Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are there any cons to applying for an Irish passport?

157 replies

battenburg100 · 05/01/2019 10:54

Hi
With Brexit so close now, I'm in a dilemma whether or not to apply for an Irish passport. I'm hesitant as although I can see the benefits of having one, alongside my British passport, there are bound to be negatives too - but I'm not sure what they may be, so I would be grateful for any mumsnetters feedback....

Background info - I was born in the UK and have a British passport - my mum was born in Northern Ireland. My sister who lives in France was worried about her employment status there, so applied for and received her Irish passport. She now has dual nationality which has pleased her French employers, but what could be the consequences, particularly negative ones, of me having both types of passport living here in the UK?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Golondrina · 26/01/2024 14:48

Why not? I haven't either but I am entitled to it (also three gps born on the island of Ireland, two in in the Republic, as well as a mother born in Belfast). I have no intention of living there but after Brexit it was better for me to continue living in Spain as an Irish passport holder so that's why I got it.

madmum5811 · 26/01/2024 13:54

I had three Irish grandparents, but never lived there so haven't applied.

Kittkat2000 · 26/01/2024 09:53

I know that I am responding to an old thread, but I would just like to clarify one point. There is a fundamental difference between applying for an Irish passport and Irish citizenship, and this goes for just about any country; not just Ireland. Passports are only issued to citizens. Therefore, under Irish law, anyone with a parent or grandparent born on the island of Ireland IS ALREADY AN IRISH CITIZEN, and therefore entitled to an Irish passport. In my case, my father was born in the United States, but his parents were born in Ireland. Both my mother and I were born in the UK, so I have triple citizenship, being British, Irish and US.

To answer the original poster, there is absolutely no disadvantage to applying for an Irish passport if one's mum was born in Northern Ireland, as the applicant is already an Irish citizen and therefore entitled to an Irish passport.

Inkspellme · 08/01/2019 18:00

Thanks MarDhea - it’s interesting to see statistics like that. The attitude of Ireland being an under developed poorer country comes from an old comparison when Ireland wasn’t the progressive thinking place it is now. Then maybe the comparison could be argued to be poor from Irelands viewpoint. However, those days have gone and Ireland should no longer be realistically be seen that way - as you showed. Thanks!

MarDhea · 08/01/2019 16:22

Sorry about weird bolding and duplicate letters - keeps happening when I put in clicky links on the app.

MarDhea · 08/01/2019 16:19

However, the GDP per capita figure is absolute nonsense. It's hugely distorted by the number of US firms that use an Irish office for tax purposes; capital flows through the Country provide some benefit to the treasury, but this has little relation to the obscene sums that flow through the books (and straight into Google etc's bank accounts).

That's true, which is why GNI (formerly GNP) per capita rather than GDP is regarded as a better way to assess income of a country's population. GNI excludes the billions in revenue from Google, Apple, etc. that count towards GDP but flow out of the country immediately.

Ireland ranks #9 in the world for GNI per capita (61,910 dollars) whereas the UK ranks #25 (42,560 dollars). They're the 2017 figuress* but the gap has been there for several years.

A better index (imo) is the % of the population living below the poverty line. Most recent figures are from 20133*, where Ireland had 8.2% in poverty (still too much) but the UK had 15%... I was shocked by that, tbh.

Enough digression, but worth noting that the jingoistic claptrap of Ireland being a poor relation of the UK doesn't hold water regardless of how many times it comes up on MN 🙄

Buteo · 08/01/2019 13:44

You may get called for Jury duty.

Only if you're on the register of electors.

Babycham1979 · 08/01/2019 13:39

Wow. Lots of posters kicking off about the previous poster's 'relatively poor' comment. In fairness, that is inaccurate these days.

However, the GDP per capita figure is absolute nonsense. It's hugely distorted by the number of US firms that use an Irish office for tax purposes; capital flows through the Country provide some benefit to the treasury, but this has little relation to the obscene sums that flow through the books (and straight into Google etc's bank accounts).

For comparison, take a trip to Anguilla or Turks and Caicos; huge GDP figures artificially inflated by their off-shore status have had little impact on the very real hardships faced by the vast majority of the population.

