Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the BBC will change or go under?

282 replies

Snowballs4ever · 16/12/2018 17:16

I don't know many people who watch the BBC, most people I know don't have a license and just have netflix, Amazon, now tv etc

I know it has some popular programmes, but I can't see how it will survive longer term when netflix etc are cheaper and imo have much better programmes. Am I in a bubble or aibu to think it will have to have to have adverts/change longer term?

OP posts:
KissingInTheRain · 16/12/2018 20:23

Segmentation

Are you suggesting that Netflix is as varied as TV? Really? Everything on it, more or less, is drama. I’m looking at it now - other than docs and stand-up there’s nothing else!

I’m not saying Netflix is useless, but on no account is it varied.

As for non-BBC news, sure. But none is as good and you have to pay much more for it. (Free stuff online will go.)

DianaT1969 · 16/12/2018 20:21

How do people do without TV news?
Online and newspapers?
We can scan a news site online (Guardian for example) in minutes. No need to sit through a 30 min broadcast waiting for news topics that interest you. People are less passive these days, they search for information when they want it. I can check the news at 8.30, 3.10pm or 7.35pm. I don't have to wait until 9pm. Granted that BBC has 24 hour news channels, but if I want to know the aftermath of the Chester Zoo fire, I look online.

MongerTruffle · 16/12/2018 20:19

The idea that the BBC needs the TV licence to produce quality content is absurd. The UK has another public service broadcaster: Channel 4. It manages fine with advertising.

Cubrrt · 16/12/2018 20:19

I'd happily pay tax towards the bbc, I like having a state-broadcaster with relatively balanced, non-sensationalist news.

I'm just not interested in their tv content or watching live tv.

LaurieFairyCake · 16/12/2018 20:18

I watch masses of BBC/Netflix/prime - happy to pay for all of them

But have not watched ANYTHING live in at least the last 3 years

I even watched the Queens Christmas broadcast later than live

Cubrrt · 16/12/2018 20:17

"But what you get on TV - for which you need a licence - is on the whole much better and more varied than what you get on Netflix."
Entirely subjective.

For a while, I used streaming services and paid my tv license. Then I realized I was watching live tv (or iplayer) less than once per month because I preferred the contents on Netflix and Amazon. I cancelled my tv license and stopped watching any live tv. Don't have an aerial or anything in my current place.

theatrelady · 16/12/2018 20:17

I don't watch the BBC because I object to the licence fee and how they collect it.

However, if they offered a season pass or similar to stream some of their better shows, I'd consider paying for that. I agree that their model needs to change.

LunaLovegoodsRadishes · 16/12/2018 20:15

My interaction with the BBC is minimal. The last thing I watched on the BBC was Mrs Wilson, and that was on iplayer. I don't like their radio or much of their programming tbh. I get my news from Sky.

We have Sky TV but thinking about going to Now TV cos it's a lot cheaper, and I resent paying for all the hundreds of channels of cack we don't ever watch.

We gave Amazon Prime for Outlander, Mrs Maisel and Preacher, and Netflix for the bulk of our telly watching. When on nights, I download stuff to watch at work.

I think streaming is the way TV is going. It's on demand, it's portable and there are no ads on BBC, Netflix and Amazon. I don't think the BBC will ever go under, but I do hope the licence fee will change to a subscription, so that viewers can choose if they want it or not. I also think that for what you get, the licence fee is not good value, and needs to be reduced to compete with other companies.

HamiltonCork · 16/12/2018 20:15

I still watch live TV but a heck of a lot less than I used to.
I love BBC4. But tbh I think the quality of programmes from the BBC has declined massively in the past 10 yrs. Things like the One Show, for example, are utter crap. I would pay not to watch it.

KissingInTheRain · 16/12/2018 20:14

We’re both trying to guess the future so I accept that anticipating the next 10 or 20 years will be largely opinion.

But would you pay £15, or £25 or £40 every month for a limited on-demand library service? No live coverage of events, no live news, relatively little that hasn’t been seen somewhere else first?

I genuinely don’t see on-demand being any more than supplemental.

SegmentationFault · 16/12/2018 20:14

"But what you get on TV - for which you need a licence - is on the whole much better and more varied than what you get on Netflix."

That's completely subjective. Like I said I, and many other people, prefer the content on other services. And it's not just US dramas. In fact there are some old BBC shows on Netflix that AFAIK you can't get on iPlayer. Are there many films being shown on TV these days outside of Sky Movies?

