Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if having a secret second family is that common?!

170 replies

trob22 · 12/12/2018 13:04

I've seen a couple of posts in the last few days about men who not only have a long-term OW in their lives but also have kids with the OW - and somehow manage to keep this a secret from their wife (and kids from that marriage) for YEARS while still seeing the OW and other child fairly regularly?

Is this really that common? How on earth do they keep the secret? How does it work with the man paying child maintenance etc?

I've only heard of one person in my life who had a secret second family but judging by MN it seems fairly run of the mill!!

OP posts:
Springmachine · 12/12/2018 22:06

I know of this happening to two different families.

In both bases when the secret family was uncovered the initial marriage split up.

Friends with secret brothers who happen to be only a few months younger etc

Both times the married couples always have seemed like the most in love and happy people on earth

Chickychoccyegg · 12/12/2018 21:56

my best friend found out last year, she was the ow, she had been with her dp for 18 years, had 3 dc with him, turns out he was married with 4 kids to his dw, 2 of the dc were born within 2 months of each other.
Everyone was shocked, he seemed so nice and genuine, a full part of her and her families life, she's since moved to another country, she had a bit of a breakdown when she found out the truth, his dw has decided to stay with him Confused

MsAwesomeDragon · 12/12/2018 21:50

My step-fil had a second family in China.

After he retired he did some contact work in China. For years he would be or there for 3 months at a time, back for a couple of weeks, then in China again, etc. He was making good money, spoke to mil every day, sent her loads of pictures etc. It was only when he died that it came out he had an other woman out there, with a toddler. He was in his 60s, nobody expected him to be having an affair with a woman younger than his own daughter and fathering children younger than his grandchildren. It hasn't worked out particularly well for his other woman either, as his promise to bring her back to the UK obviously hasn't materialised (because he died, but I don't think he ever had any real intention of bringing her home), and the money he was spending on her and their child isn't there any more either. It devastated mil, and she feels like their 20 year marriage was a complete sham.

MorganKitten · 12/12/2018 21:13

I know a few..

Myself! My mum found out when she was pregnant my dad had a wife, a 7 year old... and a baby on the way. My half brother is 3 months younger than me. My mum found out when he dropped her off at the train station, and she saw him picking up another women (my mum was the younger spitting image of her) - never trust a cab driver lol

At work, I got a call asking why we’d taken two direct debit amounts from her joint account. Turns out husband was paying for both kids to go to the same drama classes, a few months later I was asked by her lawyers to provide details etc.

My friend found out she had a half sister in America, dads business trips we code for second family.

GirlFliesHome · 12/12/2018 20:43

My grandfather's father shuttled between two wives and two sets of children. he and his mother knew about the other wife (because she was the first and only legal wife) but apparently the first family knew nothing about them.

A friend was the OW for 18 years before her now-DH told his wife. He would 'leave for work early' and spend 45 minutes with her every morning and then spend the same amount of time with her in the evening. Ss far as his wife knew he was a normal office worker and commuter who spent 90 minutes more in the office each day than he really did. They have a now-adult daughter and he used to go to her parents evenings etc.

ja9r · 12/12/2018 20:20

It's happened in my family. Before that I'd have thought it happened but was v rare.

ModreB · 12/12/2018 18:56

OK.

I am the child in a secret family, I have 2 older siblings who I have never me, but my DM lived with my DF for over 2 years until she got wise and kicked him out. This was in the 1960's.

My GGFather had 2 families, who lived about 3 streets apart from each other in the East End of London in the 1880's - to about 1920. We think they knew about each other as one of the children from the "other" family were taken in by the "original" family when the "other" wife got ill. This was found out when she applied for an identity card in 1939.

My GGF eldest son, My GM brother and his wife, adopted a child as his wife could not have children. When we looked in the records, my GM brother was listed as the legal, married father of the adopted child.

I also knew someone as a teenager who found out his father had a whole other family and children when he died. This was in the 1980's.

One of my family members was married to a man who had a brother, a couple of months younger than him, and a sister a couple of years younger to another "wife". Both "wives" turned up at the DF's funeral, and both and all siblings sat at the front of the Church for the service. This was about 10 years ago.

SemperIdem · 12/12/2018 17:43

I think women passing off children as their husband’s or partners when they’re actually another man’s is even more common than men having second families.

I know of two such instances within the same family. One generation after the other. My ex’s. He wasn’t his mother’s husband son, and in turn, the husband wasn’t the product of his own mother’s marriage.

My current partner’s mother passed him off as her partners child when he too, was not.

Neither my ex nor my partner found out until after the men they believed to be their father was dead. In both cases they were teens when this happened. In both cases those men suspected the whole time, in both cases the children suffered for it. They both, ex and my partner, had quite sad upbringings, the former especially.

It is a dreadful thing to do.

YouSmellOfBeefAndCheese · 12/12/2018 17:38

The danger is if you have siblings that live SO close and are the same age they can unknowingly end up meeting up or being in a relationship (sexually) Sad

chillpizza · 12/12/2018 17:18

I have many siblings that are in other family’s around my own age. Some months apart others a couple of years.

