Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want another baby with my ex ?

173 replies

gaelle79 · 03/01/2019 14:01

Hi all, happy New Year!

My New Year resolution is to make up my mind about this and I need your honest (non-judgemental) opinions please.

My ex and I dated for 5 years. We didn’t work out because I was not the one for him.

At the time, I didn’t realize that and kept making up excuses for the fact that he was dragging his feet regarding commitment. After 3 years and because I was pressuring him, he agreed to have a baby. When I brought up marriage (again) he said having a baby was an even bigger commitment and that made sense to me.

During my pregnancy I spent a lot of time reflecting on my life and finally saw things for what they were: He was not in love with me and didn’t want to marry me so I broke up.
It was messy and painful, he went MIA for months and I resented him for that, for failing our daughter.

Now we are back in a good place, co-parenting and getting along.
The thing is I desperately want another baby. I’m 39 going on 40. It’s been 3 years since our breakup and I wanted to meet someone, to build a relationship and maybe have baby #2 but nothing…not even a fling :(

I know I will find that person, eventually but it could be tomorrow or in ten years! If I want another child, I don’t have much more time left so I’m really considering having it with him.

We talked about it and he is totally on board with the idea. Still, there is no chance for us to work out as a couple so we would have the baby and co parent as we currently do but that’s it.

Do you think I’m crazy to even consider this?

OP posts:
NewishMum85 · 04/01/2019 22:17

No that's massively twisted. Would you also encourage people who can't afford to have kids to have lots of them because then at least they'll exist even if they live in poverty?

People with crappy parents don't tend to go around saying "oh well, I should just forget about all the horrible stuff because at least I exist?" do they?

Also, let's not forget that the OP already has a child who will be affected by this. The kids I went to school with whose parents were divorced were all massively affected by it and wished their parents would get back together. I think if their parents had another child after splitting it would make them even more confused and upset.

User758172 · 04/01/2019 22:13

I think it’s a terribly selfish idea. And only a terribly selfish person would go through with it. But as long as you’re happy, right? Hmm

Booboostwo · 04/01/2019 22:09

It’s not twisted logic, it’s a perfectly valid philosophical argument that’s difficult to dispute. PPs are claiming that the OP should not bring a child to life if it is to suffer as a child of divorced or single parents. That utilitarian argument doesn’t work because the alternative is no life.

It is not fine to abuse children, nor is it fine to have children if you intend to abuse them, but you cannot argue that the child would be better off not existing unless the life it has is not worth living.

NewishMum85 · 04/01/2019 21:46

Almost any life, unless it is a life not worth living, is better than non-existence.

That's such twisted logic. Would you encourage abusive parents to have children because as long as it's not to such an extent that the child wished they never existed then it's fine?

Booboostwo · 04/01/2019 21:09

There is some very confused thinking here about the potential harm to the child. Even if a life with divorced parents/a lone parent was harmful to a child (which it isn’t necessarily) this child currently doesn’t exist. Almost any life, unless it is a life not worth living, is better than non-existence. So even the people who think that children are harmed if their parents are divorced or lone parents can’t possibly think that the children are harmed to such a great extent that their lives are ot worth living in the first place.

Fashionista101 · 04/01/2019 18:49

I would so go for this! I think it's a great idea! As long as you know it will only be co parenting, it sounds like a great idea :)

Mummyshark2019 · 04/01/2019 18:49

If it's both what you want and you can provide a loving home for your kids, I don't see the problem....

VimFuego101 · 04/01/2019 18:47

It worked for Hugh Grant and his ex partner, I guess. I would set your expectations low when it comes to your co-parenting relationship, I don't see a new partner being happy with your arrangement and can see his involvement/ support dwindling if he gets into a new relationship.

Oakenbeach · 04/01/2019 18:41

I would because then your daughter has a full biological sibling.

Possibly the worst reason for doing something like this. Who cares about the children’s wellbeing, as long a they’re biologically related Hmm

Oakenbeach · 04/01/2019 18:37

I’d do it, just be prepared for the co-parenting to end if he meets a new woman who doesn’t like it xx

Yes, who cares if the child’s dad moves on... the child might be screwed up but it’s all about you so it doesn’t matter Hmm

NewishMum85 · 04/01/2019 18:26

Why do people post on AIBU if they are not willing to hear from people who think they are being unreasonable? The OP clearly thinks she is reasonable and has made up her mind.

I still think it's very foolish and I feel sorry for the child and potential future child...

Lifeisabeach09 · 04/01/2019 17:54

I don't think you are crazy at all.

