Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think MIL has ripped the piss?

334 replies

taxiforMIL · 11/12/2018 22:47

Please help me to see straight with this.

My MIL picks my DS up from school on a Monday. DS is in P4 I so this arrangement has been going on for the best part of 3 and a half years since DS started p1. She always walked to to the school to collect him but since Easter she’s had bother with her knee and hasn’t been up to walking the distance to the school.

We offered to send DS to afterschool care but she insisted he came to her so we offered to pay for her to pick him up in a taxi (she doesn’t drive) and bring him back to hers. All seemed ok.

We decided that instead of giving MIL money every week we’d set up an account with the local taxi company and I’d pay the bill monthly. My DH knows the guy who runs the taxi firm so was no bother to set up. We explained to her what we’d done and the account was to cover her journey to and from the school to collect DS.

Anyway, to the main issue. Since April, I’ve been calling monthly to settle the bill and it’s always been roughly the same amount, give or take a few pounds.

I called at the end of Oct to pay the bill and it was higher than usual but I was busy at work at the time and assumed that there had been a delay at school one day or something had happened. Admittedly I forgot to ask DH about it. I called at the end of November to pay the bill and it was even higher again! For instance, say the bill is normally £30 a month, it was £45 in October then £75 in November. I didn’t pay the November bill there and then as the man in the office couldn’t tell me what journeys had been made on the account.

I rang my DH and explained to him about the bills shooting up and he phoned MIL who said she’d been using the account to get out and about and she didn’t think we’d mind a few extra pounds on the bill.

My DH said to her that she’s spent roughly £60 on taxis on an account that she knows was set up solely to collect DS from school.

She is indignant about the whole thing and even used the account again after we’d told her.

WWYD? I’ve told my DH that I want DS to attend
Afterschool care. It’s cheaper than £75 a month 🙈

OP posts:
Ljlsmum · 12/12/2018 09:33

Aren't there rules on paying family to provide childcare anyway? So everyone saying the OP has had free childcare- well yes, I'm sure you can't pay them without them being properly registered? Anyway, she must like looking after the child as she was the one insisting on continuing. Perhaps OP and her husband spend extra on gifts for the Goodwill that was shown. Her looking after her GC doesn't mean they should tolerate paying more out than they are expecting.

fredleighton · 12/12/2018 09:32

I agree Annie. I'm a mil and of course I know that taxi fares cost money. It's ridiculous of anyone to suggest the MIL didn't know what she was doing.

I'm always amazed on Mumsnet at the number of people who talk about grandparents as if they're ancient and frail.

Thesnobbymiddleclassone · 12/12/2018 09:30

A few extra one month to maybe take your DS somewhere fine but it was an abuse of trust and not what the account was for.

Pay up the account and put him in after school club until she can walk again.

sansou · 12/12/2018 09:30

Unless, you’re really strapped for cash, it’s not about the money. I can’t believe anyone would seriously think that DC going to after school club once a week is better than continuing going to grandma’s where you get 1:1 loving care and attention, better food, help with reading, no stress if late pick up, etc......plus you’ve been doing it for years and presumeably love your grandma.

If MIL would like you to subsidise her taxis, I repeat - what are your DH’s feelings about this?

Maldives2006 · 12/12/2018 09:26

She’s taken extra taxi journeys without letting her son know.. that’s money that could have been spent on her grandson.

Just because someone becomes a grandmother in doesn’t entitle them to be rude and bad mannered

Woooman · 12/12/2018 09:21

No Kool, what's sad is that you think family should be paid to spend time with their relatives.

Your interpretation of this situation is very odd. The MIL wants to spend time with her gc, the OP and her dh have enabled that despite having other options that they were happy to go with, but the MIL insisted that she look after the dc each week. She has taken advantage of the situation. If she needed help getting out to do shopping then she should ask for help and her ds should offer to help her but to just take from the OP and her dh without telling them what she was doing is beyond cheeky.

In all honesty I find everyone who is working out how much has been saved on childcare over the years a bit peculiar. You can't compare a gp who wants to and insists on spending time with their gc with a childcare setting. One is offering a service and the other is spending time with a relative.

MrsFassy · 12/12/2018 09:20

Also why is everyone assuming the MiL is elderly? My mum became a Grandma at 40. And a problem with her knee could mean anything, she could have had a fall while skiing or an accident.

@taxiforMIL just for clarity how old is MiL?

sansou · 12/12/2018 09:19

OP needs to come back and respond to the thread!

