Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Makeup on an 11 year old.

161 replies

Makeupaddikt · 19/12/2018 23:24

I have an 11 year old daughter and I’ve nevr let her wear makeup as I personally think she is too young however, my friend has told me I’m unreasonable and all 11 year olds wear it although not to school????

So is it me BUmor my friend?

OP posts:
StickyCarpet · 20/12/2018 10:21

My daughter loves make up, she is really good at applying it and will often do mine for me. I'm more than happy for her to wear it around the house but not outside. She wore a bit to her year 6 disco (mascara/lip gloss)

I think if your child is interested in it then let them experiment. If not then leave it. Kids grow up very quickly these days and it's really nice to try and keep that innocence but a little bit if make up at home isn't going to harm anyone.

Trampire · 20/12/2018 10:19

I totally echo everything you've said Dragonmamma.

My dd at aged 9/10 wore black and was into dragons, Skeletons and wizards and musicals. I Did feel inwardly pleased with myself that I'd raised a confident girl who didn't 'follow the crowd', although it often set her apart from her peer group.

These days she likes to conform. Although I'm pleased she doesn't wear the knee-deep shiny contour make-up like some girls do, and isn't really into selfies - she is who she is (or at least finding out). I'm just as proud of her.

I'll never feel smug about nothing again as far as parenting is concerned. Every month seems to bring a new challenge.

RockingAroundTheChristmasTree1 · 20/12/2018 10:18

Jesus the people on here saying it's disgraceful to play with a bit of make up...in the 80's when I was little, one of the best selling toys, was a Girls World Styling Head!

DragonMamma · 20/12/2018 10:12

Trampire I try not to be smug as it usually comes to bite you on the arse eventually! Early parenting told me that.

My DD is pretty anti-pink and has gone to her school party today wearing a black knitted dress (complete with 🏳️‍🌈 on the front), black knee high socks, Docs and - shocker - mascara!

I hate this unspoken narrative that if your DD likes pink, make up and fashion that you’ve somehow failed as a parent. Feminism is surely about allowing girls to be what they want to be? Not being anti pink, not shaving your pits and wearing hemp knickers!

Ellisandra · 20/12/2018 10:10

I think it’s laughably smug to post that your child isn’t bothered about makeup and not affected by peer pressure and finds those who like it are odd.

My daughter loves makeup but doesn’t give a monkeys about squishies - despite ALL her friends being crazy about them. I don’t feel smug that this lack of interest in weird over priced gimmicky tat is due to resistance to peer pressure. She just doesn’t like them. But... she’s mature enough not to think her friends are “odd”. She understands people like different things.

Trampire · 20/12/2018 10:04

Grin Dragonmamma, yes!

I was quite 'smug' I suppose when dd was younger. She was a huge anti-pink girl who was totally confident and went out of her way to be different in a crowd. Very emotionally and mentally mature.

Now she's heading 14, peer pressure is huge thing, as is generally insecurity, normal teen anxiety and the desire to not always put your head above the crowd.

I feel a bit sad, but it's natural. I remember being exactly the same.

DragonMamma · 20/12/2018 10:01

Trampire I think it’s quite indicative of demographic of MN that ‘superior parenting’ is having your kids wearing JoJo and Boden until they are 16, no make up, TV for 30 minutes a day, no interest in pop culture whatsoever and happy playing Lego Friends and dolls until they leave home.

agnurse · 20/12/2018 10:00

I think we can draw a distinction between three separate situations here.

  1. Playing with makeup. When I was little I LOVED it when I got to have someone make me up as part of a sleepover or something. I don't see an issue with that.
  1. Wearing makeup for something specific, such as a theatrical or artistic performance. This is a logistical thing. I had a ballet concert when I was about 8. I HAD to wear heavy makeup because otherwise the lights would have washed me out. That's different.
  1. Wearing makeup for every day. I think she's too young for that.

Remember that just because a girl has started her period, that doesn't mean she is ready for adult experiences and adult responsibilities yet. Some girls start their periods as young as 8. Do you think it's appropriate for an 8-year-old to wear makeup? Obviously OP's daughter is older, but the issue still stands.

SumitosIsMyWall · 20/12/2018 10:00

Our yr7 11 year old is not remotely interested in makeup and she finds it odd that others are.

She's definitely my daughter, peer pressure is irrelevant to her.

ADastardlyThing · 20/12/2018 09:59

I think it's a bit grim. I have to sit on my hands when my friend posts pics of her 10, nearly 11 go on FB, normal average day pics, and she has a face full of mascara, lipstick, blush, it even looks like her nails get done and her brows are on fleek. She looks about 15, really sad.

Trampire · 20/12/2018 09:58

I agree Dragonmamma.

My dd is nearly 14. She started wearing a bit of brown eyeshadow and mascara towards the end of Y7. It makes her feel nice. She wasn't interested at 11 but plenty of her friends were.

I don't get the drama.

She's not 'vacuous' or 'sexualised' whatsoever and I resent the implication from parents who are coming across as having 'superior' parenting skills.

Ellisandra · 20/12/2018 09:55

My 10yo loves make-up.
Yes, that’s growing up - but it’s not growing up “too fast” for me - for example, she’s asking Santa for make up. How can she be growing up too fast if at 10 years old she still believes the makeup will be delivered by magic?! Grin

I don’t wear any makeup at all, so I am happy that I am modelling for her that you don’t have to wear it.

