Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that if you’re told a phrase is offensive, you don’t insist on using it?

803 replies

changehere · 02/11/2018 21:02

Yes, a TAAT. The context is that we explained to mumsnet HQ that the phrase ‘beyond the Pale’ is found eyebrow-raising by many (but not all) Irish people.

The Pale was the name given to an area of Ireland under English rule and those outside that area were considered uncivilised aka ‘beyond the pale’. This is a phrase that is only used with raised eyebrows in Ireland and certainly feels inappropriate, if not offensive, coming from an English person.

Mumsnet use it as part of their racism guidelines as in that they only ban language that is ‘beyond the pale’. Mumsnet accept the origins of the phrase. However, they insist on using this phrase to describe whether something is or is not racist.

Given the context, AIBU in requesting that Mumsnet find another phrase in their racism guidelines?

OP posts:
LemonTT · 04/11/2018 10:17

Blimey there are a lot of threads popping up that seem to serve no purpose other than to sow seeds of discontent between in Anglo-Irish discord. At a particularly sensitive time for Anglo-Irish politics because of Brexit.

Ironic that it turns out that this might be about a phrase of Russian origin. Heyho and wave to the factory workers.

A lot of Irish people don’t take offence because they see the historical context as referencing how difficult the celts were to conquer and control as a people, by what would have then been the Normans. It’s later usage to reference the Anglo Protestant enclave around Dublin again reflects the fact that Irish catholics retained their identity and religion. It’s one they are proud of, not ashamed of.

So for a lot of Irish people the phrase highlights a strong and positive national characteristic. That they are not so easily conquered or cowered and will rebel against foreign invasion. Even if it takes 100’s of years.

It is a facet of Anglo Irish politics that gave rise to a lot of words and phrases, like boycott and Gerrymandering. To eradicate them would be to negate important parts of a shared history that give rise to learning and advancement. It also tells us a lot about how language develops and changes over time.

Really OP, you need to put your energy into actually trying to understand more about Irish history and the diversity it gave rise to. Because that diversity exists and is recognised by all the people who live there. There are people Anglo Irish heritage who are Protestant. There are Scottish Ulster people who are largely Presbyterian and there are Irish catholics. Add a lot of ethnic minorities whilst you are at it. It is a nation of people who never have and never will want to be seen as simply passive victims of colonialism. Mainly because they weren’t, as the phrase demonstrates.

HeronLanyon · 04/11/2018 10:15

In case of any doubt at all my question above was rhetorical - my own answer is a resounding ‘no’.

HeronLanyon · 04/11/2018 09:42

But it’s all a bit messier than that bluntness isn’t it ? If we think about the ‘n’ word it as a long history and the etymology includes pure descriptive usage from various words for black. We now understand that the usage has become discriminatory (if it ever historically wasn’t) and it is pretty much universally accepted that it is racist. However some black people use it and have ‘claimed it’. Does that mean we should all now use it (irrespective of our motive - ie we could use it as a descriptor and ignore those who find it deeply offensive ( to the extent that to use it is a criminal offence) ??

Having written that I’m sure there may be problems with my logic (I did have a very late night last night!) but I think there’s something in it.

Bluntness100 · 04/11/2018 09:02

If people have never before heard that a certain phrase is offensive then they need to be cut some slack, but if they have been told, then why would they continue to say it?

Ok. Following that logic I find the word cunt offensive and mysogynistic towards women. A recent thread shows some agree, some disagree. Like this thread.

So I'm assuming now everyone has to stop saying cunt?

MQv2 · 04/11/2018 08:43

But the phrase is regularly used in Ireland by Irish people casually and I've never heard anyone complain about it.

I know and accept the origin of the phrase, but I disagree strongly with the assertion that almost all Irish people find it offensive, its so commonly used and innocuous.
It gets trotted out in discussion on sports regularly with regards to either players or fans actions. I'm baffled to see Irish people on here saying that they find it offensive or claim that this is an almost universal position in Ireland, I've just never seen it.

BishBoshBashBop · 04/11/2018 08:29

Now its going to turn into a Unionist bashing thread. How lovely Hmm

treaclesoda · 04/11/2018 07:53

I am, regrettably, very familiar with the type of unionist you refer to, living where I do, and I've never actually heard someone use the term 'beyond the pale' in real life. I always associate it with the song out of the Joseph musical, because that's where I first heard it. I'm not going to claim that no one in N Ireland has ever said it, but I don't think it's in common usage.

mathanxiety · 04/11/2018 07:43

Why yes, I do.

