Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the BBC will change or go under?

282 replies

Snowballs4ever · 16/12/2018 17:16

I don't know many people who watch the BBC, most people I know don't have a license and just have netflix, Amazon, now tv etc

I know it has some popular programmes, but I can't see how it will survive longer term when netflix etc are cheaper and imo have much better programmes. Am I in a bubble or aibu to think it will have to have to have adverts/change longer term?

OP posts:
Kazzyhoward · 17/12/2018 08:32

The BBC won't "go under" whilst it's paid for by the taxpayer.

The real question is for how long can it survive based on an unpopular tax? Sooner or later, there'll be pressure for it to stand on it's own two feet and raise it's own funding.

LoniceraJaponica · 17/12/2018 08:25

I am irritated by the fact that more and more online news is video footage. I want to read the news, especially if I am out and about and don't want to use up loads of battery juice and data.

I can't comment on the quality of the BBC news. I am not in the least bit interested in politics, so any political bias/references go over the top of my head. The only news I watch is the 6 o'clock news and Look North while I am cooking the evening meal. Oh and occasionally the 10 o'clock news.

SummerGems · 17/12/2018 08:24

While a lot of people don’t watch live tv any more, a lot of people do still:

Use iPlayer (for which you now need a tv licence) listen to bbc radio 1/2/4, use the bbc news apps, use the bbc website.

It’s fine to say that live viewing is on the decrease, however without a tv licence there would be no radio or website either and those figures are not on the decrease. So while people may not pay their licence for the live viewing, if there was no licence people would miss the radio stations/iPlayer/the website.

I’ve personally never watched anything on Netflix and don’t have amazon prime.

Kazzyhoward · 17/12/2018 08:19

I agree re the online bbc news. Very poor.

BBC breakfast news is also very poor, especially so-called business/financial reporting.

KissingInTheRain · 17/12/2018 08:10

News wise Russia Today is way superior to BBC news too.

Confused
OllyBJolly · 17/12/2018 08:09

I'd pay £150 a year for The Archers alone

Me too. And for much of Radio 4.

I love the idea of the BBC and it is still one of the best training grounds for journalists - proper journalists. As a programme provider and content editor, it's gone way off piste in recent years, particularly in news reporting and political comment. It's headed down the shouty, sound bite road rather than the cool, impartial analysis that it should be doing.

I'd hope that good leadership would get it back on track. It's too dangerous to have all our media ownership concentrated in too few hands.

Bittermints · 17/12/2018 08:03

The BBC is far from perfect but if it disappeared or had to cut its services right back we'd lose something unique and valuable. One example: the BBC is one of the few organisations left now which has foreign correspondents, trained journalists held to a high standard, all around the world reporting back to us. We need good journalism and freedom of speech. It's massively important to the health of our democracy that politicians are held to account.

Of course, the journalists and broadcasters also need to be held to account. The model we have now in the UK is far from perfect, but we do have public oversight of terrestrial broadcasters. Who regulates Youtube, Amazon and Netflix? Nobody. That worries me.

Thespace · 17/12/2018 07:56

I agree re the online bbc news. Very poor.

Dongdingdong · 17/12/2018 07:48

I get my news and information from many sources but rarely from the BBC. I find their online news page to be low quality. They often have the same articles up for days.

Agree with this!

Bowchicawowow · 17/12/2018 07:11

The BBC isn’t perfect but it’s still the best broadcaster in the world. The content it produces is world class. It sold the Strictly format worldwide, they have also sold Top Gear to lots of different territories. They produce the best wildlife documentaries in the world. Their radio is listened to my millions of people every day. They produce wonderful comedy (This County is currently my favourite) including things like The Office which the Americans copied. Whether you agree with this or not BBC news is trusted worldwide, in particular the World Service. Netflix is great but I wouldn’t want my viewing to be restricted to what they broadcast.

Charley50 · 17/12/2018 07:01

@KissingInTheRain - I had to look up profligate Blush There should be a breakdown of the costs published, when they're that huge.

Graphista · 17/12/2018 02:41

You're in a bubble.

I've just watched point break on BBC 1, now watching question time repeat as I missed it thu due to dd having a teen crisis.

Strictly isn't a programme I watch but is hugely popular. Drs & eastenders too - several threads on here too.

As example:

Tomorrow bbc1 Mary Berrys Christmas will likely get good ratings, would I lie to you another popular show, Tuesday die hard with a vengeance is on, Thursday toy story 2, Friday toy story 3 and celeb mastermind.

Tomorrow bbc2 only connect, uni challenge (both shows I love), and inside the factory (hit & miss but ok, Tuesday another only connect, popular cookery shows, QI, Thursday live at the Apollo, Friday nativity 2 and mastermind.

Throughout the last year there's been excellent dramas, documentaries, consumer programmes...

And the licence also pays for the news site, radio - national & local... And (little known fact) public interest programming on other channels.

I think it's doing just fine.

"Brexit coverage and full-on Tory bias" agree - but know thine enemy 😉

BUT in this day and age with the tech that's available and most people having tv's/watching devices that could do this - it could be sort of "password protected" and the password be the licence number. If you've no licence you can't watch - it's blocked. Absolutely no reason why this couldn't be done. Just as we have to sign in with account details to Netflix & similar.

