Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Makeup on an 11 year old.

161 replies

Makeupaddikt · 19/12/2018 23:24

I have an 11 year old daughter and I’ve nevr let her wear makeup as I personally think she is too young however, my friend has told me I’m unreasonable and all 11 year olds wear it although not to school????

So is it me BUmor my friend?

OP posts:
Trampire · 20/12/2018 12:16

Growling in make-up? - troweling on the make-up.

Trampire · 20/12/2018 12:15

Sumit I felt exactly the same about my dd when she was 11.

As I says earlier, I did feel quite smug that she was confident and different and didn't follow the crowd.

3 years on things a very different.

She's not growling in make-up or prancing about in crop tops, mini skirts or shorts that are cut to show her arse cheeks.....but she's naturally a bit more insecure and doubts herself sometimes. What teenager doesn't at times feel like that?

If wearing a bit of mascara makes her stand a bit taller then all power to her. Like other girls in this thread she still is very involved in school and hobbies and I tell her I'm proud of her achievements all the time. However, if she puts on something nice to go out and as added a bit of brown eye shadow I will often say she's looks nice. What parent wouldn't say that?

I have no idea why more girls are self harming these days. It is a worry. However, like a pp said - I used to experiment with make up and clothes in my early teens. As did all my other friends. We've all grown up to me happy, healthy women with successful careers.

SumitosIsMyWall · 20/12/2018 12:01

I think it’s laughably smug to post that your child isn’t bothered about makeup and not affected by peer pressure and finds those who like it are odd.

I'm not being remotely smug. My 11 year old is honestly baffled why people want to wear make up and finds the whole thing odd. She's not rude enough to call them odd but in conversations with me that clearly comes across as her sense of feeling. I'm sure that will change but right now as long as she can kick football in her break times and get ridiculously muddy in the process she is perfectly happy and immune to the peer pressure that seems to be rife in the rest of her friendship group.

We know that other children find her odd because she doesn't buy into the beautification of girls and that she'd rather play football with the boys. It bothers me that she gets teased for it some are rude enough to say this, but I'm proud that she isn't compromising on who she is just to fit in.

I'm happy that she's confident in what she wants. There's nothing smug or superior about that...unlike smug parents boasting how mature their child is.

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 20/12/2018 11:49

I may be being a bit dramatic, but to be honest I'm devastated that a whole generation of girls are harming themselves because of the society they live in.
I'm sure many people are quite happy to pass it off as not a big deal, especially if it's not their DD who is cutting up her arms, fine.
I'm going to call out what I think is one of the contributing factors, and that is young girls becoming overly dependent on other's validation of their looks.
But god forbid we should limit access to social media and teach them that changing their appearance to please others might not be the way to happiness.
We've created this situation, we should face up to it really.
I'm out.

Cath2907 · 20/12/2018 11:45

My DD is 8 years old and has a comprehensive selection of barbies, ponies, and dollies. She also has a makeup bag (pale eyeshadow, pale lip gloss and some perfume). She loves to do her face for special occasions and is well versed in "less is more!"

user838383 · 20/12/2018 11:44

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

knittedjest · 20/12/2018 11:42

I think it's a personal choice. Dd11(12 in a few days ) has a lot of makeup but she doesn't really use it outside competitions but because I and her sisters get sent a lot more than we need we all pass along what we don't use onto her. It's good quality stuff and I think quality is important for young skin. She just isn't that interested in it at the moment and that's okay. Dh wouldn't let her wear it every day anyway. He is very much in the let kids be kids camp and vetos clothing, hair and makeup while they are still under 16. Once they are 16 they can do as they please.

We do invest in expensive skincare for her however and have taught her to do it religiously. Good skin is the best gift you can give a child. With good skin they don't really need makeup.

Another controversial thing I do for my daughters is waxing from an early age. All of them did sports that required leotards, often high cut, and nobody likes pubic sideburns. Dd11 doesn't require it yet but she's my first brunette daughter since Dd33 , who wasn't overly hairy, but I'm like a gorilla if I don't maintain my upkeep so if Dd takes after me I would even look into laser hair removal for her which has been a huge time saver for me.

Tunnocks34 · 20/12/2018 11:38

Most year 7s I teach wear make up. The very least lipgloss and mascara.

Limensoda · 20/12/2018 11:37

I would discourage it and rather teach my daughter about being and looking healthy. It's sad seeing kids of 11 looking 16.

DragonMamma · 20/12/2018 11:31

Oh fgs, don’t be so dramatic. It’s about balance, like all things.

Yes, if you judge a child solely on how they look then no doubt they will end up with issues. However, praising somebody’s intelligence, emotional qualities and looks are part of a balanced picture.

I tell my daughter she’s beautiful whether she’s dressed up, in make up, or not. I also tell her how clever she is, how wonderfully she sings, how kind she is.

Do you think avoid anything linked to appearances is the answer? Are people who don’t wear make up are, be default, happier than those that do?

Do you never buy your DDs a nice dress or top for them to wear? If so, why? Is that not placing importance on how they look? Shall we all wear burlap sacks and avoid appearances altogether?

I think those that are of the ilk that make up and decent clothes have sexual motives are the ones with the issues. I wear nice clothes and make up, for me. Nobody else. My daughter is taught to do what makes her happy and confident.

paxillin · 20/12/2018 11:29

Is this a just-11-year old in primary school or an almost-12-year old in secondary, @Makeupaddikt? I think this makes a difference regarding "all 11 year olds wear it". It isn't all in secondary, either, but much more common than in year 6.