As for news: the internet, radio, newspapers, podcasts. Do you really think people can't stay informed without watching BBC news?

nocluenoidea · 16/12/2018 20:13

A lot of the shows on Netflix were made by the BBC?

Badbadbunny · 16/12/2018 20:12

This thread has made me realise just how little live terrestial TV we actually watch. Really struggling to think of anything on BBC or live that we've watched this weekend. I'll have to have a proper think about whether we could do without BBC/live and stop paying for the licence.

Cubrrt · 16/12/2018 20:11

I read the news and sometimes watch clips on YouTube.

I did watch CNN live during the last US election but they did a free live stream for that.

Can't find UK stats instantly but more than 60% of households in the US now subscribe to streaming services and 15% of households use only streaming services and no live tv. It'll continue to grow.

Separately, almost all of my favourite shows from the past few years are Netflix originals.

AutoFilled · 16/12/2018 20:06

I don’t watch the news on tv. Who does? It’s all online surely?

KissingInTheRain · 16/12/2018 20:05

SegmentationFault

Yes, of course. But what you get on TV - for which you need a licence - is on the whole much better and more varied than what you get on Netflix. If someone doesn’t like the BBC itself that’s another argument. Personally I think its TV, radio and web content is way better than anyone-else’s, taken in the round.

There are things like US drama that Netflix is better for. But I prefer US movies to US TV dramas and Netflix is rubbish for those.

How do people do without TV news?

AutoFilled · 16/12/2018 20:04

Depends on your social circle. I don’t have a tv license and so don’t watch the iplayer. I don’t have a TV aeriel in this house. The previous owners didn’t and we didn’t change that. We watch all streaming anyway. So I’m in your demographic of having Netflix, amazon prime and now TV movies. I won’t pay £150 just to watch strictly come dancing and whatever is on bbc. Netflix is much better value. Amazon prime we already got. And I quite like movies so we got now tv. More things to watch then I have time.

Cubrrt · 16/12/2018 20:02

Netflix is great to sit down and watch something. What if you've just got a spare 20 minutes? That's when I watch live TV.
That's when I watch YouTube.

Cubrrt · 16/12/2018 20:02

KissingInTheRain

I messed up my post. I see the current trend continuing. People will continue to watch on demand more and live tv less. On demand services will likely change their subscription prices and may introduce ads.

As I said previously, I haven't watched live tv in years (save for when visiting older relatives) and known many people in my age group that are the same.

Live services will always exist for things like sport and the news, but I can't imagine going back to watching dramas, comedies or whatever on a schedule. Old-fashioned and inconvenient. I'd happily pay considerably more than I already do for Netflix.

The trend isn't going to change. Live tv will become increasingly marginal, as it already is for a generation:

trilbydoll · 16/12/2018 20:00

Cbeebies alone is worth the license fee while dc are small. We haven't graduated to cbbc yet so I can't comment on that!

Netflix is great to sit down and watch something. What if you've just got a spare 20 minutes? That's when I watch live TV.

KissingInTheRain · 16/12/2018 19:53

but the chances of the trend turning away from live tv and to on-demand services is about as likely as everyone going back to watching black and white tv.

I couldn’t agree more. That’s my point. On-demand, like Netflix and the like, are inevitably limited. The economics aren’t on their side.

Snowballs4ever · 16/12/2018 19:53

I agree with pp that it seems like younger people are most likely to have binned terrestrial channels in favour of the likes of netflix. I'm youngish and I don't know many people who watch BBC etc but most seem to love netflix, narcos, breaking bad etc. All choosing to pay for a service with no ads but not subscribing to the BBC.

OP posts:
Cubrrt · 16/12/2018 19:52

I won't watch youtube if I can help it. They stick an advert in the middle of a video cutting off peoples sentences. At least on ITV et al the ad breaks make sense and don't just cut someone off mid sentence
Fair point, but the thing you have to remember is

CatLadyToddlerMother · 16/12/2018 19:49

I won't watch youtube if I can help it. They stick an advert in the middle of a video cutting off peoples sentences. At least on ITV et al the ad breaks make sense and don't just cut someone off mid sentence

SegmentationFault · 16/12/2018 19:47

@KissingInTheRain

If you watch a lot of BBC content it might be worth the money to you, but a lot of people prefer what's on Netflix/Amazon/Now TV. People like different things.