Babycham1979 · 08/01/2019 13:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

winterhappiness · 08/01/2019 12:38

You may get called for Jury duty. That's about it GrinGrin

Xenia · 08/01/2019 10:54

Cherry I have been doing al ot of work on our family tree and it is not that hard to trace back to people. If you have your husband's mother's full date of birth you could start by buying her birth certificate (if she does not have her own). That will give her parents' full names. Then you can buy their marriage cert and work back like that. I recently bought my great great grandparents' death certificates (not for passport reasons) from Ireland and they died in 1872 and 1892

Buteo · 08/01/2019 10:37

Wrt to Elbows post about her DH's job not permitting him to hold an Irish passport, then yes, this does happen. Back in the 90s I was told by my then employer that I could not apply for one as a spouse (when it was straightforward to do so) and my boss told me he had been given a hard time for offering the job to someone whose DH was born in NI.

Shitmewithyourrhythmstick · 08/01/2019 10:25

If she was eligible through her granddad born in Ireland but nobody has been born in Ireland since zukman, she'd need to have acquired Irish citizenship before you were born in order to be able to pass it to you. That's the only way to get it through a great grandparent.

QuinionsRainbow · 08/01/2019 09:56

*QuinionsRainbow

"Don't forget you have to apply to have your birth registered on the Foreign Births Register first. That confirms your Irish citizenship, then you can apply for a passport."

No you don't. Never even heard of this before*

You may not have heard of it before, but that's the procedure I had to go through ten years ago to get my citizenship and passport based on my grandmother's Irish birth. My brother has just gone through the same procedure, and my sister is thinking of doing it too.

As someone pointed out above, I got this a bit wrong. Children born to a parent with Irish citizenship are ipso facto automatically Irish citizens and thus immediately eligible to obtain passports. My grndmother was born in Ireland, and thus my late mother, born in England, had Irish, something we didn't discover until after she had died. To get my Irish citizenship, I first had to get my birth, in England, entered in the Foreign Births Register, for which Ihad to prove my descent using birth/mariage/death certificates a appropriate..

zukman · 07/01/2019 21:07

but her blood father! sorry

zukman · 07/01/2019 21:07

stick my mum was born in Scotland but her blood grandfather was from Ireland and born there in around 1910. My Mum’s parents split up when she was a baby, and so took her step fathers surname growing up, but Irish dad is on the birth cert

PositivelyPERF · 07/01/2019 21:03

Sorry mil

PositivelyPERF · 07/01/2019 21:03

CherryPavlova, would your mum’s birth date be on her medical records?

CherryPavlova · 07/01/2019 20:58

Shitmewithyourrhythmstick Yes I think that’s where my husband’s application would fall down. I’m not sure he could prove descent as records and his mothers memory of details are sketchy, at best. I suppose we could start applying for records but even where granny was born isn’t clear. MIL thinks Dundalk. She isn’t clear which year her mother would have been born in either. Not terribly helpful!

Shitmewithyourrhythmstick · 07/01/2019 20:51

A child of an Irish born parent does have to prove descent, yes. You can't just say your dad was born in West Cork and they say right you are, here's your passport. But you providing that evidence isn't the same thing as having to register as a citizen cherry. What you were doing was proving your citizenship. In the same way as someone born in Ireland during the period where that got you automatic citizenship would still have to prove that.

Someone getting citizenship through a grandparent born in Ireland has to provide proof of that, then also register too. That's what you did for your kids. They had one more stage to go through than you did, because they were one generation further away.

Zukman where was she born and how is she eligible?

CherryPavlova · 07/01/2019 20:50

I’ve not seen the online tool before. He’s going to be excited!

dadshere · 07/01/2019 20:49

QuinionsRainbow

"Don't forget you have to apply to have your birth registered on the Foreign Births Register first. That confirms your Irish citizenship, then you can apply for a passport."

No you don't. Never even heard of this before.

zukman · 07/01/2019 20:47

My mum is eligible to claim an Irish passport. Does that then mean I can claim it too once she does, as technically I will be the daughter of an Irish passport holder. Or are there restrictions in place for this?

CherryPavlova · 07/01/2019 20:46

My father was born in West Cork. I was advised by the embassy I needed to prove descent before getting my passport then had to register my children as foreign births, but maybe it’s changed. I’m going to look again for my husband but finding proof my be a challenge as grandmother died when his mother was sixteen.

Inkspellme · 07/01/2019 20:38

I would agree 100% on Irish neutrality not being up for negotiation. It’s an intrinsic part of Irish history and Ireland has a long and esteemed history of providing peace keeping forces in many places in the world. There is no appetite in the country to change our view to being a part of any army which is part of a conflict that I can see. The conscription to a European army is scaremongering in my opinion.

Swipe left for the next trending thread