I see it as your DH's issue to resolve. Surely, it's not that hard to go "Mum, we can't afford the extra taxis you're taking on our account" and go from there - whether she has financial issues or just plain need more practical help getting out and about.

HavelockVetinari · 12/12/2018 09:18

Hear hear, @Anniegetyourgun

Anniegetyourgun · 12/12/2018 09:16

It's depressing to me, as a GM of a school-aged child, to see GMs so often implied to be elderly and frail. MIL in this case may not be more than mid 50s, and apart from unspecified trouble with her knee could be in robust health. There are also a number of assumptions made about the OP's and MIL's relative financial situations. Nobody said MIL is widowed/single either, although she might be. Or she might be happily married to a merchant banker, although I suspect OP would have mentioned that!

Anyway, bottom line is, if you feel your children are taking advantage of you, SAY SOMETHING instead of sneaking back what you think is your entitlement through extra taxi fares. If we can't talk to our own offspring who we brought up from birth, who can we talk to?

Btw I wouldn't set a cap on the taxi costs. There's no guarantee she wouldn't use it up and then not have enough credit to fetch DGS by the end of the month! Specified journeys only would be the way forward if you wanted to keep the arrangement. If it really is hospital appointments etc it could be open to negotiation.

Copperbonnet · 12/12/2018 09:14

This is what I fear if/when I am a MIL. It’s your dh’s Mum and ds’s grandmother ffs! She most probably had no idea what it cost or what it would add to the bill,

You fear not being able to freely spend other people’s money?

If she’s mentally astute enough to look after her GS she’s mentally astute enough to understand that taxis cost money.

Vegisgrowingwell · 12/12/2018 09:13

It's very funny how some people seem to read threads differently!

Insisting to keep collecting DS does not give free reign on taxi spending. We don't know whether the OP already does her shopping, takes her to the Dr etc. So many assumptions being made here! Perhaps OP has paid and taken MIL on holiday, that would cover the costs which seem to be so important to Kool

I can make as many assumptions as you! That cost of childcare might have been paid in other ways 10 times over!!

Coffeeonthesofa · 12/12/2018 09:12

If you take the childcare issue out of the picture. You have a MiL,your DH’s mum, who is getting older and needs some additional help, you don’t mention if you or DH have ever offered any practical help, lifts etc. Yes she should have talked to you about needing extra taxis, would you have been sympathetic though?
I wish my MIL’s problems “getting out and about” were as easily solved as giving a few lifts or paying for taxis. She has many, many health problems and now has dementia as well ( recently moved into a nursing home) for many years my DH and my SIL took her shopping, took her to hospital appointments, visited her regularly, got phone calls in the middle of the night from police or paramedics asking for them to come ( they had power of attorney) etc, etc.
An 1 1/2 hr round trip for my DH with having to go to work the next day.
Welcome to the world of aging parents, she never did any childcare for us by the way, but she is my DH’s mum and needs help. Your MIL is only going to cost you more, time and money, in the future. Why not have a family discussion and work out some alternatives, home deliveries of shopping etc. It sounds like you are really resentful so maybe you should cut all ties so that the woman knows she is on her own now.

AnchorDownDeepBreath · 12/12/2018 09:09

I'm surprised the taxi company allowed this. When I had an account; I had to be there to sign for the journey even if I wasn't going in the taxi. They were strict about it.

She's taken the piss; and she knows it.

IalwayswantedtobeBeth · 12/12/2018 09:08

MrsFassy please explain what is wrong with a grandparent wanting a relationship with a grandchild. Sometimes it will be less convenient, sometimes more but it is surely the right of the child to have that relationship. There seem to be some very contentious families on here, prepared only to think about themselves. I didn't mean to get caught up in this and just feel hugely disappointed in the attitudes of some people. This will need to be sorted but that doesn't mean it can't be sorted compassionately. Off to the Archer's spoilers and will not stray from there again in a hurry.

greendale17 · 12/12/2018 09:07

The OP and her dh didn't ask for free childcare, they would have their boy in afterschool care. The MIL wanted to spend time with her grandson. That is lovely but doesn't mean she can then spend her son and dils money without their knowledge.

^This. The fact that MIL continued to use the account after the OP had told her not to is completely out of order.

diddl · 12/12/2018 09:01

I should imagine that MIL's intention was to keep seeing her GS, not to rip off her son & DIL.

Perhaps she thought that she deserved a couple of taxi trips as payment for the childcare she provides?

But that should have been discussed & agreed on, shouldn't it?

I'm sure that no one would have begrudged her her weekly shop or the odd appointment.

