Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that if you’re told a phrase is offensive, you don’t insist on using it?

803 replies

changehere · 02/11/2018 21:02

Yes, a TAAT. The context is that we explained to mumsnet HQ that the phrase ‘beyond the Pale’ is found eyebrow-raising by many (but not all) Irish people.

The Pale was the name given to an area of Ireland under English rule and those outside that area were considered uncivilised aka ‘beyond the pale’. This is a phrase that is only used with raised eyebrows in Ireland and certainly feels inappropriate, if not offensive, coming from an English person.

Mumsnet use it as part of their racism guidelines as in that they only ban language that is ‘beyond the pale’. Mumsnet accept the origins of the phrase. However, they insist on using this phrase to describe whether something is or is not racist.

Given the context, AIBU in requesting that Mumsnet find another phrase in their racism guidelines?

OP posts:
JaneJeffer · 04/11/2018 13:00

confussssed are you living in a parallel universe or something?

Wazznme · 04/11/2018 13:00

Tell the queen she doesn't live in England lol. Cos it's not a country mate. Innit

VerbeenaBeeks · 04/11/2018 12:58

as i said a country is a nation with its own government there is no government of England

Confused
Wazznme · 04/11/2018 12:57

Please don't add Ireland as one of your dominions making up your Kingdom. That would be Northern Ireland.

confussssed · 04/11/2018 12:56

The sovereign state of the United Kingdom is made up of four countries: England, Northern Ireland, Wales and Scotland. This is not difficult.
as i said a country is a nation with its own government there is no government of England

confussssed · 04/11/2018 12:55

Does this mean that the next time Ireland are playing England in soccer we can get them disqualified because they're not a country?

i guess you think the us virgin islands is a country on that basis.

Antigon · 04/11/2018 12:51

I mean I know knowledge can be lacking in some English people, but that takes the biscuit!

Hmm

That's beyond the pale unacceptable.

JassyRadlett · 04/11/2018 12:50

The sovereign state of the United Kingdom is made up of four countries: England, Northern Ireland, Wales and Scotland. This is not difficult.

Antigon · 04/11/2018 12:47

@SputnikBear s post below makes alot of sense, interesting that it hasn't been rebutted. Someone copied and paste a blog in rebuttal but that smacks of not being able to defend yourself why it's offensive.

YABU for assuming that “beyond the pale” refers to the Irish Pale. Pale comes from the Latin pālus meaning 'stake'; it means a stake fence and the area inside it. So “beyond the pale” simply means "outside the boundary".

The first use of the phrase was around the 17th century, which is very late if it refers to the Irish Pale, which was in the Middle Ages starting around 1450. The phrase could equally originate from the English Pale of Calais in France. And there have been a number of other Pales, such as the Pale of Russia.

MoaningSickness · 04/11/2018 12:47

People get offended by fake origins of terms and phrases all the time, either through ignorance or others deliberately stirring. (There have been many examples on this thread - but to add my own to the pile I was told by some americans that talking about 'tribes' was cultural appropriation unless you were talking about native americans. They apparently had no knowledge of all the other tribes previously or currently existing in the world!)

I'm not going to stop using words and phrases because somebody who doesn't know what they are talking about thinks it has an offensive meaning. I will stop using a phrase when I learn a genuinely offensive origin (I grew up saying 'off the reservation' because I grew up in a place where a 'reservation' was a nature reserve and had no idea there were people on reservations in the US!).

I have to say I have never seen any evidence that 'beyond the pale' targets the Irish, just assertions with no backup, whereas those claiming it's origins go to palings and fences can often cite references.

That said it's sufficiently contested that I choose not to use it, but I wouldn't judge anyone else for using it.

JaneJeffer · 04/11/2018 12:46

Does this mean that the next time Ireland are playing England in soccer we can get them disqualified because they're not a country?

VerbeenaBeeks · 04/11/2018 12:43

i notice how the op keeps referring to the 'English' there is no country called England has not been for hundreds of years. i find that intresting

Confused

Yes, there is. OK, it's collectively known as the United Kingdom as there's several countries, but of course it's a country in its own right!
England, Scotland, Wales, Ireland....

confussssed · 04/11/2018 12:39

@wazznme www.britannica.com/topic/list-of-countries-1993160 i dont see England on the list

JaneJeffer · 04/11/2018 12:34

To eradicate them would be to negate important parts of a shared history nobody wants words eradicated, they just feel the phrase has no place in the Talk Guidlines on here

PerverseConverse · 04/11/2018 12:32

Wazznme some English people are lacking in knowledge are they? Yet Irish people being called thick is offensive? Hmmm.

JaneJeffer · 04/11/2018 12:31

confusssssed ??

confussssed · 04/11/2018 12:30

@confussssed England isn't a country? How do you work that one out?no there is a country called the United Kingdom Of Great Britain And northern Ireland.
country definition a nation with its own government, occupying a particular territory. there is no government of England

I mean I know knowledge can be lacking in some English people, but that takes the biscuit! racist comment you will get away with it because you said English if you said any other group of people you would be condemned widely

PurpleDaisies · 04/11/2018 12:29

i notice how the op keeps referring to the 'English' there is no country called England has not been for hundreds of years. i find that interesting

Confused Really?!!

Wazznme · 04/11/2018 12:28

BTW, we usually refer to England as it was the English parliament and English monarchy who tortured us for 800 years. Not the Scottish or Welsh. Love the scene from Brave heart where the Irish are the foot soldiers for England and they just join the other side lol

Wazznme · 04/11/2018 12:25

I mean I know knowledge can be lacking in some English people, but that takes the biscuit!

Wazznme · 04/11/2018 12:23

England isn't a country? I've heard it all now lol

PerverseConverse · 04/11/2018 12:17

@confussssed England isn't a country? How do you work that one out?

confussssed · 04/11/2018 12:10

i notice how the op keeps referring to the 'English' there is no country called England has not been for hundreds of years. i find that intresting

There are many manifestations. Names like Conor and Liam are considered naughty boy names that sentence is just as stupid as what hopkins said about children names and untrue.

JassyRadlett · 04/11/2018 11:38

It came from earlier English and from laws passed in the late medieval period binding the English in the 'four obedient shires' on the east coast of Ireland most closely bound to England.

It almost certainly didn’t. Sigh.

LemonTT · 04/11/2018 10:30

Oh, btw @changehere the only time I have heard the phrase used and explained in reference to Irish people being uncouth or uncivilised is by you. When explained by Irish historians in Ireland, it is in the context of non victimhood and the strength of Irish culture and resistance.

Your post is offensive by your own standards.

Swipe left for the next trending thread