Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Makeup on an 11 year old.

161 replies

Makeupaddikt · 19/12/2018 23:24

I have an 11 year old daughter and I’ve nevr let her wear makeup as I personally think she is too young however, my friend has told me I’m unreasonable and all 11 year olds wear it although not to school????

So is it me BUmor my friend?

OP posts:
DragonMamma · 20/12/2018 15:06

Thanks Trampire and MsTSwift Smile

I don’t think you’re taking it too seriously Ihaventgottimeforthis Smile. We all love our DC, fear for them and want the best for them. Today’s world is a far scarier place than ours ever was.

But I think the danger with fear (!) is that it often makes you reject all ideas of the problem, as you see it which I think is equally as unhelpful.

I believe that being a parent isn’t about being prescriptive or telling our kids what’s right and wrong, good and bad, but giving them the tools to figure it out for themselves and dealing with things that go wrong.

All I hope is that my dc are strong and resilient enough to get through this scary life they live in and hopefully enjoy the experience along the way.

MsTSwift · 20/12/2018 14:50

Agree with dragon mamma too. My dd and her friends are really really into poetry - good poetry too so lots of poetry books on the Christmas list alongside a new sports bag and .. some eyeshadow Grin

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 20/12/2018 14:50

(She IS 9, she's nearly 10. Doh)

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 20/12/2018 14:49

DragonMamma I appreciate the world is very different now, and it does sound like you are doing all you can. My concern is that for the wider generation, it's not working. Our girls are suffering and are hurting themselves, and that is going to ripple through their lives as it impacts their mental health.
And I wonder if we need to be having more drastic conversations, before things get any worse. Not just with our own daughters, but as a whole society.
I know I've jumped this thread from 'my young DD would like some make-up for fun' to me going 'ahh but they're all going to have mental health crises and self-harm if we let them worry about their appearance' but my DD is nearly 9 and I'm worrying about how to guide her and her friends safely into being confident and happy young women. I just don't think people take this seriously!

I appreciate most people think I am taking this too seriously

Trampire · 20/12/2018 14:42

Dragonmamma, I think you have an excellent approach to raising your dd. I (hope) I do similar.

Didiplanthis · 20/12/2018 14:41

My dd 9 has some sparkly nail varnish, lip gloss and glitter gel. She plays with it with her friends when they are round and may wear sparkly nail polish to parties. She never wears it out as 'make up'. She still loves barbies, sylvanians, playmobile and plays baby dolls with her brothers. I think everything is relative. She is a sensible but young 9 year old as are her friends.

FuzzyShadowChatter · 20/12/2018 14:39

Makeupaddikt I think your friend is being ridiculous to say you're unreasonable and that all 11-year-old girls wear it - there are plenty of 11-year-olds who enjoy makeup for themselves, plenty who use it for play and plenty who've barely given it a thought. I think it would be very unreasonable and thoughtless to give any 11-year-old girl makeup purely on the basis she is an 11-year-old girl rather than because she's interested in it or requested some.

My 11-year-old Y7 daughter's wishlist is a real mix - on one hand, there are the clothes, art supplies and new sketchbooks, headphones and on the other, she also wants doll clothes and accessories to go with her dolls. She and her siblings have a lot of nail polish and she paints her toenails a lot (and fingernails when she's not going to be at cadets for a while) and likes to paint her younger siblings nails and playing with make-up with her friends - but I've never seen her use any of the make-up - blush, lip liner, lipstick - her friends have given her except when they're all using it together.

I asked her, and it seems to her to be a fun thing to do with friends rather than to be pretty at this point for her. I do think she's starting to feel pressure from her friends from the comments she's made about it and from adults to look a certain way - even at a recent funeral, pretty much all the comments towards her were about how nice she looked which was a bit confusing for both of us. It's interesting, but sad now that I think on it - my older son got asked a lot about what he's doing academically, but I didn't hear anyone ask her about it.

Honestly, I'm not sure how to handle make-up. My mother put a lot on me when I was young and as an adult, I haven't worn any except chapstick when I have a cold. I don't really understand it in a way that is of any use. So far, it's mainly been that they can do what they want with their friends and keep what their friends give them, but I haven't bought anything beyond nail polish and chapstick and they haven't asked to buy any themselves. I'm sure there are pros and cons to any way of doing it, but I don't really see benefits to giving a girl makeup just because she's a girl who has reached a certain age.

SenoraSurf · 20/12/2018 14:27

I am a secondary teacher in the south of England and 75% of year 7 (11 year olds) at my school wear makeup.

DragonMamma · 20/12/2018 14:25

Of course I’m not naive enough to think there isn’t a problem with young women today and the over emphasis on looks but I think some people are trying to go too far the other way, and try to ignore looks altogether.