Would prevent those from watching fraudulently doing so, but also remove the need for bullish doorsteppers.

Iplayer has boxsets, highly popular films (usually for a limited time), archived programmes...

That Forbes article on Netflix is interesting. Personally I think a huge untapped area for them could well be showing beloved older programmes no longer available elsewhere, nostalgia is a huge seller.

I'd love if they added things like cheers, golden girls, quantum leap, wonder years, Cagney & Lacey, moonlighting, happy days... Stuff like that and talking to friends in real life they too would love this!

For my mums generation they'd love tv shows from their era, there's a few old movies on there and that's very popular with the people I know.

It may be a "new" way of watching tv but - thanks in part - to its ease of use and lack of adverts it's very popular with those of us 40's and older but the content is trying to be too new, too "fresh" and aimed at youngsters - when they're rarely the ones deciding whether to have it in the household or not and certainly rarely are the ones paying for it!

Also knowing dd she'd love the old 80's shows, her and her friends have ended up discovering things like only fools, original house of cards, friends, charmed (I think a huge mistake losing this), Gilmore girls, party of five... And thoroughly enjoying them.

IdaBWells · 17/12/2018 01:22

I am 50 and hardly watch any TV, I haven’t been a great TV watcher since my early 20s really. Just too many other interesting things to do. I do spend plenty of time on line reading. I watch documentaries on YouTube too. I have three teenagers and they don’t watch live tv either. They love watching Friends and Grey’s Anatomy but binge watch.

TheWiseWomansFear · 17/12/2018 01:06

Oh and I'm early 20s, we do watch live TV Hmm

TheWiseWomansFear · 17/12/2018 00:58

I generally flick between Netflix and BBC iPlayer.... most people I know watch quite a bit of BBC so I find it odd that on MN there's a consensus that nobody does...

GreenDinosaur · 17/12/2018 00:58

It's worth it for the radio for me, I love Radio 4, 4 Extra and the children's radio shows are great too. My DS loves Listen and Play, Playtime etc.

Some of the tv shows are good, the wildlife documentaries are generally excellent. I enjoyed Mrs Wilson recently and thought it well done.

I'm pretty skint and don't have Sky or anything but I'm happy to pay the license fee for the BBC as I do use the radio app every single day and I worry the quality would reduce or disappear as a result of cuts or abolition of the fee.

TheRealJoseph · 17/12/2018 00:47

OP so you would to watch the BBC with ads then?

Imagine...next year, the Beeb decides to scrap the licence fee & allows ads.

The following is roughly what I watched on TV in Canada about 20 years ago.

Announcer:- "On next is program X"
Ads
Opening scenes
Ads
Opening titles
Ads
program
ads
(continue with ads & program, then 2 mins before conclusion of program)
ads
conclusion
ads
end credits
ads.

Is that what you want? Because without a licence that's what you'll have.

Btw. has the OP flounced or what?

Anticlockwatcher · 17/12/2018 00:39

And I'd pay NOT to watch homes under the hammer and it's buy to let parasite fawning.

Anticlockwatcher · 17/12/2018 00:36

News wise Russia Today is way superior to BBC news too.

Anticlockwatcher · 17/12/2018 00:34

I only watch sports live, that's it. And those sports (motorsports) aren't on the BBC - I've got to pay out for Sky (F1) and BT sport (MotoGP) for those. I 100% think the license fee should be optional, because as it stands in my case it's not great value for money.

The only BBC show I watch is Only Connect - Victoria Coren is great but £150 per year 37 1/2 hour episodes is a bit pricey!

mummymermaid · 17/12/2018 00:18

I don't understand the argument here though? I don't pay TV licence as I don't watch live TV but it's not limited to Netflix what I can watch. I'm still allowed to watch catch up TV (apart from iPlayer) so if I wanted I could still watch all the TV shows just not live. So the only shows I'm missing out on are the ones on BBC. So what am I missing out on? When I still had the TV aerial and all the channels in the past I never watched BBC anyway, hardly ever itv, channel 4 or 5 either. I mainly used to watch sky channels. If I wanted to still watch those I could swap Netflix to Now TV. So what am I missing here?

Pepper123123 · 17/12/2018 00:03

I happily miss out on some BBC programs in order to legally not need a TV licence.
There is absolutely no way I will pay a single penny towards it for numerous reasons.

Catch up services (BBC not included), Netflix etc are more than enough for us.

KissingInTheRain · 17/12/2018 00:00

No-one has new (first post-cinema) films unless you rent or buy them. Less new films become available on pay tv and on subscription services like Netflix, though Netflix’s film library is poor. Then on free tv.

What point are you making? That people can choose to buy movies? If so, sure, they can. They can read books as well. That would be cheaper.

halcyondays · 16/12/2018 23:50

I don't know anyone who doesnt have a licence.

SegmentationFault · 16/12/2018 23:48

Surely all4 doesn't have many 'newish' films either? At least not that I've seen if you want that you need sky or now TV.

And I already said that renting or the cinema isn't cheaper, unless I suppose you only watch a few films a year. Just that they have advantages over TV.