SirVixofVixHall · 20/12/2018 11:24

I have an 11 year old and although she has makeup because she likes to play around with it, she is not allowed to wear it other than that. No makeup to school, no makeup generally, although i suppose i might allow something age appropriate eg. A bit of general sparkle, for a party.
I also have an older dd , just 14. She isn't allowed makeup for school, although i do allow her to use spot cover. Outside school she sometimes wears mascara and lipstick, plays about with eyeshadow etc, but doesn’t wear makeup every day.
I went to a school where all makeup was banned and the ban was strictly enforced. We probably could have got away with subtle concealer on a spot but nothing else. In contrast my dds school also has a no makeup policy but some of the girls have the whole works, foundation, eyebrow stuff, contour, highlighter etc etc from about year nine, and it looks frankly bizarre with school uniform.

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 20/12/2018 11:20

So Maldives2006 what is it making a quarter of our girls so unhappy that they are self-harming, and why are they naming body image, appearance and gender stereotyping as one of the causes?
Make-up is part and parcel of that.

Maldives2006 · 20/12/2018 11:16

Exactly🙌🏻🙌🏻

Maldives2006 · 20/12/2018 11:15

My daughter messing about with a little make up is not contributing to unhappiness

Maldives2006 · 20/12/2018 11:14

Why is it a bad message?

Maldives2006 · 20/12/2018 11:13

What so girls who are interested in make up are not focusing on learning or developing their ambitions. Don’t be so utterly ridiculous and insulting. This is why we have the worlds unhappiest kids

Confusedbeetle · 20/12/2018 11:09

Its a terrible idea. I hate to see makup on a child. I dont care what the current trend is, its a bad message

Screaminginsidemeagain · 20/12/2018 11:07

My DD is 12 now the other year all she wanted was a sparkle ‘case’ of makeup from Claire’s. I was really anti, we sort of compromised and her cool young Antie brought it for her. She played with it a bit, wore some lip gloss and forgot about it.
She’s asked for makeup this year so I’ve got her some lipstick(nude) and a couple of otther bits.
None of the ladies in our family wear it daily, special occasions only mainly and therefore I’m hoping it won’t be a big thing for her.
A little bit won’t hurt and if you’ve given her self confidence then it Shouldn’t be a big issue

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 20/12/2018 11:02

The Children's Society report says that gender stereotypes and worries about looks were contributing to unhappiness, but sure let's all go on thinking that make-up for young girls is harmless Hmm

www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-45329030

GobblersKnob · 20/12/2018 10:54

Bold fail. Sorry.

GobblersKnob · 20/12/2018 10:53

*My dd is 11 in a few weeks and there’s no way in hell she’d get near make up.

She’s still into mlp and fairies and long May it stay that way.

Seriously? I don’t know any 11 year old who still plays/played with ponies and fairies at that age. That’s year 6/7! and you want it to continue into year 8/9/10? confused.*

My dd is 11 in a few weeks, her Xmas list consisted almost entirely of Playmobil with a smattering of Lego Elves.

She sometimes wears make up, loves nail varnish. She has no desire to shave.

She generally dresses in what might be considered 'non girl' clothes. Though yanno, she's a girl and wearing them, so they are.

She is obsessed with Harry Potter. She has never played with dolls.

She is an individual, all our daughters are. Why do we need to judge? Wanting to wear make up at 11 is normal, wanting to play with toys at 11 is normal. Let's not put each other's perceived parenting, and therefore each other down through our daughters behaviour eh?

KC225 · 20/12/2018 10:40

VIOLET Seriously? What a smug post. I posted earlier about my 11 and half year asking for make up for Christmas. I can assure you she is not interested in boys and Is not doing it for make.attention. My DD is top of her class, bilingual and is in a rowing club and plays football. Lip gloss does NOT sexualise an 11 year old. And I think that statement says more about your attitude than a girl experimenting. Both of my children (her twin brother) have shown an interest in learning to cook. I have bought them cookbooks and aprons and have encouraged that (more so) too

Make up seems to be one of those 'divisive' topics. I think the OP has made a good decision, her DD has shown no interest and she was just gathering opinions, so there is no need to be buying make up. I wouldn't have bought the lip gloss/eye-shadow and mascara combo had my DD not expressed an interest. There is no right or wrong our DDs are all individuals.

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 20/12/2018 10:32

I think girls wearing makeup is a symptom of them becoming more worried/insecure about the way they look, and susceptible to peer pressure.
That well-publicised study this year showed nearly 1 in 4 girls in the UK aged 14 had self-harmed this year.
That's one quarter of our daughters.
We're all aware of the pressures of social media, body image, sexual harrassment, peer pressure and so on, but seem reluctant to actually try and tackle any of the issues!
So when it comes to reducing internet use, taking away phones, encouraging healthy eating & exercise, or directing our daughters' focus away from the way they look, to how happy & fulfilled they are, we as parents seem very reluctant to do anything about it.
IMO a focus on make-up and looks is a massive contributor to body image concerns and self-esteem issues.
We need to do something about our young girls. Just giving in won't help. If my DD9 starts asking for makeup any time soon, I won't be allowing it.
I know that seems a bit extreme but we need to change something about the life experiences of girls and young women at the moment, don't we?
ONE QUARTER of 14 year olds self-harming?! Scary, and we are not doing anything to change what we all know is harmful.

Trampire · 20/12/2018 10:22

Nothing = parenting.