BishBoshBashBop · 04/11/2018 06:38

it is currently used in Northern Ireland by those Unionists who look down their noses at all things Irish and Catholic.

Here we go. Know that for a fact do you?

mathanxiety · 04/11/2018 04:12

You're wrong, Anasnake. You are not taking into account the full phrase 'beyond the Pale' and the meaning of that phrase, which is 'something that is unacceptable'. The phrase and the meaning didn't come to the English language from Russian or Yiddish. It came from earlier English and from laws passed in the late medieval period binding the English in the 'four obedient shires' on the east coast of Ireland most closely bound to England.

As a physical entity the Pale was a massive ditch with accompanying fortifications, many of which are still standing today (though ruined) separating the civilised English from the wild Irish who lived 'beyond the Pale'.

In terms of Irish history, it denoted the hierarchical concept of the two nations existing on the island, and this meaning is how it is currently used in Northern Ireland by those Unionists who look down their noses at all things Irish and Catholic.

limitedperiodonly · 03/11/2018 22:13

Limited. Not on that thread. We were told straight out it was wrong and we were thick

That's very bad. What was the direct reference to you being wrong and thick? If you can link i'd definitely back you up

treaclesoda · 03/11/2018 22:03

I wouldn't say it's difficult for me, but I was just expanding on my earlier comment, that I do think anti Irish sentiment exists, and I think there is a particular type of anti Irish sentiment directed towards those who are from N Ireland. Mind you, the public face of N Ireland, in the form of our politicians, doesn't paint a picture of a nation of nice friendly people, I get that. It's more that people are willing to take that at face value and not look behind all that and think 'WHY is it like that?'

AnElderlyLadyOfMediumHeight · 03/11/2018 22:03

'Aks' inevitably makes it onto the 'pronunciations/spellings you can't stand' threads, alongside 'haitch'. And it's invariably decried as teeth-itching and 'incorrect'.

limitedperiodonly · 03/11/2018 21:53

TreacleSoda. I understand it is difficult for you. But it is not unique. I am the Catholic child of an Irish father and an English mother. I've worked it out

Raydan · 03/11/2018 21:49

YANBU OP. I think it would be entirely reasonable for Mumsnet to amend the wording.

Giantbanger · 03/11/2018 21:42

In Northern Ireland it marks your cultural background. Aitch vs haitch.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-11642588

PerverseConverse · 03/11/2018 21:40

Aitch, we were always taught, was the correct pronunciation and is in the English dictionary as such. Never heard of it being an Irish thing to say haitch.

Giantbanger · 03/11/2018 21:38

Limited. Not on that thread. We were told straight out it was wrong and we were thick.

limitedperiodonly · 03/11/2018 21:37

Are you kidding me Giantbanger?

Of course saying 'haitch' rather than 'aitch' is okay.

It's not only Irish people that pronounce 'H' that way. Many people in Britain do too.

It's like people of Caribbean descent saying 'arksed' instead of 'asked'. That is also okay.

See also 'gotten'

Giantbanger · 03/11/2018 21:29

Perverse you should get on some of the Brexit threads.

The one about the Canada solution that stood for over a week, despite being reported numerous times, was exceedingly illuminating.

PerverseConverse · 03/11/2018 21:28

I've never heard any of that about Irish people!

treaclesoda · 03/11/2018 21:26

What I meant is that people from Ireland tend to be viewed, albeit patronisingly, as loveable and funny and friendly and jovial, and all the other lovely things that are associated with Ireland.

If you're from N Ireland however, then you're a knuckle dragging bigot, a drain on the resources of good hard working UK tax payers, you can't speak the English language properly, and you spend your spare time fighting your neighbours, and you're a terrorist sympathiser. And if you're from a unionist background you get to be a homophobe and not very bright as well. When it comes to how we appear to be perceived, there doesn't seem to be much in between...

bridgetreilly · 03/11/2018 21:24

TBH "pale" in itself is an odd choice of word when discussing racist language.

That's entirely coincidental, though. The meaning of pale with respect to colour is completely separate from its meaning with respect to a boundary fence. 'Beyond the pale' really, really doesn't have anything to do with colour.

Giantbanger · 03/11/2018 21:19

*pronounciation

limitedperiodonly · 03/11/2018 21:17

There is definitely bigotry towards Irish people on mumsnet. And you can double that if you are talking about the difficult folk on N Ireland, not the cute and cuddly friendly Irish from South and West of the border.

What do you mean Treaclesoda?