  1. He is the father of DC1
  2. You know him
  3. You know how he parents
  4. Your clock is ticking and he is available and agreeable to it

Do it!

KatyWhatsit · 04/01/2019 16:45

I don't care what she or the father or her parents do for a job in the sense that I'm not impressed by the status she tries to attach to these jobs or her actual income.

My concern was she ought not to consider another child if she could not afford it and would struggle to find childcare.

Listing their occupations and income came over as a boast. His job is neither here nor there unless he's going to help fund the child(ren.)

Anyway- she doesn't want any opinions or anyone voicing their concerns, she only wants confirmation that she's right. Sorry to disappoint.

OnlineAlienator · 04/01/2019 16:36

I don't see why not if you are happily co parenting? Far better than some rush job 'blended family'. Full siblings and two dedicated happy parents sounds fine to me.

QueenofmyPrinces · 04/01/2019 16:34

I would definitely do it.

Loftyswops988 · 04/01/2019 16:33

My parents wish they had done this. And i do too i think. Split when i was just a baby and both now are still single and I'm an only child. They wanted more kids, i wanted siblings. My parents are such close friends but nothing more, but could certainly have happily coparented another child

twiglet · 04/01/2019 16:22

@KatyWhatsit your reply is very contradictory....... You say you don't care about what the Ops job is etc but it was you who raised the question about how she would afford it etc. The OP was replying to your questions.......

OP as I said in my reply as long as the boundaries are clear, agreed on etc then go for it. Modern day families come in all shapes and sizes with different set ups be it surrogacy to a gay couple, adoption, sperm donors etc. As long as they are loved its not for anyone else to judge.
You seem to have your head screwed on and have thought really hard about it.

Isleepinahedgefund · 04/01/2019 16:01

If you’re both on board, I think it’s fine. I know someone who did the same and had a second child with her first child’s father after they had split up. They were very young, and She ended up having a thousand other kids with a new partner a few years later, but everyone is still very happy with it all!

KatyWhatsit · 04/01/2019 15:58

I came here, not to ask you to seek validation but because I had my own personal reservations. I wanted to know if people here would have the same concerns or bring things to my attention that I didn’t thought about

And yes, I do have those concerns and reservations. But you don't like reading them,. Your post above is completely illogical. Not to say full of contradictions.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 04/01/2019 15:56

He's a financial risk manager, a strong and confident man. I couldn’t bring him to marry me but somehow, was able to manipulate him into having a baby?

A man who walked out on his wife and baby, who didn't have the courage to end the relationship, or to refuse to have a baby with a woman he didn't love. He's not committed to you, he doesn't love you, he's not thinking into the future, and he's expecting you to pick up the emotional slack for the children when he moves on. That's not strength or confidence. That's weakness, dishonesty and passivity.

HE came up with the idea first. I was reluctant at first because I wanted to get married first so HE convinced me that having a baby was a bigger commitment and stronger proof of his love and willingness to build a life with me.

And you believed him although he was lying to himself and to you. He might sound convincing but he didn't walk the walk, did he? He left instead.

Yes he made a mistake but he regretted it, asked for forgiveness and is now doing his best to be a good father.

What "mistake" exactly does he think he made? And what have the consequences been for him - not for you or the baby, but him? What promises is he making about his children's future? You seem willing to accept a situation where you will have his child and he makes no long-term commitments at all to any of you.

Oh Gaelle, why him again? You're well off, you can afford childcare. You'd be so much better off trying for an anonymous donor. Smart women, foolish choices!

But as you say, you don't need our blessing. Look after yourself. And I hope it turns out well for you all.

KatyWhatsit · 04/01/2019 15:55

LOL!

For someone who says they are not going to write a long reply...well, what have you just done?

Your response simply shows you can't cope with honest replies on a public forum. This is AIBU!

I don't give a toss about someone's jobs, their parents' jobs or their ex's job.

Earning money or being in banking(?) doesn't give anyone some kind of moral high ground. Far from it if you look at the banking fiascos in the UK.

I really don't see what my age has to do with it. So someone in their 50s can't have an opinion? We know nothing? You are ageist?

Why did you post if you only wanted people to agree with you?

It's a very moral issue. I and everyone here who has called your actions selfish, has as much right to do that as you have to live your life as you choose.

You're clearly rattled, so when you have calmed down, maybe reflect on those of us- and not just me- who have said this is not a good idea at all.