She loves YouTube tutorials. She finds it fun and creative. She does it for herself, not for anyone else.

I didn’t think this would be my view, before I became a parent.

DragonMamma · 20/12/2018 09:52

Bloody hell. Where did allowing them to wear make up become parents allowing the kids to be sexualised?

I also resent the assumption that interest in make up = not academic or sporty. My DD is one of the top academically in her class and plays plenty of sport and plays instruments. She also happens to like playing around with make up.

Make up does not lead to vacuous adults. I wear it most days and I amcertainly not Hmm

agirlhasnonameX · 20/12/2018 09:47

DD 11 occasionally wears a little. She goes to youth club and all the girls her age are the same, some caked in it. There is a girl who wears foundation to school too, which is where I would draw the line on both counts.
She hasn't the patience for it though and hates things around her eyes so isn't obsessed or wearing it all the time by any means.
Now and again for fun I think is fine, but admittedly when she asked me last year if she could wear it "because it makes you prettier" I told her no because that wasn't true or a good reason.

Booboostwo · 20/12/2018 09:38

My 7yo plays a lot with make up and is allowed to wear it outside the house on special occasions. She has been using nail polish since she was 3yo and so has her brother. Their bodies, their choice.

I don’t wear make up btw, my choice.

As for becoming obsessed with body image, being bullied or bullying others over their looks, I don’t think make up is what’s important. A confident child will be confident with Ron without make up and a kind child will be kind with or without make up. Confidence and kindness take time and effort to develop, but neither has much to do with make up.

Deadringer · 20/12/2018 09:27

None of my girls wore any make up at all until about age 14, and then only if they were going to a party or something. It was never banned it just wasn't a thing in our house. I don't wear it really myself and my eldest 2 who are now adults only wear it on a night out. Agree with a pp who said that it's not really appropriate for primary school children, none of the 11 or 12 year olds that I know or see when out and about wear make up so it's not the norm where I live. Slap my youngest is nearly 10 and is interested in the same sort of stuff as your DD, as are most of her friends so not unusual at all.

AcidPops · 20/12/2018 09:19

Wearing makeup isn’t about being sexy/looking good for men, well, it isn’t in our house. My girls dance (ballet etc) as do I. At 7 & 10 they have quite a bit of makeup and practise different techniques for shows and festivals. Single parent here, they see me put makeup on for myself, not to impress anyone else. I let them wear it for discos or special events but not daily xx

BarryTheKestrel · 20/12/2018 09:18

Is wearing make up inherently sexualising? I don't and never have put make up on to look sexy or to attract males.

For me, make up has been a positive impact in my life as I felt negatively about the way that my face looked. Probably due to media portrayal of women rather than my peers(was never bullied about my face), but a small amount of make up did wonders for my confidence in myself.

I think make up for young teens really isn't an issue as long as it's a natural look and not caked on, if it gives them confidence in themselves.

Yes it's not ideal and they should learn to be confident/happy without it, but are years of internal torment worth it when a bit of powder and mascara can make the world of difference?

MrsStrowman · 20/12/2018 09:16

Eleven seems young for make up to me, maybe some fruity lip balm day to day and nail varnish for a party etc but no more

hobnobsaremyfavourite · 20/12/2018 09:16

see I think life is not about absolutes
My DD trains at sport several times a week, is ver academic, enjoys performing and oooohhhh shock horror occasionally puts a bit of make up on
Who knew it was possible to have a well balanced pragmatic approach to life Hmm

MsTSwift · 20/12/2018 09:13

I think Anne of green gables and Laura Ingalls flipping wilder were fiddling with ribbons etc at a similar age hardly a new thing

hobnobsaremyfavourite · 20/12/2018 09:10

This “they grow up too quickly these days” thing
I was playing “makeovers” with my friend at 9, 10 and 11 and I’m pushing 45
It’s not a new thing. Admittedly we didn’t have social media in those days and were as likely to be playing outside as inside doing our make up
It doesn’t seem to have damaged me as I rarely bother with make up these days
DD is 11 and asked for some make up to wear to her primary leaving party
I bought her a few bits and got someone more useful than me to teach her what to do with it Grin
She has worn it once subsequently to the theatre to watch a show which she also dressed up nicely for.
She looked fine and it was very subtle so I can’t get het up about it 🤷‍♂️

Thesearmsofmine · 20/12/2018 09:04

I vividly remembering gettin my first make up for my 11th birthday 24 years ago! It’s not a new thing, playing with make up is fun, the same as dressing up as a younger child is.

Longtalljosie · 20/12/2018 09:03

It needs to come from your DD! Bugger your friend and her opinions. If your DD we’re pushing for it and all her friends wore it that would need to be considered (although even that wouldn’t be an automatic yes from me) but this just sounds like your friend’s stuff, frankly...

Dulra · 20/12/2018 09:01

My dd is 11 and when she has pals over they do enjoy putting makeup and nail polish on each other but none of them wear it out anywhere it is more a step on from dress up iykwim. Tbh I don't see any primary kids wearing makeup. Thankfully none of her friends have smart phones yet so selfie putting craze hasn't kicked in yet. I am in Ireland where they are in primary school until they are 12/13 so maybe once she starts secondary in 2 years time she will want to start wearing make up more.

Swipe left for the next trending thread