Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To change my baby's name... feeling guilt and sadness

286 replies

tiffysaccount · 12/10/2018 15:23

Hello mums

Well long story short we named our baby girl Abigail and registered her and I dislike the name or so I thought. I'd like some help processing these emotions and to try to figure out what's best for us.

I hate it when people call her Abi/Abby and it seems like that is what they constantly do. Plus I knew an Abi who was a complete bitch at school and I don't know why I didn't think of the association beforehand. Stupid. We've told people we are going to call her Abigail no nicknames and they don't seem to respect it. Feels like fingernails on a chalkboard whenever I hear Abigail or Abi. Just seems off to me.

I wanted to name her something else, I don't want to post for privacy purposes sorry but it's also a classic normal name.

I don't know why on earth I didn't name her that, DH loved the name and is now OK with me changing it to that, I have his full blessing.

She is 15 weeks now, if you would have asked me to change it 6 weeks ago i would have done the paperwork immediately but now I am not sure. This absolutely breaks my heart and I'm so confused.

I was going back in her baby book the other day and saw a hospital birth record with Abigail on it and her little feet stamped on it and I just burst into tears at the thought of changing it. I feel that if I changed the name I would be changing her. It's almost like, I hate the name but now it's hers and I can't take it from her. It's the strangest emotion, hating the name but almost loving it because it's hers.

Then I think back to the hospital and my husband filling out the birth certificate and holding her in his arms. The name means "father's joy" as well.

I'm so bloody confused about this whole thing that I'm in tears about it every day. I like the other name so much more and I don't know if I can see her being Abigail or Abi the rest of her life. I think about changing it but I get such a deep feeling of heartbreak and guilt over it and I feel that if I did change it these feelings would linger forever on.

How unreasonable am I being here. From this mess I've typed out, do you think I'm best off keeping the name or changing it? I can't tell if it's mum guilt talking or my emotions or what and it's exhausting.

OP posts:
alphajuliet123 · 14/10/2018 19:44

Look, if your husband truly doesn't mind either way, and you do, just crack on and do it. You have his backing and that's really all that matters. The family will get their heads round it. Your daughter is too young to know any different. Like others have said in years to come you'll laugh about it, it will seem like a tiny blip. Stop overthinking and start calling her Charlotte - you'll know really soon whether it feels better or not.

We're all holding your hand and telling you you're a great mum, but this is obviously a sticking point you need to unstick!!

TheVanguardSix · 14/10/2018 19:40

How about Bibi? Or Avi (since Avigail is the Hebrew form of the name)?

My hunch is, she's Abigail and you will grow to love this name because Abigail will be your most precious, favourite person in the world.
I think your reaction to changing her name says it all. It's almost causing you a micro-bereavement. I really wouldn't change her name. You will really grow to appreciate and love her name. Don't think of any other Abigails but your own.

And there are so many other names you can call her other than Abi/Abby. Bibi, as I mentioned. Gigi was mentioned above. The meaning of the name is so beautiful. The name itself is beautiful.

Saraleast · 14/10/2018 19:30

I have an Eleanor that kept getting shortened to Ellie by a few people - we always remained calling her Eleanor and didn't rise to what anyone else said. When Eleanor was 3 she started correcting people herself if they called her Ellie- she used to say "it's not Ellie it's Eleanor!" Since then we don't hear Ellie anymore.

letallthechildrenboogie · 14/10/2018 19:24

OP, you've not let anyone down. In a year you'll not even think about it because she will be whatever you call her. Try your new name for a month or so. See how you feel and decide then. Babies don't start responding to their names till well into the second six months so she'll be none the wiser, but you might be more comfortable.

tiffysaccount · 14/10/2018 19:03

Ladies how do I thank you? I've had so many good responses here that I don't even know what to say.

I don't even know what I'm looking for either. Perhaps someone to take me by the hand and tell me it will be alright! Maybe someone to tell me I'm a good mum, or perhaps someone to tell me I won't be tortured by the outcome of this 10 years from now.

Had such a hard time as a new mum, not having family support really, being in a strange place physically and emotionally. I've been beating myself up about this, feeling like I'm stripping away my daughter's identity and replacing it with a new one. Almost like I'll have a new baby if that makes sense?

Been talking to DH begging for an answer or a sign to go either way, he says he's numb to the whole thing which has made me feel horrid. He says he truly doesn't mind.

