Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My ex text and I want him back

60 replies

Pollypopit · 14/12/2018 01:16

This time last year I broke up with my boyfriend because I moved to a new city to work and he didn't want to move. We were both pretty heartbroken. I threw myself into my job and didn't make contact because it wasn't fair on him and because I didn't trust myself to stay in the city I moved to and not run back to him...

Anyway after nearly a year of radio silence I got a message Monday asking how I was. I was surprised to see his name pop up but replied pretty business like.

I then received a text tonight about "our" song which was pretty mushy (basically it's the first time in a year since I listened to this I always picture you dancing to it, I miss you)

I feel pretty pathetic and teenagery but it has knocked me back a bit. I haven't really dated since I got here mainly because I wasn't ready but also because no-one caught my eye. I've had a few one night stands but nothing major. This has made me want to text back saying I wanted to come home and go back to how we were (obviously didn't).

I'm back in our hometown in 2 weeks for good (6 months early).

aibu to initiate a meet up/coffee anything else or should I just get a grip and take it as friendly chat?

OP posts:
RhiWrites · 14/12/2018 13:58

OP, you love and miss him but...
You have different ways of handling stress, it broke you apart in the past. Unless that could radically change it would do the same again.

JustanotherCHRISTMASuser01 · 14/12/2018 13:47

His behaviour during the break up would be a major thing for me - honestly believe that break ups bring out the worse in people.
A coffee never hurts

HollowTalk · 14/12/2018 13:39

Oh don't tell him what you feel yet! Noooooo!!!!

You could say you're back over Christmas and does he fancy going out for lunch one day? See what he does from there. Don't go blurting out your feelings until you know they're reciprocated in a way that means you can have a fulfilled life.

Pollypopit · 14/12/2018 13:34

The world's biggest dripfeed but maybe it will clarify a few points about it

Me and ex had a miscarriage about 9 months before I moved away. He was eaten up with guilt that he hadn't stopped me getting an abortion some 4 years earlier. So there was signs of commitment in that we were wanting to have kids. I always think what would have happened had I had the baby.

There was never talk of engagement though. We signed for a house together and always just acted as a long term couple. It never struck me as odd that we weren't not engaged - maybe my expectations are lower than that?

I suppose deep down we both needed a break from the situation as it was. I wanted to run away from it whereas he wanted to stay and kind of be sad together. I think that makes me a bad person rather than him but I can accept that.

We did have mutual friends but like I said I keep myself cut off. I saw a mutual friend on my birthday in September and was talking about ex. I think that's when I realised that everything I had ever wanted was back in a city I wasn't in anymore. But obviously I had a job at the time.

The site for this job has run up early so I wouldn't be abandoning but I would be back and forth fron another city closer to my old hometown.

I am going to reply at some point today and take it from there. I still love him so I guess ill always think what if if I don't at least tell him how I feel

OP posts:
Mumtoboy123 · 14/12/2018 08:24

As my mum said to me: you dont have to marry the guy, just go for a drink with him and see what happens. (Famous last words, we've been married nearly 3 years!)

3WildOnes · 14/12/2018 08:10

If you didn’t love each other enough to make it work a year ago I doubt you love each other enough to make it work out now. Move on.

KitschBitch · 14/12/2018 08:09

This thread has made me go all tingly, sounds like a great Christmas love story. Definitely meet up and see if the spark is there on both sides, then live happily ever after.....Whatever happens, can you keep us up to date please? Xmas Smile

MephistophelesApprentice · 14/12/2018 08:09

I'm going to be blunt here: If you were a male mate I'd say, well, have a wank before thinking about it to make sure that lust isn't doing the thinking for you.

If you still feel you want to meet him 30 seconds afterwards then yeah, do it.

Chloe84 · 14/12/2018 07:57

Wow this is better than the turgid movies on True Christmas Grin

This one would be called 'A Christmas Homecoming'.

I agree with a pp - go get your man!

Ellisandra · 14/12/2018 07:54

Was it always expected to be a temporary move?

If so, it’s not worth going back - your relationship wasn’t important enough to both of you to keep it going.

Saying “I love you” when you broke up? Words. Easy to say. If you really loved each other, you’d have stayed together.

By all means be his booty call if the sex will be good, just be ready to go through the same old shit next time you move for work.

ElsieCat · 14/12/2018 07:40

It also depends on how old you both were when you got together. If you were teenaged first loves then perhaps a year apart has done you both a world of good. It will have given you both some space to explore dating other people without the guilt of cheating, and to really reflect on what you want.

Too many people meet the right person at the wrong time (very young) and the relationship eventually fails because one of them starts to feel trapped and wonders what else there might have been out there for them if they’d not settled so soon. It’s a scratch they need to itch and it breaks up so many otherwise well matched couples.

