Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we shouldn't move to a village with a poor performing primary school?

65 replies

KPjoenix · 15/10/2018 21:23

DH and I disagree. We found a village that we both like BUT the village primary school gets dire results for no particularly reason. It's not in a deprived area. DH thinks we should go for it and hope the school improves or if not then try for a place in a neighbouring village...I think that's too risky. AIBU?

OP posts:
FrayedHem · 17/10/2018 09:48

Looking at the school's website, the 2018 SATs results seem pretty positive. But it does also appear the class numbers are dropping, if they now have a 24 for the reception/Yr1 class combined, which is roughly how many per class are in the single year groups 2-6. It could be low birth years, not necessarily just parents opting for other schools.

MinaPaws · 17/10/2018 09:47

shouldwestay makes good points about statistical skewing in smaller schools. But is the whole Ofsted report based on statistics? Isn't much of it based on classroom observations, facilities and maintenance, HT plans and goals for development, staff, pupil an dparent satisfaction etc? These are so revealing.

WhirlwindHugs · 17/10/2018 09:43

I wouldn't be happy with only 30% expected and 0% exceeding if that is usual for the school.

I would go for a different village. If you can it might be worth having a look at the different schools so you can get an idea of the styles of learning.

We moved our DC from one school to another, they had similar results (roughly same number at expected and some exceeding) but very different styles of learning.

There are several other schools in our area that have 0% exceeding, but very pressured environments. I wasn't happy with the idea of that either, seemed like the worst of all worlds!

shouldwestayorshouldwego · 17/10/2018 09:33

My point with the small numbers is that you cannot with all the statistical wizardry get away from the fact that just by random chance in a smaller cohort you might end up with skewed effects due to eight children struggling for different reasons. If you throw a dice twenty four times then you could, by chance end up with eight sixes even though you would only expect an average of four sixes. If you throw that dice 90 or 120 times then you are going to get much closer to the expected value of 1 in 6. A large standard deviation such as that school has means that it is harder to be accurate about whether it is actually substantially under performing, or actually around average - the standard deviation for that school straddles zero so it could still be average. This is before you consider that it will be a 95% confidence interval so there is still a 1 in 20 chance that it is much better or much worse than the figures are showing.

As a parent if I had a straight choice between a school which was on record as above average compared with on which was below average and in all other respects they were the same then obviously I would go for the above average one.

As a statistician though I know that particularly with relatively small sample sizes - and based on tests such as the SATs which are taken in a short time frame, there is a greater margin of error so I would want to get a wider picture.

It also of course depends on the child. We decided to move our (able even by MN standards) child from a school with a much greater emphasis on preparing and prepping for SATs (think tests every day for months) to one with a slightly more laid back approach because it is better for his mental health as he was getting very anxious. Stats offer one angle of insight into a school but they don't offer the full picture.

NotAnotherJaffaCake · 17/10/2018 08:56

The size of cohort is taken into account in the ratings of progress scores - a small school can have a score of -3.0 and still be classified as making average progress, as it's generally reflecting only a single child making poor progress, which is enough to skew the numbers. Whereas for a 3 form entry primary, a progress score of -3.0 would be well below average, as it means that a large chunk of its cohort is not making good progress for the school to have a -3 average progress rating.

CrispbuttyNo1 · 16/10/2018 21:44

“We are really please to have 24 new children in the Foundation class”

I can see why it is failing with that sentence alone.

shouldwestayorshouldwego · 16/10/2018 21:36

With only 150 pupils that is roughly 20 per year group so each child is worth 5% and you only need a few in a class to underperform on the day, or a class with quite a few children with SEN. Having said that I would want the school to clearly demonstrate that it was a blip. I would try to visit a few schools in the area, lots of them have open days around now and there might be some Christmas fairs soon too.

Lethaldrizzle · 16/10/2018 21:33

If your only goal is for your kids to go to private secondary above standard of living that's sad

Ohyesiam · 16/10/2018 21:31

I sent dd to an Outstanding school. 3 years later and it’s in special
Measures. No guarantees with ratings.
Also ofsted is about to change what/ how they rate schools with a view to less exam chasing and a broader education. So your school might perform better.

crikeycrumbsblimey · 16/10/2018 21:22

In that part of the world I wouldn’t assume you can go elsewhere - crazy amount of development means people can’t get into their own village school.

crikeycrumbsblimey · 16/10/2018 21:19

We had this with somewhere we looked at (not far from there!) and it was seemly down to headteacher absence we had been going on, on and off for years.

We didn’t buy the house

NotAnotherJaffaCake · 16/10/2018 21:14

Will Pm you.