Oh, how to get over these feelings of guilt. I think I really do need to see a therapist about it then move on with the answer as like several of you said I am making this into something WAY bigger than it needs to be and I just can't help my emotions, feeling like I've let DH and DD down. x

OP posts:
Noodledoodledoo · 14/10/2018 18:44

BertrandRussell No its not much fun, but being called by a name you hate is not much fun either, as far as I am concerned no one has the right to change your name to something you do not like.

When I wasn't quite so belligerent about it I spent about 2 years being known as the shortened version and it really does put my back up I hate it so much.

retainertrainer · 14/10/2018 18:42

And it’s things like this, little funny anecdotes that pass through the generations. All the silly mistakes we make as parents, you’ll laugh when she’s older.

retainertrainer · 14/10/2018 18:40

Gosh you’re over thinking it. You chose Abigail, you didn’t like it/it doesn’t suit her (whatever the reason!) so you’re changing it to Charlotte. No big deal,she’ll have no memory of it. You can all have a chuckle about it when she’s older. Just change it. Keep Abigail as her middle name. Job done. Move on,be happy,enjoy your beautiful daughter.

BertrandRussell · 14/10/2018 18:38

"You have to be strong willed and correct everyone who uses the shortened version"
That must be fun. Hmm

Noodledoodledoo · 14/10/2018 18:27

Those saying it will be shortened, it is not a given. I have a name that is frequently shortened and I hate the shortened version, so did my parents and I am not known by it.

You have to be strong willed and correct everyone who uses the shortened version. Once she is older, the tactic I used was to ignore people who shortened it until they used my full name - very effective! My nephew also has a normally shortened name, and was known as the full version until he opted for the short one as it was quicker to write!

If when your daughter gets older she wants it shortened thats a different matter, thats her choice but till then its yours.

I hate the assumption that shortened versions are automatic, I am teacher and refuse to shorten students names unless they tell me to.

AcrossthePond55 · 14/10/2018 17:58

Charlotte Abigail is a beautiful name. It's pretty clear that you really want to change it and I think you're right to do so since Charlotte was the name you really wanted.

You're right, in the US they do pressure you to come up with a name right away. In fact, in many states they require it before you leave the hospital because of 'enumeration at birth' (assigning a Social Security number to newborns).

If you're still in the US just google your state name and 'amending a birth certificate' and it will give you the procedure.

tiffysaccount · 14/10/2018 16:50

@Porpoises thank you. It's just that I wish I could rewind time knowing what I know now and I wish I knew what decision would bring me the most peace.

You're exactly right in wanting to make the best choice in this situation. I feel immense guilt about how I felt in the pregnancy and now I feel immense guilt that I didn't go with my heart re: the name. Now I am afraid I am going to feel yet MORE guilt on top of this for changing it- by feeling like I'm messing around with my daughter's identity and letting my husband down. Perhaps also if I change it, I feel like a bit of an inept and flaky mother in a way that I didn't get it right the first time (though I deep down know it isn't true). Yet leaving the name doesn't feel good either.

I think I have realised that either decision now is going to come with an immense deal of negative emotions: guilt and uncertainty over changing it, or keeping it, feeling grating and exhaustion re: fighting the nicknames, having gone off it, feeling it isn't right etc.

What a bloody mess I'm in! x

OP posts:
Porpoises · 14/10/2018 16:38

It's okay to be unsure, afraid or depressed in pregnancy. It's okay that you weren't sure you wanted her. I know you feel guilty about it, but it's okay to have these feelings. You haven't hurt her by having those thoughts.

Porpoises · 14/10/2018 16:34

I wish I knew how to help you with your anxiety OP. What is it that you need to hear? I get the feeling that no answer or reassurance here can solve this, because your anxiety just comes back stronger.

You made a decision you regret, and now you're scared to change it because you might then regret that decision. You're desperate to make the perfect choice to do right by your daughter and by everyone else. It's like all of your wider fears and your guilt about your feelings in pregnancy have now got channelled into this decision.

I think the counseling is a great idea, I hope they can help Smile

Loopytiles · 14/10/2018 16:06

She will be called Abby/Abi, nothing you’ll be able to do about it, so as you dislike the shortening changing the name makes sense.

tiffysaccount · 14/10/2018 16:04

@ree070603 we are in the US now. My DH is American and I'm from the UK. We moved here about two years back so he could be closer to his family.

But yes, they come round at the hospital with the birth certificate paperwork here pressuring you to fill it out. I kept saying I wasn't ready and the nurses kept coming back in saying "so what's the name? can't wait to hear it! We need a name!" and "you need to fill this out before you leave". I was just so exhausted and overwhelmed, already crying because I just wasn't sure what to name her, just remember the feeling of complete and UTTER exasperation and frustration like it was yesterday. It was horrible.