TacoLover · 04/01/2019 15:54

Now he barely talks to his kids twice a year. Of course this is not what I want but I know things will change when one of us will meet someone. I'm prepared for that

You're prepared for that. That's not really the point...It's the kids that will have to go through pain from losing their father, not you, and how can they prepare for something like that?

gaelle79 · 04/01/2019 15:32

@all the respectful PP: thank you…I really appreciate you all taking your time to answer my question. This is a really important decision the kind that must be thought through carefully with my family and friends. I did that and formed an opinion. I came here, not to ask you to seek validation but because I had my own personal reservations. I wanted to know if people here would have the same concerns or bring things to my attention that I didn’t thought about.

Some of you made really valid points, some in favour and some against this idea. Moving forward, I’ll take those concerns seriously and do my best to protect my child/children

OP posts:
gaelle79 · 04/01/2019 15:20

@KatyWhatsit I'm the one who posted the question here. That's why I respectfully read all the answers and so far refused to take the bait with anyone but enough is enough.

You insulted me, my ex, made definitive judgements based on "your perception" without knowing any of the details of our lives. If you have children in their 30s, I assume you are in your 50s, at least. I may be a selfish brat but you sound like a very unkind, mean-spirited and judgemental person.

I didn’t want to dignify you with a long and detailed answer but I will tell you this since it seems REALLY important TO YOU.

1- I'm a financial exec in the banking industry. I make >100K€ per year, own my apartment in Paris and never received a dime in "benefits" in my life and that, for a French woman (born and raised), is a record! So don’t worry, I won’t use your tax money to provide for my family.

2- My parents are 2 retired MD. They divorced when I was in my 20s. They had an unhappy marriage but stayed together for us (the kids). That was a terrible decision because we ended up being all really miserable. Still, they raised my 3 siblings and me to be law abiding, hard-working and compassionate people.

3- You know nothing about my ex. He's a financial risk manager, a strong and confident man. I couldn’t bring him to marry me but somehow, was able to manipulate him into having a baby?
I didn't force him to have a child. HE came up with the idea first. I was reluctant at first because I wanted to get married first so HE convinced me that having a baby was a bigger commitment and stronger proof of his love and willingness to build a life with me. He wanted our daughter and he loves her. Yes he made a mistake but he regretted it, asked for forgiveness and is now doing his best to be a good father.

4- In a perfect world, I would have Beyoncé’s body, be Queen of the UK, married to Ashton Kutcher and have 4 kids. Life is not perfect; children are born every day in very imperfect circumstances and still, they strive. They are very resilient beings.

5- You don’t think it’s “ethically right to bring a child into a complex situation just because you want another child”? Oh I can’t imagine what you must think of Gay people having bio kids, single women using sperm donors, poor people having large families… Having a child always start with a selfish desire to have a mini me to love, be loved by and complete your family/world. I don’t think you made a spread sheet or a SWAT assessment to decide whether or not you should have a child? You obviously didn’t since you had them…

Finally, asking a question here doesn't mean I need your blessing. At the end of the day it's my life and I’ll do exactly what I want and I couldn’t give less of a f*about what you think

OP posts:
AmaryllisNightAndDay · 04/01/2019 11:44

is this one really more likely to end in trauma?

Yes it is. She already knows for sure this man can't be relied on. She is just setting a very low bar for what she expects from the man/men who father her children. This one has already run off once and things may be nice now but as soon as they stop being quite so nice for him he'll be off again, this time abandoning two children instead of just one.

Or put it another way, if OP meets a new man who she thinks is "the one" and has a baby with him within a year, do you think that has a higher or lower chance of providing a happy and harmonious home life for both children?

Yes indeed, who can reliably make a good decision that fast and under pressure? But avoiding one poor decision doesn't make the other decision any good either.

we live together and love each other and provide a loving home to our children, and intend to do that for the rest of our lives. I don't see why children can only be happy if conceived through a passionate shag-fest...

Passion isn't needed but commitment is, to the children at least. Your DP has that, but her ex has not shown much commitment to his child(ren) so far and the OP wants to believe it doesn't matter.

IMO, the important thing is the quality of the relationship they have with both parents and that they feel loved

I agree with you. But how is this compatible with

I know a lot of situation were divorced fathers stop seeing their children once they meet someone new or see them less often. this happens a lot around me.

So how does that make children feel loved? You don't like it, but you accept it's a very likely outcome for your future child and you're still going ahead?

OP, you have a child and a living situation that more or less works at least for the time being. But is this really a good enough situation to bring another child into?

my self esteem his perfectly fine. I know my worth, that's why I decided to break up when I realized he didn't love me.

OK, then why would you put yourself in a position where your ex can walk all over you and you will have to suck it up for the sake of maintaining his relationship with the children? Because he's not committed to them, any more than he is to you.