Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I leave him or have another baby?

118 replies

Babyorbust · 21/10/2018 12:44

Think this will be a long one. I’ve name changed.

DP and I have been together for 7 years. We have 1 DS aged nearly 1. We own a home, a car, have a will, life insurance, etc. We are not married which doesn’t bother me in the slightest (I know many on here have strong opinions about this which I fully respect, but don’t want this thread to be a marriage debate please!)

My DP is a really nice, kind man and a great dad to our son. But I don’t feel anything for him any more romantically. The spark has well and truly gone. I love him but I’m not in love with him. I don’t think we will be together for the rest of our lives. He is aware of how I feel and it makes him sad but he wants to work at the relationship. We are so different, we have nothing in common, our core values are not the same and I realised this early 2017. Until then I was so madly in love with him I hadn’t noticed how poles apart we are. So early 2017 I told him how I felt and our relationship was effectively over... and then I fell pregnant. We decided to keep the baby and give our relationship a go. Everything was fine until DS was about 9mo when the old doubts started creeping in.

But I don’t know if I should leave him or stay and have another baby with him, wait a year or two and then end the relationship. I always wanted my children to be full siblings and DP is honestly the most amazing dad. I could happily plod along a few more years with him. We don’t fight or argue, we happily co exist almost as best friends.

What would you do? Am I an unreasonable arsehole for thinking I should have another baby even though I know the relationship won’t last long term? I’m prepared to be flamed but please be honest. Thanks.

OP posts:
Babyorbust · 21/10/2018 14:32

@Karmin you are spot on. Your kind, considered advice has really touched me. Thank you.

RE contraception I have had 3 contraception failures in my life. It seems high but I was absolutely taking precautions each time. I have even seen the doctor about it who said for a small percentage of people contraception just isn’t as effective. As & when we resume our sex life we will be doubling up by using hormonal contraception and condoms.

To respond to a few more comments:

  • There is no one else.
  • I will absolutely seek financial and/or legal advice, thank you.

It’s safe to say the idea of another child seems ludicrous to me having taken on board your feedback. It seems clear I need to sort my shit out and work on fixing my relationship first. It’s reallt reassuring to know all LTR’s go through these rocky patches. Thank you.

OP posts:
DreamsofJacaranda · 21/10/2018 14:32

No relationship stays permanently in the honeymoon phase. I doubt that anyone feels they are living on cloud nine after seven years together. This is perfectly normal, it’s the way of all relationships.

Splitting from your DP to start again with someone else would bring you the excitement you are craving, but what would you do when that relationship too lost it’s shine as familiarity and routine took over? What you are looking for is something transient.

Your DP sounds like a loving, decent man. Don’t give up on him now, it’s been a difficult time for both of you. Don’t underestimate the effect that pregnancy, first baby and then miscarriage can have on a couple. This is still very early days after all you have been through. Take time to rediscover each other, and enjoy your DS together. Don’t think about having another baby until you have processed the miscarriage and given your relationship time to recover from the impact it has had on you.

mumto2babyboys · 21/10/2018 14:31

And think about the nappies lol. From a practical view having another baby means another 2 years of changing nappies lol

My children have the same dad but men can walk away so easily and it could turn nasty. What if you spilt up and he met someone else and he said I’m selling that house or you need to buy me out?

If you can’t imagine being happy with him at least protect your biggest financial investment and get the living together agreement so he can’t turn around and ask to sell your house.

YearOfYouRemember · 21/10/2018 14:27

Really out of order to use him for another baby just because YOU want your kids to be full siblings.

Are you a decent person or are you not?

Jaxhog · 21/10/2018 14:21

Absolutely DON'T have another baby with him! Either commit to working on improving your relationship now that reality has set in, or leave. To have another baby is selfish, unfair to him and unfair to the baby.

