Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we shouldn't move to a village with a poor performing primary school?

65 replies

KPjoenix · 15/10/2018 21:23

DH and I disagree. We found a village that we both like BUT the village primary school gets dire results for no particularly reason. It's not in a deprived area. DH thinks we should go for it and hope the school improves or if not then try for a place in a neighbouring village...I think that's too risky. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RowanAlong · 17/09/2021 20:03

I’d do a bit more research - definitely go and see the local schools. Also, you’re going to have to drive lots anyway if you’re rural, so don’t let that get in the way of picking the school that feels best ‘in person’.

WHtonks · 17/09/2021 19:36

@RunningStrong there's nothing unusual. There's no travellers or any other vulnerable population. It was a complacent older head who lost control of the school combine with a village that simply didn't care enough. It's as white and chocolate box as they come for a village. There's nothing to excuse it.

RunningStrong · 17/09/2021 19:33

Definitely visit the school. We have a small school in a nice village near here and it gets a Good OFSTED but very poor results.

The reality is, that the pupils are 100% from Traveller families and generally have poor attendance and low levels of literacy in the family. Other local families don't send their children there and there is an unwritten acceptance from the council that even families applying for over subscribed schools won't be placed there.

It is a nice school, I've worked there, they have a unique set of challenges and actually work wonders considering the poor attendance - including achieveing vast improvements in attendance for some families.

There's a small traveller site on the outskirts of the village. The village is very nice with some lovely pubs.

This is extreme and unusual, but there's something going on for the school to be getting such poor results.

RunningStrong · 17/09/2021 19:26

Ok, so 152 makes an average of 21 children per year, so some years a year group could be 10 or 15. If 2 of those 10 children fare very badly, maybe one misses a lot of education through illness and one suffers a bereavement, that means 40% of the class "fail" before you even start.

That said, even then, the results are very poor so you need to meet the HT and find out why

Headteacher415 · 17/09/2021 18:49

Generally I wouldn't look at results in the sense of one school being 10% higher than the other, but 30% is exceptionally low, even for a school in a challenging area. Assuming that these are typical and not a one-off (some village schools enter 3-4 SEN children in a small year group and manage 0%, followed by 100% the next year!), I'd make sure you have an alternative plan up your sleeve - how far and how full are the nearest alternatives. Not sure how direct messaging works on here, I'm new but happy to look at the online data with my headteacher hat on if you send me a link to the DfE tables and let you know what I think!

CottonSock · 17/09/2021 13:10

Well looks like you were spot on then OP. Good decision

RunningStrong · 17/09/2021 13:02

@KPjoenix

I agree ofsted and SATS aren't the full picture but surely there's a happy medium between a SATS factory and 30% reaching and 0% exceeding? It looks like some of the neighbouring villages have much better performing schools and aren't oversubscribed but I really didn't want to have to drive for the school run if I could avoid it.
That does seem very odd. Meet with the head and ask them to explain what's behind it.
WHtonks · 17/09/2021 12:47

@StewedFruit Have you already moved or is this a planned move? I'd focus on getting a good place for your year 3 which will bump your reception child up the list. Year 3 places are much easier to find.

Rosesareyellow · 17/09/2021 11:57

152 in the school. Not sure how many per class? More girls than boys. Hardly any on free school meals. Everyone speaks English as a first language. Better than average attendance record. It's consistently had poor results for the last few years. 0% of students exceeding.

Statistically that is extremely unusual, I would be a bit suspicious. Can you go and visit to get a better feel for it?

StewedFruit · 17/09/2021 11:39

Yes reception and year 3. My children are confident and happy, so I obviously worry that a not great school will affect that. They will be leaving a larger town school, rated 'good'.

Malbecfan · 17/09/2021 11:38

Oh crap, just realised it's a zombie thread! Oh well, hope this helps someone...

Malbecfan · 17/09/2021 11:37

Going against the grain here. You need to visit the school and see for yourself. SATs weren't done in 2020 and were optional in 2021. So any information is about children who by now are midway through secondary school.