"She is indignant about the whole thing and even used the account again after we’d told her."

That's what makes MIL unreasonable isn't it?

What if it was run up so much that it couldn't have been afforded?

How old is P4-about 7?

Is it too late now to just have the taxi collect & drop GS at MIL's?

MrsFassy · 12/12/2018 08:59

@Kool4katz or perhaps we have parents who want to see their grandchildren and spend time with them! Perhaps them having the children one day a week after school is something they all look forward to and miss when it doesn't happen for whatever reason. And honestly I don't know of anyone who's ever paid their family for childcare- other than perhaps a teenage sibling/niece/nephew, but never adult family members.

And where does it say it's all done at the OP's convenience? She offered to put the child into paid childcare her MiL refused and insisted she still had her grandson.

People on here get so fixated on 'free childcare' they can't seem to grasp that a lot of the time grandparents offer to look after their grandchildren, because they enjoy spending time with them.

Engorged · 12/12/2018 08:54

The OP and her dh didn't ask for free childcare, they would have their boy in afterschool care. The MIL wanted to spend time with her grandson. That is lovely but doesn't mean she can then spend her son and dils money without their knowledge.

She is cheeky and she probably feels its ok or she's owed. I would probably saw she was less cheeky if she was doing them a big favor or they were demanding free childcare (which she should say fo to) but she isnt and they aren't, she insisted on doing this- it wasn't demanded of her.

Setting boundries is the right thing to do. It doesn't need to be all out arguing just a 'we are disapointed you used our account especially as we've been charged double now. We are also sad you have obviously been in a lot more pain then youve let on.

CheesyWeez · 12/12/2018 08:54

BeansAndCoffee, I agree with that. DH should ask his mum in that way. "Haha mum what's all this extra taxi stuff I can't afford!"

My mum has a health problem right now and can't drive because of it. As we live in a rural area my siblings and I have shared the trips taking her to and from hospital/shopping etc.
I would feel guilty if I hadn't been able to do that.

SuchAToDo · 12/12/2018 08:52

Am I the only one thinking op shouldn't have to pay the extra amount if you set up the account with the taxi company for specific journeys for your son...and they are adding on fare for your mil that you didn't authorise and didn't ask them to do that...then they are essentially adding someone elses taxi bill to your own and expecting you to pay..Shock,. Op you shouldn't have to pay anything other than the journeys you specified for your son...anything extra is not your bill as you didn't ask or give permission for mother in law fares to be added to your account...you should speak to whoever is in charge at taxi company as you are getting ripped off royally

YoThePussy · 12/12/2018 08:52

OP, leaving aside whether your MIL is a CF or not there are voluntary groups who will take people out shopping if they are not very mobile. They charge something like £2 a trip. My Mum went on a weekly shopping bus when she couldn’t drive anymore. She made loads of new friends and thoroughly enjoyed it. These groups also have volunteers who will take people for appointments with the doctor, hospital, chiropody, etc. If you have something like that in your area your MIL could be steered towards it. All the posters saying the OP and her DH should offer lifts, these people work full-time so are not able to take the MIL out and about during the working day.

Good luck with whatever you decide.

flamingofridays · 12/12/2018 08:48

Why should he feel guilty?
Because he isnt at his mothers beck and call 24/7 because he has to work to live like most people?

You dont have children so you have free carers.

He has spoken to his mum and she continued to use the account.

AllRoadsLeadBackToRadley · 12/12/2018 08:47

There have been a couple of posts about not being able to "pay" grandma but payment really doesn't have to be a money wage.

Agree with this. No one in our family keeps "tabs" sts, but we paint and decorate, collect things bought from eBay, the PIL have had handmade items from me to give as gifts to people...we make sure they know they're appreciated. 💜

IalwayswantedtobeBeth · 12/12/2018 08:46

"I have a 100 year old neighbour who is baffled by the internet and smartphones - but she knows that if you get in a taxi, it costs money!"

… and I know a 98 year old who began to get confused by the value of things in her early 80s but was not diagnosed with Altziemer's until her 90s. Let's hope that the OP is more sympathetic if this is something they have to deal with where her MIL is concerned. The idea of families is that we all look after one another, surely. It is not transactional but appropriate to need and ability to help. I think the harsh attitudes to a member of your family mentioned here are more extreme than I have seen in real life so perhaps it is the social media effect. This poor woman is someone's mother not an employee. As others have pointed out she cannot be. A sympathetic conversation might get a great deal further than a decision to be annoyed.