Cr0c0dile20 · 21/10/2018 14:21

Why don't you investigate some contraception. Do you work ? Take some time to think about things. Take some time to think about your partner. Is there a need to rush ?

mumto2babyboys · 21/10/2018 14:20

I definitely wouldn’t have another baby, ive got 2 but my ex wasn’t nice like yours, however

it’s double the cost of everything and you’d be paying the mortgage alone, paying for daycare for 2 children instead of just the one. Buying 2 lots of new clothes and shoes. At the park etc, if one child runs off you have to carry the other child to run them. I was really naive I didn’t realise how much harder it is with 2.

I would definitely go see a solicitor and protect yourself and your child financially. There is a child maintenance calculator online too, use that and see where you stand if you break up.

mumto2babyboys · 21/10/2018 14:11

Financial advice!

buckleten · 21/10/2018 14:10

I would think very carefully before throwing away what you have. Your husband sounds like a kind and decent man, and a great father - and a stable happy home life for your child. You loved him before, and though you are currently going through a tough emotional journey, you can get that back! All marriages have their ups and downs, but what you have now will not be so easy to find again.

mumto2babyboys · 21/10/2018 14:10

You also need funicular advice. Since you are not married you won’t automatically get to keep the house if you split up

There is something you can do though. It’s called a living together agreement where you can state that you have the same rights as married women and get to live in the house with your child etc. You should do it for your child’s future because it might turn nasty after you split up and financially you wouldn’t be entitled to much only your share of the equity in the house and child support and he could refuse to pay the mortgage etc.

Google living together agreement. Hopefully he agrees to do it. You need something to protect you financially!!

Russell19 · 21/10/2018 14:09

I suspect you are very down, very upset about what has happened and rightly so. Could this be clouding your judgements? He sounds like a decent bloke...You must have loved him at first. I think you should try and make it work. The grass isn't always greener and relationships are not like a Disney film. Good luck xx

Karmin · 21/10/2018 14:07

Wow you have been through a lot OP

From what I see from the posts that are written, you and your partner who you are not married to have a small child, have recently gone through a miscarriage and are still grieving for that child?

You have been open with your partner about these feelings, but is it right that he is almost not listening to them saying to work on the relationship. Your relationship was over and then you fell pregnant with your first child so have tried to make it work for your baby?

Firstly, as I am sure you know, a baby will make the relationship harder not easier.

It also seems like you are at different points in recovering from the loss which is also going to put a strain on it.

If you didn't fall pregnant with your first child would you still be together?

This feeling that you love him but are not in love with him, which is also about the absence of another kind of feeling, as a sign the relationship is not going to last. Although this may prove to be the truth, there is also a chance it isn't, especially with all the positives you have for him - he is amazing, your best friend, you don't argue, as parents you offset each other quite well.

Some days are cloudy, some are stormy, some are gray, and sometimes the sun shines. Relationships are seasonal and cyclical, and the statement, "I’m not in love with my boyfriend" can mean many more things than "it's time to leave." Yet it seems that for so many people, that feeling is interpreted as the end of the relationship—or at least Very Big Trouble.

It depends on are you saying: I want out of the relationship and am clear it's done, and I want to be nice about it. I don't want to hurt my partner's feelings, and this is easier to say than "It's over."

Or: I've met someone else with whom I feel alive, like I used to with my current partner.

Maybe: The person feeling this is depressed and, since the Technicolor has gone out of many things they once enjoyed, this has happened in the relationship as well. Sex can be rekindled, intimacy can be rediscovered, and depression can be treated. Relationships need constant nurturing, love, energy and input. Time management with working lives and managing children and finding quality time for a couple has to be in place.

It is a difficult decision to leave a long-term relationship, but it's even more unfair to compare the newness of a romantic love to the familiarity and comfort of a long-term relationship. Perhaps there is a depth of love that has become likened to wearing slippers and become familiar? Is this perhaps the real love? Could it be that the initial head over heels is in fact little more than sexual lust and desire, a sparkle in the honeymoon period?

