Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that if you’re told a phrase is offensive, you don’t insist on using it?

803 replies

changehere · 02/11/2018 21:02

Yes, a TAAT. The context is that we explained to mumsnet HQ that the phrase ‘beyond the Pale’ is found eyebrow-raising by many (but not all) Irish people.

The Pale was the name given to an area of Ireland under English rule and those outside that area were considered uncivilised aka ‘beyond the pale’. This is a phrase that is only used with raised eyebrows in Ireland and certainly feels inappropriate, if not offensive, coming from an English person.

Mumsnet use it as part of their racism guidelines as in that they only ban language that is ‘beyond the pale’. Mumsnet accept the origins of the phrase. However, they insist on using this phrase to describe whether something is or is not racist.

Given the context, AIBU in requesting that Mumsnet find another phrase in their racism guidelines?

OP posts:
LassWiADelicateAir · 03/11/2018 15:30

There are many manifestations. Names like Conor and Liam are considered naughty boy names

And with that OP you lost any credibility you might have had.

When I worked at a call centre I was told not to use the phrase ‘bear with me’ as it means to be naked with someone

No it doesn't. Even as a homophone for "bare" "bare with me" isn't an expression.

The pale clearly does apply to Ireland and clearly did not originate in or was used exclusively in Ireland.

HillyMillylunchmunch · 03/11/2018 15:29

@zampa I'll put details when I have 5 minutes but the phrase call a spade a spade isn't offensive! It was only offensive in that one very specific context because of a racist meaning of the word spade.
The OP accidentally made a racist pun by using the phrase. That was the problem, but the phrase itself.

Make sense?

ButchyRestingFace · 03/11/2018 15:28

I'm Irish, I find humour in many things & always will do.

You said you were "half" Irish in your last post. Where did you suddenly find the other 50%?

Wazznme · 03/11/2018 15:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

donquixotedelamancha · 03/11/2018 15:28

donqixote your link confirms the existence of the English pale in Ireland! In an article about the phrase “beyond the pale”

I didn't dispute that meaning existed. I mentioned it in my post. I don't think anyone believes the Pale in Ireland didn't exist.

The point PPs have made is that the phrase 'beyond the pale' does not appear to have the etymological origins the OP ascribes to it. The idea that it comes from the Irish Pale (or at least the geographic term in general) is common on the internet, but has no sources. There seems to be quite a lot of evidence that it is from the more recent phrase 'beyond the pale of...'

But refuse to accept that beyond the pale could be deemed offensive to Irish people.

Lots of things could be deemed offensive to lots of people. I'm amazed that someone with your username would think 'someone might be upset' should be the threshold for policing language.

Wazznme · 03/11/2018 15:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

JaneJeffer · 03/11/2018 15:25

Your sense of humour leaves a lot to be desired Flowerpot

Flowerpot2005 · 03/11/2018 15:22

It's an indicator of how ridiculous this post is & how some people can be.

I'm Irish, I find humour in many things & always will do. It's a phrase, with a background at least 90% of people on here didn't know. But oh no, someone couldn't simply explain it, they had to throw in the 'I'm offended' phrase. Be offended, it's a choice or don't be, that's also a choice just don't go telling people what they should & shouldn't find offensive because that's called dictatorship. It's 2018 people, the world has moved on.

Bejazzled · 03/11/2018 15:21

YABU

MiniMum97 · 03/11/2018 15:17

I am all for not trying to offend people but we do seem to be getting to the point when we won't be able to say anything for fear of offence. In the part of this thread I have read there are three phrases mentioned that are common usage that we shouldn't be saying. We need to take a step back I think and stop getting offended by things when no offence is intended. The intent is what is important.

Giantbanger · 03/11/2018 15:16

I’ve reported that racist post.

That type of attitude mnhq is exactly the anti Irish sentiment that needs dealt with on here. And dealt with robustly.

JaneJeffer · 03/11/2018 15:15

Flowerpot I'm reporting your racist post

Wazznme · 03/11/2018 15:12

Flowerpot your strawman argument is feeble. But enjoy the potatoes.

IStandWithPosie · 03/11/2018 15:12

You may think you’re funny flowerpot but that’s really low.

Flowerpot2005 · 03/11/2018 15:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

IStandWithPosie · 03/11/2018 15:06

Grin donqixote your link confirms the existence of the English pale in Ireland! In an article about the phrase “beyond the pale”

So what people are saying is

  1. they accept that beyond the pale means beyond the limits of acceptability.

  2. they accept that the pale existed in Ireland which Irish people lived outside of (enforced!) or, beyond the pale.

But refuse to accept that beyond the pale could be deemed offensive to Irish people. Confused bit of a logic fail there.

BeenThereDone · 03/11/2018 15:05

I am Irish and do not find that term offensive in any way.... You most definitely are BU...

JaneJeffer · 03/11/2018 15:02

We wouldn't want to offend those etymologists would we?

ButchyRestingFace · 03/11/2018 15:01

Scottish of Irish extraction person. I wouldn't use "to throw a paddy" but quite like "beyond the pale".

I would however give it up without hesitation were I to be convinced that it's dubious etymology means that the expression is a cause of great offence to Irish people at large.

The evidence on this thread and the other doesn't really support that viewpoint, I don't think. Plenty of self-identifying Irish folks saying, "it doesn't bother me or anyone I know/it's an expression that is used in Ireland."

I do agree about anti-Irish sentiment on the forum though.

donquixotedelamancha · 03/11/2018 14:54

Further reading does suggest that etymologists regard the OP's interpretation of the phrase as bobbins. Another website pulling it apart here:

wordhistories.net/2016/08/24/beyond-the-pale/

Lots of quotes from the 1700s on a number of sites show 'beyond the pale of ....' being just used to mean 'outside of...' before settling as 'beyond the pale of expedience' meaning unacceptable behaviour, which then contracted to 'beyond the pale'.

It seems to me that PPs are correct. The geographic 'beyond the Pale' referring to 14th-16th century Ireland has no historic link to the modern use of the phrase. I can't find a single sourced reference otherwise.

Wazznme · 03/11/2018 14:54

Because it's Irish people reminding English people of their history. They don't like it.

IStandWithPosie · 03/11/2018 14:48

Why on earth would they close it master? Confused

MyFavouritePlace · 03/11/2018 14:44

I didn't know the history of the saying and it's not one I particularly use but now I know the offence it causes will not use it again. Thanks for educating me.

mastertomsmum · 03/11/2018 14:42

Erm, this thread has veered off at a tangent.
Suggest mods close it

JaneJeffer · 03/11/2018 14:39

Ahah, much better.