If that rings bells with you then I’d say give it another go. If not, I’d say there are other factors that stopped you making things work around your job move and it’s only a matter of time before the same factors are an issue again.

Iloveautumnleaves · 14/12/2018 07:11

It’s EASY to meet up for a drink and reconnect. It’s EASY to get back together.

But it’s foolish to do so without first being honest about why you broke up. 6 years into a relationship you should work something out together, not just one of you move for a job & break up. There wasn’t a solid commitment from one or both parties and that is where the problem lies. If that is not addressed then there’s no depth to getting back together because there’s no trust that both parties are committed to the each other above anything else and will work together to resolve life’s curve balls.

gladheart · 14/12/2018 07:10

I'd keep it friendly and see what happens. The text about that song might have been when he was drunk/nostalgic or experiencing another mood that has now passed.

fezzesarecool · 14/12/2018 07:05

Go for it, you’ve got nothing to lose

To me it sounds like you made the right choice for both of you in the situation you were in at the time.

After a year apart you still love him and there seems to be something on his side too.

cordeliavorkosigan · 14/12/2018 06:37

I disagree with some others that it's a bad sign to have broken up, I think it depends what field you're in. For example academics often have to either move around or leave the research track, some people might only get in to one med school, and some people don't want to have an LDR while focusing on a new job in a new place. Also some people give up amazing uni offers or jobs for a boyfriend /girlfriend and later regret it! The issue is more - what if you have a drink, find you still really connect, and think about getting back together. what happens next time there's a job? is he as unwilling to move next time / later / with kids / or otherwise to support your career? are vice versa?

safetyfreak · 14/12/2018 06:13

I agree with the other posters who say you both were never commited much. 6 years and no ring or kids? 6 years and he didn't follow you when you moved?

Honestly i think your wasting your time.

Alfie190 · 14/12/2018 05:55

No way would me and DH have split up because one of us got a job in a new city. We would either both go or neither of us go. You two were not committed enough to each other. Six years in and no serious commitment? You are just going to be wasting even more years. Don’t answer him.

explodingkitten · 14/12/2018 05:40

Committed relationships need to be able to weather challenges and it seems you two split up at the first major hurdle.
This. I know relationships that survived one person spending two or three years in another country (one on the other side of europe, one who left for australia). They worked it out and both couples are now together and have children. You don't sound committed enough to me.

ElsieCat · 14/12/2018 05:22

I'm going to say no, if after 6 years you couldn't make a plan together, then maybe it's time to look forward to something else. But truly, only you can know.

I agree with this. What worries me is that after SIX YEARS the relationship had to end because your job needed to move you elsewhere and he wouldn't follow. It's making me think that it's all very conditional on things being about what he needs.

I get that he didn't want to move and shouldn't have had to, but surely if the relationship was solid you could have managed a long distance thing? Or not have taken that job in the first place? Surely there could have been some sort of compromise somewhere from one or both of you? The fact that there wasn't indicates that neither of you were prepared to prioritise the relationship over other things.

I suspect he did realise you'd be coming home soon (for Christmas) and as he hasn't met anyone else he's feeling a bit sorry for himself and nostalgic for the old times, as are you.

But if you are only going to get back together because it's become convenient again then I'm not sure that bodes well for the long term. Committed relationships need to be able to weather challenges and it seems you two split up at the first major hurdle. Maybe a year apart has just confirmed that you are both meant to be together and as the PP said, only you can truly know.

MaverickSnoopy · 14/12/2018 04:54

Go and get your man OP.

overnightangel · 14/12/2018 04:49

“You get a grip of yourself and don’t get emotionally invested. You’ll only get hurt again. ”

This is terrible advice

MerdedeBrexit · 14/12/2018 04:22

I just hope you've still got a job, if you're moving back 6 months early, OP.

Aquamarine1029 · 14/12/2018 04:00

So long as he was never abusive and you broke up due to circumstance, I say go for it and see how it goes.

jessstan2 · 14/12/2018 03:57

Agree with those who advise to see how it goes. You both sound like good people, you may be right for each other, maybe not. Take it slow and good luck.

kateandme · 14/12/2018 03:35

meet but take it steady.dont try to fall back into how it was because you've both grown up and away since then. there might be feeling and emotions from old and new lives mingled in here.
make sure you talk through anything ,any next steps,any feelings from how things were left and decision made.
also what if something came up again.would either of you make the compromise to be together then?if not where do you see this going if you want a settling down relationship.
there is no harm in meeting him.you will know then.youll no where your both at and how this can progress.

Swipe left for the next trending thread