Regarding your original question, if the relationship is truly over, and you don't want to work at it, then it is fairer on your partner to leave sooner rather than later. I would certainly not consider having a child in such circumstances.

LoniceraJaponica · 21/10/2018 14:03

First of all I am sorry for your loss.

Second of all, it is unrealistic to expect a relationship to be all hearts and flowers all the time. No matter how much you love someone the novelty wears off. I have been with DH for 40 years this year. I love him, but it isn't the same as when I first met him. Of course it isn't.

Love isn't the only reason we are still together. We share the same core values, we respect each other, we are considerate towards each other. I couldn't imagine life without him.

If the only reason you want to stay with your partner short term is to use him as a sperm donor then, sorry, but you are being selfish.

ChimesAtMidnight · 21/10/2018 14:03

I am sorry for your loss op, and it will take as long as it takes for you to come to terms with it.
But I echo Bluesmartiesarebest in that to use your partner as a sperm donor would be very wrong.
And have you heard the expression "the seven year itch" ?

ENormaSnob · 21/10/2018 14:01

What a cruel thing to do.

Bluesmartiesarebest · 21/10/2018 13:56

You would be very cruel to use your DP as a sperm donor while planning to break up with him. He deserves better.

SEsofty · 21/10/2018 13:45

Yes it’s normal

I absolutely adore my husband but for months after first miscarriage couldn’t really stand each other and certainly weren’t having sex less than two months after

RandomMess · 21/10/2018 13:44

Peaks and troughs are definitely usual in a LTR.

You have a young baby and have had a miscarriage that you are very much struggling with, this is a tough time emotionally.

Are you managing to carve out time for you and your DP?

Batteriesallgone · 21/10/2018 13:43

Its normal. Totally normal. Especially in times of stress.

LostInShoebiz · 21/10/2018 13:40

Yes it’s utterly normal after 7 years and would be the same with the next man/sperm doner (because that’s effectively what you’re thinking of reducing your DH to).

TheMobileSiteMadeMeSignup · 21/10/2018 13:39

In light of your update, slow down. I am sorry for your loss.

Keep seeing the counsellor, focus on your DS and your DP and communicate with him about your loss.

LostInShoebiz · 21/10/2018 13:39

Poor fellow being strung along. You sound a bit grass is greener to be honest. It’s not all romance and madly in love in a marriage, some of it is hard work, some of it is just rubbing along together amicably and some of it - not much - is mad passion and romance. Even if he did want the same very vague things as you, it might be a nightmare. What if he did want to move abroad but to Florida and you fancy a villa in rural France, or he wants to move to Italy and spend his retirement cycling but you want to garden.

More to the point, if you ditch him will you have enough money as a single parent of 1/2 to ever move abroad or even the spare cash to donate to a food bank?

Babyorbust · 21/10/2018 13:38

I absolutely agree that volunteering at a food bank doesn’t make me superior. I hope I’ve made it clear in my posts just how great my partner is. He is truly a wonderful person. Maybe he deserves better than me.

So, a new question then... feel free to call me naive/clueless etc but seeing as I have been with DP 7 years and that’s 1/4 of my life I am fairly inexperienced in long term relationships. Is what I describe normal for a LTR? The peaks and troughs and sometimes looking at your partner and questioning it all? Because if that’s normal in a relationship it would give me hope that mine might be ok.

OP posts:
hammeringinmyhead · 21/10/2018 13:33

You cannot let your DP think you are trying to make it work, extract another baby out of him, then send him off to live on his own and pay maintenance for 2 children or be a 50/50 parent. The idea is horrifying.

ShawshanksRedemption · 21/10/2018 13:32

@Babyorbust sorry for you loss Flowers

Right now you need time to come to terms with your loss and grieve for what might have been. Now isn't the time for big decisions; hopefully you can continue to explore your feelings with your counsellor and come to a decision when you are at a more stable point in your life.