Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Makeup on an 11 year old.

161 replies

Makeupaddikt · 19/12/2018 23:24

I have an 11 year old daughter and I’ve nevr let her wear makeup as I personally think she is too young however, my friend has told me I’m unreasonable and all 11 year olds wear it although not to school????

So is it me BUmor my friend?

OP posts:
Iliketeaagain · 20/12/2018 07:37

My Dd is 9, and starting showing an interest because some of her friends are - but she gets bored of it about 10 mins after she starts playing with it.
Personally, I'd rather show her how to put on some pink or clear lipgloss and glittery eyeshadow if she wants to.

In fact, I think by offering to show her, it takes the mystery and exciting-ness away, so means she's less interested!

But, never for school, only for parties.

Matildatoldsuchdreadfullies · 20/12/2018 07:37

There's quite a difference between a Year 6 11 year old, and a Year 7 11 year old. But at the end of the day, it's only make up. Is there really a difference between this and face paint?

For the record, my 11 year old Year 7 dd doesn't wear any make up - but neither does her 15 year old sister. My eldest, on the other hand, started wearing make up in Year 7.

MsTSwift · 20/12/2018 07:33

Bananas I would pay money to see you enforcing doll playing and wholesome childlike fun on your average 12 year old Grin. They are “playing” with make up it’s not sinister. Do you have tiny children atm?

MsTSwift · 20/12/2018 07:29

Mine has make up. They try it on with friends and copy you tubers and giggle. “Blind makeover” is a favourite game. Don’t see the harm. They only wear abit of eyeshadow outside the house.

DragonMamma · 20/12/2018 07:17

I’m clearly from the KeepServing school too.

I only know of one Yr6 girl (August born) who’s still in to dolls, MLP etc. It is very out of the norm here for girls to be playing with dolls in High School. They’ve generally moved on way before then.

Mediumred · 20/12/2018 03:11

I have a y6, so will turn 11 soon. I bought her some makeup last Xmas -more in a ‘dress up’ , your mates come round and you do each other’s eyes and look like pandas etc - but it’s hardly been touched (which is fine, was just an idea). We are in London and I would say the kids are fairly, though not ridiculously, streetwise, a lot have phones, walk home, occasionally go to coffee shops etc but this just doesn’t seem to interest them at all at this stage and certainly no one would dream of wearing it to school apart from a bit of nail varnish.

No judgment in this post, just an observation of how it is round our way.

Pandamodium · 20/12/2018 02:52

My DD started experimenting about 11. Now at 13 it's special occasions only.

She's currently arguing the toss for acrylic nails so I'm just picking my battles to be honest.

They do seem to grow up a lot faster these days.

Punto1 · 20/12/2018 02:23

I see no issues with here playing with it. Not allowed at school etc., but who doesn't like a bit of makeup!

KC225 · 20/12/2018 02:22

My 11 and a half year old has asked for some make up for Christmas. I wear make up - foundation, matte red lipstick etc., but she has shown no interest. When she moved to a school and became friendly with the daughter of a hairdresser/beautician she became more interested as her friend his lots of make up and is very knowledgeable about it.

We have talked about what I think is age appropriate. I have bought her a small palette of gold/rose gold eye shadow, a highlighter, a natural lip gloss and a mascara. She is aware its only for parties and school shows/concerts - not for every day and NOT for school.

What I have bought her is very subtle and to be honest I see it as a phase.

BananasAreTheSourceOfEvil · 20/12/2018 01:53

@slappinthebass Thankyou. The monster high and LOL dolls freak me out though the kids love them. Thankyou though for saying that I’m not the only parent whose child is still very much a child.

I apologise if I have derailed your thread OP and I don’t think you are BU at all.

I can’t believe that I am in the minority in thinking that children should be left to be children for as long as possible. I’m not naieve; I understand that when dd goes to secondary school she will learn all sorts of things, but for the time being I would just rather give her the sylvanian families and the doll clothes she wants rather than a bloody contouring kit,

It’s one thing to play dress up in mummy’s clothes and wear a bit of blusher and mascara, as opposed to sending them out in make up. 11 years old! We have all these progressive women’s movements going on (metoo; Ibelieveher) but we are still teaching little children that they need make up.

This post- not OPs- has made me so cross.

When is the deadline for telling children they can’t play with their toys anymore and must paint their faces to be accepted?

leccybill · 20/12/2018 01:02

Honestly, princess dressing up in Year 7? Doubt that very much.

Even my most babyish year 7s have moved on to Smiggle, Joe Sugg, mermaidy things etc.

PickAChew · 20/12/2018 00:58

I experimented with make up at 11 and haven't worn any for all of my 40s. Let her at it, but enforce boundaries.

slappinthebass · 20/12/2018 00:55

@BananasAreTheSourceOfEvil my dd is in year 7, and she likes MLP, LOL dolls, Monster High, soft toys, unicorns, gaming, Lego, Pokemon and wearing princess dressing up clothes, not fashion. She has never shown any interest in make up, other than face paint. She does have some more grown up interests, particularly with reading. She has plenty of friends with similar interests. Just wanted to counter the Confused. 🙄

agnurse · 20/12/2018 00:55

I was allowed to wear makeup starting at age 12. I think she's a bit young.