When my DDs were small we visited the local schools to see which one to send DD1 to. The one we were zoned to was OFSTED - Good but had really dire results. Getting there was really tough and we would have to drive. The closest one was also Good but the Head was the most disinterested person I have ever met. Children ignored her and she had rigid views on everything. We went to look at a small village primary, about half the size of the one you are considering which at the time was Satisfactory. The Head showed us round. Children ran up to him shouting "look at my sums Mr B" or "Mr B, I got a star". It was such a lovely nurturing atmosphere that we sent the DDs there. Results were never great but aforementioned DD1 hasn't suffered as she's just about to start a PhD at Cambridge. The school was able to stretch and challenge her and most importantly, work with us to extend and enrich her learning. SATs for them were rarely reported as they had to have 10 or more children in year 6 for them to be published. DD1 was one of 8, DD2 was one of 2!

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 17/09/2021 10:55

My friend's dc have been through a school that did really badly on an Ofsted while they were there. Changes were made and she was certainly happy with the school. She is a very positive person and her dc all do well.

WHtonks · 17/09/2021 10:54

Sorry I know because we still have quite a few good friends in the village who have tried to stick it out with the school and are now regretting it and scrambling for school places.

WHtonks · 17/09/2021 10:54

Behaviour remains a big issue. A lot of the practical stuff like bothering to shut the school gates does seem to have been sorted. It was pitiful during lockdown for provision and in person doesn't seem to get much better reviews. I'd stick to the waitlist if possible. Is it a reception place you need?

StewedFruit · 17/09/2021 10:44

Thanks OP for getting back to me. Glad to know what happened in the end. Can I just ask how you know the school still has big problems? I will visit, not sure we have much say in the final decision though, the schools around here seem very full. Has anyone had children that have been through an inadequate school and it's been OK in the end?

Maray1967 · 17/09/2021 10:30

My DB and DSIL moved my DN from a high performing primary at the start of Y6 as he hated it. It was one of those who go in lists of kids on times tables do everyone can see where each child is. Truly awful. He loved the new school, settled in well and was in a much better state when he started high school.
Check the school out -ask to visit. Look at the work being done and the atmosphere. This is a small school so a few pupils who are struggling will surely have a big impact on results.

WHtonks · 17/09/2021 10:26

@StewedFruit I'm the OP with a name change. We didn't go for it in the end. The school has big problems and lots of the parents simply weren't fussed. We moved to a different village and I'm really glad we did as the school is MUCH better run.

StewedFruit · 17/09/2021 10:13

I can see it was made to join an academy trust after being graded inadequate, and I wondered if that had made a difference. We are moving house and it seems to be the only school with places. Not looking for private schools.

MrsColon · 17/09/2021 09:55

Our village primary scores low for literacy and numeracy despite a good Ofsted rating - it's because it's a small, lovely and nurturing environment, so has more than the usual number of children with SEN. Look at the school, book a visit and raise your concerns - there might well be a reasonable answer.

UpHillandDownAle · 17/09/2021 09:54

If you’re looking at a private secondary school, is there a reason you’re not looking at a private primary school?

NuffSaidSam · 17/09/2021 09:52

That school is now rated inadequate by Ofsted, so seems the next Ofsted report was in line with the results. It went from good in 2015 to inadequate in 2019 from what I can see. Things can change very quickly!

StewedFruit · 17/09/2021 09:37

I'm interested to know what the OP decided in the end? I am aware of this school and in a similar position. I would love to know if you chose this school and how it worked out @KPjoenix

NotAnotherJaffaCake · 17/10/2018 10:50

The last OFSTED was conducted under the old framework, which was much more lax.

Yes, small cohorts do mean that the statistics are tricky but this is not a one off - there were two years on the trot of poor results. I'm a governor in a school with KS2 cohorts of that size and for the statistics to look like that, the progress is very, very poor indeed. These results don't look bad because of small sample size (which is accounted for by the Average/Below average/Above average rating) - they look poor because they are poor.

The 2018 SATS will be on the .gov.uk website around December, so they will be available before the deadline for primary applications.

shouldwestayorshouldwego · 17/10/2018 10:17

But MinaPaws the last OFSTED was rated good in 2015, so this is just on the progress scores/KS2 attainment, which is why there could be skewing due to small sample sizes. As I said if I was planning to move somewhere as the OP is then yes it is a factor to consider. Digging further into the data it states that there were 13 pupils eligible for ks2 assessment. This is a tiny number statistically for any meaningful comparisons with larger schools. This might be because the school is awful and the other 17 have jumped ship or had SEN and didn't complete the SATs, or it could be that the PAN when that year group was in reception was 10 or 15 and the school has expanded over time.

By the way not the head teacher or anything, just interested in the stats!