We need to be raising confident, ambitious women with a strong sense of self worth so that they aren’t obsessed with Instafame or becoming the next famous YouTube star. That’s a multi faceted approach and I think it starts with leading by example and promoting positive role models both at home and in the press.

DD admires some positive female role models so I’m happy she’s on the right track.

DragonMamma · 20/12/2018 14:17

I think MsTSwift has summed up my thinking on this @Ihaventgottimeforthis. The world we currently live in is far different to the one I and probably you grew up in.

Placing blanket bans on make up and social media until college, whilst possible, is probably not going to do your kids any favours in the long term.

With my DD, I am actively trying to instil confidence in all aspects of her life. Her education, her social life, her extra curricular achievements and yes, her looks. It’s simply unrealistic in today’s society to bury your head in the sand over this. Whether that’s wrong or right is a complete separate thread. It’s the reality of the world we currently live in.

My DD is being taught that she can express herself how she wants (within reasons for her age) - I want her to feel confident in how she looks, why wouldn’t I? Why would I pretend that looks aren’t a factor in how people are perceived in society?

She’s being taught that as long as she’s happy within herself, then that’s all the matters to me. If she wants to wear football strips and boots every day or dress up as Snow White, I couldn’t give a fig. Equally, if she wanted to give up the piano and start the drums, that would be Ok with me to.

People are not one dimensional; to place emphasis on any one part of an individuals merits (be it looks, sports or education) would be detrimental to anybody. I’m simply guiding her in how to be happy and confident with all aspects of herself, and that does include how she looks.

As I said, I wear make up most days. I probably didn’t start until I was 16/17 but I was certainly allowed to use things before then. I also don’t labour under the social conditioning that I have to wear make up every day to be attractive to men. I can and do go without it, if I choose to. As do my friends. We are all regularly seen at the school gates with not a scrap on and nobody bats an eyelid. If my daughter adopts the same approach as I have then I won’t be unhappy at all as I think it’s a common, healthy approach (certainly amongst my peers).

YouBelongHere · 20/12/2018 14:17

I started wearing make-up at 11 but only occasionally and definitely not to school. I experimented with a bit through ages 12 - 14 but then found out I wasn't really fussed and now I don't bother with it. I think a little bit at 11 is okay but wouldn't expect them to go out with a full face on.

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 20/12/2018 14:15

MsTSwift I don't have an answer, I can clearly see how it's difficult, but surely we need to be thinking about what we can change, and how?
It's lovely to hear everyone on this thread has a daughter who isn't affected by self-esteem, who only uses make-up in a healthy, balanced, fun way and really doesn't feel pressured to look a certain way, or to have a certain appearance, or that they feel unhappy about their appearance. That's really nice.
But the evidence shows us that girls in general are really struggling in their teenage years with happiness and self-esteem. Yes, social media and cyber bullying and gender stereotyping and over-focus on body image is to blame, and I see make-up all tied up in that.
So even though we all have DD's who are happy, balanced individuals who don't need make-up and feel great without it, surely we need to be thinking about how young women engage with the world, and changing the conversation?
An interesting story here: www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/stories-46610403/my-filler-was-botched-but-now-i-love-my-natural-lips

Maybe I am being dramatic and uptight, but I feel dreadful for the girls who end up struggling with confidence and image to the extent they inject their faces with chemicals.

loubluee · 20/12/2018 13:37

My ds14 made an interesting point a few weeks ago, I asked did the girls wear much make up to school? He said ‘much make up? They all wear that much and watch the same YouTube channels, that their make up is the same and they all morph into each other, we can only tell them apart by their hair!’ So I take that as a yes the girls now wear a lot!

I have to be honest I’ve always worn make up daily since a teen, but I see teenagers walking down the street with make up on now and some of them make me go
Wow, they look like they’ve walked off a cover shoot. I’m jealous by how good it looks.

But I’m saying this as a parent of boys, I did judge some of the parents of year 6/7 girls when I seen them plastered in make up. Firstly it’s not good for their skin, but secondly let them be a pre teen, without developing that worry of not wanting to go out without it on. I think a bit of lip gloss and mascara, and for those who have developed early maybe a light foundation and concealer to cover any spots. They don’t need winged eyeliner, smokey eye, and Kylie Jenner lips.

I honestly don’t envy you ladies and gentlemen with daughters these days. There is so much pressure on them to have the right ‘look’, and what do you do as a parent? Stand by your values and upset your daughter? Or give in? Hats off to you!

hobnobsaremyfavourite · 20/12/2018 13:32

This really is an
“Only on mumsnet”
Kind of thread
Meanwhile in the real world.....

explodingkitten · 20/12/2018 13:21

I used to love to wear nail polish and bright pink lipstick as a 6 year old in the 80's (and in the 80's bright pink really was bright pink). I wasn't allowed to wear it outside or to school. It was more a play thing. So I'm not sure if it is a "nowadays" thing that all the girls now do. I wouldn't let an 11 yo wear it to school but maybe at home once in a while for fun?