I do think you might consider letting her wear some pale lip gloss and some nail varnish. Those to me aren't really "makeup".

GrimDamnFanjo · 20/12/2018 00:27

I bought my DD make up for her 12th birthday as it seemed she was the last in her peer group to wear it.
I got her mainly neutral stuff and some party glitter (as my choices of nude shadows did seem a bit joyless!) and spent time with her explaining how to use it.
She wears it once a week outside school and looks very natural.
It's something she enjoys doing and I'm always careful to be body positive in general with her anyway, rather than focusing on looks etc

KeepServingTheFestiveSnogs · 20/12/2018 00:25

I disagree. By allowing your child to experiment with make up isn't the same thing as letting them wear it to school (you can reasonably ban that).

When my DD was interested in make up, I brought her some. She dolled herself up and it was like dressing up to her.

She followed tutorials from bloggers.

She had fun with it.

She rarely wears it out (didn't then, doesn't now age 17)

Make up isn't the problem, adult attitudes to it might be. I agree with the PP who said banning it makes it more alluring (esp if you're wearing it yourself).

BananasAreTheSourceOfEvil · 20/12/2018 00:19

@cakesandtea Thankyou for saying what I was trying to say.

cakesandtea · 20/12/2018 00:13

OP, this is not the question of what other DC do, or parents say. This is the question about your values and your parenting, what You think is right for your DD. In no way what others say or do can validate something that you think is wrong for your 11 years old.

I personally would never allow my 11 years old to wear make up, nor would she ask. School is for learning. There is no need to sexualise at this age and and pursue this silliness. I want my DD to focus on learning and develop her ambitions and aspirations unrelated to male sex and how she looks.

BananasAreTheSourceOfEvil · 20/12/2018 00:13

Excuse me? My dd is y5.

Should I be discouraging her away from her toys she loves and saying ‘here you go darling, why don’t I show you how to paint your face?’

She has no interest in it and whilst I know it will come in time, I find that Confused to be quite insulting. I’m prepared to let her grow up at her own rate- none of her friends round here wear make up. They all like ponies, fairies, pusheens, dolls and the like.

She has her whole life to be a grown up so I am not going to spoil that before she decides that she decides to do it.

Congratulations- your kid is into make up. Mine isn’t.

Newsername · 20/12/2018 00:03

My dd is 11 in a few weeks and there’s no way in hell she’d get near make up.

She’s still into mlp and fairies and long May it stay that way.

Seriously? I don’t know any 11 year old who still plays/played with ponies and fairies at that age. That’s year 6/7! and you want it to continue into year 8/9/10? Confused.

I buy bits and bobs for dd (11). Her friend wears concealer and foundation, but I draw the line at eyeliner and a bit of lip gloss. She has an eyeshadow palette she tries out, but she’s not allowed outside the house with it on and no make-up at school. I always dabbled with make up at home and tried out things. It’s not growing up, it’s just art/expression in another form, not on paper.

RockingAroundTheChristmasTree1 · 19/12/2018 23:54

My mother was a make up artist, and was obviously obsessed with make up, which rubbed off on me ( I have every piece of make up imaginable now)
But at 11, I didn't wear any make up..young girls these days, seem to be growing up so fast, compared to back when I was younger!
My mother at 11, took me to have my eyebrows done, which made me feel very grown up!
If she is insisting on wanting a few bits, you can take her to the make up counters at Debenhams or somewhere similar..they will do her make up for her for free (this will feel like a massive treat to her!)
I worked as one of the make up ladies for one of the counters years, and we use to get in lots of really young girls with their mum's coming in..we would use things like a tinted moisturiser, and a bit of mascara and a lip gloss..it made them feel very special and grown up..when in reality they had hardly anything on!!
And it's a free little pamper for them!!

BusterGonad · 19/12/2018 23:52

I say let her have a few bits and bobs, there's nothing worse as a child to feel like the only one with out something everyone else has, once she's got it she'll probably be bored of it soon enough. She just wants to be like her mates.

FamilyReferee · 19/12/2018 23:51

At 11, I allowed my DD to wear it round the house, and if it was subtle, the odd bit out of the house once in a while. There are colours/looks that wouldn't be appropriate, and then I just gently told her that's more of a 'dance' look, and that she can't wear it out of the house. She wore more makeup for dance shows. I felt that I wanted her to have the opportunity to experiment if she wanted to, plus didn't really want to give her something to rebel against. And to date (she's a little older now), it's not an issue - she rarely wears much, if any, usually nail varnish, but in a child sort of fashion. I have a 'none for school' rule, and as far as I know, she's never bothered.

But then, I'm not fussed on it myself - I do enjoy it, but don't wear it daily, so I guess she's just following my example.

datingloon · 19/12/2018 23:51

My Dd is 11 and likes make up, she's just started wearing a little mascara to school (she's a red head) other than that it's just a little lip gloss if going out

It def won't make her grow up to fast for Christmas she is having a reborn toddler doll to go with the other 30 odd dolls she has a loves, she plays with them all day everyday

Cherries101 · 19/12/2018 23:48

Wearing makeup isn’t growing up too fast. It’s a matter of personal choice about her body and if your 11 yo wants to wear make up, shave her body hair etc you should encourage her by giving her considered advice (or directing her to it).

Swipe left for the next trending thread