Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Makeup on an 11 year old.

161 replies

Makeupaddikt · 19/12/2018 23:24

I have an 11 year old daughter and I’ve nevr let her wear makeup as I personally think she is too young however, my friend has told me I’m unreasonable and all 11 year olds wear it although not to school????

So is it me BUmor my friend?

OP posts:
MsTSwift · 20/12/2018 09:00

It’s easy to be smug if your dd shows not the slightest interest - that’s great easy life. But if they do...do you roll your sleeves up and go into battle on that one? Ensure you stick to your principles result being they are left out of their friendship group? Have to deal with the sadness of that? Not easy parenting a tween.

GlasgowWorrier · 20/12/2018 08:57

Oops, pressed post too soon...

My DN has been obsessed with make up since she was 11. It’s not the Kardashian contouring that bothers me as much as the duck-faced selfies posted on Instagram. But then I’m old enough to remember Minipops - with a shudder.

Racecardriver · 20/12/2018 08:55

Playing with make up is not exactly encouraging good habits but it’s not harmful. But wearing make up is inappropriate. 11 is too young.

GlasgowWorrier · 20/12/2018 08:55

My DN has been obsessed

Oysterbabe · 20/12/2018 08:52

I started wearing eyeliner at 11, that was 27 years ago. I think I'd allow it.

MsTSwift · 20/12/2018 08:51

Who wouldn’t disagree with that? My girls also do all those things sport / study : extra academic schools. But sometimes play with eye make up and wear nail varnish. No need to be so absolutist.

VI0LET · 20/12/2018 08:49

I agree with you Op and also with cakesandtea.

I want my daughters to enjoy playing with their friends, doing sport, enjoying their hobbies and learning at school. Not trying to look sexy for boys/men.

My kids all do sport, so it’s about skill and strength / flexibility , your body being fit so you can be strong and healthy, not about being shaggable .

I don’t want to teach them that their faces and body are wrong so they need fake nails, fake tan and fake eyelashes at 12 and fake boobs , hair and Botox by 20.

I hate the constant message that they are not good enough as they are, they need to look like someone else to be acceptable and loved. And because I have sons as well, I can see that this doctrine of “ you are ugly and need fixed ” isn’t there for boys. So I resent my daughters being told this.

I don’t see much make up on my 12 years olds classmates either. But then it’s a very academic school and there’s a lot of focus on working and playing hard, most of the pupils will go on to college or university.

So the pressure on the girls is to do well at school, it’s not all about and getting themselves a boyfriend ASAP so you can be living together by 18 and have a baby by 20.

So just a different culture I guess.

I am well aware that this is very much a minority view here on MN and that most of you will disagree vehemently with me, but that’s ok.

EyeSaidTheFly · 20/12/2018 08:25

I wasn't allowed to wear make up until i was 16. I hated it at the time but I'm so grateful now. I truly believe it was one of the main reasons I'm so comfortable in my own skin as an adult. I wear make up most days now but I'm not at all insecure about my physical appearance and I think that's because, during an extremely formative period of my life, my parents refused to allow me to sexualize myself. I see children (invariably girls) wearing make up these days. It's sexist, it's sexualisation of children. I find it repulsive.

RandomObject · 20/12/2018 08:22

I wasn't allowed to wear makeup at 11. I was bullied at school for it.

MsTSwift · 20/12/2018 08:11

Playing with make up and playing hide and seek and imaginary games are not mutually exclusive Hmm. Who is advocating not encouraging playing? Yes of course we would all prefer if our girls wore smocks and played with dolls but if they move on from that and want to grow up that has to be supported too. My elder one started her periods at 10 not much a “keep them young” parent can do about that either.

MagentaRocks · 20/12/2018 08:10

My 10 yr old niece has a little bit of make up. She doesn't wear it often but I think just having it makes her feel grown up. She only weather for special occasions and then only very light.

Amanduh · 20/12/2018 08:08

It’s sad. The last two schools I have worked at, the year 4’s onwards have been makeup obsessed, and why?
Youtube.

AngelsWithSilverWings · 20/12/2018 08:07

I have just allowed my10 year old to have some subtle make up. She is surrounded by girls in y6 who are obsessed with looks.

DD doesn't live up to these girls high standards apparently and they have been making nasty comments. They point out the dark circles that she has under her eyes and have teased her about her bushy eyebrows. She got very down about it all and wrote me a letter telling me everything she hates about herself and handed it to me. It was heartbreaking.