VI0LET · 20/12/2018 13:20

Dragon mamma - teen beauty culture isn’t about” a bit of Rimmel Heather Shimmer on special occasions “. Hmm

Booboostwo · 20/12/2018 13:16

It’s perfectly possible for girls and women to wear make up because they want to and not because they are conforming to a sexualised image to please men. Girls and women should be free to style themselves any way they like without judgement. While cultural stereotypes currently promote beauty and a particular perception of femininity in women, suggesting that no one can adopt these styles even if they freely choose to is equally problematic.

MsTSwift · 20/12/2018 13:14

Yes but we know our own daughters and can see self harming and fear of going out without make up is a different league to playing with make up at home.

What is your solution then? An absolute ban on all make up and social media until your child is 16? Good luck with that as my dd would say. We live in our society and our kids live in it too we have to help them navigate it and grow up to be strong and confident women. I don’t think hand wringing and banning things is the solution. Encouraging self belief, strong friendships with peers open dialogue with parents and promoting sport music anything they enjoy etc is stuff we as parents can do.

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 20/12/2018 13:01

DragonMamma perhaps you can share your secret then with all the girls who are struggling nowadays.
If you think that make-up has nothing to do with girls self-esteem, or worrying about how they look, or a need to 'fit in' and get approval from their peers, then we do have very different views on it!
It is the difficulty in finding the right balance that is the problem.

If you're of the heather shimmer era, then you didn't have social media to contend with. And I bet one in four of your friends weren't self-harming because of lack of self-esteem. But many women of our age are still labouring under the illusion that they have to wear make-up before they leave the house so they don't scare the children, still suffering with crippling body image, because female conditioning that we should worry about how we look, starts at primary school, and never ends.

MsTSwift · 20/12/2018 13:00

There is some extreme thinking and catastrophising on this thread that’s for sure. 12 year olds messing about with eye shadow is not a gateway to a life of Botox, sexualisation, and a future as a non sport playing sex doll. I remember doing similar at that age as did everyone else!

knittedjest · 20/12/2018 12:48

VI0LET

Why does it have to be for men? My DIL is the most feminine woman I have ever met. She is always done up with flawless makeup, not a hair out of place in her perfect blow wave, skin as soft and pale as if she's never seen a UV ray in her life. Wears flowing dresses and expensive heels and is just generally a real life porcelain doll. And she's a huge raging lesbian. Never been interested in a single man her entire life. Likewise my dd, her wife, is currently all about being as sexy as humanly possible. She is 6ft tall and has a perfect body and beautiful face and she likes to show it off as much as she can. Again, not interested in men in any way. In fact she wanted to be a man until she was 16/17. It's got nothing to do with men, it's just how different people express themselves. In my opinion women don't dress for the approval of men, they dress for the approval (and tbh envy) of other women.

DragonMamma · 20/12/2018 12:40

bangs head against wall

@vi0let where are you getting that wearing make up is sexualising themselves and making them more attract to men? Why can’t it be for themselves and a fun activity with their friends?

Why can you be all of the things you have listed, whilst wearing make up on a special occasion, if that makes them happy?

Surely you must be able to see that growing up is all of those things, but if a youngster wants to experiment with make up AS WELL then there’s simply nothing wrong with that.

Are you going to be disappointed if/when your DD wants to try a bit of make up?

When I was growing up in the late 80s/90s being a teenager was about hanging around with your mates, reading magazines, hanging around Superdrug and Boots and buying some CDs singles in Woolies. None of my peers, or me, have gone on to have any issues.

We’ve all gone on to have great careers, as accountants, actuaries, doctors etc. A bit of Rimmel Heather Shimmer didn’t stop us achieving what we wanted to!

Trampire · 20/12/2018 12:35

I can assure you my dd is getting a great education and at the grand old age if 14 isn't interested in snogging boys!

VI0LET · 20/12/2018 12:27

Excellent and thought provoking posts @ihaventgottimeforthis.

I think it’s pretty sad that “ growing up” is now about little girls looking sexy for men. Not getting an education, taking responsibility for yourself, doing your share of household chores, caring for those you love, choosing good friends or earning money. All these things that used to be what a teenager was about.

Why have we taught our girls that this is what a woman is - a decorative object for the male gaze ? No wonder they are self harming as so may fail to meet up to the standards of Vloggers.

Posthistoricmonsters · 20/12/2018 12:25

My DC7 has been desperate to wear make up since she was 4. My DC11 has just started secondary and has only shown vague interest in lip gloss because she wants to be liked. DC7 and DC11 are both immature for their ages, but are polar opposites. Youngest wants to doll up, eldest wants to play football. DC7 gets a little nail varnish in holidays and occasional eye shadow and lipstick if we have dressed up for an occasion. But that's it. She can experiment at home but under supervision and it comes off before we go out.