KPjoenix · 16/10/2018 21:00

This require a name change but I'd appreciate any feedback:

www.compare-school-performance.service.gov.uk/school/123167/blewbury-endowed-church-of-england-primary-school

OP posts:
hamzilla · 16/10/2018 20:28

Visit the school and see the reality rather than a snapshot on one day, or what the head wanted the inspector to see.

Why would what you see on a quick visit to a school be the reality over a snapshot of one day that ofsted see? Hmm surely you would get even less of a snapshot?

FrayedHem · 16/10/2018 20:22

Have you looked at the results published on the school's website? There should be more detail there as the gov website looks at Reading writing and maths as combined. So a child that got expected/exceeding in 2/3 wouldn't be included. It is concerning for expected level, but not so much with exceeding IMO.

I think the 2018 SATs will be published in December, so the school may have started to turn things around. If they've had another poor year it's quite likely Ofsted will visit them in the not too distance future.

Due to complicated logistics mine have/had no choice but to go to a poor performing school (unless I home ed). My academically able child has still managed to do well, good SATs top sets at secondary. Really not such a happy tale for my children with SEN! It's a gamble I wouldn't take unless there was no other choice though.

KPjoenix · 16/10/2018 19:36

The parents do all seem quite happy with it because the children are happy. I assume they are happy because they aren't being asked to do much! I don't want a hothouse but I do want DC2 to reach a good enough standard to go on to private secondary.

OP posts:
Piffle11 · 16/10/2018 09:57

I think you need to find out more about the schools. See if you can go and have a look around, get a feel for the place. I never felt confident about my DS2's school, but DH thought it important to send him to the local village school in order for him to meet other children from the village … turns out there were only 2 other DC from the village in his year, and one of them moved after 18 months! The classes were mixed years too - 2 year groups in each class, and nearly 30 DC in each. Must have been difficult to teach. I think Frayed makes a good point about development too: greenbelt land is being developed on, and I know of 2 sites here that are being built on, and there's a large development in a nearby village, and an even bigger one on the outskirts - less than 10 mins drive from the school - so the local village school here and the nearest one (5 mins away) are going to be massively oversubscribed in years to come. You may not have the option of going to another village school.

NotAnotherJaffaCake · 16/10/2018 09:54

For that kind of cohort, those results are very poor, and if parents there aren't up in arms about that then I'd worry about that too, and the ethos they are happy with. There are a lot of schools in areas with no obvious issues (middle class, naice villages) which frankly have very poor results considering their intake - in many cases parents don't have ambition and aspiration as they did all right and they don't see what's changed. So if parents are happy with poor standards, that would be a red flag for me too.

The school data on compare-school-data.gov.uk is adjusted to account for small cohorts so that's no excuse - it's why you can have a school with a +3.0 progress score that's only average, as in a small school the standard deviation is generally very large (i.e., one pupil can make a big difference). Was this a poor one-off year or historically has it been bad year on year?

I'd be very, very careful, to be honest. I'm not sure I would risk it unless I was extremely confident that the school was going to be turned around. I sent my children to a school that was RI, but only because I was a governor and knew exactly what was going on to turn it around behind the scenes.

FrayedHem · 16/10/2018 09:14

It would be a risk to assume you'd get into other schools in 2 years time. Our local village primary has been historically not great for many years. It used to be you could get into other schools nearby quite easily, but with the poor reputation and new housing developments there's little to no chance now.

MinaPaws · 16/10/2018 09:06

Is there a reason you prefer this village to the others nearby? I'd definitely go for the village with the better primary. The results you're describing suggest uninspired teachers and a Head who doesn't pick them up on weak results.

KPjoenix · 16/10/2018 08:59

I agree ofsted and SATS aren't the full picture but surely there's a happy medium between a SATS factory and 30% reaching and 0% exceeding? It looks like some of the neighbouring villages have much better performing schools and aren't oversubscribed but I really didn't want to have to drive for the school run if I could avoid it.

OP posts:
Sillybilly1234 · 15/10/2018 23:58

We moved to a village but took the kids to a different school nearby for the same reason. You might be able to make it work. Good luck.

mumtomaxwell · 15/10/2018 23:24

Just looking at it from a different perspective.... maybe it’s one of those rare primary schools that doesn’t plough everything into being a SATS factory? In which case they won’t give a shit about SATS - and quite right too!!

As several PP have said - visit the school and don’t judge it by meaningless shite like Ofsted and SATS!

I’m a teacher of 20+ years experience BTW.

garethsouthgatesmrs · 15/10/2018 23:20

152 isn't very small and if it's been like that for a few years i would say it doesn't sound like the greatest school. If they would have to go there then I personally wouldn't move there

Purpleartichoke · 15/10/2018 23:18

School quality is our number one factor in choosing a home.