. Which is a bit annoying

Does that include Irish? It's usually a special case but perhaps not for MOD.

The only other downside I can think of (not with Irish) is that if you have sons and apply for another citizenship for them they might have to do national service (Poland?).

I believe that it is taking about a year at the moment to get Irish citizenship as they are pretty overwhelmed.

Clavinova · 05/01/2019 13:28

the passport is far cheaper than the British one

85 euros (80 + 5) is about the same as a British passport.

How often do you travel to Europe op? Not much point if you holiday in Devon every year.

I suppose you would have to make sure that both passports were up to date when you travel - if you let your British passport expire/forget to take it with you and you are the victim of a serious accident/ incident, then you might have to rely on the Irish consular for assistance rather than the British one??

HumblePikeman · 05/01/2019 13:16

I qualified through my DF, but my DCs have to have their birth registered before they can get a passport. The passport cost only about e90, but the registration costs nearer e290 and takes about six months even before you get the passport. All in, about £1,000 for all of us. Probably still worth it.

JennyHolzersGhost · 05/01/2019 13:16

Quinions - that only applies for second generation descent, not first generation which the OP is. OP’s mum was born in the North so OP is already an Irish citizen, she can apply for the passport straight away.

FlyingElbows · 05/01/2019 13:13

Mr Elbows needs mod security clearance for his job and has been told that if he applies for dual nationality he will lose his job. Which is a bit annoying.

Youmadorwhat · 05/01/2019 13:08

@sambob unless they are outside of Ireland for over 163 days or something like that (can’t remember the number of days

QuinionsRainbow · 05/01/2019 13:05

With Brexit so close now, I'm in a dilemma whether or not to apply for an Irish passport

Don't forget you have to apply to have your birth registered on the Foreign Births Register first. That confirms your Irish citizenship, then you can apply for a passport.

Mentounasc · 05/01/2019 11:30

DH is an Irish Dual national and my DC are Irish triple nationals - an Irish passport is great. The Irish embassy staff are lovely people and the passport is far cheaper than the British one. No downside at all, but I suspect they're a little overwhelmed right now with applications from the UK.

SamBob · 05/01/2019 11:23

*Some countries tax their citizens on their world wide income.

Some countries do. Ireland isn't one of them.*

Sorry just to clarify this I presumed you were talking about Irish citizens who are non resident. They will not pay tax in Ireland.

People resident in Ireland are taxed on their worldwide income.

golondrina · 05/01/2019 11:19

Err, none?

SamBob · 05/01/2019 11:18

Some countries tax their citizens on their world wide income.

Some countries do. Ireland isn't one of them.