I didn't feel good about this but I took her out to get her eyebrows threaded and bought her some BB cream and concealer and showed her how to wear it so that it isn't obvious. It made such a difference to her confidence.

She also wanted to have her legs and arms waxed because of teasing. I wouldn't allow that.

I thought long and hard about this issue and I know that I probably should have taken it up with the school in an attempt to stop the teasing but previous experience tells me that I would have just made things worse for DD

AliMonkey · 20/12/2018 08:07

I think the key thing here is that OP's daughter hasn't asked for it. Definitely not something to suggest to a DD. Personally it would have been a no from me in primary school but would have considered in secondary - but only for experimenting and occasional use. DD is nearly 14 and shown no interest yet but others started wearing in Y7. Personally I started wearing occasionally at at 13 but haven't worn any since I was 21.

U2HasTheEdge · 20/12/2018 08:05

My daughter turned 12 today and for the last few months she has been using her friend's makeup at school. Just a bit of mascara and lip gloss. I was quite against it but then noticed that most of her friends were wearing light makeup so for her birthday I have bought her some.

She will be told that only lip gloss and mascara can be worn for school. The rest she can play about with it home.

Makeupaddikt · 20/12/2018 07:59

Thank you everyone. My daughter hasn’t shown any interest in makeup whatsoever. The conversation came up when I was talking to my friend and telling her I was struggling to get things for my daughters stocking (she is into books and dvds) and my friend said about makeup.

As I said I let her wear nail polish but even with that I avento supervise her and can’t let her have it in her room (she painted her window sill with it 😏.

I haven’t seen any of her friends wearing makeup so it’s notmas if all her friends have it and she doesn’t, but then again they might wear it round the house and fe just not seen it.

I do appreciate everyone’s replies and views, but I think I will just leave it until she asks for makeup.

OP posts:
anniehm · 20/12/2018 07:52

It's up to your dd, if she wants some lipgloss and eyeshadow is age appropriate.

RiverTam · 20/12/2018 07:52

How dreary that apparently it's fine for 11yo girls to bow to peer and societal pressure to wear make up but God forbid they should tread their own path and be into toys and dressing up.

OP, yanbu and DD will not be wearing make up at 11.

cloudtree · 20/12/2018 07:49

It won't harm her. She's not going to end up pregnant at 15 as a result of a bit of eyeliner and lip gloss.

I started wearing makeup at 11 (secondary school) and I'm 45 so it isn't anything new.

MsTSwift · 20/12/2018 07:48

It seems the lip pursed anti make up brigade seem to think we are locking away toys and smearing foundation on children’s faces. I don’t think you can enforce what children enjoy they like different things at different stages neither is “wrong”. My year 5 and her friends play “strictly” put make up on and prance around the house. Love it!

AlaskanOilBaron · 20/12/2018 07:48

I have only boys, but I've just started to notice a bit of makeup on my son's year-8 classmates at parties.

I don't love it, but it's not my problem.

Topofthehills · 20/12/2018 07:47

I think when I was 11 I had some nail polish, some clear/glittery lipgloss and some glittery eyeshadow stuff for parties. Didn't wear any of it to school. I think my mum also got me a concealer for spots which I couldn't be bothered with. Definitely was also shaving by age 11 (underarms, not legs).

I got my period at 10 though! I understand the "let children be children" sentiment, but you've got to let them experiment with things at that age if they want to as well. Some of them are going through puberty and don't really feel like children any more.

Newsername · 20/12/2018 07:44

I can’t believe that I am in the minority in thinking that children should be left to be children for as long as possible.

Erm, I think we all agree children should be left to be children for as long as possible. You can’t dictate their interests though. You seem really weirdly against makeup like it’s the antichrist and will corrupt your child.

A majority of the people on this thread have said they don’t let their child wear it out, to school or go overboard for special occasions. What’s the difference between your girl face painting and wearing make up at home?

Your “long may it continue” comment is odd. Loads of girls are close to starting their periods at age 11/12. They’re not exactly small children are they? They’re coming into young adulthood.

Beaverhausen · 20/12/2018 07:40

Nope my dd is 11 and to me too young to wear make up. Girls grow up far too quickly these days and unfortunately this can lead to bigger problems for parents in the long run.

Do not be in a rush for them to mature too quickly, we gave them for such a short time.

Stereomum · 20/12/2018 07:39

My year 7 daughter has shown no interest yet. If and when she does then I will get her a few bits. I was starting to experiment with some make up at that age.