OP posts:
tiffysaccount · 14/10/2018 16:00

thank you ladies, oh I really do appreciate all of these comments, I've read every single one of them. thank you, thank you.

I've really analysed this yesterday and here's what I've come up with.

The entire time I was pregnant with her I wasn't sure if I wanted to be a mum, got really depressed, didn't think of names, couldn't be arsed. Was convinced the entire experience was going to be an utter disaster anyway so why bother with a name. Like I said, had the one name I really liked but didn't use it, I was in such a state.

Of course when she was born she became the most beautiful thing that has ever happened to me and has changed my life for the better in ways I never dreamed possible.

She is so precious to me and really the focus of all of my attention now, just can't help it, love her so much. And I think perhaps having something so "everyday" and big about her be such a source of pain really puts on the guilt. Plus the thoughts during pregnancy of not wanting her vs. how much I love her now, breaks my heart. Knowing that the name means "father's joy" and it was DH's choice, I think it's perhaps symbolism at taking joy away from him by changing the name. All of these feelings just wrapped up you know? I've had such a rough start.

I want to make the name right but now... I'm afraid of 'letting her down' so to speak again if that makes any sense. x

OP posts:
ree070603 · 14/10/2018 14:35

I'm a registrar and intrigued that the birth certificate was completed at the hospital. How old was the baby when you registered her? If she was only a couple of days I'd say that's very problematic as the days after a birth are such emotional times that I'm sure lots of people would make mistakes with names and change their minds.

Welliejellie · 14/10/2018 13:03

Just keep saying g Abigail when people are around if they say abi say Abigail.

I have this with my son his name is Tom! People constantly say Thomas I just Correct them and say Tom.

Most people get the message eventually!

He corrects people now he is older too.

Porpoises · 14/10/2018 13:00

I can completely empathise with this - I don't have a child yet but have mental health issues and get hugely overstressed over certain decisions.

It seems to me that your heart is telling you to change it to Charlotte, which you liked all along. But you're scared of the imagined consequences, of people's judgement, of your own guilt at changing a previously made choice. It's almost as if, having made a mistake in your eyes, you feel that you ought to be punished for the mistake.

I think your fear of the consequences is being magnified beyond all reason because of the mental health issues. Honestly it is fine to change it. Charlotte is a beautiful name. Only you and your partner's opinions matter. Allow yourself permission, allow yourself freedom, to do whatever makes your heart sing.

YearOfYouRemember · 14/10/2018 12:48

Change the name

Change the name

Change your baby's name

TAMS71 · 14/10/2018 12:40

Definitely change it if it annoys you this much, as others have said play around with versions of it, I'd be inclined to add the new name as first name and put have Abigail as the middle name. Once you have done this your guilt (undeserved) will go away. Do check you don't have PND though xxx (even if you do still change it).

Anotherweddingringnamechange · 14/10/2018 10:06

Just wanted to say have been there too and decided to change names as lots of people were pronouncing the name in a strange way and I began to really dislike it. No regrets whatsoever. Baby is now a toddler and owns their new name. Kept original name as a middle name for sentimental reason/things that had baby’s name on and I know we made the right choice as I don’t love it as a middle name - glad we did keep it for this reason but wouldn’t choose it now. Hope you make a decision you are happy with

Daddyjammy · 14/10/2018 09:54

My 18yo son terrified the whole family a couple of weeks back on his first day at uni by posting on Facebook that he hoped we would all support him "over the coming months and years" as he "struggles with his identity"!
Turned out, 3 days later, after concerns from as far away as Australia, that he wanted to change his (perfectly normal) name......to Jon!!!
My brother also changed names in his 30s and my son got a new name after 30 minutes.
If it doesn't seem right now test the new name in the family for a couple of weeks, only referring to her as "new name" and if it feels right, stick with it. You don't even need to do anything legal if you don't want to. Passports can be in the accepted name if you can show it's what is normally used, the only issue comes with "deeds" such as buying a house or setting up trusts.

RockYourSocksOff · 14/10/2018 09:53

Totally understand the need to over analyse. I’ve done it myself. Did it when Ds was a baby (also had PND) cried buckets and hated myself for not breast feeding.

I do like both names you’ve mentioned, although Charlotte would be my preferred choice. There may be an influx of Charlotte’s though due to the gorgeous little Princess Charlotte. Something to bare in mind.

My dp is known by his middle name. Always has been. It’s not really an issue. Only things like gp appointments and official records where he has to use his first name.

Good luck OPFlowers