Poodles1980 · 12/12/2018 16:57

A girl I went to college with found out when she was about 16/17 that her dad had an entire other family living fairly near them. Her half sister was only a few months younger than her and her dad never told any of them about the other family

Ollivander84 · 12/12/2018 16:52

Not married, and not an affair but I had a relationship with someone from when we were 13 to 31 and nobody had a clue. We kept it completely secret. So yeah I can see how it's done

LittleCandle · 12/12/2018 16:32

Happened to my DM. I am not sure of the exact details, as I didn't learn about this until after her death. I am not the child in the second family.

Afternooninthepark · 12/12/2018 16:32

I worked with a woman who was deliriously happy. She was pregnant with her first child and due to marry her fiancé that year. Fiancé was in sales and used to work away Mon-Thurs.
One day my work mate was tidying up their garden shed when she found a box full of info of fiancé’s ‘other’ family up north! God only knows what the other family thought, perhaps they knew about his cosy set-up down south?
Needless to say, she didn’t marry him that year. I always thought he was a slippery slimy character!

abacucat · 12/12/2018 16:28

I am sure men having a secret child from an affair is common. But having an actual secret family that they support and visit, just blows my mind.

flirtygirl · 12/12/2018 16:21

My grandfather had children come to his funeral which were from a long term mistress. I was shocked but I think my grandmother knew.

He had 5 kids with my grandmother and 5 with ow. He left them a house and money in his will but most of the estate 80% went to grandmother and her 4 kids. (1deceased.)

wijjy · 12/12/2018 16:20

genetic testing shows between 6 and 13% of paternity is not as
thought by the child, in all tested populations and cultures the
world over. Sperm competition presents some fascinating
evolutionary explanations.

This is completely wrong.

6-13% is for a very select set of people - those who get paternity testing, and so where the paternity is in some doubt. It is much, much lower when you look at populations, more like 1%. (I do genetic studies of disease and you don't see it that after when you take paternal DNA).

link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12110-012-9143-y

longwayoff · 12/12/2018 16:09

Granddaughter of a first wife here. Grandad legged it with his floozy when she eventually became pregnant. So, first family, son and daughter in Berkshire, second family of twins in London. Another child to second family ten years on. Floozy then gets cancer and dies a few years later. Grandad drafts in first wife and daughter to help deal with the traumatised kids. Lots of resentment all round for many years. 70 years on, an ancestry DNA test shows they weren't grandpas children at all. The good old days. I don't think this was as uncommon as we're led to believe in the days before easy divorce.

Jux · 12/12/2018 16:06

A guy I knew, whose parents divorced when he was a small baby, discovered when in his 30s that his uncle was in fact his dad and his cousins in fact his step-siblings.

Lovemusic33 · 12/12/2018 16:03

I think it happens a lot, I think people have affairs a lot too, I was pretty oblivious to this until I started dating again, I have met several men who have lied about having a family (who they live with) and would have happily had another relationship at the same time. I’m sure many women have affairs too and end up telling their husbands that the baby they are carrying is there’s and they raise the child not knowing Sad

I’m pleased that I am single.

Sarahjconnor · 12/12/2018 16:00

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

tryinganewname · 12/12/2018 15:56

A friend of mine found out her partner had a completely separate life from her, no children involved but they did have a dog together and he did live with her but 'travelled for work' half the week. They'd been together for years and all that fine he had another partner and a child.

He told my friend that his parents were no longer alive and so she never met them or any of his family but the parents were very much a part of the other woman and child's life.

She only found out because her sister died very young and suddenly and her friends found it very off that he'd barely been there to support her and started snooping on the internet and found his 'real' Facebook profile.

Amazing thing is, the last time I spoke to her they were 'working on things'.

SushiMonster · 12/12/2018 15:55

My dad was the product of a secret family, but in that case his dad wasn't going between the two families but had totally abandoned his first family (the thought he was dead, war time) and started a new family in a new country. All came out when my dad was an adult and his dad was long dead.

Megan2018 · 12/12/2018 15:54

I know of 2 genuine real life cases. I guess that makes it not uncommon?

One is the sister of a work colleague of mine. She has 2 children with the MM (he has 3 kids with his wife), he visits regularly but they never go out in public together. The 2 families live a few miles apart in the same town, and in a few years the children from the 2 families could end up at the same secondary school! They have been separate at primary but I fail to see how this is going to last with older kids on social media. It is madness - work colleague despairs. In this case although the sister knows she is the other woman and the kids don't know that he is their father. From what I can tell the wife has no reason to suspect anything.

The second is a school friend of mine - she found out her Dad had a second family whilst we were at school. The second family were in a different part of the country, the father worked away in this other town for work and basically did Mon-Thurs with his other family and weekends with them. I am not sure whether the other family knew - I did't know all the details but it caused a heap of devastation when discovered. This was before social media days though.

I don't understand it at all!

PumpedUpTermite · 12/12/2018 15:46

My sister (the eldest sibling, different dad to the rest of us) was a secret child.
My mum didn’t know he was married but he had a wife and 3 kids in London (we live in South Wales) she was heartbroken when she found out. He stayed with her Thursday to Monday and had multiple businesses which he always used to excuse why he wasn’t “home” much.
Sister is now in her 30’s and has never really met her dad (it all came out when she was a baby and her dad ceased all contact so his wife/first family wouldn’t find out).
I find it really sad.